Blog

A checklist for comparing Medigap quotes from different insurers

Four quotes for one Medigap letter rarely mean the same thing. A grouped checklist: pricing method, discounts, rate history, SELECT networks, insurer lookups.

When four insurers quote the same Medigap letter, the benefits are the same in most states, so the numbers should be easy to compare. They are not, because each quote bundles a different pricing method, a different set of discounts, a different set of assumptions about you and a different promise about the future. A checklist forces the quotes onto the same footing, so the one that looks cheapest is cheapest for the reasons you think it is.

Use the groups below in order. Each item says what to ask and why it matters. Write the answers next to each quote, and treat anything an agent cannot state in writing as unknown. None of this requires picking a company; it requires picking the right quote to take seriously.

Group 1: confirm the coverage is the same

  • Same letter and the same version. Plan G and high-deductible Plan G are different products with the same letter. So is a quote that quietly mixes Plan G and Plan N, which happens when two agents shorten the names. Why: a lower premium can be a policy that pays less. The medigap plan comparison chart shows what each letter pays.
  • Standard or Medicare SELECT. A SELECT policy uses a network of hospitals, and sometimes doctors, for full benefits. Why: it is often cheaper and can cost you if you use a hospital outside the network. More under Group 5.
  • State variations. Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin use their own standardized policies. Why: a letter name there may not mean what it means elsewhere.
  • The outline of coverage. Ask each insurer for it. It is a short standard document that lists what the policy pays. Why: it is the document you can compare line by line, and the quote is not.
  • The effective date. Quotes should be for the same start date. Why: a quote for next month and a quote for six months from now can differ because rates change on specific dates.

Group 2: how the premium is set

  • Pricing method. Attained-age, issue-age or community-rated. Why: it determines how the premium behaves in ten years. The post Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains the three and includes a ten-year illustration.
  • What the premium would be later. Ask for the premium at ages 70, 75 and 80 under current rate tables, if age is a factor. Why: the cheapest attained-age quote today may become the most expensive within a few years.
  • When the premium changes. On your birthday, on the policy anniversary or on January 1. Why: it affects your budget and tells you which kind of increase to expect.
  • Whether the quote is guaranteed. Ask whether the premium is subject to underwriting and could change after the application. Why: a quote based on an unverified answer can move after the insurer reviews your history.

Group 3: discounts and rating factors

  • Household discount. Many insurers reduce the premium when two people in a household both buy. Why: the discount may disappear if one person leaves the policy or dies. Ask what happens then.
  • Payment discount. Some insurers reduce the premium for automatic bank payments or annual payment. Why: the "listed" price may be before or after the discount; the quote should say which.
  • Tobacco and gender rating. Some insurers charge different rates by tobacco use or sex, and some states restrict this. Why: two quotes may rest on different assumptions about you. Check that each says whether you were quoted as a non-smoker.
  • ZIP code or county. Rates can vary by area, and quotes for a nearby ZIP code are not the same quote. Why: confirm each quote uses your actual ZIP code.
  • Rate class from underwriting. Some insurers place applicants in classes based on health. Why: where underwriting applies, your final rate may differ from the quote, in either direction.

Group 4: the increase history

  • Past rate changes on this exact policy. Ask for the percentage change in each of the last five years, and for the number of policyholders if the insurer will share it. Why: a good first-year price with steep annual increases costs more than a higher steady one.
  • Whether the insurer files rates with the state. In most states Medigap rates are filed with the state insurance department and reviewed. See rate review. Why: the filings, where public, show the requested and approved increases.
  • Whether the policy is open or closed. Some policies are no longer sold to new buyers, and their policyholders may be a shrinking and older group. Why: a closed block can see sharper increases over time. Ask whether the quote is for a policy currently being sold.
  • The loss ratio. Federal law sets minimum loss ratios for Medigap, which are shares of premium the insurer must spend on claims. Why: a regulator or the state department can tell you how an insurer compares, although a single year is a weak guide.

Group 5: Medicare SELECT and network versions

  • Which hospitals and doctors are in the network? Ask for the list and compare it with where you receive care. Why: with a SELECT policy you generally must use the network for the supplement to pay in full for non-emergency care; Medicare still pays its share either way.
  • What happens in an emergency or when traveling. Why: emergency care is covered at any facility, but you need to know how the policy treats care outside the network and outside the service area.
  • What happens if you move. If you move out of the network area, you may have rights to buy a different policy. Why: confirm the rules before choosing a policy whose savings depend on staying in one place.

Group 6: the insurer behind the quote

  • Complaint record. Ask the state insurance department for complaint data on the insurer, and read it for patterns such as claims payment, premium increases and service. how to compare health insurers: ratings, complaints and service explains where to look. Why: a company's price tells you nothing about what happens when you call.
  • Financial strength. Independent rating agencies publish financial-strength ratings for insurers; look up each insurer by its legal name and note the date of the rating. Why: a policy is a promise to pay for decades.
  • Who the agent is. Ask whether the agent sells for one insurer or many and how the agent is paid. Why: understanding the incentive helps you weigh the advice.
  • Your own record. If you have had an insurer before, note your own experience. Why: your history is data.

Do not use this group to name a winner. A high rating does not mean a low price, and a low complaint count does not mean a good fit. The point is to remove anything that would disqualify a quote on grounds the price does not show.

Group 7: underwriting and timing

  • Is this a guaranteed-issue application? Applications during the six-month open enrollment period, after losing other coverage in some situations and in some states' special windows are guaranteed. Why: if so, the insurer cannot decline you or charge more for health. See medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue.
  • If not, what will the insurer ask? Medical questions and a review of prescriptions are typical. Why: answer truthfully; a misstatement can be used to deny a claim or void the policy.
  • Overlap with an existing policy. If you are replacing a policy, do not cancel the old one until the new one is approved and has started. See Switching Medigap insurers to pay less without losing coverage.
  • The free look. New policies have a period to review and cancel. Why: confirm the length in writing.

A worked example with four quotes

Here is a hypothetical comparison for the same letter, with invented numbers. Say a household of one is quoted by four insurers. Annual totals are twelve times the monthly net.

Insurer Listed monthly premium Discount Net monthly Annual Pricing method Version
A $180 none $180.00 $2,160 Attained-age Standard
B $205 10% household $184.50 $2,214 Issue-age Standard
C $215 none $215.00 $2,580 Community-rated Standard
D $150 none $150.00 $1,800 Attained-age Medicare SELECT

The B discount works out as $205 × 0.10 = $20.50 off, so the net monthly is $184.50 and the annual is $184.50 × 12 = $2,214. Reading the table:

  • D is the cheapest by $360 a year, but it is a SELECT policy. The same insurer's standard version would be quoted at, say, $190, which makes D's network a $40-a-month decision, or $480 a year. Whether it is worth it depends on whether your hospitals are in the network.
  • A is the cheapest standard policy this year, but it is attained-age, so its price climbs with every birthday. B is $54 more a year today, but flat for age.
  • C is the most expensive this year and the only one that will never rise because you are older. For someone who expects to hold the policy for twenty years, the shape may matter more than the first year.
  • The B discount is only as good as the household that earns it. If the second person leaves, the net becomes $205, or $2,460 a year.

The table does not name a winner, and it should not. The point is that each line has a note that the price alone does not carry.

Running the comparison in practice

A comparison like this can be done in an afternoon if you set it up in a fixed order.

  1. Choose the letter first, using the chart and the guide Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N. Do not let a quote choose it for you.
  2. Request quotes with the same effective date, the same ZIP code, the same household and the same tobacco answer. Tell every insurer the same facts.
  3. Ask each one for the outline of coverage and the pricing method by email, so the answers are in writing.
  4. Fill in a table like the one above, adding a column for the premium at age 75 if the policy is age-rated.
  5. Cross out any quote you cannot explain in a sentence. A quote you cannot explain is a risk.
  6. Look up the complaint record and financial-strength rating for the remaining insurers, then decide.

Warning signs that deserve a pause rather than a rejection: a quote that is much lower than the rest and cannot be explained by a SELECT network or a high-deductible version; pressure to apply today; an agent who cannot or will not give the pricing method in writing; a reluctance to put the outline of coverage in front of you; and any suggestion that you cancel your current policy before the new one has started. None of these proves a problem, and each is a reason to slow down and ask the state insurance department or a SHIP counselor.

Keep a record

After you decide, keep the quote, the outline of coverage, the date, the name of the agent and the answers to your written questions. If the premium or terms do not match later, the record is what you use. If an insurer or agent misleads you, the state insurance department takes complaints; see how to file a complaint with your state insurance department. For general background on the policies, read Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N.

Key takeaways

  • A quote is a bundle: coverage, pricing method, discounts, rating assumptions and a promise about the future, and each part needs a written answer.
  • Confirm the letter, the version (standard, high-deductible or SELECT) and the effective date before comparing a single premium.
  • Compare quotes by pricing method over several years, and ask for the history of increases on the exact policy.
  • Treat discounts as conditional, and ask what happens if the household changes.
  • Look up each insurer's complaint record and financial-strength rating separately from price, and note the dates.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic