Blog
How to use Medicare star ratings, and where they mislead
What Medicare star ratings measure, why they describe a contract and not your doctors, the five-star switch, and how to pair stars with network and drug checks.
A reader sits down with two Medicare Advantage plans from the plan finder. One shows 3.5 stars. The other shows 4.5. The second plan looks like the obvious pick: a higher number is a better plan. That is partly true and partly not, and the part that is not can cost a year of trouble.
Star ratings are among the better pieces of public information about Advantage and Part D plans. They are also built to describe something narrower than most people assume. This post explains what the stars measure, whose performance they describe, what they cannot say about your own doctors and drugs, how a one-time-a-year switch into a five-star plan works, and how to put stars in their right place in a decision.
What the ratings are
Each fall, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) publishes star ratings for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans on a scale of one to five stars in half-star steps. The overall number is built from dozens of individual measures. The family of measures includes:
- Staying healthy: how many members get recommended screenings, tests and vaccines.
- Managing long-term conditions: whether members with diabetes, high blood pressure or other chronic conditions get recommended monitoring and treatment.
- Member experience: what members report in a federal survey about getting care, getting care quickly, and the plan's customer service.
- Member complaints and changes: how often members complain to Medicare about the plan, and how many leave it.
- Plan operations: how well the plan handles things like calls, appeals and data accuracy.
- Drug plan measures: pharmacy adherence and safety measures and member experience with drug coverage.
The glossary entry medicare star ratings gives the short definition and Insurer ratings explained: AM Best, NCQA, CMS stars and J.D. Power compares star ratings with other rating systems.
For 2027, the stars released on October 8, 2026 show a strong set of results by the numbers: about 71% of people in Advantage plans with drug coverage were in contracts rated four stars or more, 15 contracts earned five stars, and the enrollment-weighted average rating was 3.99 (it was 4.01 for 2026). In other words, a 3.5 is below the average enrollee's experience and a 4.5 is above it, and the gap between them in the scoring is real. What the gap means for you is a separate question.
Whose rating is it? Contracts, not plans
The first surprise: the star rating belongs to a contract, not to the specific plan you are choosing. A contract is an agreement between CMS and an insurance organization, identified by an H followed by digits (for example "H1234"). One contract can hold many plans, with different premiums, copays and benefits, sometimes across a large area. All of the plans under the contract share its star rating.
That has consequences:
- Two plans with different cost-sharing can show identical stars.
- The rating reflects the performance of the whole contract: the average experience across members in all the counties and plan versions it covers. If your county's network is weaker than the contract's average, the rating will not show that.
- A plan or contract that is new may have no rating yet, and the plan finder flags it as new. A missing rating is not a bad rating, but it gives you less to go on.
- Contracts change. Plans can move between contracts or be consolidated, and that can change which rating applies.
When you read a rating, look at the contract number and read the plan's details separately. The stars describe how the contract has performed, while the plan's costs and rules describe what you would sign up for.
Stars look backward
The ratings are based on data collected in earlier periods: surveys of members, clinical data and operations data from a year or two before. The 2027 ratings you see this fall describe performance leading up to now, not what will happen in 2027. A plan that has changed its network, its management or its care model since then may be different. CMS also changes the measures over time; it finalized a rule in April 2026 that begins removing some measures from the ratings starting with the 2028 and 2029 rating years. Year-to-year comparisons are therefore imperfect.
Quality bonus payments to plans are tied to star ratings, which gives plans a financial reason to care about them. Supporters say that this encourages plans to improve preventive care and service. Critics argue that it can push plans to concentrate on what is measured, and some question whether every rating gain reflects a change in care. You do not need to settle that debate to use the ratings, but it is a reminder that a number is a summary and a summary has edges.
Reading the detail behind the number
The plan finder lets you open a plan's rating and see the individual measures. Two or three minutes there can tell you more than the overall number. A contract can earn 4 stars on average while scoring low on the measure you care about most, such as getting appointments quickly or getting needed care. A few ways to use the detail:
- If you have a chronic condition, look at the measures for managing that kind of condition and at the member experience measures for getting needed care.
- If you expect to call the plan often, look at customer service and complaint measures.
- If you take many medicines, look at the drug plan measures and then do the formulary check in full.
- If you have been in a plan before, compare your own experience with its member satisfaction scores: a high score does not make your last year's problem go away, and a low one may not describe your experience.
The overall Medicare Advantage and drug rating also blends the medical and drug sides, and a plan can be strong on one and weak on the other. If the split matters to you, read the two summaries separately.
What stars cannot tell you
Stars describe a population. You are one person with specific doctors, medicines and conditions. Here is what no rating tells you.
- Whether your doctors are in the network. The most common reason a plan fails a person has nothing to do with quality scores. A five-star plan that excludes your cardiologist will not give you a cardiologist. Use the plan's directory, then call the office; see How to check a Medicare Advantage network before you enroll, doctor by doctor.
- Whether your drugs are covered and at what price. The formulary tells you. Your medicines may be on one plan's list and off another's, or in a more expensive tier.
- What you will pay. Stars do not include premiums, copays or the out-of-pocket limit.
- How the plan handles your specific condition. The ratings average across everyone. A plan may be strong for a healthy retiree and weaker for someone with rare disease or complicated surgery.
- How easy prior authorization is for the care you need. Some of the plan-operations measures touch appeals and call handling, but not the approvals you will face.
- Whether the plan will stay in your area. A well-rated plan can still leave a county. As of November 2026, KFF reported that about 4.3 million people had plans ending at the end of 2026, including Advantage and stand-alone drug plans; stars are not a guarantee against that.
A worked example, with invented details
Say Hannah, 72, compares Plan One (3.5 stars) and Plan Two (4.5 stars). Both have a $0 premium. She takes five regular medicines and sees a cardiologist, an endocrinologist and a primary care doctor.
| Question | Plan One (3.5 stars) | Plan Two (4.5 stars) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary care doctor in network | Yes (office confirmed) | Yes (office confirmed) |
| Cardiologist in network | Yes (office confirmed) | No |
| Endocrinologist in network | Yes (office confirmed) | Yes (office confirmed) |
| Her five drugs on the formulary | All five | Four; one needs prior authorization |
| Monthly cost of her five drugs | $40 | $85 |
| Yearly drug cost | 12 x $40 = $480 | 12 x $85 = $1,020 |
The numbers are invented. The year's difference in drug cost alone is $1,020 - $480 = $540, and Plan Two would require her to find a new cardiologist or pay out of network. A full star more in the ratings does not outweigh those facts. If both plans had covered all of her doctors and drugs at similar prices, the extra stars could reasonably settle the choice. In that case the star rating is a tiebreaker, and a good one.
A sensible order of use, then, is: network first, drugs second, cost third, stars fourth. Stars are valuable when you are choosing among plans that already pass the first three tests. The doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet helps you carry out the first two, and How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost covers the drug side.
The five-star switch
Medicare gives people one special opportunity tied to stars. If a five-star Advantage or drug plan is available where you live, you can generally enroll in it once during the year, with the window running from early December through the end of November, outside the usual enrollment periods. This is a kind of medicare special enrollment period. In practice it means you can move into a five-star plan even in the middle of the year, but you can use the right only once in a given year, and the plan you join has to be a five-star contract serving your address.
Some points to think about before using it:
- The usual cautions apply. A five-star rating does not say your doctors are in the network. Check them first.
- Joining a new plan can reset deductibles and your year-to-date out-of-pocket count.
- If you drop an Advantage plan for Original Medicare at the same time, Medigap rules and underwriting are not guaranteed; the star switch is not a reason to leave coverage you cannot get back.
- Check the current rules before acting. Enrollment windows and special enrollment periods can change, and Medicare.gov or a SHIP counselor will have the up-to-date terms.
If you are in an Advantage plan and find in the winter that it is not working, the Advantage open enrollment window from January 1 to March 31 is another option; see Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period.
How to combine stars with a network and drug check
Use this routine for each plan on your short list.
- Find the contract number and the stars in the plan finder, and note the year of the rating.
- List your doctors and facilities. Check the plan's provider directory, then phone each office with the plan's exact name.
- Enter every medicine into the plan finder with your pharmacy, and record the yearly drug cost and any restrictions such as prior authorization or step therapy.
- Estimate your year's costs: premium, copays for the care you expect, and the out-of-pocket limit for a heavy year.
- Look at the measures behind the stars if you care about a specific area, such as member complaints or customer service. The plan finder shows the detail for each rating.
- Compare stars last, among the plans that pass steps 2 to 4.
- Write down what you decided and why, so that next fall you can tell whether the plan did what you expected.
Key takeaways
- Star ratings belong to a contract, which can include many plans in many counties, and they reflect past performance, not your specific plan or doctors.
- Stars do not include your doctors' network status, your drugs, your costs or how easily the plan approves your care.
- In the invented example, a 4.5-star plan would have cost $540 more a year in drugs and excluded the cardiologist, so network and drug checks came first.
- Once per year, you can generally move into a five-star plan available where you live; check the current rule and confirm your doctors first.
- Use stars as a tiebreaker among plans that pass the network, drug and cost checks, and ask a SHIP counselor for help comparing.