Blog
My Part D premium is going up: should I switch plans or stay put?
How to decide by December 7 when your 2027 drug plan premium rises: compare total yearly cost, drugs, pharmacy, deductible and whether the plan is ending.
A higher premium is a reason to look, not a reason to switch. The number that decides whether to stay or go is what a plan will cost you over all of 2027, which is twelve months of premium plus what you will pay for your own drugs at your own pharmacy. A plan whose premium rose can still be the cheapest overall, and one whose premium fell can be the most expensive.
This post is for someone who has opened the notice about their 2027 Part D plan, seen a bigger premium, and has until December 7 to decide. It sets out what the record shows as of November 2026, a decision list in the order that usually matters, a worked three-plan comparison with invented numbers, and where to get free help. It is general information, not a recommendation of any plan, and the figures that change by plan are for you or a counselor to look up.
What is known as of November 2026
These facts come from federal and independent sources and were current in mid-November 2026. Each is dated because Medicare updates them.
- The deadline. The Annual Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7. A new Part D choice made in that window takes effect on January 1, 2027. The Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7 guide covers the rules.
- The standard benefit changes. For 2027, the standard Part D deductible is $700 (it was $615 in 2026), and the out-of-pocket cap is $2,400 (it was $2,100), according to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' rate announcement of April 6, 2026. Plans can set lower deductibles.
- The base premium rises. The national base beneficiary premium is $41.33 for 2027, up from $38.99 in 2026, according to CMS (July 28, 2026). It is a benchmark Medicare uses in setting premiums and penalties, not the premium of any one plan.
- Stand-alone drug plan premiums are projected to rise. KFF projected in October 2026 that the average premium for a stand-alone drug plan would go from $34 to $51 in 2027 if people stay in their current plans, and that it would be lower after people switch. CMS projects a national average of $36, up from $35. The two projections measure different things, so treat both as averages and not as a prediction for your plan.
- A support program ended. The Part D Premium Stabilization Demonstration, which held down premiums for some plans, ended after 2026. KFF reports that no stand-alone plans have a $0 premium for 2027, which affects more than 4 million enrollees.
- Fewer plans. The number of stand-alone plans falls from 360 to 316, and the sponsors offering them from 17 to 15, according to KFF. The average person has 9 stand-alone plans to choose from, down from 11.
- Plans are ending. About 4.3 million Medicare beneficiaries will have their Medicare Advantage or stand-alone drug plan terminated at the end of 2026, including about 1.2 million in stand-alone plans, and one large stand-alone plan with about 950,000 enrollees ends. If yours is one of them, you must choose a new plan.
For any of these, Medicare.gov and your plan's notice have the current word. The Medicare Part D entry and the Medicare Part D explained: drug plans, formularies and costs guide give the background.
Why the premium is only part of the picture
Your yearly cost under a plan is three things added together:
- Premium: the monthly amount times 12.
- What you pay for covered drugs: the deductible, copays or coinsurance, up to the out-of-pocket cap.
- What you pay for anything the plan does not cover: a drug that is not on the plan's list, or one that needs approval you cannot get.
A plan that lowers the premium by $20 a month saves $240 a year. If it puts one of your regular drugs on a more expensive tier, or leaves it off the list, that can cost far more than $240. The reverse also holds: a plan that costs $25 more per month, or $300 a year, may save more than that at the pharmacy. The premium is the one number you will see on a comparison screen first, but it is rarely the number that decides your year.
A worked comparison with invented numbers
Say Pat, an invented 70-year-old, takes three regular medicines. Pat's current plan raised its premium from $38 to $55 a month for 2027. Pat found two others on the Medicare Plan Finder. All figures are illustrations.
| Plan A (current) | Plan B | Plan C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium | $55 | $80 | $30 |
| Premium for the year | 12 x $55 = $660 | 12 x $80 = $960 | 12 x $30 = $360 |
| Copays for Pat's covered drugs, per month | $110 | $60 | $70 |
| Copays for the year | 12 x $110 = $1,320 | 12 x $60 = $720 | 12 x $70 = $840 |
| A drug not on the plan's list, paid in full | none | none | $90 a month, 12 x $90 = $1,080 |
| Total for the year | $1,980 | $1,680 | $2,280 |
Plan B has the highest premium and the lowest total, by $300 over Plan A and $600 over Plan C. Plan C has the lowest premium and the highest total, because one of Pat's medicines is not on its list. This is the common pattern, and it is why the decision list starts with drugs and not premiums.
Real plans add wrinkles. A deductible makes the first months of the year more expensive; a preferred pharmacy changes the copays; and a drug on a high tier can reach the out-of-pocket cap, as shown in the How the Part D out-of-pocket cap works month by month for one drug post. The Medicare Part D out-of-pocket calculator helps with those.
A decision list
Work through these in order and stop when one gives a clear answer.
- Is your plan ending? If your notice says the plan will not continue in 2027, staying put is not an option; you need a new plan, and the notice explains your choices and any extra time you have. Do not assume the replacement will fit: a plan that suited your drugs may have no close equivalent for 2027, so compare, and check the notice for what happens if you do not choose.
- Are all your drugs, in the right strengths, on the plan's 2027 list? Check each one. The formulary lists covered drugs, tiers and restrictions such as prior authorization, step therapy and quantity limits. If a drug you take is dropped or moved to a higher tier in your current plan, that alone can justify switching.
- What will you pay for your drugs in the first months? Look at the deductible, which can be up to $700 in the standard design, and which drugs it applies to. If your plan has a deductible and a competitor has none, compare the first-quarter bills as well as the yearly total.
- Which pharmacy do you use? Some plans charge less at preferred pharmacies and more elsewhere. Check your own pharmacy by name, as the Preferred pharmacies in Part D: why my copay differs across the street post explains.
- What is the total yearly cost for each plan? Premium plus drug costs, as in the table. The Plan Finder on Medicare.gov computes this if you enter your drugs and pharmacy.
- How big is the gap? If the difference between the best plan and your current plan is under about $100 a year, consider whether the effort and any change in rules is worth it. If it is several hundred dollars, it probably is. These thresholds are judgment calls, not rules.
- Do you get Extra Help? If you receive the low-income subsidy, your copays are small and set by the program, and your premium may be partly or fully covered depending on the plan. For 2027, the maximum copays are $5.80 for a generic and $14.40 for a brand drug for people above 100% and up to 150% of the poverty level, per CMS. A plan switch for a person with Extra Help is a different calculation, so see Extra Help and ask a counselor.
- Might your medicines change in 2027? If you and your prescriber expect a new, costly drug, ask how each plan would handle it: whether similar drugs are on the list and at what tier, and what approval they require. The out-of-pocket cap limits your yearly cost, but the timing of the bills still matters, and a plan with a high deductible puts the heaviest bills in January.
Do not drop Part D to avoid the premium
Some people consider dropping their drug plan because there is no $0 option. For most, that is a poor trade. Going without creditable drug coverage for a month adds a late-enrollment penalty of 1% of the national base premium for each full month, which is about $0.41 a month per month of delay in 2027 (1% of $41.33), and it lasts as long as you have Part D. Over a few years, that adds up; and a single costly drug without coverage can cost more than years of premiums. Check the late enrollment penalty entry before making the change, and ask a counselor if cost is the problem.
If you also have a Medicare Advantage plan
If your drug coverage comes inside a Medicare Advantage plan, the choice is about the whole plan, not only the drug part, because most people in those plans cannot add a separate stand-alone drug plan. The Annual Enrollment Period covers a change of Medicare Advantage plan too, and the question becomes whether the new plan's doctors, hospitals and drug list fit you. The How to compare Part D plans when you take six medications, step by step post gives a method for the drug part of the comparison, and the How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost guide covers stand-alone plans.
Steps for the next two weeks
- Find your 2027 plan notice, the Annual Notice of Change, which plans send in the fall. Read the premium, deductible, your drugs' tiers and whether the plan is ending.
- Make a list of every medicine you take, with strength, how often, and the pharmacy you use. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet is a worksheet for that.
- Enter the list into the Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov, or ask for help doing it.
- Write down the total yearly cost of your current plan and the top two or three alternatives.
- Call the plan you are considering to confirm any drug or pharmacy that matters.
- Enroll by December 7. If you are staying in a plan that is continuing, no action is needed; if your plan is ending, you do need to choose.
Where to get free help: the SHIP counselors, short for State Health Insurance Assistance Program, give unbiased Medicare help at no charge; see the SHIP entry. 1-800-MEDICARE and the Plan Finder at Medicare.gov are the federal sources. A licensed broker may also help; ask whether the broker is paid by the plans, and know that a broker may not list every plan. The window is short, so call early.
Key takeaways
- A premium increase is a reason to compare plans, but the number that matters is the total yearly cost: premium plus what you pay for your drugs at your pharmacy.
- As of November 2026, stand-alone drug plan premiums are projected to rise, the premium stabilization demonstration has ended, there are no $0-premium stand-alone plans for 2027 and fewer plans to choose from.
- Check first whether your plan is ending, then whether each of your drugs is covered at an acceptable tier, then the deductible and your pharmacy.
- Do not drop Part D to avoid a premium; a late-enrollment penalty of about $0.41 per month of delay in 2027 applies for as long as you have the coverage.
- Decide and enroll by December 7 for coverage starting January 1, 2027, and use a SHIP counselor or the Medicare Plan Finder to check your numbers.