Blog

Why does the same marketplace plan cost different amounts by age and ZIP code?

Federal rules allow only four things to change a plan's price: age, rating area, tobacco use and family size. How each works, with a small illustrative table.

Two friends open the same marketplace, look at what looks like the same plan, and see prices that are hundreds of dollars apart. Neither has made a mistake. For the plans sold to individuals and small groups, federal law lets insurers vary the price of a given plan for only a short list of reasons: age, where you live, tobacco use, and whether the policy covers one person or a family. Anything outside that list, including your health, is not allowed to move the price. The rest of this post explains each of the four, shows the arithmetic in an invented table, and then covers the reasons two quotes can differ that have nothing to do with rating.

The four rating factors

When an insurer files a plan, it sets a base price for that plan in each rating area. The marketplace then applies the factors that fit the person or family. The factors, in the order most people feel them:

  1. Age. The price of a plan rises with the enrollee's age, within a limit: for adults, the oldest age band may be charged at most three times what the youngest adult band is charged. This is often written as a 3-to-1 ratio. Children under 21 are priced at a lower rate than adults, and rates are set by single year of age for adults. Many states follow a standard federal age curve, and a few set their own rules, with narrower ratios or no age variation at all. The page for your state or the state insurance department can tell you which applies.
  2. Rating area. A state is divided into geographic rating areas, often groups of counties, and sometimes defined by ZIP code or metropolitan area. An insurer's base price may differ from one area to another because local hospital prices, doctor supply and use of care differ.
  3. Tobacco use. In most states an insurer may charge a tobacco user up to 50% more than a non-user of the same age, a 1.5-to-1 ratio. Some states prohibit or limit the surcharge. The application asks about tobacco use and how recently and often it happens, and the exact wording matters, so read the question as your marketplace words it.
  4. Individual or family enrollment. A family policy is priced by adding up the price for each member. For children, only the three oldest under 21 are counted in the premium, so a family with four children under 21 pays for three of them.

These four are the whole list. They apply to individual-market plans, both on and off the marketplace, and to small-group plans. Large employer plans follow different rules, and a company's premium for its employees depends on the whole group.

A ZIP code can also mislead. Some ZIP codes cross county lines, and rating areas and plan service areas are often drawn by county, so the marketplace may ask which county you live in. Two neighbors in the same ZIP can therefore be in different rating areas or see different insurers. Enter the address where you actually live, since that is what decides both the price and the plans you can buy. If you move during the year, the new address can change both, and the marketplace should be told.

What cannot change the price

Several things that people reasonably expect to matter are barred. An insurer may not charge more, or refuse coverage, because of a pre-existing condition, your current health status, your claims history, your sex, or your occupation. A person with diabetes and a person without pay the same price for the same plan if they have the same age, area, tobacco status and family size. The Affordable Care Act of 2010 made this change for individual and small-group plans, and it is why shoppers see a price after answering only a handful of questions.

That does not make the answers irrelevant to everything. Your health matters for which doctors you will use and what drugs you need, which should shape the plan you pick, but it does not matter to the price of a given plan.

An illustration with invented numbers

The table below uses made-up multipliers to show how age, area and tobacco use combine. It is not any plan's real price list, and the multipliers are not the official federal age curve. It uses round numbers so that you can follow the arithmetic.

Say a particular plan has a base price of $300 a month for a 21-year-old non-smoker in Area A. Say its base price in Area B, where local care costs more, is 20% higher, which is $360 ($300 × 1.20). Say the age multipliers in this illustration are 1.00 at age 21, 1.15 at age 30, 1.45 at age 45 and 2.70 at age 60.

Age Multiplier Area A (base $300) Area B (base $360)
21 1.00 $300 $360
30 1.15 $345 $414
45 1.45 $435 $522
60 2.70 $810 $972

Each cell is the base price times the age multiplier: $300 × 1.15 = $345; $360 × 1.45 = $522; $360 × 2.70 = $972. The 60-year-old in this table pays 2.7 times what the 21-year-old pays, which stays under the 3-to-1 limit. The 45-year-old in Area B pays $522 − $435 = $87 more than the 45-year-old in Area A for the same plan, because of the area alone.

Now add tobacco use for the 45-year-old in Area A. With a 1.5 factor, $435 × 1.5 = $652.50, which is $217.50 more a month, about $2,610 a year ($217.50 × 12). The tobacco surcharge is the one factor on the list that a person's own choices can change, which is why the application's tobacco question deserves a careful read. It is also the one item that the tax credit does not offset: the credit is calculated from the benchmark plan's price without any tobacco surcharge, so the surcharge usually falls on the enrollee.

For a family, add the members. A couple, both 45, in Area A would be priced at $435 + $435 = $870 for this plan. Add two children, each priced at an invented $250, and the monthly price becomes $870 + $500 = $1,370. A third and fourth child under 21 would add $250 for the third and nothing for the fourth, since only the three oldest are counted.

Why a friend's quote can still differ

Rating explains much of the gap, but a quote is a combination of choices. Before you assume there is an error, go through the other sources of difference.

  • Different plan. Two plans with similar names can sit at different metal levels, with different deductibles and networks. A silver plan and a bronze plan from the same company cost different amounts. See metal levels.
  • Different insurer or service area. Not every plan is sold in every county. Your friend may be in a rating area where an additional insurer sells.
  • Price before or after the credit. One person may be reading the sticker price and the other the amount after the premium tax credit. The credit depends on income and household, so two people with the same plan can pay different amounts after the credit.
  • Cost-sharing-reduction variant. A person whose income is below 250% of the poverty level and who buys a silver plan gets a version with a lower deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. The sticker price of that version matches the ordinary silver plan, but what the person owes at the doctor's office is different.
  • Different year. Prices change annually, so a friend's quote from last year does not apply this year.
  • Different household. A spouse, a child or a dependent on the policy can change the number.

The practical point is that a quote on a third-party website may not match the marketplace's price, because the marketplace uses the information in your application. The marketplace's own window-shopping tool shows the price for the household you enter, and the application itself shows the figure that counts.

Why the credit hides some of the differences

A person who qualifies for premium tax credits may see less difference between ages and areas than the table suggests. The credit is set so that the benchmark plan, the second-lowest-cost silver plan in the area, costs a stated share of income, and that share depends on income, not on age or area. The credit makes up the rest.

Continue the invented example. A 30-year-old and a 60-year-old each have the same household income, and suppose the share of income each is expected to pay for the benchmark plan works out to $250 a month. Say the benchmark plan costs $345 a month for the 30-year-old and $810 for the 60-year-old.

  • The 30-year-old's credit is $345 − $250 = $95, and the benchmark plan costs $250 after the credit.
  • The 60-year-old's credit is $810 − $250 = $560, and the benchmark plan also costs $250 after the credit.

Even though the sticker prices differ by $465 a month ($810 − $345), the amount each person pays for the benchmark plan is the same. A cheaper or more expensive plan than the benchmark moves the amount up or down by the difference in price. The post what is the benchmark plan, and why does my credit follow it, not my plan? works through how the yardstick operates, and the guide How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share gives the formula.

People above 400% of the poverty level do not receive the credit, so they see the full effect of age and area. As of November 2026, the cutoff for 2027 coverage is $63,840 for a single person and $132,000 for a family of four, based on the 2026 poverty guidelines. Older shoppers just above the line are the group most exposed to the 3-to-1 ratio. If you are near it, the ACA subsidy estimator shows what happens at your income.

How the prices get set

Insurers file proposed rates with state regulators and, in many states, with the federal government, and the regulators review them. The review process, called rate review, looks at whether the increases are reasonable, and the outcome can differ from what the insurer first asked for. The guide why health insurance premiums rise every year covers the reasons premiums rise. Age and area factors are part of the filing: the insurer proposes factors, and regulators check them against the rules.

Rates change each year. In plan year 2027, KFF reports that the average benchmark silver premium rises about 13%, which on a national level means the typical base price in the tables above would be higher next year than this year, even before you age a year.

When you get a quote that looks wrong

A short list of checks resolves most puzzles:

  1. Confirm the age, ZIP code and tobacco answer used in the quote. A wrong ZIP can put you in a different rating area.
  2. Confirm the household the quote covers.
  3. Check the plan's name, metal level and variant, and whether the number is before or after the credit.
  4. Check the date of the quote and the plan year.
  5. Compare in the marketplace itself. A navigator can walk through it, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs covers what to compare besides price.

For rules specific to your state, such as its own age bands, a bar on tobacco surcharges, or a state subsidy, the state insurance department and the state marketplace are the sources. How the ACA marketplace works: HealthCare.gov and state exchanges explains how the pieces fit together.

Key takeaways

  • For individual and small-group plans, only age, rating area, tobacco use and family size may change the price of a given plan.
  • Adults' prices can range up to three times the youngest adult's price, and a tobacco user can be charged up to 50% more in most states.
  • Health, sex, claims history and pre-existing conditions are not allowed to affect the price.
  • Credits are built on the benchmark plan and depend on income, so they often shrink the difference between ages and areas, but not for people above 400% of the poverty level and not for tobacco surcharges.
  • When two quotes differ, check plan, variant, ZIP code, household, year and whether the figure is before or after the credit.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic