Blog

My marketplace plan was discontinued and replaced. What should I check?

If you do nothing, the marketplace may move you to a replacement plan. Eight mistakes to avoid, a comparison table and the deadline to switch.

When an insurer stops selling a marketplace plan, the people enrolled in it do not simply lose coverage on December 31. If they take no action, the marketplace generally moves them into a replacement plan for the new year, a process called mapping or crosswalking. That protects against a gap, and it also creates a trap: the replacement can differ from the old plan in its network, its drug list, its price and its subsidy, and a person who assumes it does not can discover the difference in January, at a pharmacy counter or in a doctor's waiting room.

This post is built around the mistakes. Each entry says how the mistake happens, what it costs and how to avoid it. A comparison table follows, then a worked example of how the price can change, then the deadline question.

How the replacement is chosen

The rules are set by the federal and state marketplaces and differ in details. In broad terms, when an insurer discontinues a plan:

  • The insurer sends a notice, and the marketplace (HealthCare.gov or your state's exchange) usually sends one too. The notice names the replacement plan, or says that you will be moved if you do nothing.
  • The replacement is usually from the same insurer, if it still sells in your area, at a similar metal level and plan type. If that insurer is leaving entirely, the exchange may choose a plan from another insurer.
  • A federal protocol that once moved some Bronze enrollees to Silver plans ended for 2026 and remains unavailable for 2027, according to a secondary source read on November 16, 2026. A mapped plan is therefore less likely to change your metal level than in earlier years, but you should check on your own notice rather than assume.
  • If you take no action, you are enrolled in the replacement, and any advance premium tax credit is applied to it.

Automatic re-enrollment (automatic re-enrollment) is a convenience. It is not a recommendation, and it is not a promise that the new plan fits you. The guide what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area covers the larger picture, and the post my marketplace plan is being discontinued: what does plan mapping mean? explains the sequence of notices.

Mistake 1: Assuming the network is the same

How it happens. The replacement carries a similar name, the same insurer, even a similar price. People assume the doctors came with it. But networks are tied to specific plans, and an insurer may build a replacement plan on a narrower network, or a different one altogether.

What it costs. An out-of-network doctor can mean a much higher bill or no coverage at all, except for emergencies and the situations protected by the No Surprises Act. A specialist you see for an ongoing condition is the usual loss.

How to avoid it. Look up each of your doctors, your hospital and your pharmacy in the replacement plan's own directory, using the plan name and the network name printed on the notice. Then call the practices and ask whether they accept that plan for 2027. See how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs for the full comparison method.

Mistake 2: Assuming the drug list is the same

How it happens. The formulary belongs to the plan, not the insurer. A mapped plan can place the same medicine in a higher tier, require prior authorization, add a quantity limit or drop it.

What it costs. A medicine that cost a $20 copay can cost 30% coinsurance on the full price, or be denied at the counter.

How to avoid it. Look up each drug by its exact name, dose and form in the replacement plan's formulary. Write down the tier and any restriction. If it is restricted, ask your prescriber about a formulary exception before January. The guide what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need explains the process.

Mistake 3: Assuming the price is the old price

How it happens. The old plan's premium was $X. The notice shows a new premium, but it may be the full price before any credit, and people compare it with the old price after credit, or the reverse.

What it costs. Confusion in either direction. A person may see a large number and shop away from a plan that is affordable after the credit, or see a small one and miss that the credit has changed.

How to avoid it. Compare the same line on both plans: the monthly premium after any advance premium tax credit. Check whether the old plan's figure is for 2026 and the new plan's for 2027. For plan year 2027, KFF reports that average benchmark silver premiums rise about 13% (corrected November 6, 2026), so higher gross premiums are common.

Mistake 4: Assuming the subsidy follows automatically

How it happens. The premium tax credit is not tied to your plan. It is based on your household income, your household size and the premium of the benchmark plan, the second-lowest-cost Silver plan in your area (benchmark plan). When the plan lineup changes, the benchmark can change, and the credit changes with it. The application also carries forward last year's income estimate unless you update it.

What it costs. A credit that is too high is repaid at tax time. The cap on repaying excess advance credit was eliminated for tax years after 2025 (Public Law 119-21, section 71305, according to the KFF source in the facts sheet), so for tax year 2026 and after the full excess is owed, with no cap tied to income. A credit that is too low means paying more each month than you needed to.

How to avoid it. Update your marketplace application with your expected 2027 income, household members and any changes since last year, even if you plan to keep the mapped plan. The guide How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share explains the formula, and Repaying excess premium tax credits: reconciliation and Form 8962 explains what happens at filing.

For plan year 2027, the share of income you are expected to contribute toward the benchmark plan ranges from 2.15% to 10.22% depending on income, according to the IRS table for 2027 (Rev. Proc. 2026-26). Credits end above 400% of the federal poverty level, which for 2027 coverage is $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four.

Mistake 5: Assuming the cost sharing and the extra help are the same

How it happens. Two Silver plans, or two Bronze plans, can have very different deductibles, copays and out-of-pocket maximums within the same metal level. And if you qualify for cost-sharing reduction, the extra help that lowers your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum applies only if you are in a Silver plan.

What it costs. A higher deductible than the old plan, or a loss of cost-sharing reductions if the mapped plan is not Silver. For 2027, the reduced out-of-pocket limits for those variants are $4,000 for one person at income of 100% to 200% of poverty, and $9,600 at 200% to 250% (the federal limit for all plans is $12,000 for one person), per the CMS guidance for 2027.

How to avoid it. Compare the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum and the copays for the services you use, and check that the plan shows the cost-sharing variant that matches your income.

Mistake 6: Not shopping because the mapped plan is "chosen"

How it happens. The notice says you will be moved. People read that as the marketplace having picked the best plan for them.

What it costs. The mapped plan is chosen by rules about similarity, not by what you use. A different plan, perhaps from a different insurer, could cost less or include your doctors.

How to avoid it. Treat the mapped plan as one option. Compare at least two alternatives in your window shopping, using the same table for each.

Mistake 7: Letting the deadline pass

How it happens. The notice arrives in the fall. The change deadline is in mid-December. Holiday plans, a move or an illness intervene.

What it costs. For HealthCare.gov plan year 2027, enrollment by December 15, 2026 gives coverage starting January 1, and enrollment from December 16 through January 15, 2027 gives coverage starting February 1 (CMS fact sheet dated October 30, 2026; the December 15 and February 1 coverage dates come from secondary summaries, so confirm on HealthCare.gov). That means that if you wait until after December 15, you are in the mapped plan for January, which can mean a month of the wrong network or drug list. State marketplaces have their own windows: some end earlier, such as Idaho on December 15, 2026, and many run to January 31, 2027.

How to avoid it. Put December 15 on your calendar (or your state's date) and aim to finish a week earlier. The tool open enrollment dates and coverage start calculator shows coverage start dates.

Mistake 8: Assuming the payment arrangement carries over

How it happens. If you pay by automatic withdrawal, you may assume that continues. If the mapped plan is from a new insurer, you may have to set up payment with that insurer, and the first payment may be what activates coverage.

What it costs. A missed first payment can mean coverage never starts or is cancelled. For those who receive advance premium tax credits, the grace period for nonpayment is usually three months if at least one full month's premium was paid, but a policy that never became effective has no grace period.

How to avoid it. After the mapped plan is confirmed, check whether you owe an initial payment and to whom. Keep the confirmation.

Comparing the old and the new plan

A table to fill in

Fill in each cell from the plan documents, not from the notice's summary. The right-hand columns show an invented example.

Item Old plan (2026) Replacement (2027) Example old Example new
Insurer and plan name Insurer A, Silver Insurer A, Silver (renamed)
Monthly premium before credit $700 $790
Monthly credit $350 $416.25
Monthly premium after credit $350 $373.75
Deductible $3,000 $3,500
Out-of-pocket maximum $8,000 $9,000
Primary care visit $30 $40
Your specialist in network? Yes No
Each of your drugs: tier and limits Tier 2 Tier 3, prior authorization
Your hospital in network? Yes Yes
Extra-help (cost-sharing) variant Yes Yes

A worked example of the price change

Say a household has an annual income of $45,000, and for the illustration the expected contribution is 8% of income in 2026 and 8.5% in 2027. These percentages are invented to keep the arithmetic simple; your actual percentage comes from the IRS table for your income level. They are not from the published schedule.

2026. Expected contribution: 8% × $45,000 = $3,600 a year, or $300 a month. The benchmark plan costs $650 a month, so the credit is $650 − $300 = $350 a month. The old plan costs $700 a month, so the household pays $700 − $350 = $350.

2027. Expected contribution: 8.5% × $45,000 = $3,825 a year, or $318.75 a month. The benchmark rises to $735 a month, so the credit is $735 − $318.75 = $416.25 a month. The mapped plan costs $790 a month, so the household pays $790 − $416.25 = $373.75.

The household pays $23.75 more per month ($373.75 − $350), which is $285 more over a year (12 × $23.75). The credit rose by $66.25 a month ($416.25 − $350), but the plan's price rose by $90 ($790 − $700), so the difference is $23.75.

What if the income estimate is out of date. Say the household's 2027 income is actually $52,000, but the application still says $45,000. With the old estimate, the household receives $416.25 × 12 = $4,995 in advance credit for the year. With the correct income, the expected contribution is 8.5% × $52,000 = $4,420, and the credit is $735 × 12 − $4,420 = $8,820 − $4,420 = $4,400. The household received $4,995 − $4,400 = $595 too much, which is owed back at tax time under the rule described in Mistake 4.

What to do, in order

  1. Find the notice from your insurer and from the marketplace. Note the name of the replacement plan, the date coverage ends and the date to act.
  2. Log in to your marketplace account and update your application: income, household, address, other coverage.
  3. Fill in the comparison table for the old plan and the replacement.
  4. Compare at least two other plans, including one from another insurer, in the same table.
  5. Check your doctors by calling their offices, and your drugs by name and dose.
  6. Pick a plan by December 15 (or your state's date), and save the confirmation.
  7. Check whether you owe a first payment and when.
  8. In January, check your first claims and the card you receive.

A marketplace navigator or a licensed broker can help with any of these steps at no cost to you in the case of navigators, and the guide how to enroll in marketplace coverage, step by step covers the steps in the application.

Key takeaways

  • If you do nothing, the marketplace may move you into a replacement plan whose network, drug list, price and cost sharing can all differ from your old plan.
  • Verify doctors with the practice and drugs by name and dose, because directories and formularies belong to the specific plan.
  • Update your application with your 2027 income so the advance credit is right; excess credit must be repaid in full for tax years after 2025.
  • For HealthCare.gov plan year 2027, the date that matters is December 15, 2026 for a January 1 start, and state marketplaces have their own dates.
  • Compare old and replacement plans in one table, and compare at least two alternatives before accepting the mapped plan.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic