Blog
My state runs its own exchange: what really differs from HealthCare.gov?
State exchanges and HealthCare.gov follow the same federal credit rules; the differences are dates, extra help, plan design, help available and the site itself.
If you live in a state with its own marketplace, you have probably heard that it is "different" from HealthCare.gov and wondered how. The answer is narrower than it sounds. The federal rules that decide who gets a premium tax credit, how large it is and what a plan must cover are the same everywhere. What a state exchange can change is when you must enroll, how much extra help the state adds, how plans are laid out for comparison, who is available to help you and what the website looks like.
This post compares the two models on those points, with a table, a worked timeline for a December sign-up and a short decision list. It is written as of November 2026 for plan year 2027. You do not choose between the two models: your state's residents use the state's marketplace, whichever kind it is, and how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help shows how to find yours.
The models, in plain terms
A marketplace is the website and the eligibility office through which people buy individual-market plans and receive credits. There are three setups for plan year 2027, according to KFF:
- State-based marketplaces. The state runs the site, call center and enrollment. KFF lists 22 for 2027: California, Colorado, Connecticut, the District of Columbia, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia and Washington. See state-based exchange.
- State-based marketplaces on the federal platform. Two states make their own decisions but use HealthCare.gov's technology.
- The federally facilitated marketplace. The federal government runs HealthCare.gov for the remaining 27 states. See federally facilitated marketplace.
If you are in one of the 22, you will never use HealthCare.gov to apply. If you try, it will send you back to your state.
What is the same
- The credit. The premium tax credit is a federal tax rule. The applicable percentage table for 2027 runs from 2.15% to 10.22% of income toward the benchmark plan, and there is no credit above 400% of the poverty level ($63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four for 2027 coverage), on every marketplace. See How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share.
- The protections. No denial or higher price for a pre-existing condition, the essential health benefit categories and the limits on out-of-pocket costs apply to all marketplace plans. For 2027 the federal ceiling on the out-of-pocket maximum is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family.
- The reconciliation. You reconcile advance credits on a federal return using Form 1095-A in every case, and for tax year 2026 any excess advance credit must be repaid with no cap.
- Free help from navigators and assisters. Every marketplace has them, though the organizations differ.
What differs
| HealthCare.gov (27 states) | State-based marketplace (22 states) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who runs it | Federal government | The state or a state-created agency |
| Open enrollment for 2027 | November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027; December 15 for a January 1 start | Varies by state: Idaho ends December 15; many end January 15; others January 23, 29 or 31 |
| Cutoff for a January 1 start | December 15 | Set by the state, often later, such as December 31 in some |
| Extra state subsidies | Rare | Common in some, absent in others |
| Plan design | Plans vary by insurer | Some states require standardized plan designs or offer a public option |
| Special enrollment periods | Federal list | Federal list plus any the state adds |
| Brokers | Federally registered; new registrations paused until February 2027 | State certification and rules |
| Application experience | One site and call center for all federal states | Different site, forms and call center in each state |
| Moving | Update or reapply | Reapply on the new state's marketplace if you move between states |
The enrollment dates in the table come from a secondary compilation and the state marketplaces themselves; confirm yours at the source.
Enrollment dates: a December example
Say three invented households, each in a different place, finish choosing a plan on December 20, 2026 and pay promptly.
| Household | Marketplace | Result |
|---|---|---|
| A | HealthCare.gov | After the December 15 cutoff, enrollment generally starts February 1, 2027, leaving January uncovered (31 days) |
| B | Massachusetts Health Connector | The state page says to enroll by December 23, 2026 for January 1 coverage, so coverage starts January 1 |
| C | Covered California | The state advises applying by December 31 for January 1 coverage, so coverage starts January 1 |
A household that waits until December 28 gets a different set of results: HealthCare.gov and Massachusetts both generally start February 1, and California is still inside its stated window. A confirmation screen should state the effective date, and a plan is not in force until the first premium is paid, so the payment date matters as much as the selection date. open enrollment dates and coverage start calculator helps you check your own dates. As in the federal case, the January 15 date at the end of the window is a deadline to enroll at all, not a deadline for a January start.
One more detail: Idaho's window ends December 15, 2026, a month before most others, so Idaho residents who plan to wait until January are most at risk of finding the window closed.
Extra state help
State exchanges are where most extra subsidies live, because the state controls the website and can build its program into the application. Examples from the state pages on this site, as of November 2026:
- New Mexico pays state premium subsidies and cost-sharing help on its exchange up to 400% of the poverty level.
- Maryland Premium Assistance reaches up to 400% of the poverty level and offsets part or all of the lost enhanced federal credits, depending on income.
- Massachusetts runs ConnectorCare, a state-funded layer on federal credits.
- Virginia and Rhode Island created new state subsidies for 2027, per KFF.
Many state-based marketplaces also have reinsurance programs, and prices there are affected by it. KFF reports the average benchmark silver premium rising about 11% in HealthCare.gov states and about 16% in state-based marketplaces for 2027, after about 30% and about 17% for 2026. Those averages hide wide variation, and the reasons include state rules, insurer exits and state funding choices, not just the type of marketplace. For how the state layers work and how to look yours up, see Does my state add premium help on top of federal credits, and how do I find it?.
Plan design and comparison tools
A state exchange can decide how plans are shown and, within federal limits, how they are designed. Some require insurers to offer standardized plans with the same deductible and copays across companies, so that a shopper compares networks and premiums rather than benefit designs. Some have a public option, such as Colorado's. HealthCare.gov offers filters and a plan-compare tool across its states. Standardized plans are one area where federal rules have been in flux: KFF reports that the 2025 rule's elimination of standardized-plan requirements is not being implemented, so check what your own marketplace currently offers.
None of these differences changes what a plan must cover. They change how easy it is to compare.
Help available
Navigators, certified application counselors and brokers exist on both. On HealthCare.gov brokers register through the federal platform, and as of November 2026 new broker registrations there are paused until February 2027 as part of an anti-fraud effort. State exchanges certify their own brokers and often run their own storefront and in-person assistance programs. If you want to speak to a person, use the "find local help" feature on your own marketplace's site, not a search result or an unsolicited call. how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator explains the roles.
The site itself. Because a state controls its own site, the experience can differ: how accounts are created, which documents it accepts, how it handles proof requests and whether it shows both the federal credit and state help in one price line. If you use a state site, expect your own state's language and layout, and be careful of lookalike sites. Always type the address from the state's official source.
What a state cannot change
A state exchange has real power over presentation and extras, but not over the core. It cannot lengthen the federal credit's income range, so the credit still ends above 400% of the poverty level, and it cannot waive the requirement to repay excess advance credit on the federal return. It cannot let an insurer deny or reprice you for a health condition. It can add its own rules on top, within the limits of federal law and, for some programs, with a waiver: reinsurance and some state subsidy designs run under a section 1332 waiver. If someone tells you that your state exchange has "its own subsidy rules" that replace the federal ones, ask which part: it is almost always an addition to the federal credit, not a substitute.
Questions to ask your own marketplace
Because the differences sit in details, a few direct questions get further than general reading. Ask a navigator, the call center or the website's help pages:
- What is the last day to pick a plan for a January 1 start, and the last day to enroll at all?
- Is there any state premium or cost-sharing help, and does it apply automatically or need a separate application?
- Are plans standardized, and if so, how do I tell which are the standard designs?
- Which special enrollment reasons does the state add to the federal list, and how do I prove them?
- How are proof requests sent, and how long do I have to answer?
- If my plan is discontinued or my insurer leaves, what does the exchange do with my enrollment?
- Which of the help options near me are navigators, which are brokers and which are state employees?
The answers belong to the current plan year. A rule that applied to 2026 enrollment may not apply to 2027, and a marketplace's own page is the authority.
If you move
A marketplace plan is tied to the state where you live. If you move to another state, the plan generally ends and you apply on the new state's marketplace, through a special enrollment period for the move. The two sites are separate: your account, your credits and your plan history do not transfer. Buying from an insurer's website vs the marketplace: do I still get my credit? covers why you should be sure any new enrollment goes through the marketplace.
A short decision list
- If you live in a state-based marketplace state, use your state's site and ignore HealthCare.gov. If in one of the 27, use HealthCare.gov.
- If your state has its own exchange, check its end date first. It may be earlier or later than the federal one.
- If you want extra state help, look for it on the state exchange's financial help page and ask a navigator.
- If you are comparing a plan on an insurer's site with one on the marketplace, confirm that the enrollment goes through the marketplace so the credit applies.
- If you move, plan to reapply in the new state.
Key takeaways
- Federal credit and coverage rules are the same on every marketplace; the differences live in dates, extra state help, plan design, help available and the website.
- The enrollment deadline for a January 1 start can differ by weeks: December 15 on HealthCare.gov, later in many states, earlier in Idaho.
- Extra premium and cost-sharing help is concentrated in state exchanges, but not every state exchange offers it.
- You do not pick the marketplace; your state of residence does, and moving means reapplying.
- Confirm dates, rules and help on your own state's marketplace, because they change by plan year.