Blog

My Advantage plan says my rehab stay is ending. How do I ask for a fast appeal?

What the Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage means, who takes the fast appeal call, why the deadline is so short, and what to do if the appeal fails.

A nurse hands your mother a piece of paper in the skilled nursing facility: her Medicare Advantage plan has decided her covered stay ends in two days. She still cannot get from the bed to the bathroom without help, and nobody has told you where she will go. This post is for the relative who is holding that paper, because the clock on it is much shorter than the clock on most insurance appeals, and the first call is made to someone you may never have heard of.

The paper is called the Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage. It is not a bill and it is not the end of the matter. It starts a fast appeal right, and the right expires quickly.

What the notice is, and what it is not

When a Medicare Advantage plan (or Original Medicare) has decided that covered care from a skilled nursing facility, a home health agency, a rehabilitation outpatient center or a hospice should stop, the provider must hand the patient a written notice before services end. For a skilled nursing stay, the notice is normally delivered at least two calendar days before the last covered day. It names the effective date, which is the day coverage ends, and it says how to ask for a fast appeal.

Three things the notice does not do:

  • It does not discharge anyone. Whether the patient leaves the building is a separate question from whether the plan keeps paying.
  • It does not say the care was unnecessary in the past. It says the plan believes the patient no longer needs skilled care, meaning care that must be given or supervised by nurses or therapists, as of the effective date. Your mother's earlier days were covered.
  • It does not decide whether the patient can stay at their own expense. Most facilities will keep a resident who pays privately, but that is a business decision between you and the facility.

The reasoning the plan used matters. Coverage of a skilled nursing stay under skilled nursing facility coverage turns on whether the patient needs skilled nursing or skilled therapy services, generally on a daily basis, that as a practical matter can only be given in a facility. Improvement is not the test: a patient can need skilled care to keep from getting worse. The question of whether care is medically necessary belongs to the clinicians, and a plan's first answer is not the last. A common reason a plan gives for ending coverage is that the patient has "plateaued" or can be cared for at home with visits. Whether that is true for your relative is the question the appeal answers, and it is a medical question, not a plan-contract question.

Who decides the fast appeal

The fast appeal does not go to the plan's own internal appeal unit. See Does Medicare pay for nursing home care and home care? for how skilled nursing coverage works in general. It goes to an independent reviewer called a Quality Improvement Organization, which Medicare contracts with in each region; the current name for the type that handles these appeals is a Beneficiary and Family Centered Care QIO, often shortened to BFCC-QIO. It is staffed by clinicians and physicians who are not employees of your plan. The notice prints the name and phone number of the QIO for your area. Use the number on the paper in your hands; do not search for one online, and do not accept a number from anyone who calls you.

Because the QIO is independent, the appeal is a different animal from the appeals that go back to an insurer's own unit. Reading How to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial, from plan to independent review will show how a regular denial climbs through levels. The fast appeal for ending a stay is its own track with its own, much shorter, deadlines.

The deadline

The notice states the time limit, and the usual rule is this: the request must be made no later than noon of the day before the effective date on the notice. If the notice says coverage ends on a Friday, the call is due by noon on Thursday. If the notice arrives on a Wednesday for a Friday ending, you effectively have Wednesday afternoon and Thursday morning.

Plan around that:

  1. Read the effective date the moment you get the notice, and write the deadline on the notice itself.
  2. Call the QIO the same day, even if you are not sure you will win. A call can be withdrawn; a missed deadline cannot be undone.
  3. Do not wait for the doctor to agree before you call. You can ask for a doctor's help while the appeal is open.
  4. Do not wait for the facility to tell you what to do. The facility delivers the notice; it does not file the appeal for you.

If you miss the noon deadline, there are still options, covered below, but they are slower and the safety net is thinner. That is the single reason to move on the first afternoon.

Step-by-step: asking for the fast appeal

Step 1. Get the paperwork in order. You need the notice, the patient's Medicare number (it is on the red-white-and-blue card or on the plan card), the name of the plan, the facility's name and address, and the patient's room. If the patient signed the notice, a signature is only a receipt: it says the patient received it, not that the patient agrees.

Step 2. Decide who is calling. If the patient is mentally able, they can make the request themselves or tell the QIO that a named family member may speak for them. If the patient cannot, the person with legal authority (a health care agent under a power of attorney, a guardian, in some cases a close relative under state law) can make the request. Tell the QIO who you are and ask what it needs from you. This is a place where a short phone call to the patient's social worker at the facility can save time.

Step 3. Call the QIO number on the notice. Say: "I am calling to request a fast-track appeal of a Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage for [name], a member of [plan name], at [facility]. The effective date is [date]." Write down the name of the person you speak to, the time, and any case number. If you reach a voicemail, leave the same message and call again; the notice also tells you what to do outside business hours.

Step 4. Ask the facility for the detailed explanation. After the request, the QIO asks the plan and the facility for records. The plan must give you, in writing, a detailed explanation of why it thinks coverage should end. You may also ask the facility for the patient's therapy notes. Ask the patient's therapist and nurse a direct question: "What can she not yet do safely, and what would happen if she went home on that date?"

Step 5. Offer your side to the reviewer. The QIO asks the patient or the representative why the stay should continue. Be concrete. "She needs two people to move her" is stronger than "she is not ready." Report falls, wounds that need dressing, medications that need adjusting, swallowing problems, or therapy goals that are not yet met. Ask the patient's own doctor, if reachable, to speak with the QIO or to send a note.

Step 6. Ask about money before the answer arrives. Ask the QIO, and then the facility's business office, a precise question: "If the QIO agrees with the plan, on what day do I start owing, and at what daily rate?" Write both answers down. That is not a pessimistic question; it lets you decide, with eyes open, whether to stay, move or arrange care at home.

Step 7. Expect a decision quickly. QIOs decide fast appeals in a matter of a day or so after they have the records, and they tell the patient and the plan. The decision is communicated by phone and followed by a written notice. Keep the notice.

What happens to the bill while the appeal runs

The details of liability depend on the date and timing of the QIO's decision and on the notice itself, so ask for the date in writing. The general design of the fast appeal is that a timely request keeps the covered stay going while the QIO looks at the case, and that the patient is not charged for covered services during that review. If the QIO agrees with the plan, the notice and the QIO tell you the date from which you may be responsible for the daily cost.

Keep two numbers in mind.

First, the plan's cost-sharing for the stay. Under Original Medicare in 2026, days 1 to 20 of a covered skilled nursing stay carry no coinsurance, and days 21 to 100 carry $217 a day (the 100-day myth post explains why "100 days" is a ceiling, not a promise). A Medicare Advantage plan sets its own copayments, and the amounts and the day count can differ from Original Medicare. Look at the plan's Evidence of Coverage or ask the plan for the schedule. If the patient has been in the facility for 20 days or fewer, the daily copay may still be low or zero. Past that, the difference can be large.

Second, the facility's private-pay rate. If the stay stops being covered, the facility will quote a daily rate. Ask for it in writing, along with what it includes: room, meals, nursing, therapy, medication administration. A hypothetical illustration: at $350 a day, a week is $2,450 and a month is $10,500. Those numbers are invented to show the arithmetic, not a price. The actual rate in your area varies widely.

A patient with limited resources may qualify for Medicaid to cover a long stay, with state-specific rules on income, assets and look-back periods. That is a different program with a different office; the state's Medicaid agency and the facility's social worker can start that process while the appeal runs. See medicaid for the basics.

If the QIO agrees with the plan

You still have choices. A QIO agreeing with the plan is not a clinical verdict that the patient is fine. It means the reviewer decided that, on the records, skilled care in a facility was no longer needed as of the date.

  • Ask what skilled needs remain. If the patient will need nursing visits, wound care or therapy at home, ask whether home health care is covered and who arranges it. The plan must still cover what Medicare covers, in or out of the facility, subject to its own rules for approvals and networks.
  • Ask for a care plan before discharge. The facility's discharge planner can arrange equipment, home health, follow-up visits and transportation. Ask for the plan in writing, ask who is coming to the house and when, and ask what happens if the first visit is late.
  • Ask whether a reconsideration is possible. In some circumstances a patient who stays can ask the QIO to look again, within a very short time stated on the decision letter. Ask the QIO what the next step is and by when. If you cannot meet the deadline, you can still ask the plan for a regular appeal of the coverage decision on its own track, which is slower and does not by itself keep the facility paying.
  • Ask about a new qualifying need. If the patient falls, is readmitted to the hospital or develops a new problem, a new hospital stay can start a new coverage question. That is a clinical decision for the patient's doctor and the facility, not something to engineer.

If you missed the deadline

The fast appeal is the best tool, but not the only one. If the noon deadline has passed, call the plan and ask for an expedited reconsideration of the termination decision. An expedited request is meant for situations where waiting could harm the patient's health. The plan has a short time limit to answer an expedited request, and you can ask the patient's doctor to support it by stating that waiting would put the patient at risk. If the plan refuses to treat it as expedited, ask for that refusal in writing and ask how to complain.

You can also file a complaint with the plan or with Medicare if you believe the notice was late, incomplete or not given at all. The plan's rules require that the notice be delivered at least two days before the effective date. If it was not, say so in the first minute of any call. The state's SHIP counselor, SHIP, helps people with Medicare for free and may be able to review the notice with you.

A realistic example, with invented numbers

Say Raymond, 81, spent four days in the hospital after a fall and now lives in a skilled nursing facility for therapy. His plan is a Medicare Advantage HMO. On day 17 of the stay, the facility gives his daughter, Alicia, a notice saying coverage ends on day 19, a Friday.

  • Wednesday afternoon: Alicia reads the notice, writes "noon Thursday" at the top, and calls the QIO number on the page. She asks for a fast appeal and gets a case number.
  • Wednesday evening: she asks the facility's therapist what Raymond cannot do yet. The therapist says he needs help to get from sitting to standing and has not yet walked more than a short distance with a walker.
  • Thursday morning: she reaches Raymond's primary care doctor's office and asks the doctor to speak with the QIO if called.
  • Thursday: the QIO asks Alicia for her view and gets the plan's file. She sends a short statement of Raymond's needs.
  • Friday: the QIO calls with its decision.

If the QIO agrees with Raymond, the plan keeps paying, subject to its own review later. If it agrees with the plan, Alicia has the cost answers she wrote down on Wednesday, and the facility's social worker has already started discharge planning. The outcome is not guaranteed either way. What the calls bought was time to make a plan.

Questions to ask people

  • To the QIO: "What do you need from me to start? When will you decide? Where do I send documents? Whom do I call if I do not hear back?"
  • To the plan: "What is the written reason coverage ends? Which clinician made the decision, and what records did they use?"
  • To the facility: "Who will write the therapy summary? What is the daily private rate? Can the patient stay while we appeal?"
  • To the patient's doctor: "Will you tell the reviewer in writing what skilled care is still needed?"
  • To the SHIP counselor: "Can you help me read the notice and the plan's explanation?"

Key takeaways

  • The Notice of Medicare Non-Coverage starts a fast appeal right; the usual deadline is noon on the day before the effective date, so call the QIO number on the notice the same day.
  • An independent QIO, not the plan, decides the fast appeal, and the question is whether the patient still needs skilled care, not whether the patient is improving.
  • Ask in writing which day you would start owing and at what daily rate, and compare it with the plan's cost-sharing schedule and the facility's private rate.
  • If the deadline is missed or the appeal is lost, ask the plan for an expedited reconsideration, start discharge and home health planning at once, and call a SHIP counselor or the state Medicaid office about longer-term help.
  • Keep a log: names, times, case numbers and the notice itself, since every later step depends on them.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic