Blog
How do I tell a real marketplace broker or enrollment site from a scam?
A checklist of red flags and verification steps for calls, texts and ads promising free or cheap coverage, plus a short script for what to say on the phone.
Picture a hypothetical Tuesday evening in November. A text arrives from a number you do not recognize: "Your government health subsidy is waiting. Claim your $0 plan before Friday." A minute later a banner ad with a flag on it promises the same thing. Open enrollment is under way, you did want to look at coverage, and the message sounds almost official. The question is how to tell, in about five minutes and without any special expertise, whether this is a real licensed broker, a real enrollment site, or a scam.
This checklist is built for that moment. It is grouped by the thing you can check, and each item comes with the reason it matters, so you can apply the logic to a pitch that looks different from the examples. The last sections give a script for a phone call and the steps to take if you already handed something over.
Why these pitches work
Real health insurance enrollment is confusing enough that a confident stranger can sound helpful. Real licensed brokers do call and advertise. Real navigators do offer free help. Real government sites do send notices. A scammer borrows all of that: the flag, the word "subsidy," the urgency of a deadline that really exists somewhere in the process.
Scams in this area tend to fall into three families. Some collect personal information (Social Security number, date of birth, bank details) to commit identity theft. Some collect money for a "plan" that is not insurance at all, such as a discount card or a membership. And some enroll you in a real marketplace plan without your informed consent, or switch your plan, to earn a commission. The scam guide describes the families in general; this post is about the live decision in front of you. The glossary entry on a health insurance scam gives the short definition.
As of November 2026, federal officials have said unauthorized enrollment is a real problem, not a hypothetical one. According to a KFF analysis dated November 6, 2026, HHS cancelled about 760,000 enrollments in September 2026 that it described as "phantom," meaning people were signed up without their knowledge, and some of those enrollees were later reinstated. The same analysis reports a moratorium on registering new agents and brokers on the federal platform that runs until February 2027. Whatever one thinks of the policy response, the practical lesson for you is the same: confirm that your own enrollment is the one you chose.
Group 1: Who is contacting you
- Did you ask for this contact? An unsolicited call, text or email about health coverage is a yellow flag on its own. Legitimate agents may call someone who requested a quote, and many marketplace-related outreach messages come from your state exchange or your insurer, but a cold contact from an unknown number should not get anything beyond your time. The reason: a scammer's whole advantage is that you did not initiate, so you have no way to know who they are.
- Do they say "government," "Medicare" or "Obamacare" about themselves? A broker works for themselves or an agency and sells plans from private insurers. A person who says they are "with the government" or "calling from the marketplace" about a plan you never applied for is, at best, imprecise. The real marketplace does not need you to buy anything from a caller.
- Is the caller reading from a script that pushes you past questions? Pressure to decide today is the clearest behavioral red flag. Open enrollment runs for weeks. The date that matters to you is your own coverage start date, not a sales deadline.
- Will they give a callback number and a name you can look up? A real agent can give a full name, a license number and an agency name and expects you to verify them. A scammer deflects or hangs up.
Group 2: Where the application happens
- The address must be exactly HealthCare.gov, or your state's own exchange. HealthCare.gov is the federal marketplace (federally facilitated marketplace) for most states. Some states run their own site as a state-based exchange, with its own name and web address. Look-alike domains with extra words, dashes or a different ending, and pages reached through ads, are where applications get harvested. The reason: any site can copy a logo, but nobody can copy the real address.
- Type the address yourself or use the state lookup. Do not follow a link from a text or an ad to begin an application. The state marketplace lookup points to the right official site for your state, and your state's insurance department website also names it.
- A broker's enrollment site is not the same as the marketplace. Licensed brokers and agencies may offer their own enrollment websites that connect to the marketplace. That is legitimate when the broker is licensed and the site completes your application through the marketplace. Your safeguard is the licensing check in Group 4 and the confirmation steps below, not trusting the look of the page.
- Be cautious about "check your eligibility" forms that ask only for a phone number and email. A form that collects contact details to "have an advisor call you" may be a lead generator that sells your information to many callers. The reason is practical: a flood of calls after one form is the usual result.
Group 3: What they want from you
- A fee to apply or enroll. Applying for marketplace coverage is free. Anyone who charges you to fill out an application, "unlock" a subsidy or "hold your spot" is outside how the marketplace works. Premiums for a real plan are paid to the insurer (or, in some states, through the exchange's payment system), never to an individual's account.
- Payment by gift card, wire, cryptocurrency, cash app or a code read aloud. No legitimate insurer or exchange collects premiums this way. The reason: those methods are hard or impossible to reverse, which is exactly why scammers ask for them.
- Your full Social Security number, bank account and card details on an incoming call. A real application does ask for Social Security numbers for people applying for coverage, and your insurer will take payment details when you set up premiums, but you should be the one who initiates and controls that step on the official site. If the caller started the call and is now pulling information from you, stop.
- Your account password or a verification code sent to your phone. Nobody legitimately needs these. Giving a code lets someone else log in to your marketplace account and change your application, your plan or your bank details. The reason: the code exists to prove that you are you.
- Remote access to your computer or "screen sharing." A broker helping you does not need control of your machine.
- A request to change your email, address or phone on your marketplace account to theirs. That is how someone keeps notices from reaching you. Your contact details should stay yours.
Group 4: Licensing and registration
- Ask for a full name, license number and agency, and verify them yourself. Insurance agents and brokers must be licensed by the state insurance department to sell health insurance. Most state departments publish a license lookup. Search on the state's own site, found independently, not through a link or a phone number the caller gave you. The reason: a fake license number sounds just as confident as a real one.
- Ask whether they are registered to sell through the marketplace. Agents and brokers who help people enroll through HealthCare.gov must complete the marketplace's registration process in addition to holding a state license. A legitimate broker will tell you how that works without irritation.
- Ask how they are paid. Brokers are commonly paid by insurers when a plan is sold, and a broker is not usually paid by you for a marketplace application. That is not itself a problem, and the broker and navigator guide covers it. The warning sign is evasiveness, or a claim that the help is both free and requires a payment from you.
- Navigators and certified application counselors are different. They are trained and funded to help for free and do not sell a particular plan. A broker may recommend a plan; a navigator is meant to explain your options. If someone says they are a navigator and then asks you to pay or to buy a specific product, verify through the official marketplace.
Group 5: The promise itself
- "Free," "$0 forever," "guaranteed approval," or "no medical questions" attached to a specific plan. Some real marketplace plans cost $0 after credits, depending on income, plan and year, but no caller can promise that before looking at your application. In the ACA marketplace, insurers cannot deny you for a health condition in any case, so "guaranteed approval" is meaningless as a selling point. In a non-ACA product it may signal something with very limited coverage.
- "Discount card," "membership," "medical savings program" or "health plan" with no deductible and a monthly fee. These can be legal products that lower the price of some services, but they are not health insurance and they do not count as coverage. The guide on fake plans and discount cards explains the differences.
- "You must act before the subsidy expires." The marketplace has real deadlines, but they are published on the official site. The credits' rules for 2027 are set by law and income, not by a caller's countdown. As of November 2026, the enhanced credits that existed through 2025 have expired, and no law restores them for 2027, so any pitch that sells "the old subsidy" is selling something that does not exist.
- "You are already enrolled, just confirm your details." This is a classic way to extract a Social Security number. If you are unsure whether you are enrolled, check your own account.
Group 6: What you should have afterward
If a conversation turns into an enrollment, a real one leaves a trail in places you control.
- An account in your own name, with your own email. You should be able to log in to the marketplace and see an application, an eligibility result and a plan selection.
- A written confirmation from the marketplace and an insurer. The insurer should send a welcome packet, a member ID and instructions for your first payment. A real enrollment is confirmed by the insurer, not by the person who sold it.
- Premiums that you pay to the insurer, shown in the insurer's portal. If you cannot find a payment record in the insurer's own system, the plan may not exist.
- Your choices, not theirs. You should be able to say which plan you picked, the premium and the deductible. If you cannot, the enrollment may not have been yours.
If you want to read how to repair a plan that changed without your approval, see someone changed my marketplace plan or enrolled me without consent: what now?. For the related question of buying directly from an insurer versus the marketplace, see Buying from an insurer's website vs the marketplace: do I still get my credit?.
A phone script
Say you receive a call about coverage you did not request. Here is a script you can use word for word, or adapt.
- "Who is this, and who do you work for?" Wait for a full name and a company. If they are vague, say, "I will call back on a number I look up myself," and end the call.
- "What is your state license number?" If they give one, say you will verify it with the state insurance department. A real agent will say that is fine.
- "I did not ask for this call. How did you get my number?" A real company has an answer. A scam may hang up.
- "I do not give personal information on calls I did not start. Please send details in writing." This one sentence handles most of the situations in Groups 1 and 3.
- "I will apply myself at HealthCare.gov or my state's exchange, or with a navigator." Then do that.
- Hang up if the caller continues to press. You do not owe the caller politeness at the cost of your account.
If they say they are from the marketplace itself, you can hang up and call the number on the official site yourself, which is the safe way to find out whether there is anything wrong with your application.
If you already shared something
Acting quickly limits damage, and none of it requires a lawyer.
- Payment sent. Call your bank or card issuer right away, report the fraud and ask whether the payment can be reversed or blocked.
- Password or code shared. Change the password on the marketplace account and on any account that uses the same one, and turn on a stronger sign-in method if the site offers it.
- Social Security number or date of birth shared. Consider a credit freeze with the credit bureaus and watch for new accounts. The Federal Trade Commission runs a fraud reporting service and an identity theft recovery service you can search for by name.
- Marketplace account affected. Log in and check your application, your plan and the contact details. Call the marketplace's official help line to say your account may have been misused.
- Report it. Your state insurance department takes complaints about agents and brokers; the complaint guide explains how. The FTC takes reports about scams generally. A broker's state insurance department can investigate a license.
None of these steps accuse a particular person. They put the facts in front of the people who can look into them.
Real help exists
A final point of balance: it would be a mistake to treat every broker as a suspect. Many licensed brokers and agencies help people enroll accurately, and navigators and certified application counselors offer free help in most communities. The goal of the checks above is not to avoid help; it is to find the right kind. A real helper will welcome your verification, will use the official site, will never ask for a code or a gift card, will leave you with your own account, and will not mind if you take a day to decide.
Key takeaways
- Enrollment starts at HealthCare.gov or your state's own exchange, reached by typing the address or using an official lookup, never through a link in an unsolicited text or an ad.
- Applying is free, premiums go to the insurer, and anything that requires gift cards, wire transfers or reading out a verification code is not how coverage is sold.
- Verify any broker's license with your state insurance department using a source you found yourself, and ask how they are paid.
- A real enrollment leaves a trail you control: your own account, insurer confirmation and a premium record in the insurer's system.
- If something went wrong, act in order: bank, passwords, credit freeze, marketplace account, then a report to your state insurance department and the FTC.