Blog
Is a POS plan closer to an HMO or a PPO, and does it matter for me?
A point-of-service plan mixes HMO and PPO features. A table compares referrals, out-of-network coverage, cost sharing and claim paperwork for all three.
A point-of-service plan sits between an HMO and a PPO, and it behaves like each one depending on the choice you make at the moment you need care. Stay in the network and follow the plan's steps, and a POS feels like an HMO. Step outside the network, and it feels like a PPO with a higher bill. If you have to put it in one box, it is closer to an HMO in everyday use and closer to a PPO in what it permits, which is the very thing that makes it hard to place.
This comparison lays out the three plan types side by side and then asks who tends to be comfortable with each. The dollar figures in the examples are invented, and the real terms for any plan are in its summary of benefits and coverage.
What "point of service" means
The name describes when you decide. In an HMO you commit to the network up front; in a PPO you decide at each visit how much to pay for freedom. In a POS plan you choose the path at the point where you receive care: use an in-network provider, usually after your primary care physician (PCP) sends you there, or go outside and accept a more expensive arrangement.
A typical POS plan has these features, though every one can differ:
- You choose or are assigned a primary care physician.
- You need a referral from that PCP to see a specialist inside the network at the plan's full benefit level.
- You can go out of network, with or without a referral, and the plan pays part of the cost.
- In-network care costs less than out-of-network care, often with copays for visits and a deductible for larger services.
Some POS plans use the PCP as a gatekeeper only for in-network specialist visits and let you see out-of-network providers directly. Others reduce the out-of-network benefit further if you go outside without a referral. The words are not standardized, so the plan documents are the authority.
Side by side
| Feature | HMO | POS | PPO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary care physician | Usually required | Usually required | Usually not required |
| Referral to see an in-network specialist | Often required | Often required | Usually not required |
| Out-of-network coverage | Emergencies and approved exceptions only | Yes, at higher cost | Yes, at higher cost |
| Cost sharing in network | Copays and a smaller or no deductible are common | Copays plus a deductible are common | Deductible plus coinsurance is common |
| Cost sharing out of network | Not applicable | Higher coinsurance and often a separate deductible | Higher coinsurance and often a separate deductible |
| Claim paperwork | Rarely; the provider bills the plan | Rarely in network; often yourself out of network | Rarely in network; often yourself out of network |
| Premium compared with the others | Often lowest | Often in between | Often highest |
The table summarizes tendencies, not rules. Some HMOs have deductibles, some PPOs use copays, and some POS plans require no referral. Use it as a map to the questions you should ask, not as a substitute for the plan's actual terms. The health plan type finder and HMO vs PPO vs EPO vs POS: how the four plan types differ describe each type in more depth.
The two places a POS plan differs most
The difference between a POS plan and an HMO is the out-of-network door. An HMO generally keeps that door closed outside emergencies and approved exceptions. A POS plan opens it partway.
The difference between a POS plan and a PPO is the gate. A PPO usually lets you see any in-network specialist without asking anyone. A POS plan usually asks for the referral first. So in daily use the POS plan feels like an HMO, and the extra benefit appears only when you leave the network.
That is why the question "which is it closer to?" does not have a single answer. For routine care it behaves like an HMO. For the rare case where you want or need an out-of-network doctor, it behaves like a PPO, with all the cost-sharing issues that come with that.
A worked example
Say a hypothetical POS plan has these terms: a $40 copay for an in-network PCP visit, a $70 copay for an in-network specialist visit with a referral, a $2,000 deductible for out-of-network care, and 40% coinsurance after that deductible. The out-of-network allowed amount for a specialist consultation is $500, and the provider's billed charge is $900.
Path 1: in network with a referral. The PCP visit costs $40, the specialist visit $70. Total: $110. The plan pays the rest at its contracted rates, and no balance bill is allowed.
Path 2: out of network, early in the year, before the out-of-network deductible is met. The plan allows $500, and it all goes to the deductible. You pay $500. The provider may bill the balance of $900 − $500 = $400. Total: $900 to the specialist, with the plan paying nothing yet.
Path 3: out of network, after the deductible is met. You owe 40% of $500 = $200. The plan pays $300. The balance bill is still $400. Total: $200 + $400 = $600.
So the same consultation costs $70 in network with a referral, $900 out of network before the deductible and $600 out of network after it, counting only the specialist and not the PCP visit. Check: $300 + $200 + $400 = $900, the billed charge. The in-network path also required a visit to the PCP for $40, so the in-network path costs $110 in total, still far below either out-of-network path.
The lesson is not that out-of-network care is never worth it. It is that a POS plan's out-of-network benefit is a partial one, and the more of the bill that is balance billing, the less the benefit is worth. how out-of-network claims work: allowed amounts and balance bills describes the claim side of that path.
Claim paperwork: the part that changes
In network, a provider submits the claim to the plan, and you pay your copay or share. Out of network, a provider may ask for payment up front and leave you to file the claim, or may bill the plan and then bill you the remainder. The difference matters in a POS plan more than in an HMO, because an HMO rarely has any out-of-network claim to file.
If you use the out-of-network option, keep the itemized bill, the receipt and the provider's notes. Ask whether the provider will bill the plan directly, and check the explanation of benefits that follows to see how the allowed amount was set. If the plan reduced the benefit because you had no referral, the explanation should say so, and the PCP's office may be able to supply a late referral if the visit was medically necessary and the plan accepts retroactive ones. Many do not, so ask before the visit.
How the three tend to suit different people
These are tendencies, and they should not be read as advice about which plan any one person should buy. Each type has a case for it and a case against it.
HMO. The case for: the lowest premiums are often found here, and the coordination through a PCP can keep care organized for someone who values a home base. The case against: the network is the whole universe of covered care outside emergencies, and the referral step adds time. People tend to be comfortable with an HMO when their doctors and hospitals are all in network, when they live where the network is dense, and when they do not mind asking the PCP for referrals. How does an HMO referral work when I need to see a specialist? walks through that process.
PPO. The case for: freedom to see in-network specialists without a referral and partial coverage outside the network. The case against: higher premiums and large gaps between in-network and out-of-network bills. People tend to be comfortable with a PPO when they travel, split time between regions, see specialists directly or want an out-of-network option for a particular doctor. The cost of that option is worth pricing; What does a PPO really let me do out of network, in dollars? shows how.
POS. The case for: it offers an out-of-network option at a premium that is often below a PPO's, with the structure of a PCP. The case against: the referral step still applies, and the out-of-network benefit can be reduced or complicated by rules about referrals. People tend to be comfortable with a POS plan when they want an HMO's structure most of the time but want a way out for a specific doctor or situation. They are often less comfortable when they discover that the "way out" has conditions.
Some people find that a POS plan combines the drawbacks of both: referral steps like an HMO and out-of-network bills like a PPO. Others find it a sensible middle path. The best test is whether you can name the situation in which you would use the out-of-network door and whether you have priced it.
Questions to ask about any POS plan
Because the label covers many variations, these questions pull out the real terms:
- Do I need a referral from my PCP to see an in-network specialist, and does that apply to every specialty?
- If I go out of network without a referral, does the plan pay less than if I have one?
- Is the out-of-network deductible separate from the in-network deductible, and does an out-of-network out-of-pocket maximum exist?
- How does the plan set the out-of-network allowed amount?
- Do out-of-network costs count toward the in-network out-of-pocket limit?
- Is there a national network or another arrangement if I travel?
The plan's member services, the summary of benefits and coverage and, for employer plans, the human resources benefits office can answer these. How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage helps decode the table, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs gives a broader framework for lining several plans up against each other.
Three mix-ups that cause surprises
Assuming the PCP is optional. A person who has used PPOs for years may skip choosing a PCP at enrollment. In a POS plan that can mean the plan assigns one, and the first specialist visit then needs a referral from a doctor the member has never seen. Choose the PCP deliberately, and confirm that the office is accepting new patients.
Assuming out-of-network care counts like in-network care. A POS plan may track the two sets of spending separately. A member who has met the in-network deductible by March may still face the full out-of-network deductible in June, which is the same two-clock problem a PPO has.
Assuming a referral fixes everything. In some POS plans a referral to an out-of-network specialist improves the benefit, and in others it changes nothing. A referral to an in-network specialist does not protect you if the particular doctor is outside the network. Ask the plan, in writing if possible, what the referral does for that specific visit.
How to place it for yourself
Instead of asking which type a POS plan resembles, ask which of your own likely situations each type handles well. Make a list of the care you expect next year: your regular doctors, any specialists, planned procedures, prescriptions, travel. Mark which providers are in each plan's network and which are not. Then price a typical visit in the network and a typical visit outside it, as in the example above.
If everyone you see is in network and you rarely need an out-of-network provider, the difference between a POS plan and an HMO is mostly the premium and the referral rule. If you expect to use out-of-network providers regularly, the cost of doing so will dominate, and the comparison should be made on that cost, not on the label.
Key takeaways
- A POS plan usually works like an HMO inside the network, with a PCP and referrals, and like a PPO when you go outside it, with partial coverage at a higher cost.
- The main differences are the referral gate, which a PPO usually lacks, and the out-of-network door, which an HMO usually keeps closed.
- Out-of-network care under a POS plan can mean a separate deductible, higher coinsurance, balance billing and sometimes a reduced benefit if you had no referral.
- Plan labels are not standardized, so check the summary of benefits and coverage for referral, out-of-network and deductible terms.
- Compare plans by pricing your own likely care in and out of network, not by the label.