Blog

How can I tell what my plan covers for IUI, IVF and fertility drugs?

A checklist for reading a plan's fertility benefit: definitions, limits, approvals, network, drugs, state and employer rules, plus a sample budget table.

Fertility coverage is one of the least uniform parts of health insurance. Two people in the same company can have different benefits, because the answer depends on whether the plan is fully insured or self-funded, what the state requires, what the employer chose to add and how the plan words its definitions. Reading the plan in the right order, with specific questions, will tell you more than any general summary, including this one.

This post is a checklist for a reader who is planning treatment: a set of questions to answer from the plan documents and a call to the plan, grouped by the reason each one matters. It ends with a budget table, using sample figures, that you can redo with your own. It is not medical advice, and the clinic and your physician decide which treatment is appropriate.

Why fertility coverage varies so much

The Affordable Care Act lists ten essential health benefit categories, and fertility treatment is not named as one of them. Individual and small-group plans must cover the essential health benefits, and the details of each category are filled in by each state's benchmark plan, so a state can include or leave out infertility treatment. See Essential health benefits: the 10 categories ACA plans must cover. Large employer plans have no such list, and what they cover is a business decision.

Three layers decide what you get:

  1. Federal rules. They set baseline protections but do not require infertility treatment coverage.
  2. State law. Many states have laws about infertility coverage. Some require insurers to cover diagnosis and certain treatments, some include in vitro fertilization, some require only an offer of coverage, and some have no mandate. Most state mandates apply only to fully insured plans.
  3. The plan itself. An employer may add a fertility benefit, often with its own limits, or may choose to exclude fertility entirely. A self-funded plan is not subject to state mandates, while a fully insured plan is. See self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you.

So the first task is to find out which kind of plan you have. Your employer's benefits office can tell you. If you buy your own coverage, the state's insurance department or marketplace can tell you what applies to plans sold there.

Checklist 1: get the right documents

  • The Summary of Benefits and Coverage. It gives a short overview and usually lists major exclusions. How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage explains the layout. Look for "infertility" in any section. Reason: the summary is the quickest check on whether a benefit exists.
  • The full plan document or evidence of coverage. It contains the definitions, limits and exclusions. Reason: the summary may say "covered" while the plan document restricts it to certain conditions or procedures.
  • Any fertility rider or benefit summary. Employers that add a fertility benefit often describe it separately. Reason: the base plan may exclude infertility while the rider adds a lifetime dollar benefit.
  • The list of excluded services. Reason: "services related to assisted reproduction" is common wording, and what it captures varies.

Checklist 2: diagnosis versus treatment

Many plans divide infertility care into two parts, and the divisions can be different.

  • Is diagnosis covered? Typical diagnostic services include a physician visit, bloodwork, ultrasound and tests of the reproductive tract or semen. Plans that exclude treatment often still cover some diagnosis under the ordinary diagnostic benefits. Reason: you can learn the cause of infertility, which affects the options, even when treatment is excluded.
  • What counts as treatment? Ask the plan to list the procedures that are covered: ovulation medication, intrauterine insemination (IUI), in vitro fertilization (IVF), egg retrieval, embryo transfer and related lab services. Reason: some plans cover IUI but not IVF, or cover medications but not procedures.
  • Is treatment of an underlying condition covered? A condition such as endometriosis or a blocked tube may be treated under the medical benefit as a medical condition, separate from the fertility benefit. Reason: the same surgery may be covered as medical care even where fertility treatment is excluded.
  • Fertility preservation. Some plans cover egg or sperm freezing before treatment that may affect fertility, such as certain cancer treatments, and exclude it otherwise. Reason: coverage can turn on the reason, and storage fees are often excluded.

Checklist 3: the plan's definition of infertility

The plan's definition decides whether you qualify for the benefit at all. Look for:

  • A required period of trying. Many plans define infertility as not conceiving after a period of regular, unprotected intercourse, and some shorten the period for older ages. Reason: you may need to wait or show a record.
  • Who is covered by the definition. Definitions vary on whether they include same-sex couples, single people or people who need donor gametes or a carrier. Some states require the definition to be inclusive. Reason: a narrow definition can exclude a person who otherwise needs the benefit.
  • A diagnosis requirement. Some plans require a physician's diagnosis of infertility, and others cover treatment without a finding of cause. Reason: it affects what paperwork you need before you start.
  • Age limits. Some plans limit coverage by the age of the person who will carry or provide eggs. Reason: a limit can end the benefit sooner than you expect.

Checklist 4: limits, lifetime maximums and cycle counts

The ban on annual and lifetime dollar limits applies to essential health benefits. Where fertility treatment is not an essential health benefit, a plan may set limits that other benefits cannot have. Find each of these:

  • A lifetime dollar maximum on fertility benefits, for example a total the plan will pay across all treatment. Reason: the plan's total can run out in the middle of treatment.
  • A cycle limit, such as a set number of IUI cycles or IVF cycles, or a limit on embryo transfers. Reason: ask whether a cycle means a retrieval, a transfer or a start of medications.
  • Whether the maximum is per person or per family. Reason: couples on the same plan may share one limit.
  • Whether a live birth resets the limit. Some plans do. Reason: it matters for a second child.
  • Whether benefits are shared between medical and pharmacy. Reason: the drug benefit may have a separate limit or none at all.

Checklist 5: approvals and the clinic network

  • prior authorization. Ask whether each step needs approval: starting treatment, medications, each cycle. Reason: starting without approval can leave a bill the plan will not pay. how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains the process.
  • Clinic network. Ask which fertility clinics are in the plan's network, and whether the plan has a designated network for fertility services. Reason: a clinic may be in network for diagnosis but out of network for treatment, and a plan's special network can differ from its general one.
  • Billing structure. Many clinics quote a package price for a cycle, and plans pay by service or by the cycle. Ask the clinic how it bills and whether the plan accepts that billing. Reason: a package price may not match the way the plan pays.
  • The laboratory and anesthesia providers. Ask whether the embryology lab, the anesthesiologist and the pathology lab are in network. Reason: a separate out-of-network bill can follow a covered procedure.
  • Which spouse's or partner's plan. If you have two plans, ask both which pays first. Two health plans? Coordination of benefits decides who pays first covers how that works. Reason: one plan may cover fertility and the other not.

Checklist 6: the drugs

Fertility drugs can be one of the largest costs of treatment. Ask:

  • Are fertility drugs covered under the pharmacy benefit, and which are on the formulary? Reason: drug coverage is separate from procedure coverage.
  • Is a specialty pharmacy required? Many fertility drugs must come from one pharmacy network. Reason: the timing of delivery matters when a cycle is under way.
  • Are there quantity limits or prior authorization for the medication? Reason: a refused refill midway through a cycle is costly.
  • Does the drug benefit have its own copay, deductible or maximum? Reason: it may not count toward the same totals as the medical benefit.
  • Does the amount you pay for drugs count toward the out-of-pocket maximum? Reason: it affects how far you are from the cap.

Checklist 7: state mandates and employer opt-ins

  • Does your state require coverage? Ask your state insurance department which services the mandate covers, who qualifies and which plans it applies to. Reason: a mandate can mean coverage in a fully insured plan that the plan document does not mention.
  • Is the employer's plan fully insured or self-funded? Reason: a self-funded plan is not bound by state mandates.
  • Did the employer opt in to a fertility benefit? If it did, the benefit may be administered by a separate third-party administrator or a fertility benefit manager, with its own member services, network and rules. Reason: you may need to enroll with that organization and get approvals from it, not from the main plan.
  • Does the employer offer different benefit levels for different groups of employees? Reason: benefits can differ by location, union or class of employee.

If you are comparing jobs or plans because of planned treatment, Questions to ask HR about health benefits before I accept a job offer lists questions worth asking, and Planning a pregnancy next year, how do I choose a plan month by month? covers timing.

A budget table with sample figures

Fertility costs vary widely between clinics and regions. The figures below are round numbers invented for illustration, not prices. Replace them with the clinic's estimate and your plan's actual terms.

Item Clinic or pharmacy estimate Covered by plan? Your cost
Diagnostic workup $1,200 Yes, diagnostic benefit Fill in
IUI cycle (monitoring, procedure) $1,500 Fill in Fill in
IVF cycle (clinic) $15,000 Fill in Fill in
IVF medications $4,500 Fill in Fill in
Embryo storage per year $600 Often excluded Fill in

Example 1: three IUI cycles. Suppose a plan covers IUI at 50% coinsurance after a $2,000 deductible that has not been met. Three cycles at $1,500 each total $4,500. The deductible takes the first $2,000, which the patient pays. The remaining $2,500 is split 50-50, so the patient pays $1,250 and the plan pays $1,250. The patient's total is $2,000 + $1,250 = $3,250.

Example 2: one IVF cycle with a lifetime maximum. Suppose a plan covers IVF at 80% after the same $2,000 deductible, but has a $10,000 lifetime maximum on what the plan will pay. One cycle costs $15,000 for the clinic plus $4,500 for medications, or $19,500. After the deductible, $17,500 remains, and 80% of that is $14,000. The plan's payment is capped at $10,000, so the plan pays $10,000 and the patient pays $19,500 - $10,000 = $9,500. Without the cap, the patient would have paid $2,000 + $3,500 = $5,500. The cap added $4,000 to the patient's share, and a second cycle would receive nothing from the plan.

Put your own numbers in the table, then ask the plan and the clinic to confirm each line before you commit to a treatment plan. The health insurance cost estimator can help set the rest of your yearly costs next to these. Ask the clinic for a written financial estimate, and ask it what happens if a cycle is canceled.

Questions to ask on the call

Keep a call log, with date, name and reference number, and ask these in the order the checklists run:

  1. Is infertility diagnosis covered? What counts as treatment?
  2. How does the plan define infertility, and does the definition apply to me?
  3. Which procedures and drugs are covered, and are there limits per cycle or for a lifetime?
  4. Does each step need prior authorization?
  5. Which clinics and labs are in network?
  6. Are drugs covered, through which pharmacy and with what cost sharing?
  7. Is the plan fully insured or self-funded, and is a state mandate relevant?
  8. Is a separate benefit manager involved?

If a covered treatment is denied, you can file an appeal, and how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step covers the steps. Your state insurance department handles complaints about fully insured plans, and the federal labor department's benefits office handles questions about self-funded employer plans. Clinics often have financial counselors who know the local rules and the plan's habits.

Key takeaways

  • Fertility treatment is not an essential health benefit under federal rules, so coverage depends on state mandates, whether the plan is fully insured or self-funded, and what the employer chose to add.
  • Read the definition of infertility, the diagnosis and treatment split, and the exclusions first. They decide whether and how the benefit applies to you.
  • Lifetime maximums and cycle limits are allowed on non-essential benefits and can shift thousands of dollars to you. In the IVF illustration a $10,000 cap raised the patient's share from $5,500 to $9,500.
  • Confirm prior authorization, the clinic and lab network, and the drug pharmacy before treatment starts, and ask whether a separate benefit manager runs the program.
  • Put the clinic's written estimate and the plan's answers in one budget table, and have both confirmed in writing.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic