Blog
Medigap myths about drugs, dental, nursing homes and what it covers
Seven common beliefs about Medigap tested against how the standardized plans work, with a table of what they add to Original Medicare and what gaps remain.
Medigap has the unlucky distinction of a name that suggests it fills every gap. It does not. It fills a specific, narrow set of gaps in Original Medicare, mostly the cost sharing that Medicare itself defines, and it leaves the rest alone. Most disappointments with Medigap come from a belief that sounds reasonable and turns out to be wrong at the pharmacy counter, the dentist's desk or the nursing home admissions office.
This post takes seven beliefs one at a time, states each as a person might say it, checks it against how the standardized plans work, and says where the truth is more nuanced than "yes" or "no." A worked year and a table after the myths put it together.
The starting point: what Medigap is
Medigap is private insurance sold to people with Original Medicare. A federal framework standardizes ten plan letters, A through N, so the same letter covers the same benefits regardless of the company. A Medigap policy pays after Original Medicare pays, for services Medicare covers. It can pick up the Part A hospital deductible, the Part B 20% coinsurance, skilled nursing facility coinsurance, extra hospital days and, with certain letters, other items. It does not add new kinds of coverage that Medicare itself does not include. Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N has the full list, and the medigap plan comparison chart shows the letters side by side.
Keep one rule in mind and the myths become easy to test: Medigap follows Medicare. If Original Medicare does not cover a service, Medigap generally does not either.
Myth 1: "Medigap covers everything Medicare doesn't"
Tested. This is the broadest version of the belief, and it is wrong in both directions. Medigap covers some of what Original Medicare covers (the cost sharing) and almost nothing that Original Medicare excludes. The services that stay uncovered include routine dental care, eyeglasses, hearing aids, most long-term custodial care and private-duty nursing. The gap is not filled by Medigap at all.
The nuance. A few plan letters add foreign travel emergency coverage, with limits, and all letters add up to 365 extra days of hospital care over your lifetime after Medicare's benefits are used up. Those are real additions, but they are narrow, and they do not change the general rule. What Original Medicare does not cover: gaps to plan for lists the main gaps.
Myth 2: "Medigap covers my prescription drugs"
Tested. Not for a policy sold today. Medigap policies sold after 2005 cannot include prescription drug coverage, and drug coverage comes from a separate Medicare Part D plan, either stand-alone or inside a Medicare Advantage plan. A person who buys Medigap and no Part D plan has Medigap and no drug coverage. If they delay Part D without other creditable drug coverage, a late-enrollment penalty is added to the Part D premium for as long as they have the plan. The penalty is 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full month without creditable coverage, which is about $0.41 a month in 2027 on a base premium of $41.33, and it accumulates.
The nuance. Some very old Medigap policies, sold before 2006, did include limited drug benefits. Someone who still has one may have been told so, and the information is then right for them and wrong for a new buyer. For the real picture, read Medicare Part D and Medicare Part D explained: drug plans, formularies and costs, and compare plans every fall, because stand-alone drug plan premiums and formularies change each year.
Myth 3: "Medigap pays for a nursing home"
Tested. It pays what Medicare pays toward the same stay, and nothing for custodial care. Original Medicare covers a limited stay in a skilled nursing facility after a qualifying hospital stay, for skilled care like rehabilitation, not for long-term help with bathing, dressing or supervision. Medicare pays in full for days 1 to 20 and requires daily coinsurance from day 21 through day 100, which was $217.00 a day in 2026. Many Medigap plans cover that coinsurance. After day 100, Medicare pays nothing, and so does Medigap.
The nuance. The skilled-stay coverage is real money for the weeks it applies, and for someone recovering from surgery it can matter a lot. It simply is not long-term care. Paying for a nursing home over months or years falls to the person, to long-term care insurance if they have it, or to Medicaid after they meet its rules. Does Medicare pay for nursing home care and home care? and Does Medicare really pay for 100 days of nursing home care? walk through the 100-day rule.
Myth 4: "Medigap covers dental, vision and hearing"
Tested. No. Original Medicare excludes routine dental care, routine eye exams and glasses, and hearing aids, with narrow exceptions such as certain dental work tied to another covered procedure. Because Medigap follows Medicare, it does not add these either.
The nuance. Some people get dental, vision or hearing through a Medicare Advantage plan's extras, a separate stand-alone plan or a discount program, or through Medicaid in some states. Each comes with its own limits and costs. Does Medicare cover dental, vision and hearing care? sets out the options. The point for a Medigap buyer is that this coverage is a separate decision with a separate price.
Myth 5: "Medigap works with Medicare Advantage"
Tested. It does not. A Medigap policy supplements Original Medicare. A Medicare Advantage plan replaces Original Medicare with a private plan that has its own cost sharing, so there is no Medicare cost sharing left for Medigap to cover. It is generally unlawful for a company to sell a Medigap policy to someone it knows is in a Medicare Advantage plan.
The nuance. A person who wants Medigap after Advantage must return to Original Medicare, and may face medical underwriting unless a guaranteed-issue right applies. KFF estimated that 74% of people in Medicare Advantage have a health condition that could lead to a Medigap denial outside the protected windows, a reason to think about the choice before the first year rather than after it.
Myth 6: "A Medigap plan costs the same everywhere" and "a bigger-name insurer pays more"
Tested. These are two beliefs with one answer. The benefits of a lettered plan are the same from every company, so a Plan G from one insurer pays the same Medicare cost sharing as a Plan G from another, with the exception of Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin, which use their own standardized formats. A larger or better-known company does not pay more of your Medicare bill. The price is not standardized, and it varies by company, state, ZIP code, age, tobacco use and how the company prices over time.
The nuance. KFF's national averages for 2025 put the average Medigap premium at $244 a month across all plans and $194 a month for Plan G, with Plan G averages ranging from $164 in New Mexico to $257 in New York. Those are averages across states and companies, not quotes. What differs between insurers are the premium, the way it rises, available discounts, the customer service and claims handling, and the company's financial footing. A checklist for comparing Medigap quotes from different insurers shows how to compare quotes for the same letter, and Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains why a premium that looks low at 65 may climb faster than another.
Myth 7: "I can always buy Medigap later, when I need it"
Tested. This one sounds like common sense, because most insurance is bought before the need arises, and Medigap is no different. The difference is that its protection is concentrated in a single window. During the six months after you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, insurers must sell you any policy they offer. Afterward, in most states, the insurer can look at your health history, and a person who needs a supplement most is the person most likely to be refused or charged more.
The nuance. Some states relax this: Connecticut and New York have continuous guaranteed issue, and others have annual or birthday-based windows for certain people. Specific events, such as a Medicare Advantage plan ending in your area, create their own guaranteed rights with short deadlines. But "later" is not a safe default in most places. medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue explains the windows, and Can a Medigap insurer turn me down after my open enrollment ends? covers what happens when you apply after one closes.
A worked year with and without Medigap
To see what "following Medicare" means in dollars, take a hypothetical person, Sam, with Original Medicare in 2026. In that year Sam has one hospital admission and some follow-up outpatient care. The figures below use Medicare's published 2026 amounts for the deductibles and an invented outpatient bill.
- Part A inpatient deductible for the stay: $1,736.
- Part B deductible: $283.
- Outpatient and doctor services, approved by Medicare at $2,000 for the year.
The Part B coinsurance is 20% of the approved amount above the deductible: $2,000 - $283 = $1,717, and 0.20 x $1,717 = $343.40.
| Scenario | What Sam owes for these services |
|---|---|
| Original Medicare alone | $1,736 + $283 + $343.40 = $2,362.40 |
| Original Medicare with Plan A | $1,736 + $283 = $2,019 (Plan A pays the 20% but not the hospital deductible) |
| Original Medicare with Plan G | $283 (Plan G pays the hospital deductible and the 20%, not the Part B deductible) |
None of these totals includes premiums, which differ by plan and company, or any service Medicare does not cover. They show what the myths hide: the benefit of Medigap is in the cost-sharing lines, and the same plan does nothing for a dental bill or a drug fill that never entered Medicare's calculation.
The same facts in one table
| What you might need | Original Medicare alone | What Medigap adds | Gap that remains |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hospital stay | Part A deductible per benefit period ($1,736 in 2026) | Most letters pay all or part of the Part A deductible (Plan A does not); every letter adds up to 365 extra hospital days | The Part A deductible under Plan A, and the unpaid share under Plans K, L and M |
| Doctor visits, outpatient care | 20% coinsurance after the Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) | Part B coinsurance in most plans; Plans F and G also cover excess charges | Part B deductible in most plans; Plan N may have visit copays |
| Skilled nursing facility | Days 1-20 paid; $217.00 a day for days 21-100 (2026) | Most plans pay the daily coinsurance | Everything after day 100; custodial care |
| Prescription drugs | Outpatient drugs under Part B only | Nothing for drugs on new policies | Separate Part D plan needed |
| Dental, routine vision, hearing aids | Not covered | Nothing | All of it, unless bought separately |
| Long-term care at home or in a facility | Not covered | Nothing | All of it |
| Care outside the U.S. | Almost never covered | Limited emergency coverage in several letters | Everything above the plan's limits |
| Medicare Advantage | Replaces Original Medicare | Cannot be used with it | Not applicable |
Plan details differ by letter, so check the exact letter. The table is a summary, and the medigap plan comparison chart shows which letter pays which line.
How to test any claim you hear
Salespeople, relatives and websites say confident things about Medigap. A simple three-question test works on almost all of them:
- Does Original Medicare cover the service at all? If not, Medigap will not.
- Which plan letter? Many claims are true for one letter and false for another.
- Is the claim about benefits or about price? Benefits are standardized, prices are not.
If an answer matters to a decision, ask the free, non-commissioned source: your state's SHIP counseling program or the state insurance department, and confirm any figure from a salesperson against the plan's outline of coverage, which every company must provide.
Key takeaways
- Medigap follows Original Medicare: it pays cost sharing on covered services and does not add drugs, dental, vision, hearing or long-term care.
- Drug coverage comes from Part D, and delaying it without creditable coverage adds a penalty that lasts.
- Skilled nursing facility coverage ends after day 100, and custodial care is not covered by Medicare or Medigap.
- Medigap cannot be used with Medicare Advantage, and returning to Original Medicare may mean underwriting.
- A lettered plan pays the same benefits from every company; the price, the way it rises and the service differ.