Blog

State-run exchange or HealthCare.gov, and what really differs for me

A side-by-side of state-based marketplaces and HealthCare.gov on windows, help, plan design, state subsidies and Medicaid hand-off, and what is the same.

Where you live decides which website sells you a marketplace plan. In about half the country that site is HealthCare.gov, run by the federal government. In the rest it is a state-run site with its own name, its own deadlines and often its own extra help. The plans, the tax credit formula and the consumer protections are the same in both. Almost everything else, from how long you have to enroll to who answers the phone, can differ.

This post compares the two in a table, then walks through each difference that a buyer actually feels. It ends with the list of things you must do the same way no matter which site you use.

Why there are two kinds of marketplace

The Affordable Care Act let each state choose. A state could build and run its own marketplace (a state-based exchange), leave the job to the federal government (the federally facilitated marketplace), or split the work in a hybrid. A few states run their own marketplace but use the federal website's technology to take applications.

As of November 2026, KFF counts 22 state-based marketplaces (including the District of Columbia), 2 state-based marketplaces that use the federal platform, and 27 federally facilitated states. The list has changed over the years as states have moved their systems in and out of the federal platform, so check your own state's current setup. The state marketplace, regulator and help lookup tool and the how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help guide show which site serves your address.

The choice matters less for the product than for the service around it. A state that runs its own site can set its own enrollment calendar, fund its own assisters, require its insurers to offer certain plan designs and add its own subsidies. A state that uses HealthCare.gov takes the federal defaults.

The side-by-side

Feature HealthCare.gov states State-based marketplaces
Open enrollment dates Set federally Set by the state, within federal limits, and often longer
Local help Federally funded Navigators, plus brokers and agents Navigators, in-person assisters and certified enrollers funded by the state, plus brokers
Plan design Insurers design plans within metal-level rules Some states require standardized plan designs or limit how many plans an insurer may offer
Extra subsidies Rare; any state help is usually run separately Several states add their own premium or cost-sharing help
Customer service One federal call center and the site A state call center and a state-branded site
Medicaid hand-off The application is screened and may be sent to the state agency Often a single application that reaches Medicaid and the marketplace in one system
Special enrollment rules Federal rules Federal minimums, with some states adding extra windows
Where tax credit rules come from Federal law Federal law

None of these rows is a promise about a particular state. Treat the table as a map of where to look, then confirm on your own marketplace's pages.

Open enrollment windows

HealthCare.gov's open enrollment for plan year 2027 runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, according to the CMS fact sheet dated October 30, 2026. Coverage starts January 1 if you enroll by December 15 under the standard rule, and the first of the following month for later sign-ups. A rule that would have shortened the window starting with plan year 2027 was vacated by a federal court on June 12, 2026, and HHS has appealed, so confirm the dates on HealthCare.gov rather than relying on this paragraph.

State-based marketplaces set their own calendars. As reported by healthinsurance.org, as of November 2026 the plan-year-2027 windows include Idaho ending December 15, 2026, Connecticut running October 23, 2026 to January 15, 2027, and California, the District of Columbia, New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island ending January 31, 2027. That list is not exhaustive, and states can change dates, so the state's own site is the authority.

What this means in practice:

  • A neighbor in a different state may have two or more extra weeks. Do not assume your deadline is theirs.
  • If you moved from one kind of state to another, your old habit of waiting until mid-January can leave you shut out. Idaho's window, for example, closes before the calendar year does.
  • Coverage start dates depend on the sign-up date and the state's rules. Look for the "coverage starts" line before you finalize, not after.

The When is open enrollment? Dates for marketplace, Medicare and employer plans guide covers the dates and what happens if you miss them.

Help from a real person

Every marketplace has people whose job is to help you enroll. The difference is who pays for them and how many of them there are in your area.

On HealthCare.gov, free help comes from navigator organizations that receive federal grants, from certified application counselors at clinics and community groups, and from licensed brokers who are paid by insurers and cost you nothing to use. How many of each are in your town varies with the grants in that year.

State-based marketplaces usually run their own assister programs, sometimes larger and better funded because the state treats them as part of its enrollment strategy, and often with multilingual staff trained on that state's programs. Some publish directories on the marketplace site, with appointment booking. Others rely mostly on brokers.

A navigator or a broker should explain the whole picture, not push a single plan. Ask whether they are paid by an insurer or a grant, which is a fair question and an easy one to answer. The how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator guide covers what to ask.

Plan standardization and plan choice

On HealthCare.gov, insurers build their own plans inside the federal rules for essential health benefits and actuarial value, so two Silver plans from two insurers can have different deductibles and copays as long as each lands in the Silver band.

Some state-based marketplaces go further. A state may require insurers to offer a standard set of plan designs for each metal level, with fixed deductibles and copays, so that the only differences are the premium and the network. Supporters say that makes comparison easier and removes confusing variation. Critics say it limits innovation and may not fit every household. States that standardize usually also let insurers sell a limited number of non-standard plans, so you may see both.

If you live in a state with standardized plans, the practical advice is simple: compare premiums and networks first, because the cost-sharing rules are the same by design. In a state without them, you must open each plan's summary of benefits and coverage and compare the deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, drug tiers and primary care and specialist copays. The how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs guide walks through the comparison.

State subsidies on top of federal credits

The federal premium tax credit is identical everywhere. It is calculated from your household income, the second-lowest-cost Silver plan in your area (the benchmark plan), and a required contribution percentage that the IRS publishes each year. HealthCare.gov and state-based marketplaces apply the same formula.

What differs is the extra help some states provide. According to KFF's November 2026 summary, New Mexico fully backfilled lost federal assistance in 2026 and continues; California partially backfills at 165% to 200% of the federal poverty level; New Jersey maintained its program; and Rhode Island and Virginia created new state subsidies for 2027. Those programs are described on the state's own page and marketplace site. A state that uses HealthCare.gov can still run help of its own, but it is rarer and the help is usually advertised through the state insurance department or Medicaid agency rather than inside the shopping flow.

The practical point: if you live in a state-based marketplace state and your income is above where the federal credit ends, or just below it, look specifically for a state program before you decide a plan is unaffordable. The Does my state add premium help on top of federal credits, and how do I find it? post explains how to look for it. The state pages, such as California, list what the research found for each state and should be read as a starting point, with the marketplace site as the final word.

Customer service and what happens when something goes wrong

On HealthCare.gov, problems with your application go to a federal call center. On a state-based marketplace, they go to the state's center, which can often see the same record you see and which answers to state officials. When a marketplace error blocks you from enrolling, you generally have the right to ask for an appeal or a special enrollment period. How to file differs by marketplace, so find the "appeals" or "help" page early, before a deadline is close.

Two habits protect you in either system:

  1. Save a screenshot or confirmation number at each step. Keep the final confirmation page and the insurer's welcome notice.
  2. After you pick a plan, check that the insurer shows you as a member and has recorded the payment. The marketplace sends your choice to the insurer, and the insurer starts your coverage only when it has the first premium. A selected plan is not a paid plan.

Medicaid and CHIP: how the hand-off works

Both kinds of marketplace screen for Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program. If your income looks low enough, the marketplace either sends your application to the state Medicaid agency or tells you to apply there. The details differ:

  • In many state-based marketplaces the application is built to serve both programs, and an eligibility result for Medicaid appears in the same system.
  • In HealthCare.gov states, the federal site assesses you or transfers your information to the state agency, which then follows its own process and timeline.

Medicaid eligibility rules also vary by state, including whether the state expanded Medicaid for adults. As of November 2026, KFF lists 10 states that have not expanded, among them Texas and Florida. See Texas and the The Medicaid coverage gap: who falls between Medicaid and credits guide for what that can mean. If you are told you may qualify for Medicaid, apply for it and respond to the agency's requests on time. Medicaid and a marketplace subsidy do not combine, so the Medicaid result decides which path you are on.

What does not change, in either system

Whether you shop on HealthCare.gov or on a state site, these are the same:

  • The plans must cover the ten essential health benefit categories, cannot charge more or deny coverage because of a pre-existing condition, and are sorted into Bronze, Silver, Gold and Platinum levels.
  • The tax credit formula is federal. Advance payments are based on your estimate of the year's income, and any difference is settled on your tax return with Form 8962.
  • You must report changes. A change in income, household size or other coverage should be reported to the marketplace so that your advance credit can be adjusted. A year-end bill for repaying excess credit is now larger, since the cap on repayment was removed for tax years after 2025 (Public Law 119-21 sec. 71305).
  • Special enrollment periods exist for qualifying life events. A loss of other coverage, a move, marriage, birth or adoption opens a 60-day window in most cases. See special enrollment periods explained: qualifying life events and deadlines.
  • Your network and drug list decide your real cost. Check each doctor and each prescription in the insurer's own directory and formulary, not only in the marketplace's search box.
  • Cost-sharing reductions come only with Silver plans bought through the marketplace and only below 250% of the poverty level.
  • The plan's own appeals process and external review rights apply the same way.

A short decision list

If you are unsure which differences matter to you, work through these in order.

  1. Find out which kind of marketplace serves your state and the exact final enrollment date. Write it down.
  2. If your state runs its own marketplace, look for a state subsidy page and for the assister directory.
  3. If you want a person to help, book an appointment now. Appointment slots fill before deadlines.
  4. If your state uses HealthCare.gov and you have a complicated situation, such as a mixed-status household or a recent move, look for a navigator organization or certified counselor and ask what documents to bring.
  5. Compare plans on network and drugs first, then the cost-sharing, then the premium after any credit.
  6. Confirm that coverage is active, with your first payment received, before the old coverage ends.

For a question about your own eligibility, the final answer comes from the marketplace itself, a navigator, or your state insurance department.

Key takeaways

  • Your state decides which marketplace you use: HealthCare.gov or a state-run site. A lookup tool shows yours.
  • Deadlines, local help, plan design and extra subsidies are the places the two kinds differ; the tax credit formula, plan categories and protections are the same.
  • State-run sites often have longer windows, but not all do, and Idaho's closes in 2026, so confirm the date for your state.
  • If you may qualify for Medicaid, apply to the state agency or through the marketplace and keep every confirmation.
  • Selecting a plan is not the same as being covered: pay the first premium and confirm with the insurer.

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic