Blog
Copay card or patient assistance program: which one can I use?
A table comparing manufacturer copay cards, patient assistance programs and independent foundations: who qualifies, what each pays for and what to have ready.
Which help is open to you with an expensive drug depends mostly on one fact: what kind of coverage you have. A drug maker's copay card is generally for people with commercial insurance. A manufacturer's patient assistance program is generally for people who cannot afford the drug, and may take people with no insurance, with too little coverage, or in some cases with Medicare. Independent charitable foundations fill in around the edges. This post compares the three in a table, explains why the lines fall where they do, walks through three invented households, and lists what to have ready when you apply. Because each program sets its own rules and changes them, the last step in every case is to check with the drug maker and ask the prescriber's office.
The three kinds of help
Three different things are often lumped together under "assistance."
- A copay card (also called a copay coupon or savings card). The drug maker pays part or all of the patient's share of the cost at the pharmacy. It reduces what you pay, but the insurance claim still goes through. The copay assistance program entry describes it.
- A manufacturer patient assistance program (PAP). The drug maker, or a foundation it funds, provides the drug itself free or at low cost to people who meet need-based criteria. It usually works outside insurance: the drug may come from a special pharmacy and the claim is not billed to the plan.
- An independent charitable foundation. A nonprofit that is not part of the drug maker raises money, often from drug makers and other donors, and gives grants for out-of-pocket costs for people with a particular condition. It generally works by paying part of your share, sometimes for insured people and sometimes for the underinsured.
Side by side
| Copay card | Manufacturer patient assistance program | Independent charity foundation | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who usually qualifies | People with commercial insurance, including many employer and marketplace plans | People with low income or limited coverage; some accept people with no insurance, and some accept people on Medicare | People with a specific condition and often an income limit, insured or underinsured |
| Income test | Usually none | Usually yes, expressed as a percentage of the federal poverty level | Usually yes |
| People on Medicare, Medicaid or other federal programs | Generally excluded by the card's terms | Varies by program; some accept Medicare patients | Varies; many help Medicare patients, subject to federal rules on independence |
| What it pays for | Part or all of your share of the drug cost at the pharmacy | The drug itself, free or low cost, shipped to you or your prescriber | A grant toward out-of-pocket costs, which may include the drug, premiums or other care |
| How it works with your plan | Claim goes through insurance; plan may or may not count the card's payments | Often outside insurance; may not count toward your deductible | Payment goes to the provider or pharmacy; counting depends on the plan |
| How long it lasts | Per-year dollar limit; resets at a set date | Often a set period, with renewal each year | Grant period set by the foundation; funds open and close |
| Where you apply | Drug maker's website, pharmacy or prescriber | Drug maker's program, usually with the prescriber's office | The foundation's website, often with the prescriber |
| Typical catch | Annual limit; accumulators can reduce its value | Income and documentation rules; the drug may come from a specific pharmacy | Waitlists or closed funds; condition-specific |
Every entry in the table is a general pattern, not a rule. A given program may be the exception, so check the specific drug maker's or foundation's terms.
Why the lines fall where they do
The most common question is "why can't I use the card if I am on Medicare?" The answer is a federal law, commonly called the anti-kickback statute, that prohibits offering something of value to encourage purchases paid for by a federal health care program. Medicare, Medicaid and TRICARE are such programs. A copay card lowers a patient's cost and so encourages use of the company's drug. For a commercially insured patient the law does not apply in the same way. For a patient in a federal program it does, and so card terms exclude them.
Patient assistance programs and independent foundations are treated differently, mainly because they are need-based and, in the case of independent foundations, are run separately from the drug makers. The rules around what a drug maker may give an independent charity and what the charity may then do are set by federal guidance, and programs adjust to it. This is why you may find that a drug maker's own free-drug program accepts Medicare patients while its copay card does not. The details change, so confirm with the program.
Two other points follow from how these programs work:
- A card is only as good as your plan's treatment of it. If your plan has a copay accumulator, the card's money may not count toward your deductible. See copay accumulators and maximizers: why coupons may not count and My copay card ran out in the spring and now I owe the deductible.
- A free-drug program may take you out of the insurance process. If the drug comes outside the plan, it generally does not count toward your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. For some people that is fine; for others it is a reason to prefer a different route.
Three households, with invented numbers
These examples are illustrations. The numbers are round and made up.
A commercially insured parent
Say Rosa is covered through her employer, and her son takes a brand-name drug that costs the family $200 a month after the plan pays its share. The drug maker offers a copay card that reduces the patient's share to $10 a month, up to an annual limit.
- Without the card: 12 x $200 = $2,400 a year.
- With the card: 12 x $10 = $120 a year. The card pays $190 a month, or 12 x $190 = $2,280 in total, which is within a hypothetical $5,000 annual limit.
- Saving to the family: $2,400 - $120 = $2,280.
The card fits Rosa well. Her next question is whether her plan counts the card's money toward her deductible and maximum; see the checklist in How to find out if my plan has a copay accumulator before I enroll.
A person without insurance
Say Walt, 52, has no insurance, works part time and takes a brand-name drug whose cash price is $900 a month, or $10,800 a year. A copay card does not help, because there is no insurance claim to reduce. A manufacturer patient assistance program may supply the drug free if his income is below the program's limit. Walt's household income is, say, 250% of the federal poverty level, and the program's limit is 400%, so he may qualify.
- Without help: 12 x $900 = $10,800 a year.
- With a free-drug program: $0 for the drug while he is enrolled.
For Walt the program is the better fit. He should also check whether he is eligible for Medicaid or a marketplace plan, since eligibility for those changes which programs apply. The Health insurance for low-income households: Medicaid, credits and help explains the options, and a navigator can check them at no charge.
A person on Medicare
Say Helen, 71, has a Part D plan and a brand-name drug whose cost under the plan is $300 a month before she reaches the annual limit. She cannot use a manufacturer copay card. She can look at Extra Help, which lowers Part D costs for people with limited income and resources (Extra Help with Part D costs: the low-income subsidy explained); at a manufacturer patient assistance program that accepts Medicare patients, if one exists for her drug; and at independent foundations that serve her condition. The Can I use a drug coupon or discount card with Medicare Part D? covers the Medicare rules in more detail. If Helen's income is above the programs' limits, she may qualify for none, and her SHIP counselor can look at the whole picture.
Where each one tends to fit
A copay card tends to fit a person with commercial insurance, a brand-name or specialty drug without a generic equivalent, and a high share of the cost. It is usually the fastest to set up and has no income test. The cautions are the annual limit and the plan's accounting.
A patient assistance program tends to fit a person with no insurance, with insurance that does not cover the drug, or with low income. It takes more paperwork and a wait. The caution is that the drug may arrive outside the plan.
An independent foundation tends to fit a person with a specific condition whose costs are high even with coverage, including some Medicare patients. The caution is availability: a fund can close for the year when its money is used up, so it is worth checking often.
Many people use more than one program in sequence, and none of them are permanent. Each needs renewal.
What to have ready when you apply
Programs ask for similar documents. Gather these before you start.
- The prescription, with the drug, dose and prescriber's details, and the diagnosis if required.
- Insurance information: a copy of the card, the plan name and member number, and a denial or explanation of benefits if the plan did not cover the drug.
- Proof of income, such as a recent tax return, pay stubs, a benefits letter or a statement that you have no income. Some programs also ask about household size.
- Identification and residency. Some programs require that you live in the United States and may ask for proof of address.
- A signed authorization allowing the program to talk to your prescriber and, if needed, your pharmacy.
- The prescriber's signature on the program's form. Many programs require the prescriber to complete part of the form, so ask the office who handles these and how long it takes.
If a program asks for money up front, a fee to apply or access to your bank account or login, stop and check with the prescriber's office. Legitimate programs generally do not charge to apply, and the fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance has more on warning signs.
Steps, in order
- Ask the prescriber's office what exists for your drug. Many offices have a staff member who handles assistance forms.
- Check the drug maker's website for a patient support page. It usually lists the copay card and the patient assistance program separately, with eligibility terms.
- Match your coverage to the program: commercial insurance points to the card; no insurance or inadequate coverage points to the free-drug program; Medicare or Medicaid rules out the card and points to the others.
- Apply for the one that fits and keep copies of everything you send.
- Ask the plan how it will treat the help you receive, since it may or may not count toward your deductible.
- Set a reminder to renew. Most programs run for a year or less.
- If none fits, the plan may be able to cover the drug through an exception; see what to do when your plan will not cover a drug you need.
Key takeaways
- A copay card is generally for people with commercial insurance, and federal anti-kickback rules are why people on Medicare, Medicaid and other federal programs are generally excluded.
- Manufacturer patient assistance programs and independent foundations are need-based, may help people with no insurance or on Medicare, and often work outside your insurance.
- Help received outside your plan may not count toward your deductible or out-of-pocket maximum, so ask the plan how it will treat each kind.
- Eligibility details differ by drug maker and foundation and change over time. Check the program's own terms and ask the prescriber's office to help with the forms.
- Gather the prescription, insurance details, proof of income and a signed authorization before you apply, and never pay a fee to apply.