Blog
My Advantage plan is ending: do I get a guaranteed Medigap policy?
A plan that will not renew can open a guaranteed-issue window for Medigap. The dates, the plan letters, the drug-coverage step and where state rules differ.
Yes, in most cases a Medicare Advantage plan that is ending gives you a time-limited right to buy certain Medigap policies without answering health questions. The right is real, but it runs on a clock that starts before your coverage ends and stops about two months after, and it covers a specific group of plan letters rather than every policy an insurer sells. The sections below follow the sequence in date order, using one labeled hypothetical to make the dates concrete.
Say Ruth, 71, gets a letter in early October telling her that her Medicare Advantage plan will not renew on January 1, 2027. She has a heart condition and takes six prescriptions. She would like to return to Original Medicare with a supplement, but she knows that an insurer could turn her down on health grounds in an ordinary application. Her question is the title of this post. The answer depends on the dates, so the timeline comes first.
The notice: what it is and what it starts
When a Medicare Advantage plan or a stand-alone drug plan will not continue into the next year, the plan must tell its members in writing ahead of the next annual enrollment period. As of November 2026, KFF reported that about 4.3 million people would have their Advantage or stand-alone drug plan terminated at the end of 2026: about 3.1 million in plans that include drug coverage and about 1.2 million in stand-alone drug plans. Ruth is one of a very large group, which matters in practice because local help desks and insurers are busy.
The notice is more than a courtesy. It is the document that proves your coverage is ending for a reason outside your control, and that proof is what the Medigap insurer asks for. Keep it. Photograph it, save the envelope, and write down the date it arrived. If a notice contains the date your coverage ends, that date is the anchor for every deadline below.
Three things the notice usually tells you, and one it often does not:
- That the plan, or the plan in your county, will not renew, and the last day of coverage.
- That you can choose another Advantage plan or Original Medicare during the annual enrollment period.
- That you may have a special right to buy Medigap, usually stated in a sentence or two.
- It often does not tell you which Medigap letters you are guaranteed, or what the insurer can charge. That is what the rest of this post covers.
The dates that matter, in order
Here is the calendar for a plan that ends December 31, 2026. Use the same logic if your end date is different, because the Medigap window is counted from your own end date.
- Early October. The non-renewal letter arrives. Plan sponsors generally send it ahead of the October 15 start of the annual enrollment period.
- October 15 to December 7. The Medicare annual enrollment period. You can switch to another Advantage plan, a stand-alone drug plan, or Original Medicare, and the change takes effect January 1. See Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7.
- About 60 days before coverage ends. Under the federal guaranteed-issue rule, you can apply for a Medigap policy as early as 60 days before your coverage ends. For a December 31 end, that is about November 1. As of November 16, 2026, Ruth's window is already open.
- December 8 through the end of February. A special enrollment period for people whose plan was terminated, which gives a second chance to pick an Advantage or drug plan after the regular period closes.
- No later than 63 days after coverage ends. The guaranteed-issue right for Medigap ends 63 days after the date your Advantage coverage ends. For a December 31 end, that lands in early March 2027. Your Medigap insurer and your SHIP counselor can confirm the exact last day, because it depends on how the date is counted and on the date printed on your notice.
If you apply early and the policy starts on the day your Advantage plan ends, there is no gap. If you wait until late in the window, you can still be accepted, but your Medigap policy would start later, and you would be in Original Medicare with no supplement in between. Original Medicare alone has no cap on what you pay for outpatient care. A week without a supplement is a week of exposure.
What "guaranteed issue" means in this situation
guaranteed issue means an insurer must sell you the policy you are entitled to. In the termination situation, three protections follow from that:
- The insurer cannot deny you coverage because of your health.
- The insurer cannot charge you more because of your health. Ordinary rating factors that your state allows, such as age, can still affect the price, so two insurers can quote different premiums for the same letter.
- The insurer cannot make you wait for coverage of a condition you already have.
That is the opposite of ordinary medical underwriting, where an insurer asks health questions and can decline an application or charge more. KFF estimated that 74% of people in Medicare Advantage, about 20.9 million, have a condition that could lead to a denial of a Medigap policy outside the protected windows. For Ruth, with a heart condition, the difference between a guaranteed window and an ordinary application could be the difference between buying a policy and being refused.
Nothing here says the insurer must give you a policy at a price you like. Guaranteed issue protects access, not affordability. Run the arithmetic on a policy you would keep for years before you sign, and read Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N for how the standardized letters compare.
Which plan letters the insurer must offer
Federal rules list the letters an insurer must sell you in this situation. Under the long-standing rule the group is Plans A, B, C, F, K and L, and any insurer selling Medigap in your state has to offer the ones it sells. There is a wrinkle that matters for most readers today. For people who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, Plans C and F can no longer be sold, and the plans sold to people newly eligible are A, B, D, G, K, L, M and N. How the older list translates for someone newly eligible, and whether a letter such as G is part of the guaranteed set where you live, is something to confirm with your state's SHIP counselor or the state insurance department rather than assume. Do not rely on an agent's recollection alone. Ask for the answer in writing.
Three practical points:
- The insurer chooses the letters it sells. An insurer is not required to sell every letter in your state, only the ones on its list in the guaranteed set. You can use the medigap plan comparison chart to see what each letter covers.
- Letters are standardized in most states. Plan G from one insurer pays the same benefits as Plan G from another, with differences in price, service and rating method. Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin use their own standardized sets, so ask what the letter names mean there.
- A lower letter now is not a lower letter forever. If you buy Plan A or B in the guaranteed window to be safe, moving up to a richer letter later usually means underwriting. Read the ordinary-application rules in medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue before choosing.
What state rules may add
Federal law sets the floor. States may add more. As of KFF's October 13, 2026 overview, examples include these, and the list changes as legislatures act:
- Connecticut and New York have continuous guaranteed issue for Medigap.
- Massachusetts has an annual window from February 1 to March 31, and its insurers offer continuous enrollment.
- Maine has a one-month annual window.
- Rhode Island, under a 2025 law, has an October 15 to December 7 window for Advantage enrollees aged 65 and older.
- Delaware, under a 2025 law, has two annual periods for Advantage enrollees.
- Minnesota has an annual window for ages 65 to 70, effective August 1, 2026, with a premium penalty that starts at 15% in 2026 and rises to 35% by 2030.
If you live in one of these states, you may have more room than a plan termination gives you. If you live elsewhere, the termination window may be the only guaranteed-issue opportunity you will see after your first six months on Medicare. Check your state's current rules through the state insurance department, because laws and window dates change. The guide How to leave a Medicare Advantage plan: dates, options and risks covers the general paths out of an Advantage plan.
The drug-coverage step most people forget
Medigap policies sold today do not include prescription drug coverage. If you leave an Advantage plan that included drugs and move to Original Medicare plus Medigap, you need a stand-alone Part D plan, and you have to choose it. Ruth takes six prescriptions, so this step is as important as the supplement.
The sequence:
- Make a list of every drug, dose and pharmacy before you compare anything.
- Compare stand-alone drug plans during the annual enrollment period for a January 1 start. How to compare Part D plans: formulary, pharmacies and total cost explains formularies, pharmacy networks and total cost.
- Note the penalty rule: if you go 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage after you were first eligible for it, a late-enrollment penalty can attach to your Part D premium for as long as you have the coverage. creditable drug coverage defines the term. The penalty is 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each uncovered month, which was about $0.39 per month in 2026 by Medicare's published figure and about $0.41 by arithmetic on the 2027 base premium of $41.33.
- Remember that the stand-alone market is also changing. KFF reported that the number of stand-alone plans available to the average beneficiary falls for 2027, from 11 to 9, so the plan you would have chosen last year may not exist.
If you do nothing, and your Advantage plan ends, you are returned to Original Medicare without drug coverage and without a supplement. That default is the outcome the whole timeline is designed to avoid.
Three ways Ruth could play it
Each of these is a legitimate path, with a tradeoff:
Path one: Original Medicare, Medigap and a stand-alone drug plan. Ruth applies for a guaranteed-issue Medigap policy starting January 1, then joins a stand-alone drug plan during the annual enrollment period. This gives her the widest choice of doctors and hospitals that accept Medicare. The cost is two premiums and no cap on cost sharing unless her Medigap letter provides one. It protects her if the heart condition leads to heavy use.
Path two: another Advantage plan. If the plan's doctors, drugs and extras suit her, a different Advantage plan avoids the supplement premium. The tradeoffs are a network, prior authorization and, if she later wants Medigap, a possible denial once the guaranteed window closes. The guide Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two sets the two models side by side.
Path three: Original Medicare with no supplement. Some people do this because they have a strong retiree plan, a very low usage record or a limited budget. Ruth's heart condition makes it a risky choice for her; for someone else it could be reasonable. Note that the guaranteed window closes, so choosing this path means giving up the right to buy a supplement without underwriting.
Nobody here can say which path is correct for Ruth. A SHIP counselor, who gives free, unbiased Medicare counseling, can run her actual drugs and doctors against the actual plans.
Mistakes that cost people the right
- Waiting for the new year to apply. The window begins before the coverage ends. Applying early is allowed, and it avoids gaps.
- Losing the notice. The insurer may ask for proof that the plan terminated. A copy is enough, but you have to have one.
- Applying under the wrong right. A Medigap application asks why you qualify. Answer from the notice, not from what an agent suggests. If the insurer wrongly treats you as an ordinary applicant, ask for the guaranteed-issue review in writing and contact the state insurance department.
- Cancelling the Advantage plan yourself before the new policy is approved. If your plan is ending anyway, there is rarely a reason to disenroll early. Disenrolling yourself could change which right you have.
- Forgetting the drug plan. The Medigap application is the visible task; the drug plan is the one that surprises people in January at the pharmacy counter.
- Assuming this right repeats. Next year's plan may not end. The guaranteed window opens only because this one is.
What to ask, and whom
Questions for each insurer you contact:
- Which letters do you sell in my state that are guaranteed to me because my plan is ending?
- What is the monthly premium for each, and how is the policy priced (the pricing method matters over time; see Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained)?
- What date will the policy start if I apply today, and what proof do you need?
- If I am declined, what is the reason in writing?
Questions for a SHIP counselor or the state insurance department:
- Does my state add guaranteed-issue rights beyond the federal ones?
- Is my plan letter list affected by my Medicare eligibility date?
- Which drug plans cover my prescriptions, and what would I pay?
A related walkthrough for people who are already in an Advantage plan that is not ending is I'm in Medicare Advantage and want Medigap. What happens when I apply?.
Key takeaways
- A terminating Advantage plan generally opens a federal guaranteed-issue window for Medigap: it starts as early as 60 days before coverage ends and closes 63 days after.
- Guaranteed issue protects access and health-based pricing, not the price itself; ordinary rating factors can still differ between insurers.
- The federal list names specific plan letters, and eligibility dates after 2020 change which ones exist for you, so confirm the list with a SHIP counselor.
- A stand-alone Part D plan is a separate decision with its own deadline and penalty, and the market for them is shrinking for 2027.
- Several states add their own windows, so check the state insurance department for what applies where you live.