Blog

My ICHRA allowance is smaller than the premium, how do I size the gap?

A worksheet that turns an employer allowance and a premium quote into a yearly gap, a worst-case cost and a plan-tier comparison, with blanks for your numbers.

Say your employer gives you $400 a month toward individual coverage, and the plan you like is quoted at $650 for a 45-year-old. The $250 difference is the visible gap, but it is not the whole cost. The plan's deductible, its out-of-pocket maximum, the way your share of the premium is taxed and what the allowance does to your marketplace subsidy all change what the year actually costs. This worksheet works through each piece with invented numbers and leaves blanks for yours. Use round figures and a pencil.

Worksheet part 1: the monthly and yearly gap

The first calculation is arithmetic. Write down three numbers.

Line What goes here Example
A Monthly premium for the plan you are considering $650
B Monthly allowance from your employer $400
C Monthly gap (A minus B) $250
D Yearly gap (C times 12) $3,000

If the allowance is larger than the premium, line C is zero, not negative. Ask your employer whether the unused amount carries over or disappears, because that rule differs by arrangement. The notice from the employer should say. The walkthrough in My employer offered an ICHRA allowance, so how do I shop with it? lists the notice items to look for.

Line D is the amount you pay for the privilege of having the plan before you use any care. It is the baseline. Everything else in this worksheet adds to it.

Worksheet part 2: put the gap beside the worst case

The second calculation adds the worst case for medical spending. Look up the plan's out-of-pocket maximum on its summary of benefits and coverage. This is the most you can be required to pay in a plan year for covered in-network essential health benefits, not counting premiums.

Line What goes here Example
E Plan's out-of-pocket maximum for one person $8,000
F Worst-case year (D plus E) $11,000

In the example the worst-case year is $3,000 plus $8,000, or $11,000. For plan year 2027, the federal ceiling on a single person's out-of-pocket maximum is $12,000, so a plan can set its maximum anywhere up to that figure. The ceiling comes from the January 29, 2026 federal guidance, as of November 2026. Many plans sit below it. The out-of-pocket maximum entry lists what counts toward the limit and what does not.

The worst case is not a prediction. Most people have a year far below it. It is the number to check against your savings. If an $11,000 worst case would force you into debt, a plan with a lower maximum and a bigger gap may be the safer choice.

Worksheet part 3: compare plan tiers

The same $400 allowance buys different things at different levels of coverage. Here is a set of three hypothetical plans for the same 45-year-old in the same county. These are invented illustrations, not quotes.

Plan Monthly premium Monthly gap Yearly gap Deductible Out-of-pocket maximum
Bronze $520 $120 $1,440 $6,000 $9,000
Silver $650 $250 $3,000 $3,500 $7,500
Gold $780 $380 $4,560 $1,500 $5,000

Now compute two yearly totals for each: the worst case, and a light-use year in which you spend $800 on covered care. To keep the example simple, assume the $800 is all subject to the deductible and that the plan has no copays.

Plan Worst case (yearly gap plus maximum) Light-use year (yearly gap plus $800)
Bronze $1,440 + $9,000 = $10,440 $1,440 + $800 = $2,240
Silver $3,000 + $7,500 = $10,500 $3,000 + $800 = $3,800
Gold $4,560 + $5,000 = $9,560 $4,560 + $800 = $5,360

Three observations come out of the arithmetic. First, the cheapest plan in a light year (bronze at $2,240) is not the cheapest in the worst case (gold at $9,560). Second, the worst-case totals are closer together than the premiums suggest, because plans with lower premiums tend to have higher out-of-pocket maximums. Third, a plan with a $6,000 deductible means you pay the full allowed price for nearly everything until you reach it. If you expect regular care, such as ongoing prescriptions or specialist visits, a bronze plan's light-use number may be unrealistic for you.

Fill in your own version. Use line A through F for each plan you are considering, and add a line for your own estimate of expected care. The guide how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan shows how to build that estimate from last year's bills, and the health plan comparison calculator does the arithmetic for you.

Metal levels describe how the plan splits costs on average, with bronze plans paying about 60% of average costs and gold plans about 80%. They do not tell you your own total. bronze, silver, gold and platinum plans: what the metal levels mean explains what the labels mean.

Worksheet part 4: how your share of the premium is taxed

This is the piece that surprises people. In a typical employer group plan, your share of the premium comes out of your paycheck before income tax and payroll tax, under what is called a cafeteria plan. That makes a $250 monthly payroll deduction cost you less than $250 in take-home pay.

With an individual-coverage arrangement, the allowance reimbursement is generally tax-free, according to the federal description of the arrangement. But the part of the premium above the allowance is generally paid out of income you have already been taxed on, unless your employer's setup lets you pay it through a pretax payroll deduction. Ask the benefits office. Some employers allow it and some do not.

An illustration with a round, invented tax rate shows the size of the effect. Assume that a dollar of pay loses 25 cents to federal income tax and payroll taxes combined.

Line Pretax payroll deduction After-tax payment
Gap per month $250 $250
Take-home cost per month $250 x (1 - 0.25) = $187.50 $250.00
Take-home cost per year $2,250 $3,000
Difference per year $750

The assumed 25% is not anyone's actual rate. Your rate depends on your income, your filing status and your state. A lower combined rate shrinks the difference, and a state income tax would widen it. A tax professional can give you the real number.

The takeaway for the worksheet: if your employer lets you pay the gap pretax, your real cost is lower than line D. If it does not, line D is about right. Either way, compare an allowance against a group plan on take-home cost, not on the sticker amounts. The ICHRA vs group plan cost calculator does that comparison.

Worksheet part 5: the family version

Family coverage changes the arithmetic in two ways: the premium is larger, and the allowance may or may not rise to match. Here is a hypothetical household of four with invented numbers.

Line What goes here Example
G Monthly premium for family plan $1,850
H Monthly allowance for employee and dependents $900
I Monthly gap (G minus H) $950
J Yearly gap (I times 12) $11,400

The family's gap is large, and so is the out-of-pocket maximum, which for plan year 2027 may be as high as $24,000 for a family under the federal ceiling. A family might then compare this to the employer's group plan, where the employee share for family coverage could be much smaller, or to coverage through a spouse's job.

Two rules to check with HR. First, does the allowance increase for each dependent, and by how much? Some employers pay a flat amount per employee, some pay a larger amount for the family, and some pay per person. Second, are the children's premiums priced separately? Individual plans price each covered child separately, with a cap on how many children's premiums count, and the details vary by state and plan. Ask a navigator or look at the quote.

Worksheet part 6: age and where you live

Individual-market premiums vary with age. Under federal rules, a plan's price for the oldest adult can be at most three times the price for the youngest adult, so a 55-year-old's premium for the same plan may be noticeably higher than a 45-year-old's. If your employer offers a flat allowance regardless of age, the gap grows as you get older. If the allowance is tied to age, the gap may stay roughly steady. Ask which.

Premiums also vary by county and by the plans offered there. Your coworkers in another city may face a different gap for the same allowance. Do not compare numbers with them as if they should match. The post Why does the same marketplace plan cost different amounts by age and ZIP code? explains the main factors.

Look a year or two ahead as well: the premium for the same plan can rise with the plan's yearly rate changes, with your next birthday adding to it. For plan year 2027, KFF reported that the average benchmark silver premium rises about 13% over 2026, and the median proposed increase across insurers was 15% as of August 2026. Your plan's actual change will differ. Use these as a reminder that the gap can grow even if the allowance stays flat, since an allowance that does not grow with premiums shrinks in relative terms.

Worksheet part 7: what the allowance does to marketplace credits

Last, the piece worksheets usually skip because it cannot be solved with arithmetic alone. Whether you can receive a marketplace premium tax credit while you have an allowance depends on how the rules classify the offer, which in turn depends on the allowance, the lowest-cost silver plan's price in your area, and your household income.

The way to approach it is to ask three questions:

  1. Does the arrangement count as an affordable offer for me? The test compares what you would pay out of pocket for a benchmark-type plan after the allowance against a percentage of your household income. For employer coverage the IRS set the required percentage at 10.22% for 2027. How it applies to allowances is for a tax professional or navigator to work through.
  2. If I accept the allowance, can I also claim a credit? In general, the two do not stack, but the specifics are not something to guess at.
  3. If I decline, what do I give up and what might I gain? Declining the allowance gives up the money. Whether it makes you eligible for a credit depends on the answer to the first question.

The consequences are real. Starting with tax year 2026, excess advance credit must be repaid in full, with no income-based cap, under Public Law 119-21, section 71305, as of November 2026. A wrong guess about your credit can show up at tax time. How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share describes the credit's mechanics, and a marketplace navigator can run your case at no charge.

Putting the worksheet together

Take the results to a single page:

  1. For each plan under consideration, write the yearly gap (line D).
  2. Add the worst-case total (line F).
  3. Add your estimated light-use and expected-use totals.
  4. Adjust for pretax payment if your employer allows it.
  5. Add a note on what the arrangement means for your marketplace credit, from the navigator or tax professional.
  6. Check the network and the drug list for each plan before you decide.

A plan is not good because its gap is small. A plan is good for you if the total cost, in a year you may or may not have a hospital stay, is one you can afford, and if your doctors and medications are covered. The employer who offers an allowance generally cannot tell you which plan to choose, and neither can this worksheet. It can show you what each choice costs, which is the part that is arithmetic.

Key takeaways

  • The gap is the monthly premium minus the allowance, times 12, and it is the cost of holding the plan before any care is used.
  • Add the plan's out-of-pocket maximum to the yearly gap to see the worst-case year, which can rank plans differently than premiums do.
  • A gap paid with after-tax money costs more in take-home pay than the same gap paid through a pretax payroll deduction, so ask whether your employer allows the pretax route.
  • Family allowances, age and location can move the gap by thousands of dollars, so check each against your own quote.
  • Whether an allowance affects your marketplace credit is a question for a navigator or tax professional, and a wrong guess can mean repaying credit in full at tax time.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic