Blog
A broker switched my marketplace plan without asking. What do I do now?
Steps as of November 2026: confirm the change, protect your care, get reinstated, report the agent and guard against a subsidy repayment problem at tax time.
If a new insurance card arrives for a plan you did not pick, or a bill shows a premium you did not agree to, treat it as a problem to fix now, not at tax time. Marketplace plans can be changed or started by an agent or broker who is authorized to act for you, and in some cases by someone who is not acting in your interest. The steps below are in the order that tends to protect your coverage first, your money second and your tax return third.
This walkthrough is current as of November 16, 2026, and enforcement in this area is moving. It rests on what federal officials have announced, and it is not a statement about any particular agent or company. For what is current, check HealthCare.gov or your state's exchange and the CMS newsroom, and ask a navigator.
What has been announced
Three facts frame this, each with its date.
- September 22, 2026. CMS announced it had canceled about 315,000 unauthorized enrollments covering more than 760,000 people, with about $2.2 billion in subsidies to be recovered. It also said it had sent termination notices to more than 200 agents and brokers since January 2026, plus 569 notices of intent to terminate that summer, and was re-identity-proofing all agents. It froze registration of new agents and brokers on the federal platform for 2027 through an interim final rule, a pause that KFF reported runs until February 2027.
- Also in September 2026, KFF reported that HHS sent insurers a list of about 1.2 million enrollments for review, and that some of the people whose enrollments were canceled were later reinstated.
- November 16, 2026. CMS proposed a rule it calls CRUSH, which would restrict marketplace access for agents and brokers with certain felony convictions or exclusions, allow immediate suspension for credible allegations of abusive conduct, and require safeguards against marketplace access from outside the United States. Comments are due January 19, 2027. It is a proposal, and this post does not predict what will happen to it.
Those figures describe enrollments made without a person's knowledge. A change of plan by an agent is a related problem, and the same channels apply. If you were enrolled or switched without authorization, you are not alone, and the agencies already have a process for reports.
Step 1: confirm what actually happened
Before calling anyone, collect the facts.
- Log in to your own account on HealthCare.gov or your state exchange. Use the website address you typed yourself, not a link from a text or email. Look at the current plan, the monthly premium, the advance premium tax credit amount, the start date and the date of the last change. The application may also show an agent or broker; if it does not, the Marketplace can tell you who the agent of record is.
- Compare with what you chose. Do you recognize the plan, the insurer, the household members listed, the income and the tax credit? Note every difference.
- Check your old plan. Log in to the old insurer's portal or call it, and ask whether the plan is still active and until what date.
- Check the new plan. Ask the new insurer for the effective date, the premium due and whether any payment has been taken from you.
- Look at your mail and bank account for cards, welcome letters, bills and any withdrawals.
Signs that fit the pattern: a card from an insurer you never contacted, a different premium, doctors who are no longer in the network, a pharmacy that says your drugs are not covered under the plan on file, or a plan you thought you canceled still appearing.
Step 2: protect your care today
Coverage questions should not delay treatment. Until the Marketplace sorts this out:
- Before a scheduled appointment, prescription pickup or procedure, call the doctor's billing office and the pharmacy and ask which plan they show as active. If the plan on file is wrong, ask what they will accept while the question is open.
- Ask the insurer in writing whether a claim submitted now would be paid, and keep the answer.
- If you need emergency care, get it. Emergency departments treat first, and billing can be sorted out later.
Step 3: contact the Marketplace and ask to be reinstated
For a HealthCare.gov plan, call the Marketplace Call Center using the number on HealthCare.gov. For a state-based exchange, use the number on its official site. When you reach someone:
- Say it plainly: you did not authorize this change, and you want it reversed. If your plan was changed by an agent, name the agent if you know it.
- Ask to be reinstated in the plan you intended, starting from the date of the unauthorized change, with the same premium tax credit that applied to your real information.
- Ask whether the situation qualifies for a special enrollment period if the change is outside open enrollment. Open enrollment for plan year 2027 runs November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027, with coverage starting January 1 if you act by December 15. Outside that window, a special enrollment period usually requires a qualifying life event, so ask directly how the Marketplace treats agent errors or misconduct. See special enrollment period.
- Ask that the agent be removed from your application and that no agent be authorized to act for you unless you say so.
- Get a reference number, the representative's name or ID, and the date and time. Ask for a written confirmation to be sent to you.
- Ask what the appeal route is if the Marketplace refuses. There are marketplace appeal rights, and the representative or a navigator can explain how to file.
If the line is busy or the call goes poorly, call again and keep a log. A free navigator can sometimes escalate a case, and how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help shows where to find one.
Step 4: deal with both insurers
- The new insurer. Tell it that you did not enroll. Ask it to cancel the policy from the start date and to refund any premium taken. Ask for the cancellation in writing.
- The old insurer. Ask whether the old coverage was ended, whether it can be reinstated without a gap, and how claims for the period in between will be handled. The answer may depend on the Marketplace, so do this alongside Step 3.
- Claims in the gap. If you went to the doctor during the period, ask both insurers who processed the claims and whether anything needs to be resubmitted.
An invented example of the money: say Rosa, 52, had a plan with a $720 monthly gross premium, minus a $600 tax credit, for a $120 payment. In August an agent switched her to a plan with a gross premium of $1,000. The tax credit, based on a benchmark plan and her income, stays at $600, so her payment becomes $400. She did not notice for three months. The difference of $280 a month for August, September and October comes to $840, which she asks the new insurer to refund or the Marketplace to credit.
Step 5: document everything
Keep a single folder, paper or digital:
- A dated log of every call: the number, the name or ID, what was said, the reference number.
- Screenshots of the account pages showing the plan, the premium, the tax credit and any agent name, with dates visible.
- Every letter, card, bill and email from the new insurer and the Marketplace.
- Bank records of any payments.
- The same for the old insurer.
This record is what a navigator, a state regulator and, if it comes to it, a tax professional or lawyer will ask you for first.
Step 6: report the agent
Reporting does two things: it can protect other people, and it puts your account on record.
- The state insurance department. It licenses agents and takes complaints about them and about insurers. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department describes what to include. Give the agent's name, the license number if you have it, the dates and what you were told.
- The Marketplace. When you call to be reinstated, ask how to report suspected agent or broker misconduct. For federal programs the Marketplace has a channel for it.
- The agent's agency or the sellers' call center, if you know it, in writing.
Where do I report health insurance fraud, and which agency takes which kind? explains which agency handles which kind of report. A complaint does not guarantee a particular outcome, and the agencies cannot give you legal advice. If the amounts are large, a consumer lawyer can tell you about your options.
If you want a sense of what legitimate brokers look like, see How do I tell a real marketplace broker or enrollment site from a scam? and how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator.
Step 7: protect your tax return
This is the step people skip, and the consequences arrive months later.
A premium tax credit is paid in advance to your insurer on your behalf, based on your estimated income and household. When you file your tax return, you reconcile the advance payments with what you were actually entitled to. The Form 1095-A you receive from the Marketplace shows what was paid. Starting with tax year 2026, there is no cap on how much excess advance credit you must repay; all of it is repayable regardless of income. That makes accuracy more important.
If an agent changed your application, check three things: the income estimate, the household members and the tax credit amount. An invented example: Rosa's real income estimate is $48,000, and the agent entered $30,000, which raised the credit from $600 to $850 a month. Over six months that is $250 times 6, which equals $1,500 of excess credit paid for her. If the application is not corrected, she may owe that back at filing, in addition to the other problems.
What to do:
- Ask the Marketplace to correct the application and the credit amounts, and to confirm in writing which months of enrollment are valid.
- When the January mailing arrives, compare the 1095-A with your records and your log. If it is wrong, ask for a corrected form before you file. My 1095-A lists a marketplace plan I never bought. What do I do? covers the case where the form lists a plan you never held.
- Do not file with a form you know is wrong and hope it sorts itself out. Explain the situation to a tax professional, who can tell you how to report it and what to attach. The guide on Repaying excess premium tax credits: reconciliation and Form 8962 describes the repayment rules in general, and premium tax credit reconciliation explains the process.
- Keep the proof that the enrollment or the change was unauthorized.
Step 8: guard against it happening again
- Tell the Marketplace you do not authorize any agent to make changes without your consent, if that option is available to you.
- Use a unique password for your marketplace account and do not give your login or your Social Security number to anyone who calls you.
- Do not read your application details aloud to a stranger who calls offering to "update" your plan.
- At renewal, log in during November or December and check the plan, the premium and the credit before the window ends on December 15, or January 15 for a February start.
- Open your mail from insurers and the Marketplace, even the pieces that look routine.
Where to get help
A free navigator or a state exchange's assisters can walk through your account with you. A licensed tax professional can advise on the 1095-A and reconciliation. The state insurance department handles complaints about agents and insurers. A consumer lawyer can advise if there is a financial loss that is not resolved. For the larger picture of scams aimed at enrollees, see how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it.
Key takeaways
- Confirm what changed by logging in to your own marketplace account, then call the Marketplace or state exchange and ask to be reinstated from the date of the unauthorized change.
- Keep a dated log of every call and screenshot of every page; the paper trail supports every later step.
- Report the agent to the state insurance department and ask the Marketplace how to report misconduct; federal officials announced large-scale cancellations and agent terminations in September 2026.
- Check the income, household and tax credit on the application, because for tax year 2026 and later excess advance credit must be repaid in full.
- Compare the January 1095-A with your records and see a tax professional before filing if it is wrong.