Blog

What will my COBRA bill be? Working out 102% of the full premium

A repeatable worksheet that turns your payroll deduction and the employer's share into the full premium, adds the 2% fee and checks your COBRA notice.

The COBRA notice arrives and the monthly amount is several times what came out of your paycheck. Nothing is wrong with the arithmetic: the paycheck deduction was only your share of the premium, and COBRA asks you to pay all of it. This post shows how to rebuild that number yourself, so you can see where it comes from and spot a bill that does not add up.

The worked example uses invented, round figures for a hypothetical family. Substitute your own at the end, in the blank worksheet. The rule underneath is federal: a plan can charge a person continuing coverage up to 102% of the cost of the coverage, and up to 150% during the extra months for a disability extension.

Why the notice number looks so large

While you worked, the premium for your coverage had two payers. You paid a share through payroll, and the employer paid the rest. When coverage ends and you elect COBRA continuation coverage, the employer stops paying. The premium itself has not changed, but the whole of it now falls to you, plus a small administrative fee.

So the COBRA price is:

(your share + the employer's share) × 1.02

The 1.02 is the 2% administrative fee, which is the difference between 100% and the 102% ceiling. That is the whole formula. The hard part is finding the second number, because the employer's share does not appear on a pay stub.

Plans also price COBRA by coverage tier: employee only, employee plus spouse, employee plus children, or family. Your price is the one for the tier you were in, or the tier covering the people who elect.

Step 1: Turn the payroll deduction into a monthly number

Pay stubs show a deduction per paycheck, and the premium is a monthly figure. Convert it:

(deduction per paycheck × paychecks per year) ÷ 12

Common pay schedules are weekly (52 paychecks), every two weeks (26), twice a month (24) and monthly (12). A biweekly schedule has 26 paychecks, so the monthly figure is higher than "two paychecks" suggests.

Say the family in the example is paid twice a month and a $250 medical deduction comes out of each check:

$250 × 24 = $6,000 a year, and $6,000 ÷ 12 = $500 a month

That is the employee share.

Step 2: Find the employer's share

This is the number most people do not have. Places to look, roughly in order of how easy they are:

  • The benefits statement or total-compensation statement. Many employers print "employer cost" next to your cost.
  • The open enrollment rate sheet. It often lists the total monthly premium for each tier and the employee contribution beside it.
  • The COBRA election notice itself. Some notices show the plan's full rate for each tier before the fee.
  • HR or the plan administrator. Ask in writing for the monthly premium for your tier that the COBRA rate is based on, and how it was calculated.

For plans where the employer pays claims directly instead of buying insurance (a self-funded plan, explained in self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you), the "premium" is an estimate of the cost of coverage rather than a bill from an insurer. The rate must be set in good faith under the rules, and the administrator should be able to explain it. Whether your plan is self-funded or fully insured is listed in the summary plan description.

In the example, the employer pays $1,300 a month toward the family tier.

Steps 3 and 4: Add the shares, then the 2% fee

First the full premium. Full monthly premium = employee share + employer share

$500 + $1,300 = $1,800 a month

This number should equal the plan's total rate for your tier before the fee. If you can find it on a rate sheet, it is a useful anchor, because it ties out independently of the notice.

Then the fee. COBRA price = full premium × 1.02

$1,800 × 1.02 = $1,836 a month

The fee is $1,836 − $1,800 = $36. Do not multiply by 1.2 by accident; the fee is two percent, not twenty.

Step 5: Check the notice

Compare your result with the notice. Three outcomes are normal and one is a flag.

  • Your number matches the notice. The bill is built the way the rule allows.
  • The notice is lower. The employer may be subsidizing part of the cost, or the plan may charge less than the maximum. The rule sets a ceiling, not a price.
  • The notice is different because you estimated. If you guessed the employer's share, the gap is probably in your guess. Ask for the rate sheet.
  • The notice is higher than 102% of the full premium. This one needs an answer. Unless it falls in the disability-extension months, when the ceiling is 150%, ask the administrator in writing how the number was calculated.

Mistakes that make a rebuilt number come out wrong, even when the notice is right:

  1. Using the deduction from a single paycheck as the monthly figure. On a twice-a-month schedule that understates the monthly share by half.
  2. Leaving out vision or dental. If the notice is for medical only, use only the medical deduction. If the notice bundles dental or vision, include those lines.
  3. Using the wrong tier. An old family deduction compared with an employee-only COBRA price, or the reverse, will never match.
  4. Forgetting a spouse surcharge or a tobacco charge that was part of the payroll deduction. The full premium is the plan's rate; surcharges set by the employer's own rules may or may not carry into the COBRA price. Ask.

You can run the check backward, too. Divide the notice amount by 1.02. If the notice says $1,836, then $1,836 ÷ 1.02 = $1,800, and $1,800 should match the plan's total rate for your tier.

Step 6: Compare with what you used to pay

The honest comparison is not only price against payroll deduction. It is price against what the deduction cost you in take-home pay. Payroll deductions for employer health premiums are usually taken before income tax, and COBRA payments are usually made from after-tax money. Say the family's combined tax rate on the margin is 25%, an invented figure:

  • Old cost in take-home terms: $500 × (1 − 0.25) = $375 a month
  • COBRA cost: $1,836 a month
  • Difference: $1,836 − $375 = $1,461 a month

Over a full year, that is $1,461 × 12 = $17,532 more in take-home pay, before counting anything else. Premiums can be deductible for some households as medical expenses, but only above a threshold of income, and a tax professional can say whether yours qualify. The COBRA cost and deadline calculator runs the same arithmetic.

The family example in one table

Line Calculation Amount
Employee share per month $250 × 24 ÷ 12 $500
Employer share per month From the rate sheet $1,300
Full premium $500 + $1,300 $1,800
COBRA price with fee $1,800 × 1.02 $1,836
Monthly increase over payroll $1,836 − $500 $1,336
Cost for 12 months $1,836 × 12 $22,032
Cost for 18 months $1,836 × 18 $33,048

Say the family loses coverage and expects to be back in a job-based plan in four months. Four months is a smaller commitment than the 18-month line suggests: 4 × $1,836 = $7,344. A shorter horizon changes the comparison with a marketplace plan, since a new job's waiting period is often what sets the length of the COBRA stay, and a short stay raises the value of keeping the same doctors and deductible progress. My new job's health plan has a waiting period, so how do I cover the gap? covers that situation.

The 18-month line shows the longest period COBRA runs for a job loss. Most people use it for less time, since a new job's coverage or a marketplace plan often replaces it. But it helps a household see the total commitment it is considering. The How COBRA works: eligibility, cost and how long it lasts guide covers the periods.

Change one thing: pick a cheaper tier

COBRA prices are per tier, and each person can elect for themselves. Say the same plan lists these full premiums, again invented:

Tier Full premium COBRA price (× 1.02)
Employee only $600 $612
Employee plus children $1,200 $1,224
Family $1,800 $1,836

If a spouse has another source of coverage, the household can elect for the employee and children only: $1,224 instead of $1,836, a saving of $1,836 − $1,224 = $612 a month. That is a decision with trade-offs, since a spouse who drops off needs other coverage, and it is worth confirming with the administrator that the tiers work this way in your plan. Each qualified beneficiary has the right to elect separately.

What can change the price after you elect

The COBRA price is not locked for the whole period. A few events change it:

  • The plan's rates are updated. Rates usually reset when the plan renews, often once a year. The plan should notify you before a new amount applies.
  • A tier change. A child who ages off the plan or a spouse who leaves changes the tier you pay for.
  • The disability extension. If the disability extension applies, which can stretch coverage to as long as 29 months in total, the ceiling for the extra months is 150% of the cost.
  • An employer subsidy ending. Some severance agreements include months of paid COBRA premiums. When that ends, your own bill starts.

If the amount changes, apply the same steps: find the plan's new full rate, add the fee and compare it with the notice. Keep every notice. They are the evidence if a payment is ever disputed.

What to do with the number

Once the price is clear, the next question is whether it is the right use of the money. The numbers change the question without answering it.

For some households COBRA is worth it. It keeps the same network and the same plan, and the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum already met this year carry over. For others, a marketplace plan with a premium tax credit costs far less. A lower income after a layoff can mean a bigger credit, but the credit depends on estimated income for the whole year, and the rules have changed in recent years. The COBRA or a marketplace plan after a job loss: how to compare guide compares the two, and My spouse was laid off, so do I add them, use COBRA or go to the marketplace? works through households with a spouse's plan as a third option. For the decision on your own numbers, a marketplace navigator or a licensed broker can run quotes, and a tax professional can look at the credit.

Whatever you decide, the election deadline runs separately from the price. From layoff day to first COBRA payment, the dates I must not miss covers the dates.

Your worksheet

Copy this table and fill in your own figures. Repeat it for each tier you are weighing.

Line Your figure
A. Deduction per paycheck for health coverage $_____
B. Paychecks per year _____
C. Employee share per month: (A × B) ÷ 12 $_____
D. Employer share per month, from the rate sheet or the plan administrator $_____
E. Full premium per month: C + D $_____
F. COBRA price per month: E × 1.02 $_____
G. Amount on your COBRA notice $_____
H. Difference: G − F (should be zero or lower; ask if it is higher) $_____
I. Tax rate you used for the old take-home comparison, if you use one _____%
J. Old take-home cost: C × (1 − I) $_____
K. Monthly increase: F − J $_____
L. Months you expect to keep COBRA _____
M. Total commitment: F × L $_____

If line H is positive, the next step is a written question to the plan administrator asking how the notice amount was calculated. If the answer does not explain the gap, the U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration has benefits advisors who answer questions about COBRA, and the state insurance department handles complaints about insured plans.

Key takeaways

  • The COBRA price is (employee share + employer share) × 1.02, so the notice amount reflects the whole premium and a 2% fee, not just the part that came out of your paycheck.
  • Convert payroll deductions to a monthly figure by multiplying by the paychecks per year and dividing by 12.
  • The employer's share is the missing number; look in the benefits statement, the open enrollment rate sheet or the notice, or ask the administrator in writing.
  • The rule sets a ceiling of 102%, so a notice can be lower, and a notice above the ceiling, outside the disability-extension months, deserves a written question.
  • Prices are set by tier, so electing for fewer people can lower the bill, at the cost of those people needing other coverage.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic