Blog

Medicare approved amount and excess charges: why a doctor billed me extra

How assignment, participating status and the limiting charge set what a doctor may bill under Original Medicare, with a $200 example and how to question a bill.

A Medicare patient finishes a visit, Medicare pays its share, and a bill arrives for more than the expected 20 percent. The difference is sometimes an excess charge: an amount a doctor billed above what Medicare approves for the service. Excess charges are legal in some situations and prohibited in others, and the rules depend on a few labels most patients have never heard: assignment, participating, non-participating and opt-out. Which label your doctor carries decides whether a bill above Medicare's approved amount is allowed, how large it can be, and who you should call about it.

This explainer defines the terms, works through a $200 service three ways with exact arithmetic, describes how Medigap and Medicare Advantage change the picture, and gives a method for checking a bill that looks too high. The numbers in the example are illustrations. Dollar amounts for the Medicare deductible and premium change every year, and Medicare.gov holds the current figures.

Start with the Medicare-approved amount

Original Medicare, meaning Part A and Part B, does not pay whatever a doctor charges. For each service, Medicare sets an approved amount: the fee it considers appropriate. For doctors' services, the approved amount comes from a fee schedule. After you meet the Part B deductible for the year, Medicare pays 80 percent of the approved amount and you owe the other 20 percent as coinsurance. As of 2026, the Part B deductible is $283, according to CMS's fact sheet; the 2027 figure had not been announced as of November 2026, so check Medicare.gov.

Everything that follows is a story about who may charge you more than the approved amount, and how much more.

Three labels that decide the rules

Participating providers (they accept assignment on every claim)

A doctor who signs a participation agreement with Medicare agrees to accept the Medicare-approved amount as full payment for all covered services for all Medicare patients. That is called accepting assignment. The provider bills Medicare directly, receives 80 percent from Medicare and may collect only the deductible and the 20 percent coinsurance from you. No excess charge is allowed. The accepting assignment entry is the short definition.

Non-participating providers (they may accept assignment case by case)

A non-participating doctor has not signed the agreement but still treats Medicare patients and can decide, claim by claim, whether to accept assignment. There are two possibilities.

  • If they accept assignment on a claim, they are paid like participating providers, with one difference: the Medicare fee schedule amount for non-participating providers is 95 percent of the participating amount. You still owe the 20 percent, calculated on the lower amount.
  • If they do not accept assignment, they may charge you more than the approved amount, up to a cap called the limiting charge. The limiting charge for most doctors' services is 115 percent of the non-participating fee schedule amount. The difference between what the doctor charges and the approved amount is the excess charge, and you owe it. The doctor must still submit the claim to Medicare for covered services.

The limiting charge is a ceiling. A non-participating doctor who does not accept assignment may not bill more than that cap for the covered service. The cap applies to most physician and many practitioner services but not to every type of supplier or item, such as certain equipment and supplies, so a bill from a different kind of supplier follows its own rules.

Opt-out providers (they have left Medicare)

A small number of doctors formally opt out of Medicare for two years at a time. These doctors enter private contracts with each patient, and Medicare pays nothing for those services. The doctor sets the price, and the limiting charge does not apply. They must give you a written contract before treatment explaining that Medicare will not pay. If you did not sign one and the doctor is an opt-out provider, ask the doctor and Medicare to explain.

Some states go further than the federal rules by limiting or prohibiting excess charges. Whether your state does is a question for your state's SHIP counselor (the State Health Insurance Assistance Program, which offers free Medicare counseling) or the state insurance department.

A $200 service, worked three ways

All figures are illustrations. Say the participating-provider Medicare-approved amount for a service is $200, and the patient has already met the Part B deductible for the year, so Medicare pays 80 percent and the patient owes coinsurance.

Case 1: A participating doctor

  • Approved amount: $200
  • Medicare pays 80 percent: $200 x 0.80 = $160
  • You pay 20 percent: $200 x 0.20 = $40
  • Total paid to the doctor: $160 + $40 = $200
  • Excess charge: $0

Case 2: A non-participating doctor who accepts assignment on this claim

  • Approved amount at 95 percent: $200 x 0.95 = $190
  • Medicare pays 80 percent: $190 x 0.80 = $152
  • You pay 20 percent: $190 x 0.20 = $38
  • Total to the doctor: $152 + $38 = $190
  • Excess charge: $0

Case 3: A non-participating doctor who does not accept assignment

  • Approved amount at 95 percent: $190
  • Limiting charge, 115 percent of $190: $190 x 1.15 = $218.50
  • Medicare pays 80 percent of the approved amount: $190 x 0.80 = $152
  • The doctor may charge you up to $218.50, so your maximum bill is $218.50 - $152 = $66.50
  • Of that, $38 is the ordinary 20 percent coinsurance and $28.50 is the excess charge ($218.50 - $190)

Side by side:

Medicare pays You pay at most Total to doctor
Participating $160.00 $40.00 $200.00
Non-participating, accepts assignment $152.00 $38.00 $190.00
Non-participating, no assignment $152.00 $66.50 $218.50

In this illustration, the most a patient could be asked to pay in excess of the participating case is $26.50 ($66.50 - $40). The excess charge is small per visit, but it can accumulate across a course of treatment, and a doctor who bills well above the limiting charge, or the full "usual" fee, is billing more than the law allows for a non-participating provider.

Where Medigap fits

medigap (Medicare Supplement insurance) is sold by private insurers to people with Original Medicare. It pays some or all of what Original Medicare leaves, depending on the lettered plan. The relevance here is the Part B excess charge: some Medigap plans pay it, and others do not. Plans F and G cover Part B excess charges, while plans such as N do not, and that difference can matter if you see non-participating doctors who do not accept assignment. Plan F is available only to people who were first eligible for Medicare before 2020, so most new enrollees choose among the others.

Using the Case 3 numbers, a person with a plan that covers excess charges and the coinsurance could owe nothing for the visit after the Part B deductible, while someone with a plan that covers coinsurance but not excess charges could still owe the $28.50. The guide to Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N and the medigap plan comparison chart show what each lettered plan covers. A related post, Part B excess charges: why some Medigap plans cover them and others don't, goes deeper into how the plans handle excess charges, and What does it mean when a doctor does not accept Medicare assignment? looks at the same situation from the patient's side of the desk.

Medigap does not work with Medicare Advantage. If you have an Advantage plan, a Medigap policy cannot be used with it, and the rules below apply instead.

How Medicare Advantage changes the rules

A Medicare Advantage plan (Medicare Advantage) replaces Original Medicare with a private plan that must cover what Original Medicare covers. The plan sets its own cost sharing, with copayments or coinsurance that may differ from the 20 percent, and has its own network and its own out-of-pocket maximum. The limiting-charge arithmetic above does not carry over. What you owe depends on the plan's rules and whether the provider is in the plan's network.

  • With an HMO-type plan, care from out-of-network providers is generally not covered except in emergencies and urgent situations, so a "billing extra" problem is more often "this visit was not covered."
  • With a PPO-type plan, out-of-network care may be covered at a higher cost to you, which is described in the plan's evidence of coverage.
  • A provider in the plan's network is bound by the plan's contract and generally cannot bill you above the plan's cost sharing.

If you are in an Advantage plan and receive a bill that looks like an excess charge, the questions go to the plan first, and the plan's member services can explain how it processed the claim. The comparison in Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two covers the structural difference. One pending item: a proposed rule for 2028 plans announced in October 2026 would address provider directory accuracy and in-network cost sharing when a listing was wrong, but a proposal is not yet a rule, so check Medicare.gov for its status.

How to question a bill that seems too high

Do this in order, and do not pay until you finish step four unless a payment is clearly correct.

  1. Find the Medicare Summary Notice (MSN). The MSN, mailed quarterly and available online, lists each service, the amount the provider charged, the Medicare-approved amount, the amount Medicare paid and a column labeled "Maximum You May Be Billed." That final figure is the most the provider may bill you for the service under the rules that apply to that claim. The post on How do I read my Medicare Summary Notice and spot billing errors? walks through it.
  2. Compare the bill to the MSN line. If the provider's bill exceeds the "Maximum You May Be Billed," the extra is not allowed. If the MSN shows that the provider did not accept assignment, the excess may be allowed up to the limit.
  3. Check whether the provider participates. Ask the doctor's office whether it participates in Medicare, and whether it accepted assignment on this claim. You can also look up the provider on Medicare.gov's physician tool, which shows participation status. Check the date you looked.
  4. Do the arithmetic. If the approved amount is X, the limiting charge is the approved amount times 1.15 for a non-participating provider who did not accept assignment, and 20 percent coinsurance applies to the approved amount. If the bill exceeds that total, ask for a corrected statement.
  5. Ask the provider to explain, in writing. Say that your MSN shows a maximum billable amount of $___ and that the bill is for $___, and ask them to correct it or to explain the basis. Some provider offices bill at their usual fee by mistake.
  6. Call Medicare or your SHIP counselor. A SHIP counselor can examine your MSN and the bill and tell you whether the charge is allowed in your state. The Medicare helpline, printed on your MSN and on Medicare.gov, can verify the claim. If a provider repeatedly bills more than the limit, Medicare can be told, and the guide on Medicare Parts A, B, C and D explained: what each part covers describes the program's structure.
  7. Do not sign a private contract on the spot. If a doctor presents a document stating that Medicare will not pay, find out whether the doctor has formally opted out and whether you have another choice. A signed private contract for that doctor's services means Medicare will not pay at all.

If you have both Medicare and Medicaid, or you qualify for a Medicare Savings Program with the Qualified Medicare Beneficiary designation, providers are generally not allowed to bill you for Medicare cost sharing at all. That is a different situation with its own protections, and the post A provider billed me even though I have QMB, so what do I do? describes it.

Mistakes that cost people money

  • Assuming "accepts Medicare" means "accepts assignment." A doctor can take Medicare patients and still be non-participating and not accept assignment.
  • Never asking about participation before a scheduled procedure, when the answer changes the bill.
  • Paying a bill without comparing it to the MSN.
  • Assuming Medigap covers everything. Check whether your lettered plan covers Part B excess charges.
  • Treating a Medicare Advantage bill as if the limiting charge applied.
  • Signing a private contract without understanding that Medicare will pay nothing.

When to get help

A SHIP counselor is the best first contact for a specific bill, since the counselor can see your coverage and your state's rules without a fee. Medicare's helpline can check what Medicare approved. If a provider refuses to correct a bill that exceeds the maximum, Medicare can be told, and for Advantage plans the plan's grievance process and the state insurance department are the next steps. Your Medigap insurer can explain what it will pay for a specific claim.

Key takeaways

  • Under Original Medicare, what you may owe above the Medicare-approved amount depends on whether the doctor participates, accepts assignment on the claim, or has opted out.
  • A non-participating doctor who does not accept assignment may bill up to the limiting charge, 115 percent of the non-participating fee schedule amount, for most physician services; in the $200 example the most you would owe is $66.50 against $40 for a participating doctor.
  • The Medicare Summary Notice shows a "Maximum You May Be Billed" figure for each service; a bill above it is a reason to ask for a correction.
  • Medigap plans differ on excess charges, and Medicare Advantage uses its own cost sharing instead of the limiting-charge rules.
  • A SHIP counselor can check a particular bill and tell you what your state adds.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic