Blog
Buying from an insurer's website vs the marketplace: do I still get my credit?
An insurer's site can enroll you with or without the tax credit, depending on the path behind it. How to tell which you are on and how to fix a wrong one.
You have found a plan you like on an insurer's own website, with the same name, the same network and what looks like the same price as the one on the marketplace. Whether you keep your tax credit depends on something the website may not make obvious: whether the enrollment is processed through the marketplace's system or outside it. Buying the plan "directly" can be perfectly fine, or it can quietly cost you thousands of dollars of credit for the year.
This post compares the paths, shows how to tell which one you are on, works a numeric example with invented figures and explains what to do if you discover you are on the wrong one. It is written as of November 2026, during open enrollment for plan year 2027. The person who answers your own case is a marketplace navigator, a licensed broker or the insurer's enrollment line, and a tax professional for the return.
Three paths that can look alike
Marketplace plans reach consumers three ways.
- The marketplace itself. HealthCare.gov or your state's exchange. You apply, the marketplace determines eligibility for the credit and cost-sharing help, you pick a plan, and the insurer is told. This is "on-exchange."
- Enhanced direct enrollment. Some insurer sites and private web-based brokers are approved to host the full marketplace application and plan selection on their own pages. Behind the scenes the application goes to the marketplace for the eligibility determination and the enrollment is recorded as on-exchange. You can get the credit on one of these sites, provided the site is an approved partner and you complete the marketplace application on it.
- Off-exchange direct purchase. You apply to the insurer for a plan sold outside the marketplace. The coverage can be an identical plan, with the same premium and the same network, but the marketplace has no record of it. Premium tax credits and income-based cost-sharing reductions are not available for it.
From the screen alone you cannot always tell paths two and three apart; the second looks like a long application with income questions, the third like a short purchase form. Both are "the insurer's website."
How the paths compare
| Marketplace (HealthCare.gov or state exchange) | Enhanced direct enrollment site | Off-exchange direct purchase | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Premium tax credit | Yes, if eligible | Yes, if the site completes the marketplace application | No |
| Cost-sharing reductions | Yes, on silver plans if eligible | Yes, same | No |
| Plan menu | All plans in your area from participating insurers | Depends: often one company's plans or a limited set | One insurer's plans, including some sold only off-exchange |
| Who helps | Navigators, counselors, brokers, call center | The site's agents or brokers | The insurer or its brokers |
| Records afterward | Form 1095-A from the marketplace | Form 1095-A from the marketplace | A 1095-B or 1095-C may be sent; no 1095-A |
| Premium for the same plan | Same as off-exchange | Same | Same |
| Typical user | Anyone, especially those wanting credits | People who want credits through a specific site | People with no credit anyway, or a plan sold only off-exchange |
The premium for the same plan is the same inside and outside the marketplace, because insurers must charge the same rate for the same plan. The credit is what differs, and the credit is applied to the on-exchange premium.
A worked example, with invented numbers
Say a single adult has an income of $31,920 for 2027, which is 200% of the 2026 poverty guideline of $15,960. The 2027 table asks someone at 200% to pay 6.78% of income toward the benchmark plan, which is $31,920 x 0.0678 = $2,164 a year. Assume the benchmark plan costs $700 a month, or $8,400 a year, and the person chooses a plan priced at the benchmark.
- On the marketplace or an approved partner site: credit = $8,400 - $2,164 = $6,236 a year, or about $520 a month. The person pays about $180 a month.
- Off-exchange, same plan: no credit, so the person pays $700 a month, $8,400 a year.
The gap is $6,236 for the year for the same insurance card, the same doctors and the same insurer. Claiming the credit later on the tax return is not a way out, because the credit is not available for coverage that was not purchased through the marketplace. For someone at this income level, getting the path wrong is expensive. For someone with an income above 400% of the poverty level ($63,840 for one person, $132,000 for a family of four, for 2027 coverage), there is no federal credit either way, so the path matters much less.
How to tell which path you are on
Do not rely on how the site looks. Check evidence that the marketplace has your enrollment.
- Look for your plan in your marketplace account. Log in to HealthCare.gov or your state's marketplace. If the plan appears under your application's coverage, it is on-exchange. If not, it is probably off-exchange.
- Look at the application. An on-exchange or partner application asks about household, income and tax filing and then reports an eligibility result, such as the amount of credit you qualify for. An off-exchange form usually does not.
- Read the confirmation. The insurer's confirmation may say "individual and family plan" without saying on or off the exchange; the marketplace sends a notice for on-exchange coverage.
- Ask directly. Call the insurer's enrollment line, using the number from its own website, and ask whether the coverage is on-exchange and whether the marketplace has been told. Ask the same of a broker.
- Watch for Form 1095-A. Exchange coverage produces Form 1095-A in early the following year, which the tax return uses to reconcile the credit. If you expected one and none arrives, that is a signal, but it is a late one.
how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator covers how to tell who is who.
Which path suits which person
The cases below do not recommend a company. They show how the same facts point to different paths.
- You expect a credit. Use the marketplace, or an approved partner site that completes the marketplace application. Do not use an insurer's short purchase form.
- You are above 400% of the poverty level. There is no federal credit under the schedule that returned on January 1, 2026. The marketplace and off-exchange paths cost the same for the same plan. Choose by plan, network and convenience, and ask whether your state has any extra help. See Does my state add premium help on top of federal credits, and how do I find it?.
- You want a plan sold only off-exchange. Some insurers sell products outside the marketplace that do not appear on it. You are free to buy them, but you give up the credit and the cost-sharing reductions for that plan. Compare the net price with the best on-exchange alternative.
- You are in a state with its own exchange. The state site is the source for state help, and the plan menu is the full list for your state. My state runs its own exchange: what really differs from HealthCare.gov? explains the difference between exchange types.
- You want a person to walk you through it. A navigator or certified application counselor is free and works on the marketplace. A broker may use the marketplace or an enhanced direct enrollment site and is usually paid by insurers.
Cost-sharing reductions
Cost-sharing reductions lower deductibles and copays for people with incomes up to 250% of the poverty level, and only on silver plans bought through the marketplace. In some states insurers also sell off-exchange silver plans priced without the cost of those reductions built in (the practice behind silver loading), which can make an off-exchange silver plan a useful choice for someone who will not receive credits. For anyone below 250% of the poverty level, the on-exchange silver plan is the one that carries the reduction.
If you already bought off the marketplace by mistake
It happens: an ad, a call or a polished website and the person did not know. What to do depends on timing and whether you meant to use the credit.
- Confirm what you have. Check your marketplace account and call the insurer. Get the plan name, the start date and the amount you paid.
- If open enrollment is still open, you can apply on the marketplace, choose the plan with the credit, and ask the insurer to end the off-exchange policy as of the date the new one begins, so you are not paying for two. Do not cancel the first policy before the new one is confirmed and paid, or you could be left without coverage.
- If open enrollment has closed, you may need a qualifying event to enroll on the marketplace. If a broker or an agent misled you, ask the marketplace about an exceptional circumstances request and say what happened. Approval is not guaranteed and is judged by the marketplace on the facts.
- Ask about a free-look period. Some states require insurers to allow a short period to cancel a new individual policy and receive a refund. Ask the insurer and your state insurance department.
- Keep the paper. Save the confirmation, the sales material, any recorded call details and the names of the people you dealt with.
- Complain if you were misled. The state insurance department takes complaints about agents and insurers, and the federal marketplace has a way to report suspected fraud. If you did not enroll yourself, see someone changed my marketplace plan or enrolled me without consent: what now?.
Expect that you cannot claim the credit for months in which you were enrolled only off-exchange; the tax-time fix is not available.
Questions to ask before you enter any personal details
Put these to the site's chat, the call center or the agent, and write down the answers.
- Is this enrollment on-exchange? Will the marketplace receive my application and my plan choice?
- Will I see an eligibility result for the tax credit before I pick a plan, and does it use my income estimate for 2027?
- Is the premium shown before or after the credit, and for which plan is the credit calculated?
- Does the plan list on this site include every insurer in my area? If not, which ones are missing?
- What is the exact plan name and ID, and how do I find the same plan in my marketplace account?
- When is my first payment due, and what happens to my coverage start date if I pay late?
- If I want to change my mind, who cancels the enrollment and by when?
Two answers should make you pause. One is a promise that you "do not need" to use the marketplace because the price is the same; the price may be the same but the credit is not. The other is a refusal to say whether the marketplace is involved. A navigator's answers to the same questions are free, and the state insurance department can tell you whether an agent or company is licensed.
Why the question is sharper this year
In September 2026 CMS reported canceling about 315,000 unauthorized enrollments covering more than 760,000 people on the federal marketplace and froze new broker registrations there until February 2027; on November 16, 2026 it proposed further rules on agent and broker conduct, with comments due in January 2027. Many agents and brokers help people legitimately, and the point for a shopper is practical: be certain who is enrolling you, make sure the marketplace has the record, and never read your Social Security number to an inbound caller. How do I tell a real marketplace broker or enrollment site from a scam? has the warning signs.
Key takeaways
- The credit goes with the enrollment path, not the plan name: marketplace and approved partner sites can carry it, off-exchange purchases cannot.
- The premium for the same plan is the same on and off the exchange, so the gap is exactly the credit and any cost-sharing reduction.
- Check that the plan appears in your marketplace account, not just on the insurer's confirmation page.
- Above 400% of the poverty level there is no federal credit either way, so the choice rests on plan, network and convenience.
- If you bought off-exchange by mistake, act during open enrollment, keep the old policy until the new one is confirmed and ask the marketplace and your state insurance department about options.