Blog

What to ask for about health coverage when negotiating severance

A grouped checklist of health items to raise before signing severance, each with its reason, plus a worked comparison of paid premium months and cash.

A severance offer usually arrives as a single number: weeks of pay, a bonus, a date. Health coverage is often one line near the end, or nothing at all. Yet coverage can be worth thousands of dollars, and most of its terms can be raised before anyone signs. After signing, the options narrow.

This post is a checklist for the health parts of a severance conversation. Each item says what to ask and why it matters. It closes with a worked comparison of employer-paid premium months against cash, using invented round numbers. Nothing here is legal or tax advice, and the agreement itself, the plan documents and the right professional decide how a particular offer works. An employment lawyer is the person who reviews the agreement, and a tax professional is the person who looks at how the money is taxed.

Why health terms belong in the conversation

Under federal rules, a person who loses job-based coverage can usually elect COBRA continuation coverage and pay up to 102% of the full premium, with no employer share. For a family, that can be several times the old payroll deduction, as What will my COBRA bill be? Working out 102% of the full premium shows. The severance package is often the only time the employer is willing to take on part of that cost, and it can do it in several ways that have different values to the employee.

None of these items is an entitlement. An employer can say no to any of them. The aim is to know what to ask so that the answers, and the "no" answers, are in front of the person before a decision is made.

Group 1: The dates

  • Ask: On what exact date does my active coverage end, and is that date written in the agreement? Why: the end of coverage starts the clocks for COBRA and for marketplace special enrollment. A coverage end date that differs from what the plan document says is a common source of confusion. How do I find my real coverage end date, and why does it start my 60 days? explains how to pin it down.
  • Ask: Can my termination date be moved later, or can my salary continue through a stated period? Why: coverage as an active employee often continues while the person is still on payroll. A termination date at the end of a month rather than the middle, or a period of paid notice, can add weeks of coverage at the cost of the employee share only. At the figures used below, a month of active coverage costs the employee about $500 where COBRA would cost $1,836, a difference of $1,336.
  • Ask: Does coverage end on the termination date or at the end of that month? Why: plans differ, and the answer sets how many days are left for the marketplace window and how many months the first COBRA bill covers.
  • Ask: When will the COBRA election notice be sent, and to what address? Why: the notice starts the 60-day election clock, and an agreement that delays it can delay the clock. From layoff day to first COBRA payment, the dates I must not miss shows the dates.

Group 2: Employer-paid COBRA premiums

  • Ask: Will the company pay all or part of my COBRA premium, and for how many months? Why: this is the most common health term in a severance agreement. It is worth the most to someone who will actually use COBRA, for example because of ongoing treatment, a deductible already met or a network that matters.
  • Ask: Which people does the subsidy cover? Why: a subsidy for "employee-only" coverage does little for a family that needs the family tier. Say who was on the plan, and ask that the subsidy match the tier.
  • Ask: Is the subsidy paid directly to the administrator, or reimbursed to me after I pay? Why: reimbursement means advancing $1,836 a month in the example and waiting. Direct payment keeps the money out of the household's cash flow.
  • Ask: What ends the subsidy? Why: the agreement may stop it when you find another job, become covered elsewhere or miss a payment. Know the triggers, and ask whether a spouse's coverage counts.
  • Ask: If the COBRA price changes during the period, who pays the difference? Why: the plan's rates can reset, and the agreement should say whether the subsidy is a fixed dollar amount or a share of the premium.
  • Ask: Who pays the 2% administrative fee? Why: a small item, but one that is easy to leave undefined.

Group 3: Cash in place of premiums

  • Ask: Can the COBRA subsidy be paid as cash instead, or can I choose? Why: a household that expects to buy a cheaper marketplace plan, join a spouse's plan or start a new job soon may do better with cash. A household with ongoing care may prefer the premiums.
  • Ask: If I take cash, is it a lump sum or paid over time? Why: how the cash lands affects the tax year and the income used for marketplace credits.
  • Ask: If the benefit is paid premiums, what happens to the unused months if I get coverage elsewhere? Why: some agreements pay out the remaining months in cash, and others let them lapse.

A worked comparison: paid premium months or cash

Say a family's COBRA price is $1,836 a month, the figure from the worksheet post. The employer offers either of these, both invented for illustration:

  • Offer A: the company pays 6 months of COBRA premiums directly: 6 × $1,836 = $11,016 in value.
  • Offer B: a $9,000 cash payment. Say 25% is withheld or owed in taxes, an invented rate. The after-tax amount is $9,000 × (1 − 0.25) = $6,750.

The family could use either offer with either kind of coverage. Say a marketplace plan would cost $700 a month after a tax credit, so six months is 6 × $700 = $4,200. These are illustrations, not quotes.

Choice Premiums the family pays over 6 months Cash received Net cost
Offer A, use COBRA $0 (employer pays) $0 $0
Offer A, use marketplace $4,200 $0 $4,200
Offer B, use COBRA $11,016 $6,750 $4,266
Offer B, use marketplace $4,200 $6,750 −$2,550 (a net gain)

On these numbers, the best outcome depends on the plan. For a family that will use COBRA, Offer A is worth $4,266 more than Offer B, since $4,266 − $0 = $4,266. For a family that will buy a marketplace plan at $700 a month, Offer B comes out $2,550 ahead, and Offer A pays nothing toward that plan. Neither offer is better for every household. If the employer will let the employee choose after learning the marketplace price, that choice is worth asking for.

The invented tax rate is the weakest part of the comparison, and it matters, so the next group is about that.

A smaller ask with real value: keeping the employee on payroll longer

Not every health term is about COBRA. Say the employer agrees to keep the employee on payroll for two more months as paid notice, and the plan treats the person as an active employee for that time. The family keeps paying only the employee share, $500 a month in the example, instead of the COBRA price of $1,836:

  • Two months of active coverage: 2 × $500 = $1,000
  • Two months of COBRA: 2 × $1,836 = $3,672
  • Difference: $3,672 − $1,000 = $2,672

The agreement and the plan document have to say that coverage continues, and the plan administrator can confirm that it will. This kind of arrangement can also delay the start of the COBRA clocks, since coverage ends later, so ask for the new dates in writing.

Group 4: Taxes and income

  • Ask: How will the severance and the health benefit be reported? Why: cash severance is generally treated as wages. Employer-paid COBRA premiums are often treated differently, but the rules vary with the type of plan, and a tax professional can say what applies.
  • Ask: In what tax year will the cash be paid? Why: severance counts toward income for the year it is paid. For marketplace credits, income matters a great deal. As of November 2026, under current law, there is no premium tax credit above 400% of the federal poverty level, and excess advance credits must be repaid in full starting with tax year 2026. A lump sum that pushes a household's yearly income above a threshold can change the credit. the enhanced subsidies ended: the 400% cliff and what changed explains the cliff, and the premium tax credit entry covers how the credit works.
  • Ask: If the company pays my COBRA premiums and I enroll in COBRA, does that affect a marketplace credit? Why: a person who is enrolled in COBRA cannot claim a credit for those months. Being offered COBRA does not block the credit, but enrolling in it does.

This is a place where a tax professional's help can be worth the fee, because the interaction between a one-time payment and a year of credits is hard to do by hand.

Group 5: The accounts and other benefits tied to the job

  • Ask: What happens to my flexible spending account and any health reimbursement arrangement balance? Why: unspent balances can be lost on a termination date, and some plans allow a short run-out period for claims. I'm leaving my job, so what happens to my HSA, FSA and HRA? covers the usual rules for an FSA, HRA and HSA.
  • Ask: Will the company keep funding my HSA through the severance period? Why: an HSA belongs to the employee, but employer contributions typically stop with payroll.
  • Ask: Is there any retiree or early-retirement medical benefit I qualify for? Why: some employers have retiree coverage that depends on age and years of service, and it can be worth far more than a few months of COBRA.
  • Ask: Does anyone in the family approach Medicare age? Why: COBRA does not let a person delay Part B the way active employer coverage does. Why COBRA after I retire does not let me delay Medicare Part B explains it.

Group 6: The paperwork

  • Ask: Does the agreement say anything about COBRA rights, and does it ask me to waive any claim relating to benefits? Why: a release can be broad. A lawyer can tell what it covers and whether COBRA and benefit claims are affected.
  • Ask: Is every health promise in the written agreement? Why: a spoken promise from a manager is not a term of the contract.
  • Ask: How long do I have to review, and can the deadline be extended? Why: time to read the document and to ask a lawyer is itself a term worth requesting.
  • Ask: Is the coverage the agreement describes the same coverage in the plan document? Why: if the agreement and the plan disagree, the plan administrator generally follows the plan. A lawyer or the plan administrator can say how to reconcile them.
  • Ask: If the company changes or ends its health plan during the subsidy period, what happens? Why: COBRA ends when the employer ends every group health plan, and a promised subsidy needs an answer for that case.

Who to ask

An employment lawyer reviews the agreement and the release. A tax professional looks at the payments and the year's income. The plan administrator answers questions about COBRA prices and dates. A marketplace navigator or licensed broker can price the alternatives, and COBRA or a marketplace plan after a job loss: how to compare and health insurance when you lose your job: your options and deadlines cover the choice in general terms. The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration answers questions about COBRA rights.

Key takeaways

  • Raise the health items before signing: the coverage end date, any employer-paid COBRA months, the people covered and what ends the benefit.
  • Employer-paid premiums and cash are worth different amounts to different households, and the worked comparison shows the ranking can flip depending on the alternative plan.
  • Severance cash counts as income for the year it is paid, which can change marketplace credits, so the tax year and amount are worth discussing with a tax professional.
  • Check the accounts and benefits that end with the job: FSA, HRA, HSA contributions, retiree medical and Medicare timing.
  • Get every health promise in the written agreement, and have an employment lawyer review the release before signing.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic