Blog
A treatment and symptom log that makes a future appeal easier
A fill-in log for people with a long-running condition: what to record, a worked example for a fictional patient and which entries reviewers weigh most.
When a plan questions a long-running treatment, it asks the same kinds of things: what has been tried, for how long, what happened, and how the condition affects daily life. Doctors' notes hold some of that, scattered across years and offices. A patient who has kept a simple log can answer in an afternoon, while a patient who has not may spend weeks reconstructing it from memory. This worksheet gives you the log, a filled-in example for a fictional patient, and a plain account of which entries tend to matter most to a reviewer.
It is a memory aid for you and a conversation aid for your doctor. It is not a medical record, it does not replace your doctor's notes, and it should never be used to claim something that did not happen. Its value comes from being accurate and written close to the time.
Who benefits from a log
People with a chronic or recurring condition, such as migraines, a gut or joint condition, asthma, diabetes, a mental health condition or chronic pain, tend to face the same problem in different forms. Plans may ask the patient to try a cheaper treatment first (the rules called step therapy), re-approve an ongoing treatment on a schedule (a repeat prior authorization) or ask whether a service is still medical necessity. Each of those questions is easier to answer when the history is on paper.
A log is useful even if you never need it. If the plan approves everything, you have lost nothing but a few minutes a week. If a denial arrives, the log shortens the work in how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step from reconstruction to selection.
The worksheet
Keep one row per event: a symptom episode, a visit, a new treatment, a change in dose, a test, a call or a denial. A paper notebook, a spreadsheet or the notes app on a phone all work. What matters is that you can sort by date.
| Date | Symptom or event (with a 0 to 10 severity if relevant) | Treatment or action | Result or side effects | Who said what | Authorization or reference number |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ |
| ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ |
| ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ |
How to fill each column:
- Date. Use the full date. If you are filling in something from the past, mark it "approximate" or "from memory" so that nobody mistakes it for a contemporaneous entry.
- Symptom or event. Describe what happened in plain, factual words: "migraine, could not work, in bed for most of the day." Include a severity number if your doctor uses one, and keep the same scale each time.
- Treatment or action. Write the name of the medication or service, the dose or amount and the frequency as you were told, or "as prescribed" with the label's details. Record who prescribed it.
- Result or side effects. Note whether it helped, how much and for how long, and any reaction or reason you stopped. "Stopped after 6 weeks, nausea every day" is the kind of entry reviewers look for.
- Who said what. Name the person, their role and what they told you: "Dr. Ruiz said the plan wants two preventive medicines tried before approving the next one." Insurance calls belong here too: representative's name, what they promised.
- Authorization or reference number. Write every number you are given: prior authorization, claim, call reference, appeal. A row with a number lets someone look the event up.
Add a column or a second page for missed activities, such as work days missed, tasks you could not do or help you needed, if your condition affects function. Many criteria are about function, and a number of missed days is more persuasive than "bad month."
A filled-in example for a fictional patient
The following is invented for teaching. The patient, the doctors and the treatments are made up, and "Medicine A" and "Medicine B" stand in for real drugs.
Say Priya has chronic migraines. Her neurologist wants to prescribe a new preventive treatment, and the plan's rules say she must first try two older preventive medicines. Her log, over the past year:
| Date | Symptom or event | Treatment or action | Result or side effects | Who said what | Reference number |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 12 | Migraine, severity 8 of 10, missed work | Rescue medication per label | Relief after about 5 hours | Primary care doctor referred to neurology | none |
| Feb 3 | Neurology visit | Started Medicine A, daily | Planned 3-month trial | Dr. Ruiz: "Give this at least 8 weeks at full dose" | Referral 4471 |
| Mar 20 | 11 migraine days in March so far (counted from calendar) | Medicine A continuing | Fewer than hoped; drowsy daily | Called nurse line, advised to stay on it | Call ref 88213 |
| Apr 28 | Neurology follow-up | Stopped Medicine A (12 weeks total) | Not enough benefit, daytime sleepiness | Dr. Ruiz: "Documented as an inadequate response" | Visit note Apr 28 |
| May 5 | Started Medicine B, daily | Dose raised after 2 weeks | Side effect: tingling | Pharmacist noted the interaction check | Rx 1190 |
| Jun 30 | Neurology phone visit | Stopped Medicine B (8 weeks) | Tingling persisted | Dr. Ruiz: "Intolerance, will request the newer drug" | Phone note Jun 30 |
| Jul 15 | Prior authorization request for new treatment | Submitted by office | Pending | Office staff: decision in "about two weeks" | PA 20-5532 |
| Aug 4 | Denial received: "step therapy not met" | Called plan | Said Medicine B trial "too short" | Rep (name written down) said appeal in writing | Call ref 90377; denial letter Aug 4 |
Notice what the log gives Priya without any extra work: a start and stop date for each older medicine, the reason it was stopped, the doctor's own words, the reference numbers for each contact and the date of the denial. Her appeal can quote it, and her doctor can check it against the chart.
A repeatable calculation: symptom days per month
A monthly count is a small, concrete statistic that many criteria ask for. The method is the same each month:
- Count the days in the month with the symptom (or the missed-activity days).
- Divide by the number of days in the month.
- Multiply by 100 to get a percentage, and round.
For Priya's March, suppose the full month, counted on the last day, comes to 14 migraine days out of 31. Then 14 divided by 31 is about 0.45, so about 45% of the days in the month. If April shows 12 days out of 30, then 12 divided by 30 is 0.40, or 40%. Write the counts and the percentages on a separate monthly line, and note which days you counted from. The comparison between months is what a doctor or a reviewer can use, so use the same definition of a symptom day every month.
Your own blanks:
| Month | Symptom days | Days in month | Percent (days divided by days in month, times 100) |
|---|---|---|---|
| ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ |
| ____ | ____ | ____ | ____ |
Which entries matter most to reviewers
Reviewers read records looking for evidence that a specific rule was met. The details differ by plan and condition, but a few kinds of entry recur in many policies, so they deserve the most care.
- Dates and durations of earlier treatments. Step therapy rules usually ask whether each earlier treatment was tried and for how long. Start date, stop date and the dose reached are the core facts. The guide on step therapy explained: "fail first" rules and how to get an exception describes the rule, and step therapy exceptions: the reasons that win and how to document each covers what kinds of reasons plans commonly accept for an exception.
- The reason a treatment stopped. "Did not work," "side effects" and "contraindicated" lead to different conclusions. Record which one your doctor wrote and what you experienced.
- Functional impact. Missed work, missed school, falls, trouble with stairs, sleep disruption and the like are evidence of how much the condition matters day to day. Keep numbers and dates.
- The treating doctor's statements. What the doctor said about why the treatment is needed, written the day it was said, helps you ask the doctor to put it in writing for the plan.
- Reference numbers and denial dates. These let you prove the timeline, which matters for deadlines and for any later complaint.
- Who you spoke with. A name, a date and what was promised make a phone call usable evidence. For a log built specifically around calls, see insurer call log and script worksheet: how to document every call.
Entries that matter less: opinions about the plan, long descriptions of how you felt emotionally in a way unconnected to function and anything you cannot date. They belong in your own private notes, not in what you hand a reviewer.
Habits that keep the log trustworthy
- Write it within a day or two. An entry made close to the event is more reliable than one reconstructed months later.
- Never edit the past. If you made a mistake, add a dated correction instead of overwriting.
- Keep it factual. The log should read like a calendar and not like an argument.
- Store it with your other records. Keep denial letters, authorization letters and explanations of benefits in one folder. build an appeal file: which documents to gather and how to organize them suggests a layout, and prior authorization and claim tracker can hold the authorization and claim numbers.
- Protect it. A log of your health history is sensitive. Keep it on a device or in a place you control, and send only what an appeal needs.
Adapting the log to different conditions
The columns stay the same; the details change. Someone managing diabetes might add readings and the dates of supply changes. A person with asthma might note flare-ups, emergency visits and rescue inhaler use per week. Someone in mental health treatment might record the dates of therapy sessions, which treatments were tried and how long each lasted, without writing down anything more private than they want in a file. Someone with a joint condition might log which activities they can no longer do. Pick the two or three measures your doctor already tracks, and keep to them, because a short log you maintain beats a detailed one you drop after a month.
If the log is for a child or for a parent you help, the same rules apply, with one addition: record who is writing the entries, and keep in mind the privacy points in appealing for a parent, spouse or child: authorized representative forms.
How to use the log with your doctor
Bring the log, or a one-page summary of it, to appointments. It helps in three specific ways.
First, it makes the visit shorter. Instead of "I think the second medicine was around the spring," you can say "I started it May 5 and stopped June 30." Second, it lets the doctor check that the chart matches your account, and correct the chart if something is missing. Third, it gives the doctor material for a letter. The worksheet in letter of medical necessity worksheet: what to give your doctor is built for handing your doctor the facts they need to write a strong letter.
You can also request your records, which you generally have a right to; the post on getting my medical records for an appeal: fees, timelines and what to ask for covers how, and what fees and waiting periods can apply. Compare the chart with your log once a year and ask the office to fix any real errors.
What the log cannot do
A log does not prove the clinical case on its own. Your doctor's notes, test results and letters are what a reviewer treats as medical evidence, and your log points to them. It also cannot predict how a plan will decide. If a denial arrives, the plan's appeals unit, a patient advocate or a lawyer can tell you what route applies to your plan, and your doctor can say whether the clinical history supports the request.
Key takeaways
- Keep one row per event, with the date, the symptom or action, the result, who said what and every reference number.
- Reviewers most often look for the start and stop dates of earlier treatments, the reason each stopped, the effect on daily function and the treating doctor's statements.
- A monthly symptom-day count, calculated the same way each month, turns a vague history into a number you and your doctor can compare.
- Write entries soon after the event, never rewrite the past and keep the log with your denial letters and authorizations.
- Bring the log to visits and use it to help your doctor write an accurate letter; the log supports the medical record and never replaces it.