Blog

My claim has said pending or in review for weeks: what is going on?

Ten questions on why a claim sits in pending or in review, what the plan may be waiting for, how long is too long and how to escalate.

A claim that says "pending" or "in review" is not denied, and it is not paid. It is waiting for something, and the waiting can be on the plan, the provider or you. The status word is usually a label for an internal queue, not a decision, so the useful question is what the claim is waiting for and who is expected to supply it. The ten questions below cover the common causes, how to find out which one applies and how to escalate when the wait goes on too long.

Timing rules differ by plan type and state, and the plan's own documents and notices control. Treat the time frames here as general patterns, and check your plan for the real ones.

What the status means

What does "pending" actually mean?

It means the plan has received the claim but has not finished deciding it. A pended claim has been set aside by the plan's system or by a person. The cause might be as simple as a queue, or it might be that the plan needs information. Some portals use "pending," "in process," "under review" and "in review" for the same thing, and others use them differently.

The status on its own does not tell you whether the plan is waiting for you, the provider or its own staff. The way to find out is to ask the plan, "What is this claim waiting on, and when was that requested?" A claim pended for a record request looks identical on the portal to one waiting in an ordinary queue, and the two call for different actions.

Is "in review" worse than "pending"?

Not necessarily. "In review" often means a person or a clinical reviewer is looking at the claim, for example to check whether the service meets the plan's coverage criteria, whether an authorization was needed or whether the charges are consistent with the diagnosis. It can end in payment as easily as in denial. A review does not mean the plan has decided against you, and it is not an appeal. It is part of claims adjudication, the process by which a plan decides a claim.

If a claim is "in review," ask whether the review is clinical, for medical necessity, or administrative, such as an eligibility check, and what additional documents would help.

Missing information and records

What information might the plan be missing?

Common gaps include a diagnosis code that does not match the service, an authorization number, a referring-provider name, the place of service, an operative report, a dollar amount that is unusual for the code or an itemized bill for a hospital claim. The plan sends a request to the provider, usually electronically, and the claim waits until the answer arrives or a deadline passes.

What to do: ask the plan exactly what it needs and from whom, and the date it asked. Then ask the provider's billing office whether it received the request. Requests sent to an old fax number or an unworked inbox can sit for weeks. Ask the provider to respond and to tell you the date it did.

Why would the plan ask for my medical records?

A plan may ask a provider for records to check that a service was medically necessary, that the documentation supports the codes billed or that a procedure was what the claim says. It is common for high-cost claims, certain categories of services and claims that trigger an audit edit. The plan generally asks the provider, not you, and the provider must send the records.

What to do: call the provider's medical records or billing office and ask whether a records request arrived and whether it was answered. Records requests can be slow because of the volume of requests. Ask for the date the records were sent. Then ask the plan to confirm receipt. This is a case where a patient's call to both sides moves the claim. For how a plan judges necessity, see medical necessity.

Questionnaires and authorization checks

What is a coordination of benefits questionnaire?

Plans use coordination of benefits rules to decide which plan pays first when someone has more than one source of coverage, such as a spouse's plan, a parent's plan or an auto policy. When the plan's records suggest another source, or when it has not updated its records in a while, it may send a questionnaire to the member asking whether other coverage exists, and it may hold claims until you answer.

What to do: answer it, even if the answer is "no other coverage." Return it by the method the letter describes and keep a copy and the date. If you cannot find it, call member services; many plans let you answer by phone or online. The Two health plans? Coordination of benefits decides who pays first guide explains the rules for who pays first.

What is an accident questionnaire?

If the diagnosis code suggests an injury, the plan may ask whether it was caused by an accident, a workplace incident or another person's fault. The reason is that another insurer, such as an auto policy, a workers' compensation carrier or a liability insurer, may be responsible for part of the cost, and the plan may seek reimbursement from it later. The plan often pends claims until it gets the answer.

What to do: answer truthfully and quickly. If it was an accident at work, say so. If it was a fall with no other party involved, say that. If you are unsure of the right answer because a lawsuit or a claim with another insurer is involved, a lawyer is the right person to ask before you answer, since your answers may matter in that other matter. The hurt in a car crash: whose insurance pays the hospital, and what is subrogation? post covers how those claims interact.

Could a prior authorization question be the reason?

Yes. If the service is one the plan requires approval for and the claim arrives without an authorization number, the plan may pend it while it checks whether one exists, or it may deny it. If the service was an emergency, the approval rules generally differ.

What to do: ask the provider whether an authorization was requested and the approval number. Ask the plan whether it has one on file for that date. If you hold the paperwork for an approval, send the number to both. The prior authorization and claim tracker can help you keep these records.

How long is too long?

How long can a claim stay pending?

There is no single answer. Many claims clear in a couple of weeks; some take longer for the reasons above. Rules set outer limits. For most employer plans, the federal claims regulations generally expect a decision on a claim for care already received within about 30 days, with a possible extension of 15 days when the plan notifies you of the reason. If the plan needs information from you, the clock typically pauses while you have time to respond, which the rules generally set at no less than 45 days. Many states have prompt-payment laws for insurers, with their own deadlines and interest in some cases. Individual-market and marketplace plans have their own rules and state variations.

Your plan documents, the notice the plan sends and your state insurance department can tell you which clock applies to your coverage. If a claim has been pending longer than that clock, you have grounds to push. If it is within the clock, ask what the plan is waiting for and whether you can speed it up.

Who to call and how to escalate

Who should I call, and what should I ask for?

Call the party that owns the next step. If the plan says it asked the provider for records, call the provider. If the plan says it is waiting on you, answer it. If neither knows, call the plan's member services and ask for a supervisor or a claims specialist.

A short script helps. "I am calling about a claim for [provider] with date of service [date]. The status has shown pending since [date]. What is it waiting for, who was asked and when? Is there a deadline? What can I do to move it?" Ask them to repeat the answer back so you have it exactly.

How do I get a reference number?

Ask for one at the start of every call: "Can I have a call reference number and the name or ID of the person I'm speaking to?" Many plans also assign a claim number, a case number or an inquiry number. Write down the call date, the time, the reference number and what was promised. When you call again, quote it. A written message through the member portal is even better, because it creates a record with a date.

If a plan says it will call you back or send a letter by a date, put the date on your calendar. If it does not happen, call back and cite the earlier reference.

When should I file a complaint with the state insurance department?

Consider it when a claim is pending beyond the time frames that apply to your plan, when you have asked the plan and the provider for status and got no clear answer or when the plan is not responding to your requests. The state insurance department regulates insured plans in the state and takes consumer complaints. A complaint does not need a lawyer, and the guide how to file a complaint with your state insurance department explains what to include: dates, claim numbers, the contact log and what you have asked for.

Two cautions. First, if your employer's plan is self-funded, it is generally regulated by the federal Department of Labor rather than the state insurance department, and the state may not have authority over it; the guide above and your plan documents say which applies. Second, a complaint is different from an appeal. An appeal challenges a denial. A complaint asks a regulator to look into a delay or a practice. If the claim is eventually denied, you will need the appeal process, and the deadline for that starts from the denial notice, not the delay. The Appeal, grievance or complaint: which one am I filing? post helps you pick the right one.

A worked example of one claim's wait

Say Keiko's physical therapy claim for a date in early October has shown "in review" for six weeks. This is invented.

  • Week 1. She checks the portal: "received," then "in review." She waits.
  • Week 3. She calls the plan. The representative says the claim was pended on day 4 for a coordination-of-benefits check because her records show a second plan, a former employer's coverage that ended two years ago. A questionnaire was mailed to her old address.
  • Same call. She answers by phone that she has no other coverage, gets a reference number and asks the representative to note her current address. The representative says the claim will be released to processing.
  • Week 4. The status still says "in review." She calls again, quotes the reference number and learns that the claim was released but now needs the therapist's treatment notes because the number of visits is high. The plan sent a request to the therapist.
  • Same week. She calls the therapist's office, which says it never received a request. They find it in a general fax inbox and send the notes.
  • Week 6. The claim is processed and an EOB is issued.

No single call solved it; two causes in a row did. The lesson is to ask each time what the claim is waiting for, since the answer can change.

What not to do

  • Do not assume pending means denied, and do not start an appeal before there is a denial.
  • Do not pay a provider's balance on a claim that is still pending unless you must; the plan's share and your share are not set until it finishes.
  • Do not let a questionnaire sit. An unanswered letter can hold a claim indefinitely.
  • Do not rely on one phone call. Follow up in writing, through the portal if possible.

Key takeaways

  • Pending and in review are queue labels, not decisions; ask the plan what the claim is waiting for, who was asked and when.
  • The most common causes are missing information, medical record requests, coordination-of-benefits or accident questionnaires and authorization checks.
  • Answer questionnaires promptly and ask the provider whether it received the plan's request for records.
  • Get a reference number on every call and keep a dated log; use the portal's secure message for a written record.
  • If a claim is pending past the time frame in your plan documents, or you cannot get a clear answer, a complaint to the state insurance department is the next step for insured plans.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic