Health plan comparison calculator
Compares two to four plans at low, typical and high use, with employer or HSA money and the points where one plan starts costing less than another.
Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.
How to use it
- Enter each plan's monthly premium (your share), deductible, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximum and average copay. Plans 3 and 4 are optional: leave the premium empty to leave a plan out.
- If a plan comes with employer or HSA/HRA money, enter the yearly amount in its last field.
- Under the plans, set the three levels of care: allowed charges and the number of flat-copay visits and fills. Every plan is compared at the same levels.
- Read the table, the bars for typical use and the break-even sentences.
How the math works
For one plan at one level of care, the cost is twelve premiums, plus the deductible (up to the allowed charges), plus coinsurance on the rest, plus copays, with the care part stopped at the out-of-pocket maximum, minus any account money. The copay for a level is the plan's average copay times the number of visits and fills at that level.
The break-even compares every plan with the one that has the lowest premium. Each plan's cost is a series of straight lines that bend at the deductible and again where the maximum is reached. The tool finds the bends, then finds exactly where the two lines cross. It uses the copays of the typical row.
Worked example with the starting numbers. Plan A: $350 a month, $5,000 deductible, 30% coinsurance, $9,000 maximum, no copays, $500 from the employer. Plan B: $520, $1,500, 20%, $6,000, a $30 copay, nothing from the employer.
- Typical use ($5,000 allowed, 6 copays): Plan A is $4,200 + $5,000 − $500 = $8,700. Plan B is $6,240 + $1,500 + $700 + $180 = $8,620.
- High use ($40,000, 15 copays): both reach their maximums. Plan A is $4,200 + $9,000 − $500 = $12,700; Plan B is $6,240 + $6,000 = $12,240.
- Break-even: Plan A costs less up to about $4,900 of allowed charges, and Plan B costs less above that.
These were checked by hand and by script.
What it assumes
- The starting numbers are illustrations, not typical plans.
- Allowed charges are what each plan has agreed with providers, so the same care is assumed to have the same allowed charges on every plan. Different networks may negotiate different prices.
- Copays count toward the maximum unless you untick that box.
- Account money is treated as a full offset. An HSA keeps unspent money; many HRAs do not.
- A plan with no maximum entered has no ceiling, and the tool says so.
Where it stops being right
- It compares dollars only. It does not know which doctors, hospitals and drugs each plan covers; check those with the network and drug worksheet.
- Services that skip the deductible, a separate drug deductible and out-of-network charges are not modeled.
- "Lowest" marks the lowest estimate in a row. It is not advice, and the cheapest estimate is not necessarily the plan that fits your care.
- For real prices and terms, use the plans' own documents, your employer's benefits office, or HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026