Blog
Reading my marketplace auto-renewal notice line by line before December 15
What each line of a marketplace renewal notice means, what to verify or change, and which dates decide whether next year's plan is locked in.
The envelope or email looks like routine mail, and that is the danger. A marketplace renewal notice says, in effect, that if you do nothing, you will be re-enrolled for next year in a plan that may not cost, cover or include what this year's did. Each line on it is a decision made on your behalf unless you act.
This walk-through assumes you have one of two things in hand: a renewal notice from the marketplace or your insurer, or the "window shopping" screen in your account that shows next year's plans and prices. It takes the lines in the order they usually appear, says what each means, and tells you what to verify, what to change and when. It is written as of November 2026, when open enrollment for plan year 2027 is under way.
The dates that govern everything else
Start with the calendar, because the rest of the page is only useful before the deadline.
On HealthCare.gov, open enrollment for plan year 2027 runs from November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, according to the CMS plan year 2027 fact sheet dated October 30, 2026. The commonly cited rule is that a plan chosen or confirmed by December 15 starts on January 1, while a plan chosen from December 16 through January 15 starts February 1. That split comes from the standard effective-date rule and secondary summaries, so confirm it on HealthCare.gov for your own case.
States that run their own marketplaces set their own windows. As reported by healthinsurance.org, Idaho's closes on December 15, 2026, and others run into January, with some ending January 31, 2027. If you live in one, your notice states your deadline.
A rule from 2025 would have cut every window to end by December 31. A federal court in Maryland set aside the shortened-window provision on June 12, 2026, and the government has appealed, so the window described above is the one in place as this is written. A later court ruling could change that, so recheck HealthCare.gov or your state exchange before relying on January dates.
So the practical meaning of "December 15" is this: it is the last day to make a choice and still have it start January 1. After it, doing nothing still gets you the renewed plan for January. A change made after it takes effect a month later. The post When does coverage start if I enroll on January 10 instead of December 15? covers the gap in coverage dates.
Line 1: the plan name, insurer and plan ID
The first line shows which plan you are being renewed into. There are three outcomes.
- The same plan, same name. The usual case. Terms may still have changed, which is covered below.
- A renamed or re-numbered plan. Insurers revise their products every year, and a plan can keep the name while the benefits change, or change the name while the benefits stay. The plan ID (a long code) and the summary of benefits are better guides than the name.
- A different plan, because yours is being discontinued. The notice says your plan is being replaced and shows a "mapped" or "crosswalk" plan. The post my marketplace plan is being discontinued: what does plan mapping mean? covers that sequence in detail.
What to verify: compare the plan ID and the summary of benefits against your current ones. If you cannot find a difference, the name probably is not the whole story, and the summary of benefits and coverage is where the differences will appear.
What to change: nothing yet. Note the plan ID and move on.
Line 2: the new price, before and after the credit
Two prices appear, and people confuse them. The full premium is what the insurer charges for the plan. The premium after credit is what you pay each month once the advance premium tax credit is applied. If you do not receive an advance credit, the two are the same.
Look at the after-credit amount first, but check the full premium too, because the full premium changes more than most people expect. KFF reported in November 2026 that the average benchmark silver premium is up about 13% for 2027, after about 26% for 2026, though individual plans move more or less than that. A rise in your plan's full premium does not automatically raise what you pay, because the credit is tied to the benchmark plan in your area, not to your plan. The glossary entry for benchmark plan explains the link.
What to verify: the after-credit monthly amount against what you paid this year and what you can afford. If it jumped, the post My marketplace premium jumped at renewal: what should I check first? lists the causes to check.
What to change: if the price no longer works, plan to compare other plans in the same account before the deadline, which is covered below.
Line 3: the credit estimate and the income behind it
This line shows how much advance premium tax credit the marketplace plans to send to your insurer each month. It comes from the income and household size on your application, which the marketplace updates from your previous application and sometimes from tax data. The number on the notice is only as good as those inputs.
Several things changed for 2027 that make this line matter more than usual:
- The credit schedule is the original Affordable Care Act schedule, not the enhanced version that expired on December 31, 2025. For 2027, the share of income expected toward the benchmark plan runs from 2.15% to 10.22%, according to IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26, and there is no credit above 400% of the poverty level.
- That cutoff for 2027 coverage is $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four, using the 2026 poverty guidelines.
- Excess advance credit must be repaid in full beginning with tax year 2026, with no cap tied to income.
What to verify: that the income on file is your best estimate for 2027, not last year's number carried forward. Include everyone who will be in your tax household. If income is irregular, the post My income swings month to month: how do I estimate a year for the marketplace? shows how to estimate.
What to change: update the application if the numbers are wrong. A realistic estimate lowers the risk of a repayment; an inflated one means paying more each month than necessary. The How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share guide has the method.
Line 4: the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum
Two figures decide how much you pay when you actually use care. The deductible is what you pay before the plan starts sharing most costs. The out-of-pocket maximum is the most you pay in covered in-network care during the plan year.
For plan year 2027 the federal ceiling on the out-of-pocket maximum is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for other than self-only coverage, up from $10,600 and $21,200 for 2026 (CMS guidance published January 29, 2026). Many plans set theirs lower. If you qualify for cost-sharing reductions with a silver plan, the 2027 limits for the lower-income variants are $4,000 for one person at 100% to 150% of the poverty level and $9,600 at 200% to 250%.
What to verify: both figures against this year's, and whether the deductible is embedded (each family member has an individual one) or aggregate. What to change: nothing on this line by itself. It feeds the comparison in the next section.
Line 5: copays and coinsurance for the services you use
Not every service sits behind the deductible. Many plans charge a flat copay for primary care visits or generic drugs from the first visit and apply the deductible to hospital stays and imaging. The summary of benefits lists these in a table.
Pick the five or six things you actually use: a primary care visit, a specialist visit, a generic prescription, a lab test, urgent care, and one planned procedure if you have one. Compare each between this year's plan and next year's. Small changes, such as a $30 copay becoming $40, add up when you use them often.
Line 6: the network
A plan renews with the same name but may not renew with the same doctors. Networks change from year to year as insurers and providers renegotiate contracts, and a plan can narrow its network at renewal without changing its name.
What to verify: search the insurer's directory for each doctor and facility you use, and for any you may need, then confirm by calling the doctor's billing office and asking whether they participate in the specific plan by name and ID. Directories can be out of date. The guide how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network provides a step-by-step method.
What to change: if a key doctor or the hospital you rely on has dropped out, you have a reason to shop. The post My doctor just left my plan's network. Do I have to switch plans or doctors? covers what to do if the change happens during the year.
Line 7: the drug list
The formulary decides whether each drug is covered, at what tier, and whether prior authorization, step therapy or quantity limits apply. A drug that was on the list this year can move to a higher tier or off the list next year.
What to verify: look up each prescription by its exact name and strength in next year's formulary, using the search tool on the plan page or the insurer's website, and note the tier. Then confirm by phone if the drug is expensive or essential.
What to change: if a drug moved up a tier or came with new restrictions, compare other plans, and ask the prescriber whether an alternative exists.
Line 8: other items near the bottom
The last items on the notice are easy to skip and sometimes matter most.
- People on the plan. Confirm that everyone who should be covered is listed and that nobody who has left your household remains on it.
- Other coverage. If you have been offered employer coverage, or you are newly eligible for Medicare or Medicaid, tell the marketplace. Eligibility for premium tax credits can depend on it.
- Contact information. If the marketplace cannot reach you, you may miss a request for documents, and a missed request can lead to loss of credits.
- Tax filing. The credit is reconciled on your tax return using Form 1095-A. Not filing, or filing without reconciling, can create trouble in later years.
What happens if you do nothing
Doing nothing is a real option, and for some people it is the right one. If you do nothing and your plan is still offered, you are generally re-enrolled in it, and the advance credit continues under the income on file, as updated from available data. This is automatic re-enrollment.
As of November 2026, two cautions apply. First, a rule that moved some people from bronze to silver at renewal is no longer available, according to healthinsurance.org's summary, so the plan you are renewed into is not upgraded for you. Second, auto-renewal with credits is expected to change for plan year 2028. The post what does the end of automatic renewal with credits mean for my plan? explains what the statute and a proposed rule say.
A plan that auto-renews is not the same as a plan you have compared. The post compare my renewed marketplace plan with the other options: a worksheet provides a worksheet.
A checklist to finish before the deadline
- Write down the plan ID and the full and after-credit premiums.
- Update income, household and other coverage in your account.
- Check each doctor, facility and drug against next year's plan.
- Compare at least two other plans for total yearly cost, using the worksheet.
- Pick a plan and confirm it, or confirm in writing that you intend to stay.
- Save the confirmation page or email and look for the new insurer's first bill.
A navigator or licensed broker can walk through the account with you at no charge to you in most cases. The guide How the ACA marketplace works: HealthCare.gov and state exchanges explains the process.
Key takeaways
- A renewal notice is a proposal: if you do nothing, you are generally re-enrolled in the plan it names, at the price it shows, with the income on file.
- On HealthCare.gov the plan year 2027 window runs through January 15, 2027, and December 15 is the last day to choose a plan that starts January 1.
- Check the income and household in your account first: the 2027 credit schedule has no credit above 400% of the poverty level.
- Compare the network and drug list line by line, because the plan name staying the same does not mean the doctors and drugs did.
- Save every confirmation and watch for the first bill from your plan.