Blog

How to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial, from plan to independent review

Medicare Advantage appeal levels in order: who can file, what the notice deadlines mean, how to build the file with a doctor statement, and fast appeals.

The denial notice is in your hand. Whether it says the plan will not approve a service, will not pay a claim, or is ending coverage for a stay, it contains the one thing you need first: a date. The Medicare Advantage appeal process runs on deadlines, and the notice you received states yours. This walk-through follows the process from that notice through each level, in order, and shows how to assemble the file that wins appeals when they are won.

Nothing here predicts how your case will come out. Appeals are decided on the facts, the medical records and Medicare's coverage rules, and a free counselor can look at your notice with you.

First, read what kind of decision you have

Medicare Advantage uses specific words, and the type of decision decides which track you are on.

  • Organization determination: the plan's decision on whether to cover a service or pay a claim. A denial of prior authorization is one. So is a refusal to pay a bill for care you already received.
  • Reconsideration: the first level of appeal, a fresh review by the plan of its own decision.
  • Pre-service request: you are asking before the care. Timeframes are shorter.
  • Payment request: you are asking the plan to pay a bill or reimburse you for care you already got.
  • Fast-track appeal: a separate, quicker route for notices that your hospital stay, skilled nursing care, home health care or rehab coverage is ending. It goes to a reviewer outside the plan, the Quality Improvement Organization, and it runs on a much shorter clock. My Advantage plan says my rehab stay is ending. How do I ask for a fast appeal? covers that route.

A grievance is something else. It is a complaint about service, such as a long hold time or rude staff, and it does not reverse a coverage decision. grievance and Appeal, grievance or complaint: which one am I filing? explain how to tell them apart. If your goal is to get something covered or paid, you want an appeal.

Who can file

You can file your own appeal. So can an appointed representative: a family member, friend, lawyer or advocate you name using Medicare's Appointment of Representative form (CMS-1696) or an equivalent written statement signed by both of you. A physician who treats you can request a standard pre-service reconsideration on your behalf, and can request an expedited one, without the form. For a payment request after the fact, the rules are narrower for doctors who contract with the plan, so ask the plan which route applies.

If you are acting for a parent or spouse, appealing for a parent, spouse or child: authorized representative forms covers the forms and the questions to expect.

Level 1: the plan's reconsideration

This is where nearly every appeal starts. You ask the plan to take another look. A different clinician than the one who made the first decision must review it, and when the denial was based on medical necessity, the reviewer is a physician with appropriate expertise.

Deadline to file. The notice states how many days you have, counted in calendar days from the date on the notice. It runs to roughly two months. A late request can be accepted if you show good cause, such as serious illness, but do not plan on it.

How to file. In writing, by mail, fax or the plan's portal, and by phone for expedited requests, to the address in the notice. Keep a copy, and record the date and method. claim denial appeal letter builder helps organize a letter, and how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read covers structure.

The plan's time to decide. For a standard pre-service request the plan has 30 calendar days. For a request to pay for care already received, the period is longer. If the plan decides in your favor, it must authorize or pay within the stated time. An expedited reconsideration gets a decision within 72 hours.

If the plan misses the deadline, the failure is treated as upholding the denial, and the plan must send the case to the next level automatically. Do not wait silently: call and ask for the status in writing.

Level 2: the independent review entity

If the plan upholds its denial, in whole or in part, it must forward the case to an independent review entity (IRE), a contractor outside the plan that works for Medicare. You do not file this level, and you do not pay for it. The plan sends the case file, and you are told it has been sent.

What you can do at this level is add evidence. If you have new records or a new statement from your doctor, send it promptly to the IRE with the case reference. The reviewer decides whether the service meets Medicare coverage rules and, for a medical necessity question, looks at the clinical record.

If the IRE rules in your favor, the plan must provide the service or pay within the time limits in the decision. If it rules against you, the notice tells you whether you can go further, and by when.

Level 3: a hearing before an administrative law judge

If the IRE upholds the denial and the amount in question meets a minimum dollar threshold that is set each year, you may request a hearing before an administrative law judge. The request is generally due within 60 days of the IRE's notice, and the notice gives the exact date. The hearing is often by phone or video, and you can bring a representative or a doctor.

The threshold and the time the case takes both change, and the wait at this level can be long. The notice of the IRE decision states the current amount, so do not rely on an older figure you may see elsewhere.

Level 4 and level 5: the Appeals Council and federal court

If the judge rules against you, you can ask the Medicare Appeals Council to review the decision, again generally within 60 days. If that fails and a higher amount is at stake, the last level is a lawsuit in federal district court, generally within 60 days of the Council's decision. Few cases get this far, and most people who reach this stage use a lawyer or legal aid. For a plain-language path, Medicare Advantage appeal levels from reconsideration to federal court describes the same levels in a separate post.

The pattern to remember: the first level asks the plan again, the second brings in an outside reviewer automatically, and the later levels are yours to request, each with its own deadline in the previous notice.

Build the file: what to gather

An appeal is a document, and a well-organized file does more than an emotional letter. Assemble:

  1. The denial notice, with the date and the stated reason.
  2. The plan's coverage documents: the Evidence of Coverage sections on the benefit and on the appeal process.
  3. Medicare's own coverage rules that apply, if your doctor or a counselor can point to them. A plan generally must follow Medicare's coverage criteria where they exist, under a CMS rule in effect since 2024.
  4. Medical records: visit notes, test results, imaging, procedure reports, a list of treatments tried and what happened.
  5. A statement from your treating doctor (see the next section).
  6. A short timeline of symptoms, treatments and dates.
  7. A cover letter that names the decision you are appealing, states what you want, and lists the enclosures.

A copy of the file stays with you, and each submission gets a date. build an appeal file: which documents to gather and how to organize them goes deeper on assembly.

The doctor's statement that carries weight

The decision turns on whether the service is medically necessary and covered. The treating doctor is the person best placed to say why, and a good statement is specific. It should:

  • Name the diagnosis and the service requested.
  • Say what treatments were tried, when, and what happened.
  • Explain why alternatives the plan may prefer are not appropriate for this patient.
  • Describe the risks of not providing the service, including functional loss.
  • Refer to the criteria the plan cited and say where the patient meets or exceeds them.
  • State the doctor's credentials and specialty.

A letter that says "the patient needs this" is weaker than one that says "she has had six months of physical therapy and two injections, with continued pain and loss of function, and the next step under accepted practice is surgery." Ask the office early, and give them the denial notice so the statement answers its reasons. how to ask my doctor's office to support my appeal, with scripts to use has scripts for the request.

Fast appeals: when speed is the point

An expedited reconsideration is available when waiting for the standard time could seriously jeopardize your life, health or ability to regain maximum function. A request made or supported by a physician who says that is generally granted. The plan then decides within 72 hours, and expedited review exists at the independent level as well.

Use it when the stakes are about health, not preference. If the plan refuses to expedite, it must switch your request to the standard timeline and tell you promptly, and you can file a grievance about the refusal. Expedited appeal: when does my case count as urgent and how do I prove it? covers what to include.

Practical timeline: a hypothetical case

Say Walter, a hypothetical reader, receives a denial notice dated June 3 for a planned shoulder procedure. The notice gives a deadline to appeal about two months later. His steps look like this:

  • June 4: He calls the surgeon's office, sends them the notice and asks for a statement.
  • June 10: He sends a written reconsideration request with the notice, the records and the doctor's statement. He keeps a copy and the date.
  • By July 10: The plan decides, within 30 days of receiving the request. Say it upholds the denial.
  • July: The plan sends the case to the independent review entity. Walter sends the IRE any additional note from the surgeon.
  • August: The IRE decides. If it rules for him, the plan must cover the service. If not, the notice states his next step and the next deadline.

The dates are invented. The structure is not: act within days, keep dates and copies, and let each notice tell you the next deadline.

Where to get free help

  • A SHIP counselor in your state can read the notice with you and explain the next step, at no cost.
  • Medicare's own line, 1-800-MEDICARE, takes questions and complaints about plans.
  • Unlike a private employer or marketplace plan, a Medicare Advantage plan is overseen mainly by federal rules and CMS, and the state insurance department's role is more limited, so the state department is not always the right first call.
  • A legal aid office or an attorney who handles Medicare appeals can help with later levels or large disputes.

Mistakes that cost appeals

  • Waiting for a verbal answer instead of the written decision.
  • Missing the deadline because the date was counted from the day the notice was read, not the date on it.
  • Appealing without the doctor's statement.
  • Describing hardship but not the medical facts and the rule the plan applied.
  • Not keeping copies of what was sent.

Key takeaways

  • The denial notice states your appeal deadline. Count from the date on the notice, and file well before it.
  • The plan's reconsideration comes first; if it upholds the denial, the case goes to an independent review entity automatically, and later levels you must request, generally within 60 days each.
  • A treating doctor's specific statement, with records and a timeline, is the strongest part of the file.
  • Fast appeals exist for situations where waiting could seriously harm your health, and a physician's support matters.
  • A SHIP counselor can help for free, and a lawyer or legal aid office may help at the later levels.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic