Blog

High-deductible plan or copay plan? Four households, four different answers

Four hypothetical households priced on a high-deductible plan and a copay plan, with an HSA tax-savings line and the reasons the answers differ.

No plan wins for everyone, and the usual reason is arithmetic rather than opinion. A HDHP charges a lower monthly premium and asks you to pay more of your care before it helps. A copay plan charges more each month and takes the sting out of routine visits and prescriptions. Which one costs less over a year depends on how much care a household uses, what kind of care it is, and whether the household takes advantage of a tax-advantaged account.

The four households below are invented, and every figure is a round illustration, not a real premium or plan. They show how the answer changes with the household, and the method for pricing your own is at the end. The amounts are the household's share of the premium, as if the employer or the marketplace credit had already been subtracted.

How the four comparisons work

For each household there are two plans:

  • HDHP: lower premium, a deductible the household pays first, then 20% coinsurance up to an out-of-pocket maximum.
  • Copay plan: higher premium, flat copays for office visits, urgent care, labs and prescriptions, and a smaller deductible that applies to hospital and procedure costs.

For each, the total cost is twelve months of premiums plus what the household pays when it uses care. An "allowed amount" is the plan's negotiated price for a service. Each household's usage is the same on both plans, so only the plan design changes.

The last line of each comparison is a tax line. If a household contributes to a health savings account (HSA), the contribution is generally deductible from federal income, so the line assumes a 22% federal bracket, an invented round figure that ignores state tax and payroll tax. The contribution is not a cost, because the money stays in the household's account for future care, but the tax it avoids is a real reduction in what the year costs. Whether a particular household gets that benefit, and how much, depends on its income and filing status. A tax professional is the person to ask.

Household 1: single and healthy

Say Taylor, 28, rarely sees a doctor and takes no regular medication.

HDHP Copay plan
Monthly premium $250 ($3,000 a year) $400 ($4,800 a year)
Deductible $4,000 $0 for office visits, with a hospital deductible
Out-of-pocket maximum $7,000 $5,000

Taylor has a free preventive checkup, two sick visits (allowed $150 each) and one urgent care visit (allowed $200). That is $500 in allowed charges.

  • HDHP: all $500 falls inside the $4,000 deductible, so Taylor pays $500. Total: $3,000 plus $500 is $3,500.
  • Copay plan: two sick-visit copays of $30 are $60, and an urgent care copay of $75 brings it to $135. Total: $4,800 plus $135 is $4,935.

The HDHP costs $1,435 less. Tax line: if Taylor puts $1,500 into an HSA and the contribution is deductible at 22%, federal tax falls by $330 (1,500 times 0.22). After the tax line, the HDHP year is $3,170, which is $1,765 below the copay plan.

The worst case reverses the order. Premiums plus the maximum are $10,000 on the HDHP ($3,000 plus $7,000) and $9,800 on the copay plan ($4,800 plus $5,000). Taylor wins in most years and is slightly worse off in a year with a catastrophic claim, and the key question is whether Taylor could find $7,000 in that year. Should I pick a high-deductible plan if I can't cover the deductible in cash? looks at that situation.

Household 2: a family with frequent pediatric visits

Say the Nguyen family has two parents and two young children who are always at the pediatrician.

HDHP Copay plan
Monthly premium $1,000 ($12,000 a year) $1,150 ($13,800 a year)
Family deductible $6,000 $2,000, for hospital and procedures
Copays none before the deductible $30 visit, $75 urgent care, $10 generic, $300 emergency room
Out-of-pocket maximum $12,000 $9,000

The premium gap is only $1,800 here, because the family plan's premium difference is smaller than for one person.

A quiet year. Ten sick visits (allowed $150 each, $1,500), two urgent care visits ($200 each, $400) and six generic prescriptions ($20 each, $120). Allowed total: $2,020.

  • HDHP: the family pays $2,020. Total: $12,000 plus $2,020 is $14,020.
  • Copay plan: ten visits at $30 is $300, two urgent care visits at $75 is $150, six prescriptions at $10 is $60. That is $510. Total: $13,800 plus $510 is $14,310.

The HDHP is $290 cheaper in the quiet year.

A year with one big event. Add an emergency room visit for a child's broken arm (allowed $1,200) and an outpatient procedure for ear tubes (allowed $6,000). Allowed total: $9,220.

  • HDHP: the family pays the first $6,000, then 20% of the remaining $3,220, which is $644. Cost sharing is $6,644. Total: $18,644.
  • Copay plan: the usual $510 of copays, a $300 emergency room copay, and for the procedure the $2,000 deductible plus 20% of the remaining $4,000, which is $800, so $2,800. Cost sharing is $510 plus $300 plus $2,800, or $3,610. Total: $17,410.

The copay plan is $1,234 cheaper in the big-event year. If the family puts $3,000 into an HSA, the tax line is $660 (3,000 times 0.22), and the HDHP year drops to $17,984. The copay plan is still $574 ahead.

Both plans here work, and which is cheaper depends on whether the one big event shows up. A family with young children has a better chance than most of at least one such event. The worst-case numbers are $24,000 for the HDHP ($12,000 plus $12,000) and $22,800 for the copay plan ($13,800 plus $9,000).

Household 3: a couple with one regular specialist

Say Sam and Robin, both 45, are mostly healthy, but Robin sees a specialist four times a year and takes one brand-name medicine every month.

HDHP Copay plan
Monthly premium $480 ($5,760 a year) $780 ($9,360 a year)
Deductible (the couple together) $5,000 $0 for visits, labs and drugs listed below
Copays none before the deductible $60 specialist, $20 lab, $300 imaging, $50 brand drug
Out-of-pocket maximum $12,000 $8,000

Robin's year, at allowed amounts: four specialist visits at $250 ($1,000), two lab draws at $200 ($400), one MRI ($1,800) and twelve fills of the brand drug at $200 ($2,400). Allowed total: $5,600.

  • HDHP: the couple pays the $5,000 deductible and 20% of the remaining $600, which is $120. Cost sharing is $5,120. Total: $5,760 plus $5,120 is $10,880.
  • Copay plan: four specialist visits at $60 is $240, two labs at $20 is $40, the MRI at $300 and twelve drug fills at $50 is $600. That is $1,180. Total: $9,360 plus $1,180 is $10,540.

Before any tax effect, the copay plan costs $340 less. Add a $3,000 HSA contribution and the 22% tax line is $660, which brings the HDHP to $10,220, a $320 edge. The answer flips depending on whether the household uses the tax-advantaged account and whether the tax line applies to them.

This is the most sensitive of the four. If Robin's medicine were a generic costing a tenth as much, the HDHP would win comfortably. If the specialist added an infusion or a second imaging test, the HDHP deductible would be met sooner and the HDHP's advantage would shrink, and then the copay plan would win. Also note that Robin's drug is paid in full every month at the start of the year on the HDHP, a cash-flow cost the annual total hides. The deductible vs premium break-even calculator is a way to test variations.

Household 4: empty nesters on three medicines

Say Pat, 58, and Lee, 60, take three regular medicines between them: two generics and one brand-name.

HDHP Copay plan
Monthly premium $700 ($8,400 a year) $1,000 ($12,000 a year)
Deductible (together) $4,000 $0 for visits, labs and drugs listed below
Copays none before the deductible $30 visit, $20 lab, $10 generic, $40 brand drug
Out-of-pocket maximum $10,000 $8,000

Usage and allowed amounts: a generic at $20 a month ($240 for the year), another generic at $30 a month ($360), a brand drug at $450 a month ($5,400), eight doctor visits at $150 ($1,200) and four lab draws at $150 ($600). Allowed total: $7,800.

  • HDHP: $4,000 deductible plus 20% of the remaining $3,800, which is $760. Cost sharing is $4,760. Total: $8,400 plus $4,760 is $13,160.
  • Copay plan: 24 generic fills at $10 is $240, twelve brand fills at $40 is $480, eight visits at $30 is $240, four labs at $20 is $80. That is $1,040. Total: $12,000 plus $1,040 is $13,040.

Before taxes the copay plan is $120 cheaper, close enough to call a tie. The tax line does more work here. Both spouses are 55 or older, and for 2027 the HSA limit is $9,000 for family coverage, plus a $1,000 catch-up contribution for each spouse who is 55 or older and has an account in their own name. Suppose the couple contributes $6,000. The 22% line is $1,320, which makes the HDHP year $11,840 and the HDHP $1,200 cheaper.

Pat and Lee also have a time limit. Contributions to an HSA stop when a person enrolls in Medicare, so the tax advantage has a few years left. HSAs and Medicare: when you must stop contributing covers the timing. The worst-case numbers favor the HDHP in this case: $18,400 ($8,400 plus $10,000) against $20,000 ($12,000 plus $8,000), because the premium gap is larger than the gap between the maximums.

What the four have in common

Look at the pattern across the households.

Household Total on HDHP Total on copay plan Cheaper before the tax line Cheaper after the tax line
1. Single and healthy $3,500 $4,935 HDHP HDHP
2. Family, quiet year $14,020 $14,310 HDHP HDHP
2. Family, one big event $18,644 $17,410 Copay plan Copay plan
3. Couple with a specialist $10,880 $10,540 Copay plan HDHP
4. Empty nesters $13,160 $13,040 Copay plan HDHP

Four things drive the results:

  • The premium gap. It is the HDHP's guaranteed benefit. When the gap is large and usage is small, the HDHP wins.
  • How much of the usage is "predictable" care. Regular prescriptions and visits are what copay plans price well, and an HDHP prices at full cost until the deductible.
  • Whether a big event is likely. The deductible is the cost of the big event on one side; the copay plan's smaller deductible pays off when the event comes.
  • The tax line. It turns several close calls into HDHP wins, but only for a household that can afford to fund the account and whose tax situation makes the deduction real. It is not a reason to choose a plan that the household cannot afford to use.

The reverse is also worth saying plainly. A household that does not use the HSA, or cannot, should price the comparison without the tax line.

What the examples leave out

Real comparisons have wrinkles that these four tables do not show, and any one of them can change a result.

  • An employer contribution to the HSA. Some employers deposit money into the account for people on the high-deductible option. That is a direct reduction in the HDHP's cost, and it can be the deciding factor in a close call such as Household 3.
  • Different networks and drug lists. The two plans may not share the same doctors, hospitals or formulary. A medicine that costs a $40 copay on one plan might be on a higher tier, or not covered, on the other. Check each plan's list before comparing prices.
  • Other coverage in the household. A spouse's general-purpose flexible spending account or a second health plan can make the household ineligible for an HSA, which removes the tax line. Is this plan HSA-eligible? A checklist to verify before you enroll lists the checks.
  • Timing. Household 3's brand drug and Household 4's prescriptions are paid in full early in the year on the HDHP, until the deductible is met, so the cash needed in the first months is higher than the annual average suggests.
  • Usage that changes. A pregnancy, a new diagnosis or a child's injury can turn a quiet-year household into a big-event household with no warning. The point of looking at both is to see how far the totals move.

Price your own household

  1. Write down the premiums for twelve months on each plan, after any employer share or tax credit.
  2. List last year's visits, prescriptions, tests and any procedures, and look up the allowed amounts on the explanation of benefits.
  3. Run those through each plan: copays on the copay plan; deductible, coinsurance and the maximum on the HDHP.
  4. Add a "big event" year, and then compare the worst-case total: premiums plus the out-of-pocket maximum.
  5. Compute the tax line only for contributions you could actually make, using a tax professional's figure rather than the 22% placeholder here.
  6. Check the plan's rules about what is covered before the deductible. I have an HMO, a PPO and an HDHP at work, so how do I pick one? covers the choice when network type is also in play, and Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even and High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) explained: pros and cons cover the general case.

A benefits office or a navigator can help with real plan numbers.

Key takeaways

  • The same plans produce different winners for different households, because premium savings, predictable care and the chance of a big event pull in different directions.
  • A large premium gap and low usage favor the high-deductible plan; steady prescriptions and specialist visits, or a year with one expensive procedure, can favor the copay plan.
  • The tax savings from HSA contributions can tip close comparisons, but only for a household that can fund the account and for whom the deduction applies, which a tax professional can confirm.
  • Compare worst-case totals (premiums plus the out-of-pocket maximum) as well as typical years, since the order can reverse.
  • Test your own numbers with last year's explanations of benefits before you choose.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic