Blog
How to ask my Part D plan to cover a drug that isn't on its formulary
Steps when a new medicine is not covered: the exception request, the prescriber's statement, expedited review, appeal and a sample doctor's letter.
You hand the pharmacist a prescription your doctor wrote this morning. The pharmacist types, waits, and says the plan will not pay: the drug is not on its formulary. You are standing at the counter with two choices that feel like the only ones, pay the full price or go home without the medicine. There is a third, and it is built into Part D. You can ask the plan to make an exception.
This post is a playbook for that request, in the order the steps happen. It covers what to do at the counter, how to file the request, what the prescriber has to supply, when to ask for a faster decision, what to do after a denial, and a sample outline for the doctor's letter. For a second view of the same process from the plan's side, see Part D coverage determination and exception: the step order that works. The general guide is what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need.
First, what kind of "not covered" is this?
Three different problems look the same at the counter, and only some can be fixed with an exception.
- The drug is not on the plan's formulary. The plan covers many drugs but not this one. This is what a formulary exception is for.
- The drug is on the formulary but needs approval first, or has limits such as a quantity cap or a requirement to try a cheaper drug first. That is a prior authorization or utilization management issue. Plans call the same request an exception to the rule.
- The drug is on the formulary but on a high tier. You can ask for a tiering exception to pay the cost sharing of a lower tier. The plan can refuse this one more easily, and some plans do not allow it for certain tiers, such as specialty drugs.
A fourth case cannot be fixed by an exception: a drug that Part D excludes by law. By statute, Part D does not cover drugs used for certain purposes, such as weight loss, fertility, cosmetic uses and some others, and it covers only drugs approved for their use. If a plan says a drug is excluded by law, the exception process does not apply. The plan's coverage determination notice says which kind of problem you have.
Step 1: Ask the pharmacy for the reason and the notice
When a Part D plan will not pay for a prescription, the pharmacy is generally required to give you a written notice about your right to ask the plan for a coverage determination. If you did not get it, ask for it. Ask the pharmacist two questions: what reject message came back from the plan (for example "not on formulary", "prior authorization required", "quantity limit"), and whether there is a covered alternative on the plan's list.
Write the answers down, with the date, the pharmacy and the drug name and dose. If the medicine is urgent, ask the pharmacist what the plan will pay for a short supply. New enrollees and people whose plan changed its formulary are often entitled to a temporary transition supply, so ask whether one applies. Do not leave the pharmacy without knowing whether you can get any supply today.
Step 2: Call your prescriber the same day
The exception request needs a statement from the person who wrote the prescription. Without it the plan cannot decide, and the plan's clock for a decision does not start until it has the statement. So call the prescriber's office early and say, in these words if you like: "My Part D plan does not cover this drug. I need a supporting statement for an exception request. What do you need from me?"
Two things help the office. First, tell them the plan's name and where to send the statement (the plan's phone number for coverage determinations, fax or online portal; your plan's website and card list them). Second, tell them whether you need a fast decision. A prescriber who has done this before may already have a standard letter.
Step 3: File the coverage determination
A coverage determination is the plan's first formal decision on whether and how it will cover a drug. An exception request is a type of coverage determination. You, your prescriber or your representative can file it. Many offices prefer to file it themselves, since they have the clinical details.
Ways to file, in order of usefulness: the plan's online form, the plan's coverage determination form, or the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' standard model request form, which every plan must accept. Phone requests are possible, but keep a record. Keep a copy of whatever you send and note the date.
What the request has to state:
- Your name, member ID and date of birth.
- The drug, dose, directions, quantity and prescriber.
- That you are asking for an exception and which kind (formulary, tiering or utilization management).
- That the prescriber's supporting statement is attached or will follow.
- Whether you are asking for an expedited decision (see step 4).
How long the plan has
Federal rules set short deadlines for Part D decisions. For a standard request, the plan must decide within 72 hours after it receives the prescriber's supporting statement for an exception. For an expedited request, the deadline is 24 hours. These are the rules for the first-level decision; the notice you receive lists what applies to you, and your plan's materials list the deadlines for the later steps.
Step 4: Ask for an expedited decision when it applies
An expedited, or "fast," decision is available when waiting for the standard time could seriously harm your health or your ability to function. If your prescriber says so, the plan must treat the request as expedited. If you ask and your prescriber has not said so, the plan decides whether it meets the test, and if it does not, it moves to the standard clock and tells you.
Examples of the kind of situation where a prescriber might support a fast decision include a drug whose interruption can cause a relapse or a serious complication. Whether your situation qualifies is your prescriber's judgment, not a website's. If you are unsure, ask the prescriber's office to state in the letter whether the delay could cause serious harm. The explanation matters more than a label.
Step 5: Build the supporting statement
The plan must approve a formulary exception when the prescriber's statement shows that the drugs on the formulary would not be as effective for you, or would be likely to cause harm, compared with the drug requested. In practice that statement has to say specific things. Here is a sample outline for the prescriber's letter. It is a format, not medical advice, and the clinical content must come from the prescriber.
Re: [Patient name], member ID [number], date of birth [date] Request: Formulary exception for [drug name, strength, form, directions, quantity]. Diagnosis: [Condition and relevant history, with the date of diagnosis]. Drugs tried: [Each formulary alternative the patient has taken, with dates, doses and what happened: not effective, side effects, allergic reaction, intolerance]. Why formulary alternatives are not appropriate: [Specific reasons, such as a contraindication, a drug interaction with a current medicine, a coexisting condition, or a prior failure, and what the prescriber expects would happen on the alternative]. Why the requested drug is appropriate: [Clinical rationale, and any guideline or labeled use the prescriber relies on]. Urgency: [Whether delay could seriously harm the patient's health; if yes, an explicit request for an expedited decision]. Contact: [Prescriber name, office phone and fax, best time to call].
Notice what the plan is looking for: a reason tied to this patient. A letter that says only "the patient prefers this drug" is weak. A letter that says what was tried and what happened is strong. If your own records show a drug that did not work, tell the prescriber's office; they may not have the old chart.
Step 6: Wait, then read the decision carefully
The plan sends a written notice. If it approves the exception, the notice states how long the approval lasts. In many cases an approved exception lasts for the rest of the plan year, if the prescriber continues to prescribe the drug and it remains safe. Ask when it ends, because a new plan year can start the process again.
If it denies, the notice must state why, and tell you how to appeal. Keep that notice and read for these points:
- The reason (not enough clinical detail, a formulary alternative the plan says should be tried first, an exclusion by law).
- The deadline for the next step and how to file.
- Whether the plan asked for more information. If so, supply it right away.
Step 7: Appeal (redetermination)
The first level of appeal in Part D is a redetermination, a new review by the plan, done by a person who was not involved in the first decision. If the denial was about medical necessity, the reviewer is a physician or other qualified health professional. You, your prescriber or your representative can file it, within the time stated in the denial notice. Missing that date can cost you the right to this level, so mark it on a calendar the day the notice arrives.
A good redetermination does what the first request did not:
- Answers the plan's stated reason directly. If it said the drug was "not shown to be necessary," the new statement says why it is.
- Adds new evidence: lab results, chart notes, a hospital summary, a specialist's opinion.
- Asks again for an expedited decision if delay is harmful.
The how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read guide and the claim denial appeal letter builder help you organize the letter, though the clinical support still has to come from the prescriber.
Step 8: Independent review and beyond
If the plan upholds its denial, you can ask for review by an independent reviewer outside the plan, called the Independent Review Entity. In many cases the plan sends the file automatically, but check the notice. If you lose again, there are higher levels: an administrative law judge, a Medicare appeals council and, past that, federal court. The higher levels depend on the amount involved, so for a single prescription most people stop at the independent review.
Throughout, you may name a representative, a family member, advocate or lawyer, with the right paperwork.
While you wait
An appeal can take days or weeks, and the medicine may not wait. A few things to ask about:
- A temporary supply or a covered alternative. Ask your prescriber whether a short course of a covered drug is safe as a bridge. That is a medical decision.
- Samples or a short supply from the prescriber's office, if they have it.
- Manufacturer assistance programs. Some drug makers have programs for people who qualify. Their rules, including how they treat people on Medicare, vary, and you should ask the prescriber's office or a pharmacist about them. Part D plans and the programs can interact in ways a pharmacist can explain.
- Extra Help, the low-income subsidy, if your income and resources are modest. It lowers costs for covered drugs but does not make a non-covered drug covered.
- Another plan next fall. The Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, is the time to choose a plan whose formulary includes your drug. Check each plan's formulary for the exact drug and dose before enrolling. The How to compare Part D plans when you take six medications, step by step post shows how to compare plans medication by medication.
When to get help
If the denial rests on a technical reading of the plan's rules, or if you are uncertain about the deadlines, a SHIP counselor can look at the notice with you at no cost; see the SHIP entry. The plan's customer service line can explain its own process but is not your advocate. A lawyer who handles Medicare appeals is useful if a lot of money or a serious health risk is involved.
Key takeaways
- A formulary exception is a request for the plan to cover a drug it normally does not; it is a type of coverage determination, and the prescriber's statement is what makes it succeed.
- Federal rules set short first-level deadlines, 72 hours for standard exception requests and 24 hours for expedited ones, and the clock for an exception starts when the plan has the prescriber's statement.
- A strong supporting letter names the drugs tried, what happened and why formulary alternatives would be less effective or harmful for this patient.
- A denial can be appealed through redetermination and then independent review; the denial notice states the deadline, so calendar it immediately.
- Exceptions cannot override Part D's legal exclusions, and approvals often last only through the plan year, so check next fall's formulary too.