Blog

Is my plan ERISA or state-regulated? Five clues and why it changes my appeal

Employer plans are either self-funded or fully insured, and that decides who regulates them. Five clues to tell which you have and what changes in an appeal.

Two coworkers can hold ID cards printed with the same insurer's name and have different legal protections. One of them is in a plan the employer pays for out of its own funds and the insurer only administers. The other is in a plan the insurer sells to the employer and bears the risk on. From the member's side, the cards, the websites and the phone lines look alike. For a denied claim, though, the difference decides which law applies, who takes your complaint and whether your state's rules help you at all.

This post is a checklist for finding out which kind of plan you have, built from five clues you can check with documents in your own hands, followed by a table of what changes in an appeal. It is not legal advice; for a specific plan and a specific dispute, the plan's own documents, your benefits office and, for large disputes, a lawyer are the authorities.

First, untangle the terms

"ERISA or state-regulated" sounds like a choice between two options, but the two ideas overlap.

ERISA is the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, a federal law that sets rules for most private-sector employer benefit plans, including health plans. ERISA has the short definition. Almost every employer plan from a private company is an ERISA plan, whether or not it is also regulated by the state.

What matters is how the plan is funded:

  • Fully insured plan. The employer buys a policy from an insurer and pays premiums. The insurer takes the financial risk of claims. The policy is regulated by the state insurance department, and the plan is also subject to ERISA's federal rules for employer plans. fully insured plan covers it.
  • Self-funded plan. The employer pays claims from its own money, often with a stop-loss policy as a backstop. An insurer or another company is commonly hired as a third-party administrator to process claims, supply the network and print the ID cards. State insurance laws generally do not reach a self-funded ERISA plan, because federal law preempts them. self-funded plan explains the structure and self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you explains why it matters to you.

So the practical question is not whether your plan is under ERISA. It is whether the plan is fully insured, so the state insurance department can act, or self-funded, so the federal Department of Labor is the main regulator.

Two groups are outside ERISA and have their own rules: government employers (state and local government plans, which are typically under state law and their own plan rules) and church plans that have not elected ERISA coverage. Federal employee plans are another category. If you work for a government or a church, ask your benefits office which rules apply, because the answer is different from a private company's.

Clue 1: The plan's own documents say how it is funded

The most reliable clue is in the document you may never have opened. An ERISA employer plan must have a Summary Plan Description (SPD) that explains the plan's terms. Its text typically names:

  • The plan sponsor and plan administrator, usually the employer.
  • The claims administrator, the company that decides claims, which may be an insurance company acting as administrator.
  • A statement about funding: either that benefits are "provided through an insurance policy issued by" an insurer, or that benefits are "paid from the general assets of the employer" or a trust.
  • A statement about whether the plan is subject to state law or relies on federal preemption.

Look for words such as "self-insured," "self-funded," "administrative services only" (ASO) or "stop-loss." Any of these points toward self-funded. Words such as "group policy," "certificate of coverage," "evidence of coverage" or "insured by" point toward fully insured, because those documents come from an insurer that issued a policy. The summary of benefits and coverage is a different, shorter document; it is a plan summary that does not necessarily say how the plan is funded. If you cannot find the SPD, your employer must give it to you on written request, and your benefits office usually has a copy.

Clue 2: The ID card and member materials

Insurers print cards for both kinds of plans. Some cards give hints:

  • A card that says "administered by" or "claims administered by" a company, or carries a line about the plan being self-funded, points toward self-funded.
  • A card that names the insurer as the one that "issues" or "underwrites" the coverage points toward fully insured.
  • Cards for fully insured plans often include the legal name of the insurer that is licensed in your state and sometimes a state-specific line or mention of the state department of insurance. Cards for self-funded plans commonly have a network brand but no state licensing line.
  • Fine print on the back or on the member website may say "This plan is self-funded and is not subject to state insurance laws" or may list a state department of insurance for complaints.

These are hints, not proof. Plans change forms, and an absent statement does not mean either way. Use this clue to guide your questions, then confirm with Clue 1 or Clue 5.

Clue 3: The wording of the denial letter

The denial notice must tell you how to appeal and what rights you have after the internal appeal. The language differs between the kinds of plans and often gives away the funding.

  • A fully insured plan's notice often tells you that you may contact the state department of insurance or a state consumer assistance program, and may describe a state external review process.
  • A self-funded plan's notice often describes a federal process, tells you that you may contact the Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) and may mention your right to bring a civil action under Section 502(a) of ERISA after you finish the plan's appeal process.
  • Either may refer to "an independent review organization," but the party that arranges it can differ.

If the notice names your state's insurance department and a state process, the plan is probably insured. If it names the federal agency, probably self-funded. Read the paragraph about your rights after the appeal, because it is the most telling part of the letter. What must my health plan's denial letter include? A checklist to hold it against lists what the letter should contain.

Clue 4: The benefits and the coverage mandates

State benefit mandates, such as requirements to cover certain services or conditions, apply to insured plans and generally do not apply to self-funded ERISA plans. If your plan's benefits differ from what your state's insurance law requires insurers to cover, that may be a sign the plan is self-funded. The reverse does not hold. A self-funded employer can choose to offer a benefit the state requires, so a match proves nothing.

Use this as a supporting clue. It works best as a question to ask: "My state requires insurers to cover [service]. Does that apply to my plan, or is the plan self-funded and exempt?" The answer tells you whether you can rely on the state mandate in an appeal.

Clue 5: Ask, and check the public record

You are entitled to ask, and the question is simple. Send your benefits office or HR a short message:

Is our health plan fully insured or self-funded? If it is insured, who is the insurer that issues the policy? If self-funded, who is the plan administrator and the claims administrator, and may I have a copy of the Summary Plan Description?

Plans with 100 or more participants generally file an annual report with the Department of Labor, Form 5500, which is publicly searchable and has schedules that describe how benefits are funded. Smaller plans are often exempt from filing. A search under your employer's name can confirm what you were told, but reading it takes some care. A benefits office, a broker or a lawyer can help.

Size is also a hint, though only that. Large employers are more likely to self-fund because they can absorb claim swings; very small employers rarely do, though some small employers use self-funding arrangements with stop-loss coverage. Ask rather than assume.

What changes in an appeal

Here is a comparison of the usual differences. It is a summary, not a rulebook; individual plans vary and your documents govern.

Question Fully insured plan Self-funded plan
Main regulator State insurance department, plus federal rules for employer plans U.S. Department of Labor (EBSA), plus federal rules
Where to file a regulator complaint State insurance department Department of Labor benefits assistance
State benefit mandates Generally apply Generally do not apply
Internal appeal Required by the plan; at least 180 days to file for most plans Same federal minimum
External review A state process or a federal process, depending on the state Federal process or arrangements the plan makes
Lawsuit after appeal Usually federal court under ERISA for employer plans Federal court under ERISA
Who decides the claim The insurer The plan administrator, often delegating to a claims administrator
Who pays if the appeal is won The insurer The employer's plan funds

Three of these differences matter most in practice.

Where you complain. The state insurance department can generally take complaints about an insured plan and ask the insurer to explain. It generally cannot act on a self-funded ERISA plan, and a complaint sent there will usually be redirected. For a self-funded plan, the Department of Labor's benefits assistance is the free route. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department and After I file a complaint with the state insurance department: what happens next describe the state route.

Which rules you can cite. A state law on step therapy, prior authorization timelines or coverage mandates is something you can cite in an appeal to an insured plan. It will not help in a self-funded plan, where you should cite the plan document, the federal claims rules for employer plans and federal laws that apply to all plans, such as the Affordable Care Act's appeal and external review requirements, the No Surprises Act and the mental health parity law.

How much the record matters. In both kinds of plans, a lawsuit about a denied claim under ERISA generally focuses on the record built during the plan's internal appeal. That is the subject of Why the internal appeal is your only chance to build the record under ERISA. If you have an employer plan, treat the internal appeal as the main event.

A short worked scenario

This is a hypothetical. Say Lena works for a mid-sized company and her plan denies a prescription as "not medically necessary." Her ID card shows a familiar insurer's logo.

  1. She reads her denial letter. The rights paragraph names the Department of Labor and mentions the right to bring a civil action under ERISA. That points toward self-funded.
  2. She asks HR the Clue 5 question in writing. HR answers that the plan is self-funded and administered by the insurer. She asks for the SPD, and it arrives within a few weeks.
  3. In the SPD, she finds the appeal procedure, the deadline, the address and the list of documents she can request.
  4. She decides not to cite her state's step-therapy law, because it likely does not reach her plan. She cites the plan's own coverage criteria, her doctor's letter and the federal appeal rules.
  5. She files the internal appeal within the deadline, attaches the records and asks for the claim file. If it is denied, she knows the next step is the federal external review process, and that a complaint, if needed, goes to the Department of Labor.

Had HR said "insured," she would have gone through the same appeal but added the state law argument, noted the state's external review process in her notes and kept the state insurance department as the complaint route.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Assuming the insurer's logo means the insurer is responsible. In a self-funded plan, the logo is the administrator, and the employer pays.
  • Complaining to the wrong agency and losing weeks. Check the denial letter's rights paragraph first, then ask HR.
  • Citing state law to a self-funded plan as if it controls. Mention it only where it adds to the argument on medical grounds.
  • Treating "ERISA" as a reason not to appeal. ERISA plans have internal appeals, external review and federal protections. The structure is different, not absent.
  • Waiting for an answer before appealing. If the funding question is slow to resolve, file the internal appeal within the deadline and keep asking.

Key takeaways

  • Most private employer plans fall under ERISA; the question that matters is whether yours is fully insured (state insurance department regulates the policy) or self-funded (federal Department of Labor oversight, state insurance mandates generally do not apply).
  • Five clues: the Summary Plan Description's funding language, the ID card and member materials, the rights paragraph of the denial letter, whether state benefit mandates apply and a direct written question to your benefits office, checked against the public Form 5500 where one exists.
  • Where you complain, which laws you can cite and what the external review looks like all depend on the answer.
  • Government and church plans and federal employee plans follow different rules; ask your benefits office which apply.
  • Whichever kind of plan you have, build the internal appeal carefully, because for employer plans it is usually where the record is made.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic