Blog
Appeal, grievance or complaint: which one am I filing?
How an appeal, a grievance, a regulator complaint and a reconsideration request differ, who decides each, how timing works and when to file more than one.
You are angry at your health plan, and the plan gives you a phone number, a fax number and a form for something called a "grievance." You call the number and complain for twenty minutes. A month later you learn that what you needed was an appeal, the deadline for which has been running the whole time.
The words matter because the plan sorts what you send it into channels, and each channel has a different decision-maker, a different clock and a different outcome. This post compares four of them: an appeal of a coverage decision, a grievance about service, a complaint to a regulator and a request for reconsideration. It then explains when to file more than one. Terms and details vary by plan type and state, so treat the table as a map and check the plan's notice for the rules that apply to you.
The short version
- An appeal asks the plan to change a decision about coverage or payment: a denied claim, a refused approval, a service cut off.
- A grievance tells the plan you are unhappy with service, conduct or access, and it does not ask to reverse a coverage decision.
- A complaint goes to an outside regulator, such as a state insurance department, when you think the plan broke a rule or you have been stuck inside the plan's own process.
- A request for reconsideration can mean two quite different things: the name Medicare Advantage uses for its first-level appeal, or an informal request from a doctor's office to reprocess a claim.
The comparison
| Appeal | Grievance | Regulator complaint | Reconsideration | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it challenges | A coverage or payment decision | Service, behavior, access, communication | A plan's compliance with law or its own rules | Depends on setting: a Medicare Advantage decision, or a claim processed incorrectly |
| Who decides | The plan, by a reviewer not involved in the first decision; then an independent reviewer if external review applies | The plan's grievance or member services unit | A state or federal regulator, which investigates | Medicare Advantage: the plan, then an independent reviewer; provider claim review: the plan's claims unit |
| Typical deadline to file | Set by the plan's notice; at least 180 days for a standard internal appeal in most plans | Set by the plan; check the member materials | Regulator sets it; often longer, with exceptions | Medicare Advantage: stated in the denial notice; provider reprocessing: set by the plan's contract |
| Usual outcome | The decision is upheld, reversed or partly reversed | An answer, an apology or a process change; coverage is not changed | Information, a plan response and sometimes enforcement; the regulator may or may not change your claim | The decision is upheld or reversed |
| Next step if you lose | External review in many plans | Complaint to the regulator | Other legal or administrative options | The next appeal level, as the notice says |
None of the entries replaces the notice you received. The denial letter is where a plan tells you the channel, the address and the dates.
Appeals: the coverage decision
An appeal, sometimes called an internal appeal, is the formal request that a plan reconsider a decision it made about your benefits. The decision may be a claim denial, a refusal of prior approval, a reduction of services or an end to coverage you were relying on. Most plans must offer at least one level of internal appeal, and federal rules set a minimum filing period of 180 days for most plans. After the internal appeal, many plans must offer independent external review by a reviewer who does not work for the plan. how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step and appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have cover how the steps and the dates fit together.
An appeal fits the following examples:
- Your plan denied an MRI because it says the scan is not medically necessary.
- The plan paid nothing for a hospital stay, citing a coverage exclusion that you think does not apply.
- Your plan refused a drug that your doctor says you need, because you did not try cheaper drugs first.
- The plan told you it will stop paying for ongoing treatment on a given date.
An appeal tends to succeed when it is specific: it answers the reason the plan gave and attaches the records. Compare denied as not medically necessary: what the phrase really means for one common reason in detail.
Grievances: the service problem
A grievance is a complaint to the plan about something other than a coverage decision. The details differ by plan type, but the usual grounds include rude or unhelpful staff, long hold times, a provider directory that listed a doctor who was not accepting patients, a failure to return calls, billing confusion and trouble getting an appointment within the network. In Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care, the word has a defined meaning and its own timing rules, and the plan's materials explain how to file and when you can expect an answer.
A grievance fits these examples:
- You waited on hold for an hour and were transferred three times.
- The plan's online directory lists a specialist who left the network a year ago.
- A customer service representative gave you wrong information about a deadline.
- A plan mailing contained another member's information.
A grievance rarely changes a coverage decision. If you file one instead of an appeal, the appeal deadline does not stop. This is the common trap in this topic. See grievance for the definition, and note that a few plans have rules that connect the two, so ask the plan how it treats a letter that contains both.
Regulator complaints: going outside the plan
A complaint to a regulator is a report to an agency with authority over the plan. Which agency depends on the kind of coverage:
- Individual and fully insured employer plans: usually the state insurance department.
- Self-funded employer plans: generally the U.S. Department of Labor, since state insurance law does not usually apply to them. The plan documents or your benefits office can tell you which type you have.
- Medicare Advantage and Part D: 1-800-MEDICARE, a number the program publishes, and the plan's own materials.
- Medicaid managed care: the state Medicaid agency, and in many states an ombudsman.
A regulator can look into whether the plan followed required procedures, met its deadlines, sent proper notices or applied the law correctly. The agency may request records from the plan and may press for a correction or take enforcement action. A regulator does not stand in the plan's shoes: it may not order your claim paid in a particular case, and the effect of a complaint varies by state and by situation. Even so, a complaint can break a logjam, especially where the plan has missed its own deadline or has refused to give you a required notice. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department describes the state route, and After I file a complaint with the state insurance department: what happens next describes what happens afterward.
A regulator complaint fits these examples:
- The plan ignored your appeal past the date it was required to decide.
- The denial letter left out the instructions for appeal or external review.
- A plan repeatedly refuses to release documents you are entitled to.
- You suspect a pattern, such as inaccurate provider directories that affect many members.
Reconsideration: two meanings
In Medicare Advantage, "reconsideration" is the name for the first-level appeal of a plan's decision. The path from there runs through an independent review organization and then further levels, each with its own notice and deadline. The denial notice sets them out. How to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial, from plan to independent review follows the path in order.
In an ordinary claims context, a doctor's office or hospital may ask a plan to "reconsider" or reprocess a claim that it believes was paid or denied incorrectly. That is a provider-side payment dispute, handled under the plan's contract with the provider. It does not stop your own appeal clock and is not an appeal in the formal sense. If a bill reached you because of a billing or coding mistake, it may be fixable that way, and billing mistakes that make a covered claim look denied covers examples. If your own appeal rights are at stake, file your own appeal on time regardless.
How to decide: a short decision list
Ask what you want the plan to change.
- If you want a decision reversed, file an appeal. Use the channel and address in the denial letter. Meet the deadline.
- If you want an apology or a fix to how you were treated, file a grievance. It will not reverse a coverage decision.
- If the plan is not following the rules, file a complaint with the regulator that oversees your plan. Do it in addition to, not instead of, an appeal when a decision is at stake.
- If you are in Medicare Advantage and the notice says "reconsideration," that is your appeal. Follow the notice.
- If it is not clear, ask the plan in writing which channel your letter will be treated as, and file in the way that protects your deadline.
When to file more than one
It is common, and proper, to use two channels for different parts of one problem.
Scenario A. A plan denies a surgery, and a representative told you the wrong deadline on the phone. File the appeal on the denial, with the deadline from the written notice. File a grievance about the wrong information. The grievance may help your appeal later by showing why a deadline question arose.
Scenario B. The plan receives your appeal but does not decide it within the time the rules allow. Keep the appeal active, and file a regulator complaint about the missed deadline. Federal rules also have a provision that treats certain failures by a plan to follow its procedures as grounds to move on to the next step; the notice or your state insurance department can say whether it applies.
Scenario C. A doctor's office thinks a claim was coded wrong. The office asks the plan to reprocess it, and you also file an appeal for the same claim, in case the reprocessing fails. Tell both sides what you are doing so that you do not receive conflicting notices.
Scenario D. You are not sure whether the problem is coverage or service. Say the plan promised an approval over the phone and then denied the claim. File an appeal on the denial, and a grievance on the conversation, keeping the call log.
A rule of thumb: if a decision is at stake, appeal. If conduct is at stake, grieve. If either channel is not working, complain to the regulator.
Mistakes that come from mixing the channels
- Filing a grievance and waiting for the appeal to start on its own. Appeals and grievances run on separate clocks.
- Sending the appeal to the regulator. A regulator does not decide your claim the way the plan does, and it will not preserve your appeal deadline.
- Calling instead of writing. Phone calls may be logged, but a letter or portal message is a record. Follow up on a call with a dated note.
- Using strong language in place of a clear request. Say what happened, what you want and by when.
- Skipping the external review. After the internal appeal, an independent review may remain; appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have explains the deadlines, and appeal and external review deadline calculator helps with dates.
If you are overwhelmed, free help exists. State consumer assistance programs, SHIP counselors for people with Medicare and patient advocates can help you see which channel fits, and free help fighting a denial, by plan type: who to call lists who to call by plan type.
Key takeaways
- An appeal challenges a coverage or payment decision; a grievance challenges service or conduct; a regulator complaint asks an outside agency to look at the plan; reconsideration is Medicare Advantage's name for a first-level appeal.
- A grievance does not stop the appeal clock, so when a decision is at stake, file the appeal first and by the deadline in the notice.
- Which regulator you contact depends on the plan type: state insurance department, Department of Labor, Medicare or the state Medicaid agency.
- Filing in more than one channel is normal when a problem has both a coverage part and a service part, as long as you keep each paper trail separate and dated.
- When in doubt, ask the plan in writing which channel your letter will be treated as, and keep your own copy.