Blog
Letter of medical necessity worksheet: what to give your doctor
A fill-in worksheet that turns a denial into a short packet for your doctor: history, treatments tried, risk of delay, guidelines and the plan's own criteria.
A letter of medical necessity is a doctor's written explanation of why a treatment, test, drug or device is needed for a particular patient. Reviewers at a health plan read dozens of them, and the ones that move a decision share a feature: they answer the exact reason the plan gave for the denial, with dates and facts, instead of restating that the patient is sick and the doctor recommends the treatment.
Your doctor knows the medicine. What you hold, and the doctor may not, is the denial letter, the plan's wording and your own history in the order it happened. This worksheet is a way to give the doctor those pieces on a single page, so that writing the letter takes minutes instead of an evening. Fill in the blanks, attach the listed papers and hand it over. A worked example follows the blanks.
What the letter has to do
A useful letter does four things, in this order:
- Names the request and the decision it answers: the service, the date of the denial and the plan's stated reason.
- Gives the clinical picture: the diagnosis, how long you have had it, how it affects function and what the doctor found.
- Shows that other options were tried or are not suitable, with dates and results.
- Quotes the plan's criteria and shows where you meet them, and states what is at risk if the decision stands or the treatment is delayed.
The plan decides by its criteria, so the letter works best when it speaks in the criteria's own words. That is why the worksheet starts with the denial letter and the request for the plan's criteria. If you have not yet asked the plan for the rule it applied, see how to ask your insurer for your full claim file and the criteria it used. For the general shape of an appeal that the letter will sit inside, how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read is the companion guide.
Before you fill it in: set the dates
Find the appeal deadline in the denial notice. Most plans give at least 180 days for a standard internal appeal, but the notice states yours. Work backward from it. A hypothetical illustration: a denial notice dated March 1 with a 180-day appeal period runs out on August 28 (30 days to March 31, 60 to April 30, 91 to May 31, 121 to June 30, 152 to July 31, 180 to August 28). A plan to have the signed letter in hand two weeks before the deadline means asking the doctor's office no later than mid-July, and in practice much sooner, since offices can take a week or more to produce a letter.
If the delay could harm your health, ask your doctor about an expedited appeal instead; Expedited appeal: when does my case count as urgent and how do I prove it? covers that.
| Date | Fill in |
|---|---|
| Denial notice date | ______ |
| Appeal deadline (from the notice) | ______ |
| Date I want the letter signed | ______ |
| Date I will give this worksheet to the office | ______ |
The worksheet
Copy this section onto a page you can hand over or send through the patient portal. Short answers are fine. Dates matter more than adjectives.
Part 1: The request and the denial
- Patient name, date of birth, member ID: ______
- Plan name and the claim, case or authorization number: ______
- The service, drug or device requested, with any code on the paperwork: ______
- Ordering doctor and facility: ______
- Date of denial and who issued it (plan, pharmacy manager or review vendor): ______
- The reason given, copied word for word from the notice: ______
- The plan provision or criteria cited, if any: ______
Part 2: Diagnosis and history
- Diagnosis and the date it was made: ______
- First symptoms and when they began: ______
- Tests and findings that support the diagnosis (name, date, result): ______
- Current symptoms and how they affect daily life, work or school, in specifics such as "cannot stand for more than ten minutes" or "missed 12 days of work in six months": ______
Part 3: Treatments tried and results
One line per treatment. Plans often require "failed" or "contraindicated" alternatives, so be exact about dates, doses and why each ended.
| Treatment | Dates and dose | Result | Why it stopped |
|---|---|---|---|
| ______ | ______ | ______ | ______ |
| ______ | ______ | ______ | ______ |
| ______ | ______ | ______ | ______ |
Part 4: Why the plan's alternative does not fit
If the denial suggests a cheaper or earlier-step option, write why it does not suit you. The reasons should be medical, not a preference: an allergy, a drug interaction, a prior bad outcome, a condition that makes the alternative unsafe, a documented failure of that same option. If you do not know the reason, leave the line blank and let the doctor fill it in.
- The alternative the plan proposed: ______
- Why it is unsuitable or already failed: ______
Part 5: Risk of delay or denial
- What could happen if treatment is delayed or not given (progression, hospitalization, loss of function, pain that cannot be managed): ______
- Whether a delay could seriously jeopardize life, health or the ability to regain function, which would support an expedited review. Leave this one to the physician. ______
Part 6: Guidelines and evidence
Your doctor may cite a professional society guideline, a published study or the product's approved use. Do not fill this out from internet searches; leave it to the clinician, and write down only what the doctor has already told you.
- Guideline or evidence the doctor mentioned: ______
- Whether the doctor can state that the request is consistent with standard practice for this condition: ______
Part 7: The plan's own criteria, matched line by line
If you have the plan's criteria, list each requirement and the chart evidence that meets it. This is the part reviewers use most.
| Criterion in the plan's words | Evidence in the chart (date, note, result) | Met? |
|---|---|---|
| ______ | ______ | ______ |
| ______ | ______ | ______ |
| ______ | ______ | ______ |
Part 8: What I am asking the doctor to do
- Write or sign a letter of medical necessity addressed to the plan's appeals unit: yes or no
- Request a peer-to-peer call with the plan's reviewing physician, if the plan offers one: yes or no
- Send chart notes and test results with the letter: yes or no
- Return the signed letter to me by (date): ______
What to attach
Put these behind the worksheet:
- The denial letter
- The plan's criteria or guideline, if you have it
- Chart notes for the visits that cover Parts 2 to 4, or a note that you have requested them; getting my medical records for an appeal: fees, timelines and what to ask for explains how to get records
- Test results and imaging reports
- Pharmacy or treatment records that show the dates in Part 3
A one-page cover note on top helps. It can say: "I am appealing the plan's denial of [service]. The appeal is due [date]. I would be grateful for a letter that addresses the reason in the denial letter, and I have filled in the worksheet to save you time. Please change anything I have wrong."
A model paragraph for a fictional patient
Imagine Maria, a hypothetical 46-year-old with severe plaque psoriasis whose plan denied a biologic drug because "step therapy not completed." Her worksheet shows that she used a topical steroid for six months, phototherapy twice weekly for three months and a standard oral medication that was stopped after liver tests rose. The plan's criteria require "an inadequate response or contraindication to at least two conventional therapies." A paragraph in her doctor's letter might read:
Ms. Alvarez has had plaque psoriasis since [year], now involving about [percent] of her body surface, with documented flares that have caused her to miss work. She has tried and failed two conventional therapies required by your criteria. Phototherapy, given twice weekly from [date] to [date], produced no sustained improvement. Methotrexate was started on [date] and discontinued on [date] because liver enzymes rose to [value] on testing, which is a documented contraindication to continued use. Topical steroids from [date] to [date] were insufficient. Each treatment, with the dates and results, is documented in the attached notes. Given these failures, I request approval of [drug] as consistent with your stated criteria and with standard practice for her condition.
The patient, the drug and the numbers are invented to show the shape. Notice what the paragraph does: it quotes the criterion, lists each prior treatment with a date and a result, and says where the evidence is. Notice also what it leaves out: adjectives, appeals to sympathy and promises about how the plan will decide.
Hypothetical timeline for the handoff
- Day 0: the denial arrives. You find the deadline and request the plan's criteria and file.
- Day 3: you fill in Parts 1 to 3 from memory and papers. Part 7 waits for the criteria.
- Day 7: the criteria arrive and you complete Part 7.
- Day 8: you send the worksheet and attachments to the clinic through the portal and call to confirm the right person has it. how to ask my doctor's office to support my appeal, with scripts to use has scripts for that call.
- Day 15: you check in. If a letter is not yet signed, ask whether a nurse or coordinator can draft it for the physician's review.
- Day 22: the signed letter arrives, and you submit the appeal with the denial letter, the letter and the records.
These are not required timelines, only a rhythm that leaves room for delays.
Checks before you submit the letter
Read the signed letter once against the worksheet:
- Does it name the service and the date of the denial?
- Does it respond to the stated reason in the plan's own language?
- Does it list the treatments tried with dates?
- Does it say what could happen if the decision stands, if the physician believes that?
- Is it on practice letterhead, dated and signed with credentials and contact details?
- Are the claims consistent with the chart? An inconsistency, such as a different date or drug name, gives a reviewer an easy reason to discount the whole letter.
Fix mistakes by asking the office for a corrected letter, not by editing the doctor's signed words yourself.
Gaps that weaken letters
A few patterns recur in letters that fail, and the worksheet is built to prevent them.
- A generic letter. If the same text could be sent for any patient with the diagnosis, the reviewer has nothing to apply the criteria to. Specific dates, doses and results are what make a letter about you.
- A letter that answers a different question. If the plan denied for lack of documentation of failed alternatives, a letter about how serious the disease is will not help. Part 1 makes you copy the reason word for word for this purpose.
- Claims that outrun the chart. A letter that says the patient "failed" a therapy needs a note somewhere showing the therapy and the result. The reviewer will look.
- No request. A letter should end with a plain statement of what is being asked: approval of the named service, for a named period, reviewed by a physician in the relevant specialty if possible.
- Missing the format the plan wants. Some plans take appeals only through a form, a portal or a fax number. The denial letter says how. Send the doctor's letter that way and keep proof.
When the doctor will not write one
Some doctors are too busy, some do not see themselves as responsible for insurance appeals and some doubt the treatment is right for you. Ask which it is. If the answer is time, ask whether a nurse or coordinator can draft and the doctor sign. If it is doubt, ask what the doctor would recommend instead and what evidence would change the doctor's mind. If the practice declines, you can ask another treating clinician, such as a specialist, or ask the hospital's patient advocate. You can also appeal without a letter. A plan reviewer would still weigh your records, but a physician statement is generally the strongest single exhibit.
A state insurance department or a patient advocacy organization may help you with the plan, though neither can write a clinical letter for you. free help fighting a denial, by plan type: who to call lists who to call by plan type.
Key takeaways
- The letter works best when it answers the plan's stated reason in the plan's own criteria language, supported by dated facts from the chart.
- Fill in the denial details, history, every treatment tried with dates and results, and why the plan's alternative does not fit, then let the doctor handle guidelines, risk and clinical judgment.
- Work backward from the appeal deadline in the notice and leave room for the office to take a week or more.
- Attach the denial letter, criteria, records and test results, and check the signed letter for consistency with the chart before submitting.
- If the doctor will not write one, ask whether a nurse can draft it, try another treating clinician or the hospital's patient advocate, and still file on time.