Blog

How a medical loss ratio rebate is calculated, with a worked example

A worksheet for the insurer rebate formula: premiums, claims and quality spending, the 80% or 85% floor, three-year averaging, and who receives the money.

A letter or a small check arrives from your health insurer. It calls the payment a medical loss ratio rebate and says little about where the number came from. The formula is not complicated, but the notice rarely shows it. This post walks through it with round, invented numbers so you can see how a rebate is built, who is entitled to it and what you can check.

The short version: the Affordable Care Act (ACA) requires most health insurers to spend at least a set share of premium dollars on medical care and quality improvement. If an insurer falls short over a three-year period, it owes the difference back to policyholders as rebates, paid once a year.

What the medical loss ratio is

The medical loss ratio (MLR) is the share of premium revenue an insurer spends on two things: claims for medical care, and activities that improve the quality of care. What is left over covers administration, marketing, profit and reserves.

The ACA sets minimum MLR floors:

Some states set a higher floor for a market segment, and some states obtained adjusted standards for their individual markets, so your state's number may differ. The notice or your state insurance department can say.

The rule applies to each insurer, in each state and each market segment, separately. A company that is above the floor in one state and below it in another owes rebates only in the second.

What the rule counts

  • Premium revenue, adjusted. Premiums earned, minus certain federal and state taxes and fees. The result is sometimes called adjusted premium or premium after taxes.
  • Claims. Payments to providers for covered services.
  • Quality improvement activities. Spending the rules define as improving health outcomes, preventing readmissions, improving patient safety or promoting wellness and health information that supports those goals. Which activities qualify is set by regulation.

What does not count as claims or quality spending: most overhead, sales commissions and general administrative costs. Critics argue the categories give insurers room to classify spending favorably and that the rule can blunt the incentive to bargain prices down, because a larger spending base earns a larger margin in dollar terms. Supporters answer that the floor guarantees a minimum share of premiums goes to care, and that the rebates return money when it does not. Both points are made in policy debates, and neither changes how the arithmetic works.

The three-year average

An insurer's results can bounce around from year to year. A flu season, a large claim or a pandemic year can swing the ratio. To smooth that, the MLR is computed on a three-year average: the sums of the three most recent years of adjusted premiums and of claims plus quality spending, divided as one fraction. It is not an average of three percentages. Years with more premium weigh more.

Very small insurers, those with few members in a state and segment, are subject to credibility adjustments or are excluded because their results are too erratic to judge; mid-sized books of business get an adjustment that can reduce the rebate. The formulas are in federal regulations, and the notice or the insurer can explain how credibility applied.

The worksheet, with a worked example

All figures are hypothetical, rounded and invented. They show the mechanism and are not any insurer's results. Say an insurer's small-group business in one state looks like this.

Step 1: List premiums and taxes for each of the three years.

Year Premiums earned Taxes and fees Adjusted premium
Year 1 $880,000 $80,000 $800,000
Year 2 $990,000 $90,000 $900,000
Year 3 $1,100,000 $100,000 $1,000,000
Total $2,700,000

Check: 880,000 - 80,000 = 800,000; 990,000 - 90,000 = 900,000; 1,100,000 - 100,000 = 1,000,000; and 800,000 + 900,000 + 1,000,000 = 2,700,000.

Step 2: List claims and quality spending for each year.

Year Claims Quality spending Total counted
Year 1 $610,000 $30,000 $640,000
Year 2 $660,000 $30,000 $690,000
Year 3 $735,000 $35,000 $770,000
Total $2,100,000

Check: 640,000 + 690,000 + 770,000 = 2,100,000.

Step 3: Compute each year's ratio for reference. Total counted divided by adjusted premium.

  • Year 1: 640,000 / 800,000 = 80.00%
  • Year 2: 690,000 / 900,000 = 76.67%
  • Year 3: 770,000 / 1,000,000 = 77.00%

Step 4: Compute the three-year MLR. Add the numerators and the denominators: 2,100,000 / 2,700,000 = 0.7778, or 77.78%.

Step 5: Compare with the floor. This is small group, so the floor is 80%. The insurer is below it by 80% - 77.78% = 2.22 percentage points (more exactly, 2.2222).

Step 6: Convert the shortfall to a rebate percentage and apply it to the latest year. The rebate is the shortfall multiplied by the most recent year's adjusted premium: 0.022222 x 1,000,000 = $22,222 in total for this insurer's small-group business in this state.

Notice what the averaging did. If you looked at Year 3 alone, the ratio is 77.00%, a shortfall of 3.00 points, and the rebate would be 0.03 x 1,000,000 = $30,000. Because Year 1 was at 80% and pulled the average up, the three-year result produces a smaller rebate. In a different history, averaging could produce a larger rebate. The rule neither helps nor hurts consistently.

Dollar check from another angle: to reach 80% of the three years' $2,700,000, the insurer would have needed $2,160,000 of counted spending. It had $2,100,000, so it was $60,000 short over three years. The rebate is $22,222 rather than $60,000 because the formula, as described here, applies the three-year shortfall percentage to a single year's premium. If your notice seems to treat this differently, ask the insurer to explain its method in writing.

Step 7: Divide the rebate among policyholders in proportion to their premium. The percentage, 2.2222%, applies to what each policyholder paid in the latest year. That is the same as saying each policyholder gets 1/45 of its premium (0.022222 = 1/45).

Why many policyholders get nothing

Most years, most insurers in most states and segments meet the floor, so most policyholders never see a rebate notice. Reasons you might not get one:

  • The insurer's three-year ratio was at or above the floor in your state and market segment.
  • The insurer's book of business was too small for the result to count, or the credibility adjustment erased the shortfall.
  • Your coverage is self-funded, a government program or another type the commercial rule does not reach.

Rebates are calculated after the end of a year, once the insurer reports its figures to federal regulators, and federal rules set a late-September deadline for paying them. That is why a rebate can arrive long after the premiums it relates to. If you changed plans or jobs in the meantime, ask the insurer or your former employer how it handles former members.

Your own numbers: a blank worksheet

Copy this and fill in the blanks from your notice or by asking the insurer.

  1. Market segment (individual, small group, large group): ________
  2. Floor for that segment and state: ______ %
  3. Insurer's three-year MLR, from the notice: ______ %
  4. Shortfall: (line 2) - (line 3) = ______ percentage points
  5. Premium you paid in the reporting year: $ ______
  6. Estimated rebate: (line 4 as a decimal) x (line 5) = $ ______
  7. Rebate stated on the notice: $ ______
  8. Difference: ______

If line 8 is small, the notice is consistent with the formula; credibility adjustments and the base the insurer uses for premium can explain small gaps. If it is large, ask the insurer to show the calculation, or ask your state insurance department.

Example 1: an individual buyer

Say Alex bought an individual plan from an insurer whose individual-market floor in the state is 80%, and suppose that insurer's three-year MLR was also 77.78% (we use the same figure to keep the arithmetic familiar). Alex paid $450 a month for 12 months in the reporting year: 12 x 450 = $5,400.

  • Shortfall: 2.2222 percentage points.
  • Rebate: 0.022222 x 5,400 = $120.00.

Alex's insurer must pay the rebate. For individual policies it may do so by a check or deposit, or by a reduction in a premium, depending on its process. If Alex received premium tax credits, how a rebate interacts with the credit and with taxes is a question for a tax professional or the marketplace, not something to guess at. See why health insurance premiums rise every year for why premiums change from year to year.

Example 2: a small business with an insured group plan

Say a business with 12 employees has a fully insured small-group plan from the same insurer. Total premiums for the year were $60,000, of which the employer paid 70% ($42,000) and employees paid 30% ($18,000 through payroll deductions). Check: 42,000 + 18,000 = 60,000.

  • Rebate at 2.2222%: 60,000 x 0.022222 = $1,333.33 (60,000 / 45).
  • Employees' share of premiums: 18,000 / 60,000 = 30%, so about 30% of the rebate, or $400.00, is attributable to what employees paid.
  • Employer's share: 1,333.33 - 400.00 = $933.33.

If the business were in the large-group market, the floor would be 85% and the shortfall for the same 77.78% ratio would be 85% - 77.78% = 7.2222 points. The rebate would be 60,000 x 0.072222 = $4,333.33 (about $1,300 attributable to employees, 30% of that). Large groups are the more common recipients because the floor is higher, but the formula is identical.

Who gets the money in a group plan

The rebate is paid to the policyholder, which is the employer. When employees paid part of the premium, federal guidance says the portion attributable to employees' contributions is generally to be used for their benefit. Employers commonly do one of three things with that portion: pay it to employees as cash, apply it to reduce future employee premium contributions, or use it for other benefits for plan participants. The details depend on whether the plan is subject to ERISA, whether it is a governmental or church plan and what the plan documents say. Ask your benefits adviser or the plan administrator how your employer handles it; the Department of Labor publishes guidance on the topic.

Self-funded employer plans do not generate these rebates, because the employer rather than an insurer pays claims and there is no insurer premium to measure; see self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you and self-funded plan. A fully insured plan does.

Tax treatment varies. A rebate may be taxable to employees in some circumstances, may reduce an employer's deduction for premiums or may interact with a premium tax credit. Ask a tax professional before assuming either way.

What you can do with a rebate and what to check

  1. Read the notice. It should say the reporting year, the insurer's MLR, how it was computed and how the rebate is paid.
  2. Run the blank worksheet above.
  3. Ask how you will be paid. For an employer plan, ask the employer.
  4. Decide how to use it. For individuals: pay down medical bills, build a health savings account if eligible or reduce next year's premium. For small employers: consider how to share the employee portion fairly, and document the decision.
  5. Keep records for tax time and for any later question.
  6. Do not read a rebate as a verdict on your plan. An insurer that owes a rebate may have had a good or bad year in claims, and an insurer that does not may still raise premiums. The MLR is one blunt measure among many. For how premiums are set, see how state rate review decides whether my premium increase is allowed. For small business owners weighing group plan options, see Health insurance for small business owners: group plans, ICHRA and credits.

Key takeaways

  • The MLR rule requires insurers to spend at least 80% (individual and small group) or 85% (large group) of premium revenue, after taxes and fees, on claims and quality improvement, with states sometimes setting a different floor.
  • The ratio is measured over three years, and the rebate is the shortfall percentage applied to the latest year's premium, so averaging can raise or lower a rebate.
  • In the worked example, a 77.78% ratio against an 80% floor gives a 2.22 point shortfall, a $120 rebate on $5,400 of individual premium and $1,333.33 on a $60,000 group plan.
  • In a group plan the employer receives the rebate, but the portion attributable to employees' contributions is generally to be used for their benefit; ask the plan administrator and a tax professional.
  • If your notice does not match the worksheet, ask the insurer to show its calculation or contact your state insurance department.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic