Blog

Is a narrow network plan worth the lower premium?

A decision list for weighing a plan that costs $90 a month less but covers fewer hospitals, with the savings-versus-worst-case arithmetic in round numbers.

Picture a shopper looking at two plans side by side during open enrollment. One costs $90 a month less. Scrolling down the plan details, the reader finds the reason: the cheaper plan leaves out one of the two big hospitals in town. Whether that trade is worth making depends on four things you can check in an evening, plus one piece of arithmetic that shows how much the premium difference is really buying you.

The short version: a narrow network is a reasonable bargain for someone whose doctors and hospital are all inside it, who lives close to its specialists, and who could absorb a bad year. It is a poor one for someone mid-treatment with a specialist outside it, or for anyone who would have to travel far for ordinary care. The rest of this post gives you the criteria, the numbers and a decision list.

What a narrow network is, and why it costs less

Insurers build a network by negotiating with doctors and hospitals: in exchange for sending patients their way, the insurer asks for lower prices. A narrow network is a network built with fewer participants, so the insurer can concentrate volume on the ones that accept its prices. Supporters of the design say it holds premiums down and can steer people toward coordinated care. Critics say it shifts the burden of access onto patients and can leave gaps that only show up when someone gets sick.

Both descriptions can be accurate for the same plan. A narrow network with a good primary care base and one strong hospital can work well for a healthy household. The same design can be hard on a person with a rare condition that is treated at the one hospital the plan left out.

Most narrow networks are attached to plans that pay little or nothing for non-emergency care outside the network, such as HMO and EPO designs. A few pair a narrow network with a PPO that reimburses out-of-network care at a lower rate. The plan type matters because it sets what happens when you step outside: the plan documents tell you which kind you have, and in-network vs out-of-network care: what it means for your bill explains the difference in dollars.

The four criteria that decide it

The premium gap is one number. These four are the ones that tell you what it costs to use the plan.

1. Which hospital do you actually use, and is it in? For most households the hospital question is really three: where would you deliver a baby or have planned surgery, where would an ambulance take you, and where does your child's or your own specialist hold privileges? A doctor can be listed in a plan and still operate only at a hospital the plan excludes. Check the doctor and the hospital separately.

2. How many specialists in the specialties you may need are in the network, and how far away are they? If you take the cardiology, orthopedic or oncology listings and count the practices within a drive you would accept, a narrow network often shows two or three where the broader plan shows twelve. Two is not necessarily a problem, but appointment wait times grow when few practices share the load. A plan's directory will not tell you the wait; the practice's scheduling desk will.

3. How far is far? Distance is a cost. Treat it as one: extra miles, lost work time, a hotel night for early appointments. Later in this post a worked example puts a number on it.

4. What does the plan do in an emergency? For plans that must follow the ACA's rules, emergency care is covered without prior approval and at in-network cost sharing even when the ambulance delivers you to an out-of-network hospital, under what is called the prudent layperson standard: if a reasonable person would think the symptoms were an emergency, the plan covers it as one. The No Surprises Act added protection against being balance-billed for emergency care. These protections mean a narrow network is not a gamble in a true emergency. The exposure is in the planned and ongoing care that follows, because once you are stable the plan may expect you to transfer to an in-network hospital.

The arithmetic: what the $90 buys and what it risks

Everything below is a hypothetical with round numbers, not a price from any insurer. Say Plan N, the narrow network, costs $410 a month and Plan B, the broad network, costs $500 a month. Both have a $3,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and an $8,000 out-of-pocket maximum for in-network care.

The premium difference is $90 × 12 = $1,080 a year. That is what Plan N saves you before anyone sees a doctor.

Now consider three kinds of years.

  1. A quiet year, all care in network on both plans. Plan N costs $410 × 12 = $4,920 in premiums; Plan B costs $500 × 12 = $6,000. Plan N is ahead by $1,080, plus whatever copays you both pay.
  2. A bad year, with a hospital stay at a hospital in both networks. Both plans reach the $8,000 maximum, so the in-network cost is $8,000 plus premiums on each. Plan N is still ahead by $1,080.
  3. A bad year where the care you need is only at the hospital Plan N leaves out. Say the planned procedure comes to $40,000 in allowed charges and Plan N, an EPO-style plan, pays nothing for non-emergency out-of-network care. On Plan B the same procedure would cost you the deductible and coinsurance, capped at the maximum: $3,000 + 20% of $37,000 ($7,400) is $10,400, so you pay $8,000. On Plan N you owe the whole $40,000 unless you win an exception or negotiate a lower price. Annual totals: Plan N is $4,920 + $40,000 = $44,920; Plan B is $6,000 + $8,000 = $14,000. The narrow plan is behind by $30,920.

Divide the savings by the extra exposure for a rough break-even: the extra exposure is $40,000 − $8,000 = $32,000, and $1,080 ÷ $32,000 is about 3.4%. In plain words, if you think there is better than roughly a one in thirty chance this year that you need non-emergency care available only at the excluded hospital, the broad plan has the lower expected cost. If you are confident there is no such chance, Plan N wins.

Three cautions about that number. It is not a forecast; nobody can put a precise probability on a future illness. It is the wrong measure for a person who could not pay a $40,000 bill at all, because the damage from a rare disaster is larger than its average cost. And a plan that grants a network exception, which sometimes happens when no in-network provider can treat you, changes the outcome. See network gap exception for how that request works.

The distance version of the same math

Suppose you see a specialist 14 times a year, and the nearest in-network one in Plan N is 60 miles farther each way than the one you use now. The extra round trip is 120 miles, so 14 visits means 1,680 extra miles. At an illustrative $0.50 a mile for fuel and wear, that is $840, which is already most of the $1,080 premium gap before you count a day off work or a hotel night.

The break-even mileage is $1,080 ÷ $0.50 = 2,160 miles. At 120 extra miles per visit, that is 18 visits. A person who sees the specialist 18 times or more a year loses the savings to travel alone. A person who sees the same specialist twice a year comes out well ahead.

The decision list

Read down it in order. The first rule that applies usually settles the question.

  • If you are mid-treatment with a doctor or hospital outside the narrow network (chemotherapy, a pregnancy near its due date, a planned surgery, a child's ongoing care at a children's hospital), choose the plan that includes them, or find out in writing that the plan will cover continuing care before you enroll. See My doctor just left my plan's network. Do I have to switch plans or doctors? for how continuing-care rules work when a provider leaves a network.
  • If your regular doctors are all in the narrow network and the plan's hospital is one you would choose for planned care, the narrow plan is a serious option. Confirm each doctor by phone, as The directory lists my doctor as in network. How do I confirm before I enroll? describes.
  • If you live far from the narrow network's specialists and expect to need them regularly, price the travel as above and compare it with the premium gap.
  • If you rarely use care, your doctors are inside, and you could pay the out-of-pocket maximum in a bad year without a crisis, the narrow plan's savings are real money for a modest risk.
  • If you could not cover the out-of-pocket maximum, let alone a bill outside the network, the cost of the plan's gaps may matter more than the monthly saving, and a plan with some out-of-network coverage deserves a look.
  • If you are unsure about a hospital or a doctor, treat unknown as out until a person at the practice or the plan says otherwise.

None of these rules is a recommendation for any plan or insurer. Two households with the same premium gap can reasonably reach opposite answers.

Questions worth putting to the plan

Before you enroll, call the number on the plan page and ask:

  1. Which hospitals are in this specific network, listed by name and campus? Insurers often run several networks in one area under similar plan names.
  2. Is [name of hospital or children's hospital] excluded, and is there any in-network facility that offers the same service?
  3. If no in-network provider can deliver a service I need, what is the process for an exception, and how long does it take?
  4. What does the plan pay for non-emergency care outside the network: nothing, or a reduced share?
  5. Do my specialists' ongoing visits need referrals or prior authorization, and who files them?

Write down the date, the representative's name and what they said. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet gives you a place to record each answer, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs shows where the network sits next to premium, deductible and drug coverage in a full comparison.

When to get help with the decision

A marketplace navigator, a licensed broker or a SHIP counselor (for Medicare questions) can look at the specific plans in your county and tell you what the network documents say, at no charge to you in the case of navigators and SHIP counselors. Your state insurance department can tell you what network adequacy rules apply to the plan you are considering, since those standards vary by state and by type of plan, and self-funded employer plans generally fall outside state insurance rules. They will not choose for you, but they can tell you where the plan's obligations begin and end.

Remember too that networks are not fixed for the year. A hospital and an insurer can fail to renew a contract, and a doctor can leave a practice. A narrow network has fewer alternatives to fall back on when that happens, which is one more reason to weigh the exposure and not only the premium.

Key takeaways

  • The $90 monthly saving is $1,080 a year. Measure everything against that figure.
  • In a true emergency, ACA plans cover care at in-network cost sharing, so the real exposure is planned and ongoing care outside the network.
  • In this hypothetical, the narrow plan loses if there is roughly a one in thirty chance of needing non-emergency care available only at the excluded hospital.
  • Price distance: at $0.50 a mile, 18 specialist visits with 120 extra miles each erase the savings.
  • Confirm each doctor and each hospital by phone, and treat anything you cannot confirm as out of network.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic