Blog
Someone changed my marketplace plan or enrolled me without consent: what now?
Steps when a marketplace plan appears that you never chose or a broker changed yours: check the account, report it, keep records, and handle Form 1095-A.
A letter from an insurer you do not remember dealing with says your coverage is active. Or your own plan has a different name than it did last month, and you never agreed to the change. Or a tax form arrives for marketplace coverage you did not use. Each of these has happened to real people, and federal officials have said that it happened on a large scale.
This playbook is for a reader who finds a marketplace plan they did not choose or a change they did not approve. It lists the steps in order, with what to say, what to keep and what each office can and cannot do. Facts about recent federal actions are stated as of November 2026 and come from CMS and KFF.
What happened, and what is known
Marketplace enrollment can occur through the marketplace website, through a phone call to the marketplace, through an insurer's site, or through a licensed agent or broker who is registered to enroll people on the federal platform. Most of this is legitimate and useful. The problem arises when an agent, or someone posing as one, enrolls or changes a plan without the consumer's knowledge, sometimes to collect commissions, and the federal government pays an advance premium tax credit to the insurer on the person's behalf. The guide how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it lists the warning signs.
CMS has described the problem. According to a September 22, 2026 CMS release, the agency canceled about 315,000 unauthorized enrollments covering more than 760,000 people, with about $2.2 billion in subsidies to be recovered. It said it had sent termination notices to more than 200 agents and brokers since January 2026, plus 569 notices of intent to terminate that summer, froze new broker registration for 2027 through an interim final rule, and is re-identity-proofing all agents. KFF reported on November 6, 2026 that the cancellations were of enrollments HHS called "phantom," meaning signed up without the person's knowledge, that HHS sent insurers a list of about 1.2 million enrollments for review, that some canceled enrollees were reinstated, and that the freeze on registering new agents on the federal platform runs until February 2027.
On November 16, 2026, CMS proposed a further rule, called CRUSH (CMS-6098-P). It would restrict marketplace access for agents and brokers with certain felony convictions or exclusions, allow immediate suspension on credible allegations of abusive conduct, and require safeguards against marketplace access from outside the United States, including through virtual private networks. Comments are due January 19, 2027. It is a proposal, so nothing in it is in effect yet.
None of this tells you whether your own enrollment was unauthorized. Only the marketplace's records can. The steps below find out.
Three ways it can look
- A plan you never chose. You have no memory of applying, but there is an active plan or an insurer's welcome packet in your name.
- A change you never approved. You enrolled yourself or through a broker you trust, and later your plan, your income, your household or your agent of record was changed.
- A mismatch. You enrolled with a broker, but the plan or credit differs from what you agreed to, or the household includes people who are not yours.
The first steps are the same. The steps diverge when you decide what you want to happen to the coverage.
Step 1: Check the account before you call anyone
Log in to your HealthCare.gov or state exchange account, or create one if you do not have one, and look at the current application. In particular:
- The plan and the insurer, with the start date and whether it is active or terminated.
- The household, including the names, ages and the income listed.
- The advance credit that is being paid each month.
- The agent or broker of record, if the account shows one, with a name and a number.
- The contact information. If the email address or phone number is not yours, someone changed it.
Take screenshots or print the pages, with the date visible. Check your mail and your email, including the spam folder, for letters from an insurer or the marketplace dated since you last used the account.
If you cannot log in, because the password was reset or the email was changed, tell the marketplace when you call. That is itself evidence.
Step 2: Decide what you want
The right response depends on the goal, and it is worth deciding before you call.
- You did not want the coverage and have not used it. You want it ended and, if possible, treated as unauthorized.
- You did not choose this plan but you want coverage. You may want to keep a plan, change to a different one, or be reinstated in a plan you had before.
- You used the coverage (a visit or a prescription) and are not sure it is a mistake. Be careful. Ending a policy retroactively can affect claims, so ask about this before you request cancellation.
Step 3: Call the marketplace
Use the number on HealthCare.gov or on your state exchange's website, not a number from a letter or a text message. Say that you are reporting an enrollment or a change that you did not authorize. Ask for:
- the date of the enrollment or change, and the way it was made (online, phone or through an agent)
- the name or identifier of the agent or broker of record, if any
- to have the enrollment cancelled or the change reversed, and whether a case or complaint number is assigned
- a plain statement of whether a special enrollment period or other path exists for you to get the coverage you want
- how and when you will get written confirmation
Write down the date, the time, the name of the person you spoke with and the reference number. If you are told to wait, ask how long, and call back.
If you are in a state with its own exchange, call that exchange. If you are not sure which one applies to you, the state marketplace, regulator and help lookup and the guide how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help can help.
Step 4: Report the agent or broker
If a broker was involved, report them. The marketplace can take reports about agents and brokers and has said it terminates those it finds abusing the system, as the figures above show. The state insurance department licenses agents, so it can investigate and take action on a license. A complaint to both is reasonable. The guide how to file a complaint with your state insurance department shows how to file one.
Include in the complaint:
- your name, your account and your plan details
- the agent's name and license number, if you have them
- what you did not authorize, and when you found out
- copies of what you saved
If you worked with a broker you trust and the issue was a mistake rather than fraud, say so. A change may have been made in error, and the marketplace may still need the report to fix it.
Step 5: Contact the insurer
The insurer holds a policy in your name, so contact it too. Ask:
- whether it shows the plan as active, and since when
- whether any premium has been paid, and by whom
- whether any claims have been processed
- how to terminate the policy, with an effective date as the date it began if it was unauthorized
- how to get written confirmation, and a corrected record
Do not pay a premium on a plan you do not want, and do not agree to an automatic payment. If the insurer is billing you, tell it that the enrollment is being disputed with the marketplace, and ask it to hold the bill while the dispute is open.
Step 6: Keep the records
Create a folder. Put in it:
- screenshots of the account before and after any change
- letters, emails and texts, including envelopes with postmarks
- notes of every call with dates, names and reference numbers
- copies of every complaint you file and any replies
If the situation involved someone who used your personal information, also consider the steps for identity theft, such as a fraud alert or a credit freeze, and the FTC's identity theft reporting process. The guide how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator explains how to find someone legitimate for the next time you enroll.
Step 7: Check Form 1095-A and the tax effect
After the year ends, the marketplace sends a Form 1095-A for coverage that was in your name. It lists the months of coverage, the premium and the advance credit that was paid. If you were enrolled without your consent, the form may show coverage and credits that you did not authorize or use.
What to do:
- Compare the form to what you know. Check the months, the people and the amounts; the post Form 1095-A walkthrough: what each box means and how to use it at tax time explains each box. A form for a policy you never had is a sign that the problem is not resolved.
- Ask the marketplace for a corrected form, and tell it why.
- Tell your tax preparer or a tax professional about the unauthorized enrollment before you file. Do not guess about how to report it. Whether and how an unauthorized advance credit is reconciled on Form 8962 (see premium tax credit reconciliation) is a question for a tax professional, and perhaps the IRS.
- Know the stakes. Beginning with tax year 2026, excess advance credit must be repaid in full under Public Law 119-21, with no income-based cap. That is a reason to resolve the matter early. The guide Repaying excess premium tax credits: reconciliation and Form 8962 explains the rule.
Keep the confirmation of cancellation with your tax records.
What each office can and cannot do
| Office | Can | Cannot |
|---|---|---|
| The marketplace | Look up the enrollment, cancel it, investigate the agent, correct records, tell you about a special enrollment period | Guarantee reinstatement or a refund, or give tax advice |
| The insurer | Confirm the policy, terminate it, answer billing and claims questions | Change the marketplace's eligibility decision |
| The state insurance department | Take a complaint, investigate and discipline a licensed agent, help with an insurer's conduct | Cancel a federal marketplace enrollment itself |
| A navigator | Help you through the account and the calls, at no charge | Act as your lawyer or tax professional |
| A tax professional | Advise on Form 1095-A and Form 8962 | Change the marketplace's records |
If you need coverage now
A cancellation can leave you without coverage. Open enrollment for plan year 2027 runs through January 15, 2027 on HealthCare.gov, with state-run marketplaces setting their own windows, and a plan chosen by December 15 begins January 1. For coverage in the current year, ask the marketplace whether you qualify for a special enrollment period, and ask for the answer in writing. The post How do I tell a real marketplace broker or enrollment site from a scam? helps you pick a legitimate source of help for the new enrollment. Use a navigator, the marketplace itself, or a broker you can verify with your state insurance department, and never give a stranger who contacts you your Social Security number or bank details.
Key takeaways
- Check the account first, screenshot it, and note the agent of record and the contact details on file.
- Call the marketplace on the number from HealthCare.gov or your state exchange, report the enrollment as unauthorized, and write down the reference number.
- Report the agent to the marketplace and to the state insurance department, which licenses agents and can act on a complaint.
- Contact the insurer, do not pay for a plan you did not choose, and keep every record.
- Ask for a corrected Form 1095-A and tell a tax professional before filing, because excess advance credit must be repaid in full starting with tax year 2026.