Blog

My Advantage plan requires prior authorization for my surgery. What do I do?

A step-by-step playbook for a planned knee replacement: confirm the rule, get a written decision, track the clock, ask for a fast review and appeal a denial.

Say Rosa, a hypothetical reader, is 71, has a Medicare Advantage plan and has been told by her orthopedic surgeon that she needs a knee replacement. A date is on the calendar six weeks out. Then the surgeon's scheduler says the plan requires prior authorization first. Nobody has told her what that means, who files it, or what happens if the answer is no.

This playbook follows Rosa's case in order. The steps work for most planned procedures under a Medicare Advantage plan. Dates and amounts are illustrations, and your own plan's documents control the details.

What prior authorization is, in this setting

Prior authorization is the plan's approval, before a service, that it will cover the service. In Medicare Advantage the formal name for the plan's decision is an organization determination. It is a written decision about whether the plan will cover a service, and it triggers the appeal rights described below. Approval is not a guarantee that every bill will be paid in full, but it is the step the plan itself requires.

Two points to keep in mind:

  • Original Medicare uses prior authorization for only a narrow set of services, while a Medicare Advantage plan may require it for many, because plans set their own approval requirements within federal rules.
  • A Medicare Advantage plan must cover what Original Medicare covers and generally must follow Medicare's coverage criteria where they exist. Under a CMS rule that took effect in 2024, a plan may not use stricter internal criteria when Medicare already has criteria for a service. If a denial seems out of line with Medicare's own rules, that is a point worth making.

how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied covers the general idea. prior authorization has the short definition.

Step 1: Confirm that the plan requires it, and for what

Do not rely on the scheduler's summary. Ask the plan, and ask for the answer in writing.

  1. Call the member services number on the card and say, "I am scheduled for a total knee replacement on [date]. Does it require prior authorization, and does that include the hospital or surgery center, the anesthesia and any rehabilitation afterward?"
  2. Write down the date and time, the representative's name and the reference number.
  3. Find the plan's list of services requiring prior authorization in the Evidence of Coverage or on the plan's website, and keep a copy.
  4. Ask whether the surgeon and the facility are both in the network. A procedure approved at a hospital outside the network can still be paid at a much higher cost-sharing level or not at all, depending on plan type. Medicare Advantage networks and prior authorization: what to expect explains how HMO and PPO networks change this.

A common surprise is that the surgery, the facility stay and the post-surgery rehabilitation (a skilled nursing facility or home health) are separate approvals. Ask about each.

Step 2: Ask who files, and what the office will send

In most cases the surgeon's office submits the request, because the plan wants clinical information from the doctor. You are not required to do this yourself, but you are entitled to know the status. Ask the surgeon's office:

  • Who on staff handles authorizations, and how do I reach them?
  • When did you submit the request, and by what method?
  • What did you send: notes from my visits, imaging results, the history of treatments tried (physical therapy, injections, medicines) and a description of how the knee limits my daily activities?
  • Did the plan ask for anything else, and have you answered?
  • What is the reference or case number?

A request that arrives with thin records is the most common reason for delay. A short, specific letter from the surgeon, describing what has been tried and why the surgery is medically needed, helps. Rosa can ask the office to include her own description of what she can no longer do, such as climbing stairs or walking a block, since those details belong in the record.

Step 3: Ask for the written decision, and know the clock

A plan must decide a request within set times. Starting January 1, 2026, under a CMS rule on prior authorization (CMS-0057-F), Medicare Advantage plans must decide standard requests within seven calendar days and expedited requests within 72 hours, and they must give a specific reason when they deny one. Before 2026 the standard period was longer. These are the times in the federal rule as described by CMS, and your plan's notice and Medicare.gov are where to confirm the current rule.

Here is Rosa's tracking table, in a form you can copy. A tracker like the prior authorization and claim tracker does the same job.

Date Event Who Reference number Next step
Week 6 before Plan confirms prior authorization required Plan rep (write it down) Ask surgeon's office to file
Week 6 before Request submitted Surgeon's office Call in 3 days to confirm received
Week 5 before Decision due (7 calendar days after the plan receives the request) Plan Get the written notice; if none, call the same day
Week 4 before If denied: reconsideration filed Surgeon's office Track the plan's 30-day clock

Note the date the plan received the request, not the date the office wrote it, because the clock runs from receipt. If the deadline passes without an answer, call the plan and the surgeon's office the same day, and ask for the decision in writing. A missed decision deadline is a reason to push, and under the Medicare appeals rules a plan that fails to meet a deadline for a reconsideration must send the case to an independent reviewer.

If the plan says no prior authorization is needed

If the plan tells you approval is not required but you want certainty, you can ask for an organization determination in advance. The plan must then issue a written decision on coverage. It is slower than relying on a phone answer and it gives you a document with appeal rights.

Step 4: If the answer is yes

Approval is good news, and it still deserves a check before surgery.

  • Read the approval for the exact service, the facility, the dates and the number of days.
  • Confirm that the date of surgery falls inside the approval's validity period. Plans often approve for a window, and a delayed surgery may need a new approval.
  • Keep the written approval with you, and ask the surgeon's office to confirm the same details match their records.
  • Ask what the plan says you will owe. A cost-sharing amount is stated in your plan documents, and the yearly out-of-pocket maximum caps in-network spending.

Approved, then denied: Medicare Advantage prior authorization mistakes explains how an approved service can still produce a problem when the details do not match, and scheduled surgery: the prior authorization timeline and weekly checks has week-by-week checks.

Step 5: If the answer is no

A denial is not the end. It starts a formal process, and the denial notice is the most important document you will receive.

  1. Read the notice. It should state the reason for the denial, the criteria the plan used and how to appeal. Under the 2026 federal rule, the plan must give a specific reason. Keep the envelope or the electronic date stamp.
  2. Note the deadline. The notice states how many days you have to ask for reconsideration, counted in calendar days from the date on the notice. It runs to roughly two months, and the notice controls.
  3. Call the surgeon's office the same day and ask whether the doctor wants to request reconsideration, or a peer-to-peer conversation with the plan's medical director. A treating physician can ask for a plan's reconsideration of a pre-service denial on the patient's behalf.
  4. Ask the plan for the clinical criteria it used, and the name of the reviewing clinician's specialty. Compare the criteria with what the surgeon documented.
  5. File the reconsideration, in writing, with new information addressing the reason for denial: updated notes, imaging, a statement from the surgeon, records of treatments tried.

The plan makes a decision on a standard pre-service reconsideration within 30 calendar days. If the plan upholds the denial in whole or in part, it must forward the case to an independent review entity, which reviews it without the plan's involvement. How to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial, from plan to independent review follows every level in order, and how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step covers appeals in general.

Step 6: Ask for a fast review when waiting could harm your health

An expedited reconsideration is available when waiting for the standard timeline could seriously jeopardize your life, health or ability to regain maximum function. If a physician says that waiting would put the patient's health at that kind of risk, the plan must treat the request as expedited. The plan then must decide within 72 hours.

This test is about health, not convenience. A scheduled surgery date that would be inconvenient to move does not by itself qualify. A knee replacement in a patient with severe, worsening pain and mobility loss may or may not meet the standard, and that is the surgeon's clinical judgment to state, not yours. If the surgeon writes that delay risks serious harm, say so plainly in the request. Expedited appeal: when does my case count as urgent and how do I prove it? covers what makes an urgent case and how to document it.

Step 7: Move the surgery date, not the process

While the review runs, the surgery date is a moving part. Ask the surgeon's office whether the operating room slot can be held, whether a later date is possible without clinical harm, and whether the facility's financial office wants proof of approval before the date. If the approval is delayed, it is usually better to reschedule than to proceed without it, because an unauthorized procedure can leave the patient with a large bill.

If a plan's decision and the date of surgery conflict, ask the office, in writing, who bears the risk if surgery goes ahead before approval. Do not assume the surgeon's office or the hospital will absorb it.

What to ask the surgeon's office

  • Who submits the request, and how will I know the plan received it?
  • Which codes are on the request, and do they match the planned surgery and facility?
  • Does the request include the hospital stay or outpatient setting, anesthesia and rehabilitation?
  • If the plan denies it, will you ask for a peer-to-peer call and file the reconsideration, and how soon?
  • What can I add from my own side: a log of symptoms, a list of treatments tried, a statement of what daily activities I can no longer do?

how to ask my doctor's office to support my appeal, with scripts to use has scripts for these conversations.

Where free help is

If you are stuck, a SHIP counselor in your state explains Medicare Advantage rights at no cost and can help read a notice. Medicare itself takes questions and complaints about plans through 1-800-MEDICARE. Neither is a lawyer, and for a complicated or high-stakes dispute a legal aid office or attorney who handles Medicare appeals may be the right call.

Key takeaways

  • Ask the plan, in writing, whether prior authorization applies to the surgery, the facility and the rehabilitation, because they can be separate approvals.
  • The surgeon's office usually files, so ask for the reference number, the date of receipt and what was sent.
  • Under the federal rule effective January 1, 2026, standard Medicare Advantage prior authorization decisions are due in seven calendar days and expedited ones in 72 hours, with a specific reason for any denial.
  • A denial starts a reconsideration, with a deadline in the notice; a physician's statement that delay risks serious harm triggers an expedited review.
  • Do not rely on a phone answer: get the approval or denial in writing, and confirm the dates before the day of surgery.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic