Blog
Marketplace open enrollment: the questions people ask in the first week
Twelve questions from the first week of open enrollment, from whether you must reapply to why a price differs from the quote, answered from how the rules work.
The first week of open enrollment produces the same dozen questions every year, and this year they come with a twist: the price on the screen is probably higher than last year's, and some people see a plan that has been renamed, replaced or withdrawn. The answers below are written as of November 2026 for plan year 2027 coverage. Dates and rules at this speed can change, so the state marketplace or HealthCare.gov is the final word on your deadline.
The dates people ask about
| Marketplace | Open enrollment for 2027 coverage | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| HealthCare.gov (federal platform) | November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027 | Enroll by December 15 for coverage on January 1; later enrollment generally starts February 1 |
| Idaho | October 15 to December 15, 2026 | The only state-based marketplace whose window ends in 2026 |
| Connecticut | October 23, 2026 to January 15, 2027 | |
| Massachusetts | October 23, 2026 to January 23, 2027 | |
| California, D.C., New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island | Ends January 31, 2027 | |
| Virginia | Ends January 29, 2027 |
The state dates come from a secondary compilation and are not exhaustive; confirm on your state's marketplace. The federal January 15 end date reflects a court ruling in June 2026 that vacated a rule which would have shortened the window to December 15; HHS appealed, and as of the reports available in November 2026 no appellate outcome had been published. Check HealthCare.gov for the current dates rather than relying on this paragraph.
Staying, switching and missing the deadline
Do I have to reapply if I already have a plan?
Not necessarily. If you do nothing, most people with a marketplace plan are automatically re-enrolled in the same plan or a similar one from the same insurer for 2027. That is automatic re-enrollment. Re-enrollment is a convenience with traps:
- The premium on the renewal is not last year's premium. Almost every plan got more expensive.
- The credit attached to it is recalculated from the income your account shows, which may be a year old.
- The plan you are renewed into may have a different deductible, drug list or network, and in some cases it replaces a plan that is being discontinued. The practice of moving bronze enrollees automatically into silver is reported to be unavailable for 2027, so a bronze plan is generally not upgraded for you.
The renewal notice from your insurer and the marketplace is the place to read the new numbers. Reading my marketplace auto-renewal notice line by line before December 15 goes through one section by section. Updating your application takes ten minutes and can change what you pay by hundreds of dollars.
When does open enrollment actually end for me?
It depends on where you live and when you want coverage to start. On HealthCare.gov the window runs to January 15, 2027, but the date that protects a January 1 start is December 15. Many state-based marketplaces end later, and a few have an earlier cutoff for January 1 coverage, such as December 23 in Massachusetts. Use your state's own site, or the open enrollment dates and coverage start calculator, and look for two dates: the last day to pick a plan for January 1, and the last day to enroll at all.
What happens if I miss December 15?
On HealthCare.gov, enrolling between December 16 and January 15 generally means coverage starts February 1, which leaves January uncovered. On a state marketplace the cutoff for a January 1 start may be later or earlier, and it is stated on the state's site. After the window ends entirely, you need a special enrollment period, and "I forgot" is not one. Missed open enrollment? Your options for getting covered lists what is and is not accepted, and What can go wrong if I wait until the last day of open enrollment? covers the errors that make people miss even when they tried.
A month without coverage is a month of full prices if care is needed. No federal penalty applies, though a few states have their own mandates; is there still a penalty for not having health insurance? explains.
Can I change my pick after I choose a plan?
Yes, during open enrollment. Until the deadline for the coverage start date you want, you can go back, pick a different plan and the last selection before the deadline is the one that counts. After that deadline, a change generally pushes the start date later. The confirmation screen shows the effective date of the plan you just chose; read it before you click through.
Two cautions. First, your coverage does not exist until you pay the first month's premium to the insurer, so a plan chosen but not paid for is not a plan. Second, switching insurers changes the network and often the drug list, and the deductible starts fresh with the new insurer. If you have already met part of your 2026 deductible, that progress does not follow you into a new year anyway, because deductibles reset each January.
Can I cancel if I no longer want the plan?
Yes. You can end marketplace coverage at any time, and you should do it deliberately rather than by ignoring the bills. If you were auto-re-enrolled into a plan with advance credits and you decide not to keep it, tell the marketplace so advance payments stop. Credits paid on your behalf are reconciled on your tax return. Starting with tax year 2026 the cap on repaying excess advance credit is gone, so credits paid for months you did not intend to be covered can come back at tax time.
Ending coverage also has consequences for later: you cannot generally re-enroll outside a window unless you qualify for a special enrollment period. A navigator can tell you whether a cheaper plan, not no plan, is the better move.
Prices and quotes
Why is my price different from the quote I saw earlier?
There are five common causes, and they stack:
- The plan's price went up. KFF reported in November 2026 that the average benchmark silver premium rises about 13% for 2027, after about 26% for 2026, and 11 insurers announced they were leaving at least one state's marketplace for 2027. Prices are different in every county.
- The credit changed. The 2027 table asks households to pay between 2.15% and 10.22% of income toward the benchmark plan, versus 2.10% to 9.96% in 2026. The enhanced credits that capped contributions at 8.5% of income expired on December 31, 2025, and no law restores them for 2027 as of November 2026.
- Your income estimate changed. A quote based on your old application is not the quote based on a new one.
- The household changed. Adding or removing a person changes the poverty-level math. who counts as part of my household on a marketplace application? explains who counts.
- The quote was for a different person. A window-shopping estimate that assumes a 40-year-old and no tobacco use is not your price.
If the price still seems wrong, compare the "premium before credit" and "credit" lines separately. A plan can cost more and still cost you about the same if the credit is larger.
Do I need an account to browse plans?
No. HealthCare.gov and most state marketplaces let you preview plans and prices by entering a ZIP code, ages and an income estimate without creating an account. The preview is an estimate and it cannot enroll you. An account is needed to apply, get an eligibility determination and pick a plan. Creating one does not commit you to buying anything.
The application
What does a new application ask for?
A first-time application asks for household members and how they file taxes, an estimate of the year's income (see modified adjusted gross income and Marketplace income estimate worksheet: what counts as MAGI and what does not), Social Security numbers or immigration documents for people who want coverage, whether anyone has an offer of employer coverage and at what cost, whether anyone is pregnant, and other coverage in the household. Having a recent pay stub and last year's tax return in front of you saves a session.
Some people are asked to send proof after applying, for example of income or immigration status. The marketplace sets a deadline; missing it can end the credit. Answer promptly.
My income changes month to month. What do I put?
The estimate is for the whole calendar year 2027, not a month. A salaried employee uses the expected annual wage. Someone with irregular income, a freelancer or a seasonal worker, estimates a total, updates it when it changes and keeps records. The repayment rule matters: from tax year 2026 any excess advance credit must be repaid in full, and there is still no credit above 400% of the poverty level. For 2027 coverage, 400% is $63,840 for one person and $132,000 for a family of four. Being slightly above that line can cost the whole credit, so an honest, careful estimate is worth more effort than a guess.
My plan was discontinued. What do I do?
The insurer notifies you, and the marketplace maps you to a replacement, which may be from a different company. Some insurers are leaving states altogether: KFF counted 11 insurers announcing exits from at least one state's marketplace for 2027, including Cigna leaving the individual market in the 11 states where it participated. You are not obligated to take the mapped plan. Compare it with at least two others, check that your doctors and drugs are covered, and pick before the deadline. how to enroll in marketplace coverage, step by step has the steps.
Paying and getting help
Do I have to pay the first premium right away?
Yes. The marketplace picks you a plan, but your coverage starts when the insurer has your first payment, and the insurer sets the due date. A common failure is that a person selects a plan on December 14 and assumes it is done. If the first payment does not arrive, coverage does not start, and the January 1 date is lost. The insurer should send an invoice or a payment link. If nothing arrives within a few days of selecting a plan, call the insurer using the number on its own website and confirm.
Someone called me about my plan. Is that real?
Be careful. In September 2026 CMS reported canceling about 315,000 unauthorized enrollments covering more than 760,000 people, and it has frozen new broker registrations on the federal platform until February 2027. Real brokers exist and help many people, but you should never give a Social Security number or payment details to an unsolicited caller, and you should never let anyone enroll you without your explicit consent. If you find a plan you did not choose in your account, someone changed my marketplace plan or enrolled me without consent: what now? explains how to respond.
Where can I get free help?
Marketplace navigators and certified application counselors are not paid by insurers and do not charge you. They are listed on HealthCare.gov and on your state marketplace's site. Licensed brokers can also help; they are usually paid by insurers rather than by you, so ask which companies and plans they can show you. how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator covers the difference. For Medicare questions, a SHIP counselor is the equivalent, but that is a different enrollment period.
What to do, in order
- Look at your renewal notice and compare it with last year's.
- Update the application: household, income for 2027, other coverage.
- Compare at least three plans on total cost, not premium alone, using the out-of-pocket maximum. For 2027 the legal ceiling on that maximum is $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family, and many plans are lower.
- Check that your doctors, hospital and prescriptions are in the plan.
- Pick a plan, pay the first premium and confirm the start date.
- Save the confirmation and the plan's documents.
Key takeaways
- Do nothing and you are likely re-enrolled, at a higher price, with a credit based on whatever your application last said.
- The dates differ by marketplace: on HealthCare.gov, December 15 protects a January 1 start and January 15 is the last day; state marketplaces vary.
- Your coverage starts only after you pay the first premium, so selecting a plan is not the finish line.
- Quotes differ because of plan prices, the credit schedule, your income estimate, household and age.
- Free help comes from navigators and counselors; be wary of unsolicited calls and keep control of your own enrollment.