Blog

I have an HMO, a PPO and an HDHP at work, so how do I pick one?

A decision list and one worked comparison for a family of three choosing among three employer plans, with a low, middle and high medical year.

Picture a 34-year-old we will call Dev. He, his spouse and their 4-year-old are healthy most of the time. His employer's open enrollment for plan year 2027 offers three options for the family: an HMO, a PPO and a high-deductible plan with a health savings account. The premiums on the payroll screen point one way and the deductibles point the other. Dev needs a way to decide that does not depend on guessing which plan is "best," because none is best in general.

The method below has two parts: five questions that sort the plans, and a worked comparison that prices each plan in a low, a middle and a high medical year. All plan terms and dollar figures are invented round numbers for illustration, not any real plan's.

What the choice really turns on

Each plan takes a different bet. The HMO usually has a lower premium and a smaller network, and it often asks for a primary care doctor and referrals to specialists. The PPO usually costs more each month and allows more doctors without referrals, including out-of-network ones at a higher cost. The HDHP pairs a lower premium with a high deductible, and it comes with a HSA, a tax-advantaged account for medical costs. The HMO vs PPO vs EPO vs POS: how the four plan types differ and High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) explained: pros and cons guides describe each design in more detail.

The premium is the price of the bet and the out-of-pocket maximum is the limit of the loss. The mistake families make is comparing only one of those two numbers. The guide Higher premium or higher deductible? How to find the break-even frames the trade as paying now or paying later.

Five questions that sort the plans

Answer these before touching a calculator.

  1. How much care will the family use? Count last year's visits, prescriptions and anything scheduled for next year: a planned surgery, pregnancy, therapy or a child's regular specialist. The more predictable care you expect, the more a lower deductible helps, because you will cross it anyway.
  2. Are the doctors in the network? The cheapest plan is not cheap if your child's pediatrician or your spouse's specialist is not in it. Look up each doctor and the hospital in each plan's directory, and then call the doctor's office to confirm, because directories can be out of date. A narrow network can be a good trade for a household with no strong attachments, and a poor one for a household with several.
  3. Are there chronic or high-cost drugs? Look up each drug on each plan's formulary and note the tier and whether the deductible applies first. Some high-deductible plans cover certain preventive drugs before the deductible, and many do not cover other drugs until it is met. A monthly drug that costs $300 matters more than almost any premium difference.
  4. Is there a cash cushion? A high-deductible plan works best when the family could write a check for the full out-of-pocket maximum in a bad year without borrowing. If the answer is no, a plan with a lower maximum is a safer fit even at a higher premium.
  5. What does the employer put in the HSA, and who is eligible? Employer HSA money lowers the true cost of the high-deductible plan. But an HSA requires an HSA-eligible plan, and some other coverage can disqualify you. A spouse with a general-purpose health FSA, for example, can make the whole family ineligible to contribute, which the blog post My spouse has a general-purpose FSA, can I still contribute to my HSA? explains.

The three plans in the example

Say Dev's family of three sees these plan options for 2027. Every number is invented.

Feature HMO PPO HDHP with HSA
Payroll premium, per month $400 $500 $300
Payroll premium, per year $4,800 $6,000 $3,600
Family deductible $1,000 $1,500 $4,000
Coinsurance after the deductible 20% 20% 20%
Family out-of-pocket maximum $6,000 $7,000 $7,500
Employer HSA contribution none none $1,000

To keep the arithmetic readable, the example treats all care as subject to the deductible and 20% coinsurance, and ignores flat copays and the difference between embedded and aggregate family deductibles. Real plans are messier, so the pattern matters more than the exact dollars. The 2027 federal rules for HSA-eligible plans, which this plan would have to meet, require a family deductible of at least $3,500 and an out-of-pocket maximum of no more than $17,400, per IRS figures for 2027, so these invented numbers fit inside them.

One family, three kinds of year

Dev's family will not know its year in advance, so price three: a low year with $1,000 of total allowed charges (a few routine visits), a middle year with $8,000 (a broken wrist and some therapy), and a high year with $40,000 (a hospital stay). "Allowed charges" are the amounts the plan has agreed to count, which can be lower than the sticker price a provider first states.

The HMO

  • Low year, $1,000: the whole amount falls inside the $1,000 deductible, so the family pays $1,000. With the $4,800 premium, the total is $5,800.
  • Middle year, $8,000: the family pays the $1,000 deductible, plus 20% of the remaining $7,000, which is $1,400. That is $2,400. With the premium, the total is $7,200.
  • High year, $40,000: the deductible plus 20% of $39,000 would be $1,000 + $7,800 = $8,800, but the out-of-pocket maximum stops it at $6,000. With the premium, the total is $10,800.

The PPO

  • Low year: $1,000, since it is under the $1,500 deductible. With the $6,000 premium, the total is $7,000.
  • Middle year: $1,500 plus 20% of $6,500, which is $1,300, for $2,800. With the premium, the total is $8,800.
  • High year: $1,500 plus 20% of $38,500 is $1,500 + $7,700 = $9,200, capped at $7,000. With the premium, the total is $13,000.

The HDHP

  • Low year: $1,000, under the $4,000 deductible. With the $3,600 premium, the total is $4,600. The employer put $1,000 in the HSA, which pays that $1,000 bill, so the family's own net cost is $3,600.
  • Middle year: $4,000 plus 20% of $4,000, which is $800, for $4,800. With the premium, the total is $8,400. The employer's $1,000 brings the net cost to $7,400.
  • High year: $4,000 plus 20% of $36,000 is $4,000 + $7,200 = $11,200, capped at $7,500. With the premium, the total is $11,100. After the employer's $1,000, the net cost is $10,100.

Side by side

Year HMO PPO HDHP before HSA seed HDHP net of $1,000 seed
Low ($1,000 of care) $5,800 $7,000 $4,600 $3,600
Middle ($8,000 of care) $7,200 $8,800 $8,400 $7,400
High ($40,000 of care) $10,800 $13,000 $11,100 $10,100

Each figure is the premium plus what the family pays out of pocket. Read the pattern, not the winner. In the low year the HDHP is cheapest by $2,200 against the HMO, because the premium saving and the employer seed are not offset by claims. In the middle year the HMO is cheapest by $200 over the seeded HDHP, because the family crosses the HMO's low deductible and still saves on the premium. In the high year the HDHP is again slightly ahead of the HMO, by $700, because the lower premium offsets the higher maximum. The PPO costs the most in all three years, which is the price of a wide network. Whether that price is worth paying depends on question 2, and the numbers cannot answer it.

How a family deductible behaves

One detail changes how the example would play out in a real plan. Some family plans use an embedded deductible: each person has an individual deductible inside the family one, so a single member who has a bad year stops paying deductible after reaching the individual amount. Others use an aggregate family deductible, where the whole family amount must be met before the plan pays its share for anyone. The summary of benefits states which kind a plan uses, and a high-deductible plan with an aggregate design can feel very different from one with an embedded design when only one person is sick. For a household with a young child who may have most of the claims, ask HR or the insurer which design applies, because it can matter as much as the headline deductible.

What the numbers leave out

The comparison is a sketch. Four real-world details can move the answer.

Tax effects. HSA contributions Dev makes himself are generally deductible or made before tax, and withdrawals for qualified medical costs are tax-free. The 2027 family contribution limit is $9,000 including any employer money, per IRS figures. The size of the tax saving depends on his tax bracket, so it is left out of the table, and a tax professional can estimate it.

Cash timing. In the high year, the HDHP asks for up to $7,500 of the family's own money before the plan stops paying, and the HSA balance may be only the $1,000 seed plus whatever Dev has added. The HMO's maximum is $1,500 lower. If the family could not cover that gap, the HMO is the safer plan.

Network details. An HMO that excludes the child's specialist hospital might force an out-of-network bill, or a change of doctor. The numbers above assume everything stays in network.

Mid-year changes. A birth, a move or a job change can alter the picture, and employer plans usually lock the choice for the year unless a qualifying event allows a change. The What happens if I do nothing at my employer's open enrollment? post explains what happens if you do not choose at all.

A decision list

Use this as a starting point and adjust it with your own numbers. The deductible vs premium break-even calculator and health plan comparison calculator can run the same arithmetic with real figures.

  • If the family expects little care and has a cash cushion for the maximum, then the HDHP is worth a serious look, especially with an employer HSA contribution.
  • If the family expects a predictable middle year (a pregnancy, a planned procedure, regular therapy), then the plan with the lowest deductible and maximum, often the HMO, usually costs less in total.
  • If a doctor or hospital the family relies on is out of the HMO's network but in the PPO's, then the PPO's extra premium may be the price of keeping care you want.
  • If a chronic drug carries a high price and its tier differs across plans, then price the drug in each plan before deciding.
  • If the family could not pay the HDHP's maximum without borrowing, then a lower-maximum plan is the safer choice, even if the premium is higher.
  • If the spouse has a general-purpose health FSA or other coverage that affects HSA eligibility, then settle that before choosing the HDHP.

When to get help

Your employer's benefits office can explain what the summary of benefits says, including how family deductibles work, and it can often tell you whether a doctor is in the network. A tax professional can answer whether you are eligible to contribute to an HSA and how much it would save you. If the family has an ongoing condition, the doctor's office can help you estimate next year's care. And if you cannot get a straight answer on a term, ask for the plan's summary of benefits and coverage, a standard document that lets you compare plans on the same terms; the how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs guide shows how to read it.

Key takeaways

  • Compare premium plus out-of-pocket cost in a low, a middle and a high year, not the premium or the deductible alone.
  • In the example, the HDHP won the low and high years and the HMO won the middle year, while the PPO cost the most in every year, so the right plan depends on how much care you expect.
  • Network and drug coverage can outweigh the arithmetic. Check each doctor, hospital and drug in each plan before deciding.
  • An HDHP is safest for a family that could pay its out-of-pocket maximum from savings and has no HSA eligibility problems.
  • Employer HSA money lowers the true cost of an HDHP, so count it, but count only what the employer has confirmed in writing.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic