Blog
No zero-premium drug plans in 2027: picking the cheapest for your drugs
As of November 2026, no stand-alone plan has a $0 premium for 2027. Why the lowest premium is not always the lowest total, and a decision list for choosing.
If your stand-alone Medicare drug plan had a $0 premium in 2026, look closely at the plan list for 2027 before you let it renew. As of November 2026, KFF's analysis of the 2027 plan landscape, summarized on this site's fact sheet, finds no zero-premium stand-alone drug plans for 2027, a change that affects more than 4 million enrollees. The Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, is the time to decide what to do about it.
This post explains what the fact sheet says changed, why the plan with the lowest premium is often not the plan with the lowest cost for you, and gives a decision list you can work through with your own medicines. It is written for two readers: someone with Extra Help who now sees a premium, and someone with a stand-alone plan who is watching the price go up.
What changed for 2027, in the numbers we have
These are the facts on record as of November 16, 2026, with their dates. They are not a forecast.
- The Part D Premium Stabilization Demonstration ended after 2026. It was a temporary federal program that held down stand-alone premiums in recent years. Its ending is the main reason plan prices moved.
- Average premiums are projected higher. KFF projects the average stand-alone premium rising from $34 to $51 in 2027 if enrollees stay in their current plans, though it expects the actual rise to be smaller because many people will switch. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) projects the national average stand-alone premium weighted by enrollment at $36, up from $35.
- Fewer plans. The average person will see 9 stand-alone plans, down from 11. Total stand-alone plans fall from 360 to 316, and the number of sponsors from 17 to 15.
- Plan terminations. About 1.2 million stand-alone enrollees get notices that their plan ends at the close of 2026, part of 4.3 million Medicare beneficiaries, including Medicare Advantage enrollees, whose plans are ending.
- The standard benefit changes. The standard deductible is $700 and the out-of-pocket cap is $2,400 for 2027, up from $615 and $2,100 in 2026.
- The national base beneficiary premium is $41.33 for 2027, up from $38.99. Its annual increase is capped at 6% through 2029. This is a reference figure used in calculations, including late-enrollment penalties; it is not what a plan charges.
Why the gap between KFF's $51 projection and CMS's $36 projection? They measure different things: one assumes nobody moves, the other weights by expected enrollment. Neither is your premium. Your premium is on the plan's page in the Medicare Plan Finder.
Why the cheapest premium is not the cheapest total
A premium is one of several costs. For anyone who takes more than a drug or two, the others can be bigger. A year in a drug plan costs:
Total = 12 x monthly premium + deductible paid + copays and coinsurance for your drugs (up to the cap)
Here is the arithmetic with three invented plans for an invented person, Lena, 70, who does not receive Extra Help. She takes two generic drugs and one brand-name drug. The brand drug costs $350 a month at the plan's negotiated price. All three plans cover all three drugs. Every figure is made up for illustration.
| Plan X | Plan Y | Plan Z | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium | $18 | $52 | $30 |
| Deductible | $700 (brand drugs only) | $0 | $350 (brand drugs only) |
| Each generic, monthly | $5 | $0 | $4 |
| Brand drug, monthly after deductible | $45 | $45 | $47 |
Plan X.
- Premium: $18 x 12 = $216.
- Generics: two drugs x $5 x 12 months = $120.
- Brand drug: the first two fills, $350 each, use up the $700 deductible: $700. The other 10 months cost $45 each: $450. Brand total: $700 + $450 = $1,150.
- Total: $216 + $120 + $1,150 = $1,486.
Plan Y.
- Premium: $52 x 12 = $624.
- Generics: $0.
- Brand drug: 12 x $45 = $540.
- Total: $624 + $0 + $540 = $1,164.
Plan Z.
- Premium: $30 x 12 = $360.
- Generics: two drugs x $4 x 12 months = $96.
- Brand drug: the first fill, $350, meets the $350 deductible. The other 11 months cost $47 each: $517. Brand total: $350 + $517 = $867.
- Total: $360 + $96 + $867 = $1,323.
Ranked by premium alone, Lena would choose Plan X, at $18 a month, the cheapest. Ranked by what she actually pays in a year, Plan Y at $1,164 is lowest, and Plan X at $1,486 is the highest, $322 more than Plan Y. The plan with the highest premium was the cheapest for her, because she uses a brand drug that the other two plans load with a deductible.
Change one assumption and the answer flips. If Lena took no brand drug at all, Plan X's deductible would never apply, and Plan X's total would be $216 + $120 = $336, against $624 for Plan Y. The "cheapest" plan depends on the medicines. That is why the comparison starts with a list of your drugs.
When the premium really is the deciding number
There is a case where the premium does decide the plan. Say a second invented reader, Omar, 68, takes one drug that costs $3,000 a month at the negotiated price. Under the standard 2027 design he would reach the $2,400 out-of-pocket cap within the first three months of the year, whichever plan he is in. Past the cap he pays $0 for covered drugs, and the plans differ only in how fast he gets there and in their premiums. His yearly drug cost is about $2,400 in any plan whose cost sharing is at least that of the standard design.
Now the premium difference is the whole story. Say two invented plans both cover his drug on a tier that reaches the cap:
- Plan A: $20 a month, so $20 x 12 = $240 for the year.
- Plan B: $60 a month, so $60 x 12 = $720 for the year.
His total is $2,400 + $240 = $2,640 in Plan A and $2,400 + $720 = $3,120 in Plan B. Plan A is $480 cheaper. But the comparison only holds if both plans cover the drug, if he can get it filled where he wants, and if the plan does not restrict it with prior authorization he cannot satisfy. A person who reaches the cap should therefore check coverage rules first, then compare premiums. If the cheaper plan does not cover the drug, or the exception process would take weeks, the savings do not exist.
The cap also changes the timing question. In Omar's case the January and February bills will be large no matter what. The A month-by-month year of Part D with an expensive brand drug post follows a drug like his through a year, and the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan, which every Part D plan must offer, can spread those bills over the months left in the year without changing the total.
What Extra Help changes
For readers with Extra Help, the mechanics differ. Extra Help pays the premium up to a regional benchmark amount, removes or reduces the deductible, and puts a ceiling on copays. For 2027, the maximum copays on the fact sheet are up to $5.80 per generic and $14.40 per brand drug for people with income above 100% and up to 150% of the federal poverty level, and $1.65 and $5.00 for the lowest-income dual group.
So for an Extra Help enrollee the three variables are the premium after Extra Help, whether the plan covers each drug, and whether the pharmacy is convenient. A plan whose premium is within the benchmark costs nothing in premium; a plan above it leaves a remainder for you to pay. The 2027 benchmark amounts were not on the fact sheet, so do not assume one number applies to you. The Medicare Plan Finder, when you tell it you have Extra Help, shows the premium after Extra Help for each plan in your area. See the Extra Help with Part D costs: the low-income subsidy explained guide for the basics.
If the plan you were in is ending or its premium rose, Medicare may move you to another plan with a premium within the benchmark, but a reassignment may not cover your drugs. Check it.
A decision list
Work through these in order for each plan on your short list. Stop at the first "no" for any drug you cannot do without.
- Is each of your drugs on the plan's formulary, in the dose and form you take? If not, set the plan aside, unless your prescriber would support an exception. Extra Help does not cover a drug the plan does not.
- Are there limits on the drug? Prior authorization, step therapy or quantity limits add friction. A plan that requires you to try other drugs first may not fit.
- What is the premium after any help you get? For Extra Help, use the figure the Plan Finder shows after the subsidy.
- What is the deductible, and does it apply to your drugs? A deductible that applies only to higher tiers matters only if your drugs are on those tiers.
- What will you pay for each drug at each phase? Use copay or coinsurance per tier, not just the premium. For brand and specialty drugs, a coinsurance percentage can be larger than a copay. The formulary tier entry explains how tiers set the price.
- Which pharmacy will you use, and is it preferred in this plan? A preferred pharmacy can cut the copay; the Preferred pharmacies in Part D: why my copay differs across the street post shows by how much in an example.
- Add it up for the year: 12 x premium + deductible + the year of copays, as in Lena's table. Compare the totals.
- Do you reach the cap? If you take a high-priced drug, you may hit the out-of-pocket cap ($2,400 in 2027 for the standard design) within a few months. Past that point, plans with different copays cost you the same, and the premium becomes the main difference. The Medicare Part D out-of-pocket calculator shows when you would reach it.
- Decide whether the cheapest total is worth switching for. Changing plans is a bother, and it resets the deductible phase. The decision is yours; a savings of several hundred dollars usually deserves a look.
For a medicine-by-medicine walk-through with six drugs, the How to compare Part D plans when you take six medications, step by step post is a good companion, and the How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost guide covers the same ground in outline.
If you do nothing
Plans renew automatically unless they end. If your plan is continuing, you stay in it at the new price, which for 2027 may be higher; if your plan is ending, you receive a notice and Medicare gives you a special window, but waiting can leave you with a gap in drug coverage or a plan reassigned for you. Going without drug coverage can lead to a late-enrollment penalty: 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full month you go without creditable drug coverage, which is about $0.41 a month in 2027 by arithmetic on the $41.33 base, added to your premium for as long as you have Part D. People with Extra Help do not pay this penalty.
Where the right answer comes from
Prices and formularies are set plan by plan, and your Annual Notice of Change spells out what your plan does next year. Compare in the Medicare Plan Finder, and check the result with the plan. A SHIP counselor, a free, unbiased state Medicare counselor, will go through the comparison with you; see the Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7 guide for deadlines. If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, the drug coverage is part of that plan, and joining a separate stand-alone plan can disenroll you from it, as the Adding a stand-alone drug plan to an Advantage HMO or PPO: the trap post describes. The period from January through March for people already in an Advantage plan is described under Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period.
All figures in this post are as of November 16, 2026. Final 2027 premiums for individual plans appear in the Plan Finder and may differ from the averages reported in the press.
Key takeaways
- As of November 2026, KFF reports no zero-premium stand-alone drug plans for 2027, after the Part D Premium Stabilization Demonstration ended, affecting more than 4 million enrollees.
- The 2027 standard deductible is $700 and the out-of-pocket cap $2,400; averages in the press measure plan premiums, not what you pay.
- A year's cost is 12 times the premium plus the deductible plus your copays, so the lowest premium can produce the highest total, as in the invented example.
- With Extra Help, the key numbers are the premium after Extra Help in the Plan Finder, whether each drug is covered, and your pharmacy.
- Check each drug's formulary status first; then compare totals; and use a SHIP counselor if you want a second look before December 7.