Blog

What must my health plan's denial letter include? A checklist to hold it against

A checklist of what a compliant denial notice contains, what each item is for, and what to request in writing when your letter is vague or leaves something out.

A one-paragraph letter that says your claim is "not covered" and gives you a phone number is probably missing things the rules require. For most private health plans, a denial notice has to give a specific reason, point to the plan provision behind it, say what could change the outcome, and explain how and by when to appeal. A letter that skips those items does not erase the denial, but it is a defect you can point to, and it leaves you without the information you need to answer it.

Use the checklist below to read the letter you have, mark what is present and what is missing, and ask for the rest in writing. The exact requirements come from federal claims-procedure rules that apply to most employer plans and, under the Affordable Care Act, to non-grandfathered individual and group plans. Some states add their own requirements, and Medicare and Medicaid have separate notice rules. Your plan documents and your state insurance department can confirm what applies to you.

Which letters this checklist fits

The checklist fits a written notice that a plan sends when it denies, reduces or ends a benefit or a payment. The technical term is an adverse benefit determination. It includes denials of claims you already filed, denials of a request in advance such as prior authorization, a reduction of a benefit already approved, and a decision to cancel your coverage back to an earlier date.

It does not fit a plain explanation of benefits showing that part of a claim went to your deductible. That is a statement of how the plan processed the claim, not a denial. It also fits some plans less well than others:

  • Grandfathered plans keep a few older rules in place and may differ on the details.
  • Medicare and Medicaid plans send notices governed by their own rules, with their own deadlines and appeal levels.
  • Self-funded employer plans follow the federal claims-procedure rule, but state insurance law generally does not apply to them. The post Is my plan ERISA or state-regulated? Five clues and why it changes my appeal shows how to find out which kind you have.

The checklist

Go through each group below with your letter in hand. Each item says what to look for and why it matters.

Group 1: What was decided

  • Enough information to identify the claim. The date of service, the provider, the amount billed and the service in question. Why it matters: so you know exactly which claim or request the plan is talking about, especially when several claims from one visit were processed together.
  • The decision itself, in plain terms. Denied, reduced, ended or rescinded, and the amount affected. Why: an ambiguous letter makes it hard to decide whether to appeal the whole claim or one line.
  • The date of the notice. Why: every deadline you have runs from it. Circle it.

Group 2: Why

  • The specific reason for the denial. Not "not covered" alone, but what was not covered, and why under the plan. Why: you can only answer a reason you can read. The reason decides whether the fix lies with your doctor, with the billing office or with an argument about the plan's terms.
  • The denial code and its meaning, and the diagnosis and treatment codes with their meanings, on request. The plan has to supply these if you ask, and a good notice includes them. Why: the codes are what the provider's billing office sees. The post How do I read the reason and remark codes on my denial letter? explains how to read them.
  • A reference to the plan provision relied on. The page or section of the plan document, with the rule quoted or named. Why: a denial rests on a contract, and the clause is the thing you will argue with.

Group 3: How the plan applied its rules

  • Any internal rule, guideline, protocol or criterion the plan used. The notice should either quote it or tell you it was used and that you can get a copy free of charge on request. Why: many denials rest on written clinical criteria or coverage policies that are not in the plan booklet.
  • For a medical-necessity or experimental-treatment denial, an explanation of the scientific or clinical judgment, applying the plan's terms to your circumstances, or a statement that you can have it free on request. Why: a bare statement that a treatment is "not medically necessary" is not an explanation. You are entitled to one.
  • Whether a clinician reviewed it. Many appeals involve a health professional with the right training, and the notice may identify the expert consulted if you ask. Why: you may want to request that the reviewer be someone who has not already decided the claim.

Group 4: What could change the outcome

  • A description of any additional material or information needed to complete the claim, and why it is needed. Why: if the denial is "we did not receive records," this is the sentence that tells you what to send. A notice without it leaves you guessing.

Group 5: Your right to appeal

  • A description of the plan's internal appeal procedure and the time limits. For most plans the deadline to file an internal appeal is at least 180 days from receiving the denial notice, and the plan's documents state its exact period. Why: missing it can forfeit the right to review. The calculator appeal and external review deadline calculator helps you count from the notice date.
  • How to file, where to send it, and a contact point. Why: some plans accept appeals by phone, fax or an online portal, and some require paper.
  • How quickly an expedited review is available. If the delay could seriously jeopardize your health, you can ask for a faster decision, and the notice should say how. For urgent situations, federal rules set a very short decision time, measured in days, not weeks.

Group 6: What comes after the internal appeal

  • Information about external review. If the plan upholds the denial, an independent reviewer outside the plan can generally decide, and the notice should describe how to ask. The guide external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides covers what an external review is and when it applies.
  • A statement about court action, in employer plans under the federal law called ERISA, describing your right to sue after the plan's appeal process. Why: in those plans the record you build in the appeal can be the record a court reviews.
  • Contact information for a consumer assistance program, where your state has one, such as an office of health insurance consumer assistance or an ombudsman. Why: these offices help with appeals for free.

Group 7: Documents and access

  • A statement that you may get, free of charge, reasonable access to and copies of all documents, records and other information relevant to the claim. Why: the file is how you find out what the reviewer saw. You can ask for it even if the notice leaves the statement out.

Group 8: Language and clarity

  • Written so you can understand it. Why: the rules call for a notice that a layperson can follow.
  • Language help. Plans must offer assistance in other languages when a certain share of the population in an area speaks that language, including oral help through a customer line, and in some cases translated notices on request. Why: a notice you cannot read is no notice at all.

How quickly the notice should arrive

The federal claims-procedure rule sets maximum decision times that run from when the plan receives the claim or request. For most employer plans and non-grandfathered individual plans, the usual ceilings are 72 hours for an urgent request, 15 days for a non-urgent request for approval in advance, and 30 days for a claim for care you already received, and a plan can take a limited extension when it tells you why and what it still needs. A letter that arrives much later than that is worth noting in your appeal. Your plan documents state the periods that apply, and state law can shorten them. If a plan never answers, ask the plan in writing for its decision and check with the state insurance department about what the missing decision means for your appeal rights.

A vague letter next to a compliant one

Here is a hypothetical comparison, with an invented claim, to show the difference in practice.

Vague version: "Your claim for the January 12 procedure has been denied. This service is not covered under your plan. If you have questions, call member services."

Compliant version: "Your claim 12345 for a knee MRI performed on January 12 by Example Imaging, billed at $1,800, has been denied in full. The reason is that the plan's imaging policy requires a documented course of conservative treatment before an MRI for knee pain, and the claim did not include records of one. The provision relied on is Section 4.2 of your plan, which covers only medically necessary services, and the imaging policy, which is available free on request. If your doctor can send records showing physical therapy or other conservative care, we will review the claim again. You may appeal within 180 days of this letter by writing to the address below or by calling the number below. If we uphold the decision, you may ask for an independent external review. You may receive copies of all documents relevant to your claim at no charge. For help, contact your state's consumer assistance office at the number below. Language assistance is available."

The second letter gives you something to work with: it names the missing evidence, so the fix is a records request to the doctor, not an argument about coverage. The first gives you nothing, and the request letter above is how you turn it into the second.

Scoring your letter

Count the items present. A letter with most of Groups 1 through 5 present is probably compliant in form even if you disagree with the decision, and your energy belongs in the appeal. A letter missing several items, especially the specific reason, the provision relied on, the appeal steps and deadlines, and the right to the file, needs a written request.

What to request in writing when something is missing

Write to the plan's appeals address, or the address on the notice, and keep a copy. A request can be short.

I received a notice dated [date] about claim [number] for services on [date of service], member [name and ID]. The notice does not state [the specific reason for the denial / the plan provision relied on / the clinical criteria used / the steps and deadlines for appeal / my right to external review]. Please send, free of charge, (1) the denial code and its meaning and the diagnosis and treatment codes with their meanings, (2) the plan provision and any guideline, criterion or protocol relied on, (3) the explanation of the clinical judgment if the denial is based on medical necessity or experimental treatment, (4) the complete claim file, including reviewer notes, and (5) the deadline for my appeal. I am requesting this while I prepare an appeal, and I am not waiving any right to appeal.

Send it by a method that gives a receipt, and note the date. The guide how to write a health insurance appeal letter that gets read covers the appeal letter itself.

Does a defective notice make the denial invalid?

Not by itself. A notice that leaves out required items is a procedural problem and it can help you, but it rarely makes the underlying decision disappear. Under federal rules for many plans, a plan that does not follow the required claims procedures can allow you to treat the internal appeal as exhausted and move to external review or court. Whether that applies to your plan and what the standard is can depend on the plan, the state and a court's reading, so a lawyer or a state insurance department specialist is the right person to ask.

Two cautions follow. First, do not wait for a corrected notice before acting. The clock for your appeal generally runs from the date of the first notice, and a plan's later reply does not automatically restart it, so mark your deadline and file on time, noting the missing items in the appeal. Second, send the plan a written request for the missing items now, since that request and its reply become part of your record.

If the plan does not answer, a complaint to the state insurance department, for plans it regulates, or to the U.S. Department of Labor for many employer plans, puts the plan's conduct on the record. The post free help fighting a denial, by plan type: who to call lists free places to turn for each plan type.

Key takeaways

  • A compliant denial notice names the specific reason, cites the plan provision, says what information could change the outcome, and explains how and by when to appeal.
  • You are entitled, free of charge, to the criteria the plan used and to the claim file, even when the notice does not mention them.
  • Look for the notice date first, since every deadline starts there, and keep it in view even if the letter is incomplete.
  • A vague or missing item is a reason to write to the plan and ask, and a reason to note it in your appeal, not a reason to wait.
  • Whether a defective notice changes your rights depends on your plan type and state, so ask the state insurance department, a legal aid office or a lawyer.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic