Blog
Can I buy Medigap if I'm under 65 and on Medicare for disability?
Answers on Medigap for people under 65 on Medicare through disability: state rules, enrollment windows, prices, what changes at 65 and the alternatives.
The short answer is that it depends on your state, and the reason is that federal law does not require insurers to sell Medigap to people under 65. A state has to require it. Most do: 38 states require insurers to sell at least one Medigap policy to people under 65 during an initial open enrollment period, according to KFF's 2026 review of the federal and state rules. In the other states, a company may choose to sell policies to younger people, but you may have no right to buy one.
Many people on Medicare through disability hear "there is no Medigap for you" from a broker or a phone line, and sometimes that is true for their state and sometimes it is incomplete. The questions below walk through what is usually asked, in the order people tend to ask it.
Whether Medigap is available to you
Is Medigap available to people under 65 at all?
Medigap is a set of standardized private policies that pay some of what Original Medicare leaves you with: the Part A hospital deductible, Part B coinsurance and, depending on the letter, other pieces. Federal law sets the benefits of each plan letter. It does not say that every insurer must offer every letter to every age group.
For people under 65 the main rules come from the state. As of the 2026 KFF summary, 38 states require insurers to sell at least one Medigap policy to people under 65 during an initial open enrollment period. The remaining states leave it to each insurer, and some insurers there sell policies to younger people while others do not. Because the list of states and the details change, check the current rule with your state insurance department or your SHIP counselor, not with a sales call.
What does "required to sell at least one policy" mean in practice?
It means a floor, not a menu. In many states that require it, the guaranteed policy may be limited to one plan letter or a short list, and it is often the basic one. It does not mean you can pick any letter from any company. The insurers that are required to offer a policy may charge more for people under 65 than for people 65 and older, and some states regulate how much more.
So even in a state with a requirement, ask three things: which plan letters must be offered to people under 65, which companies are offering them, and what each charges for your age and ZIP code. The medigap plan comparison chart shows what each letter covers once you know which ones you can get.
Windows and underwriting
When is my open enrollment window?
For people 65 and older, the federal rule is a one-time six-month Medigap open enrollment period that begins the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During it, an insurer cannot refuse you or charge more because of health conditions.
For people under 65, the window is set by the state, and the usual pattern is that it begins when you enroll in Part B. Some states set the length differently, and some add extra windows. If you were approved for Social Security disability benefits, you generally become eligible for Medicare after 24 months of disability benefits, with exceptions for certain conditions, so the Medigap window usually begins when your Part B starts, not when your disability began. If you already have Part B and have not looked at Medigap, find out now whether your state's window is still open. Windows do not stop and restart because you have been busy. medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue covers the general idea of the window and the guaranteed-issue rights that sit around it.
Can a company turn me down because of my health?
Inside your state's open enrollment window, no, assuming your state gives you one and you apply for a policy the insurer sells. Outside it, in most states an insurer may use medical underwriting, which can mean denial, a higher price or an exclusion for conditions you already have. People on Medicare through disability often have conditions that underwriting would flag, which is why the window matters more for them than for most people.
Ask each insurer, before you fill in a form, whether you are applying under open enrollment or under regular underwriting. The questions on the application will look different. An application during a guaranteed window should not ask for the sort of medical history that decides whether you are accepted.
Price and renewal
Why is the price higher than the prices I see for older people?
People under 65 on Medicare are a smaller group than the 65-and-older group, and as a group they tend to use more care. Insurers price Medigap for the pool they expect, so premiums for younger beneficiaries can be notably higher than for the same letter at 65, and sometimes the gap is large. How an insurer sets its price also matters: policies priced by attained age, issue age or community rating behave differently over time. Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains the three methods.
A few states have rules to limit the difference. Whether yours does is a question for the state insurance department. If the price is steep, ask the same insurer whether it sells a different letter, ask a second insurer for the same letter, and compare the total yearly cost with what you spend in an average year.
Does buying at a younger age lock me into the plan?
Medigap policies are guaranteed renewable: as long as you pay the premium, the insurer cannot cancel for health reasons. The price can change, and how it changes depends on the pricing method and the state. Having a policy under 65 also does not use up the federal window at 65.
What changes at 65
What happens when I turn 65?
You get a federal Medigap open enrollment period of six months, starting the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, whether or not you bought a policy before. During it, insurers in every state must sell you any Medigap policy they offer, at the same price they charge others of your age, health and tobacco status, regardless of health conditions. For many people on disability that is the first time every letter is available at a fair price.
That makes turning 65 a planning date even if you have no Medigap now. Some people deliberately wait for it. The tradeoff is that you could go years without a supplement and have to pay the Part B 20% and the hospital deductibles yourself in the meantime. I've had Medicare through disability and I'm turning 65, so what changes? covers the other changes at that birthday, such as the end of the disability basis for Medicare and the way job-based coverage interacts with Medicare.
If Medigap is not open to you
If my state does not require Medigap, what are my options?
You have several choices, and none of them is as simple as buying a standardized policy:
- Ask whether any insurer in your state voluntarily sells to people under 65 and on what terms.
- Look at Medicare Advantage, which does not depend on a Medigap rule. A Medicare Advantage plan is a private plan that replaces Original Medicare. Advantage plans generally take people with Medicare through disability, and since 2021 people with end-stage renal disease can generally join one too.
- Check whether you qualify for a Medicare Savings Program or Medicaid, either of which can pay your cost sharing. Many people on disability have low incomes. Health insurance with a disability: Medicare, Medicaid and SSDI explains how Medicare, Medicaid and SSDI fit together.
- Consider employer or retiree coverage, if you or a spouse have it, which may wrap around Medicare.
Is Medicare Advantage the alternative, and what are the tradeoffs?
Medicare Advantage is the main alternative, and it comes with its own set of choices. In its favor: no Medigap underwriting, a cap on what you can pay out of pocket in a year, and often drug coverage and extras in the same plan. Against it: networks, prior authorization, and less freedom to see any doctor who takes Medicare. For a person with a complex condition who sees several specialists, the network question can decide everything.
The other cost of choosing Advantage is that a later move back to Original Medicare may not bring a Medigap policy with it unless you are in a guaranteed window. KFF estimated that 74% of people in Medicare Advantage have a health condition that could lead to a denial of a Medigap policy outside the protected windows. Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two lays out how to compare the two for your situation.
Can I switch between Advantage and Original Medicare?
Yes, within the usual enrollment periods: the Annual Enrollment Period from October 15 to December 7, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31 for people already in a plan, and special enrollment periods for qualifying events. Switching from Advantage to Original does not by itself bring Medigap eligibility. That is the point to confirm in your state before you drop a plan.
Special situations
Does the rule differ if I qualify through kidney failure or ALS?
It can. Medicare's waiting period and eligibility differ for end-stage renal disease and for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and some state Medigap rules treat reasons for being under 65 differently. Ask your state insurance department whether the under-65 rule applies to your reason for Medicare, and ask your SHIP counselor to walk through the timing, because the open enrollment window usually begins with Part B and the Part B date depends on the path.
What if I am denied a policy outside the window?
Ask the insurer for the reason in writing. Then ask a second and a third company, because underwriting rules differ by company, and ask your state insurance department whether your state has a guaranteed-issue rule for your situation. In some states the department can tell you which insurers are required to sell to people under 65 and which are not. If you have a Medigap-related complaint, the department is where it goes.
What should I have ready when I call insurers?
A short list keeps the calls comparable, and it keeps a salesperson from steering the conversation:
- The date your Part A and Part B began, as shown on your Medicare card or your Social Security letter.
- Your state of residence and ZIP code, because prices are set by area.
- The plan letter or letters you want quoted, so every company prices the same benefits.
- A direct question: "Am I applying under open enrollment, or under regular underwriting?"
- A request for the rate in writing, including how the company sets future increases: by attained age, issue age or community rating.
Write down the name of the person you spoke with and the date. If you later think you were told something wrong about your rights, that record helps when you bring it to the state insurance department.
Getting a real answer for your state
Who can look at my situation and give me the real answer?
Two groups are free and do not sell policies. Your state's SHIP program has trained counselors who explain Medicare and Medigap rules in your state, and the state insurance department regulates the insurers and can tell you what is required in your state. A licensed insurance agent can also quote policies and does earn commissions, which is a reason to compare with the counselor's information. Bring your Medicare card, the date your Part B started and a list of your medicines and doctors to either conversation.
Key takeaways
- Federal law does not require Medigap for people under 65; 38 states require at least one policy during an initial open enrollment, and the rest leave it to insurers.
- Your window for guaranteed issue is usually tied to the start of Part B, and it can be short. Find out the dates now.
- Premiums for people under 65 are often higher, and the plan letters offered may be limited.
- At 65 you get a federal six-month Medigap open enrollment period even if you bought a policy earlier.
- Medicare Advantage and Medicaid or a Medicare Savings Program are the main alternatives, and your state insurance department or SHIP counselor can confirm the rules where you live.