Blog
How do I know a Medicare plan sales call or ad is legitimate?
A checklist for the fall marketing season: federal marketing rules in principle, questions for an agent, red flags, and how to verify a plan and report abuse.
Between mid-October and early December, the mailbox, the television and the phone fill with Medicare plan offers. Most are from real agents and real plans, and a few are not. Telling them apart is easier than it sounds, because legitimate Medicare marketing operates under federal rules that scammers ignore, and because a legitimate offer survives being checked.
This checklist is organized in the order you would use it: what the rules generally require, how to look at the contact in front of you, what to ask an agent, what counts as a red flag, how to verify independently and where to report. The rules are described in principle, since the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) revises them from year to year, and the current text is on CMS's website and in your plan's materials.
Part 1: What Medicare marketing rules generally require
Plans and the agents and brokers who sell them are regulated. In broad terms, and subject to change, the federal rules for Medicare Advantage and Part D marketing include these points:
- Limits on unsolicited contact. Plans and agents generally may not cold-call you, text you or email you to sell a plan unless you have given permission or have a relationship with them. Door-to-door sales without an appointment are also prohibited. A plan may contact its own current members about the plan, and anyone may return a call you made to them.
- Permission for a sales conversation. Before a one-on-one sales appointment, an agent generally must record what you agreed to discuss (often called a scope of appointment), and there are waiting-period rules for scheduled appointments. The agent should not widen the discussion to products you did not agree to hear about.
- Required disclosures. Agents who sell for several plans must say how many companies and plans they represent, and that other options may exist. Plan materials and advertisements must identify the plan or the marketer and not suggest that they are from the government.
- No implied government endorsement. Marketing may not use the Medicare card, the Medicare logo or language that makes a private plan sound like the official program. A mailer designed to look like a Social Security or Medicare notice is a warning sign.
- Limits on claims and incentives. Advertisements generally cannot make claims such as "best" or "lowest" without support, cannot promise benefits that depend on conditions without saying so, and are limited in what gifts they may offer.
- Recorded calls. Many sales and enrollment calls must be recorded, and you can ask for the recording or the plan's confirmation of what was said.
- Licensing and training. An agent or broker who sells Medicare plans must be licensed in the state, appointed by each plan they sell and trained on Medicare and the plan's products, usually every year.
None of this guarantees good advice. A legitimate agent can still be wrong, or push a plan with a higher commission. But these rules give you levers: you can ask for the disclosures and the paperwork, and refusing them is itself informative.
Part 2: Triage the contact you just received
Ask these questions about any call, mailer, text, online ad or door knock.
- Did I ask for this? If you did not request the call, the text or the visit, the sender may be breaking the rules, or may not be an agent at all. A mailer with a reply card is an invitation you can decline, while a phone call from a stranger is a different category.
- Who is the sender, by name? A real mailer or ad names a company or a licensed agent. "Medicare benefits department" or "Senior benefits center" is a label, not a company.
- Is it claiming to be Medicare, Social Security or the government? Private plans are not allowed to imply this.
- Is there a deadline that only they can see? "Your benefits expire this week" and "act today" are pressure tactics. The Annual Enrollment Period runs from October 15 to December 7, and a plan does not disappear on another date. See Medicare Annual Enrollment Period: October 15 to December 7 for the real schedule.
- Is it asking for your Medicare number, Social Security number or bank details up front? An agent may need your information to compare plans, but a real one will explain why and will not pressure you to give it on an unsolicited call. A plan will want your number to enroll you, at the point where you have chosen to enroll.
- Is it offering something that sounds too generous? A gift card for switching, "free" groceries or a monthly check can be a real benefit of a particular plan in some cases, with conditions, or can be bait. The blog post Medicare Advantage selling points tested: $0 premium, perks and giveback plans looks at how to test these claims.
If the answers raise doubt, stop. You can always call back later through a number you find yourself.
Part 3: Questions to ask a licensed agent
An agent you invited, or one you reached by calling a number you verified, should be willing to answer these. Write the answers down.
- Are you licensed in my state, and what is your license number? The state insurance department can confirm it.
- Which plans do you sell, and which companies do you represent? The disclosure may say you represent a limited number of companies. Ask which plans in your area you cannot offer.
- How are you paid? Agents are generally paid by the plans. A neutral broker will tell you that and explain that it is not a reason to avoid them, but it is a reason to compare independently.
- Is my doctor in this plan's network, and where did you check? The right answer is the plan's own directory, followed by a call to the office. Providers move in and out of networks. The provider directory can be out of date.
- Are my drugs on the formulary, and at what tier and cost? Ask the agent to show it on the Medicare Plan Finder with your pharmacies selected.
- What happens if I need care out of the area or out of network? Plans differ, so ask.
- What is the plan's out-of-pocket limit, and what extra benefits come with conditions? For example, a dental allowance with a small annual cap is a different benefit from "dental covered."
- If I enroll today, what is the effective date, and what will I receive in writing? Enrollment generally leads to a confirmation from the plan. If it does not arrive, call the plan.
- Can I take time to compare? A good answer is yes. A bad one is "this offer ends today."
- Can you send me the summary of benefits and the evidence of coverage? Those documents are the contract, not the brochure.
The guide how to work with a health insurance broker or navigator explains the role of the broker and how it differs from a navigator or a State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor, who sell nothing.
Part 4: Red flags, tested against the rules
| What you hear or see | Why it is a red flag |
|---|---|
| "I'm calling from Medicare about your new card or your benefits" | Medicare does not cold-call to sell plans |
| A call you did not request from an agent for a plan | Unsolicited calls are generally not allowed |
| "I need your Medicare number to see if you qualify" | Used to bill Medicare or switch you without consent |
| A ticking deadline outside October 15 to December 7 | Real enrollment windows are set by federal rules |
| A plan "approved by Medicare" or "recommended by Medicare" | Medicare does not endorse private plans |
| A mailer that mimics a government notice | Marketing may not imply government endorsement |
| "Everyone qualifies for a free monthly allowance" | Benefits come with conditions and vary by plan |
| An agent who will not say which companies they represent | Disclosures are required |
| Pressure to enroll during the first call | Real advisers invite comparison |
| A request to pay anything by gift card, wire or cash | Plans do not collect premiums that way |
| An agent who offers to enroll you over a "three-way call" to a plan, then gets off the line | You should hear the plan's own confirmation |
A single flag does not prove a scam. Several together should end the conversation.
Part 5: Verify the plan and the agent independently
- Look up the plan on the official Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov. If you cannot find it, find out why. Plans must be approved to be sold, and the finder lists them for your ZIP code.
- Read the star rating, but check what it measures. A high rating describes the contract, not your doctors or your drugs. medicare star ratings explains the system, and CMS publishes the ratings.
- Check the agent's license with your state insurance department, many of which offer a lookup tool.
- Check your doctors and drugs yourself. Use the plan's directory, then call the office and ask whether they accept that exact plan for the new year. The post How to check a Medicare Advantage network before you enroll, doctor by doctor goes doctor by doctor.
- Call a SHIP counselor. The SHIP is free, local and not paid by plans. Many offer appointments during the fall.
- Take the plan's own materials home. A real plan will send a summary of benefits and an evidence of coverage that you can read before enrolling or in the period after.
Part 6: If you already enrolled, or gave information
If you enrolled in a plan on a call and have doubts, call the plan using the number on its official website, and ask for the enrollment date, the method and a copy of the recording or application. If you did not authorize the change, ask the plan to cancel it and consider a call to 1-800-MEDICARE. If you changed plans and then regret it, your options include the Annual Enrollment Period (until December 7) and, for people already in an Advantage plan, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31. How to leave a Medicare Advantage plan: dates, options and risks describes the dates and risks, and your SHIP counselor can help with specifics. The related post I was switched into a Medicare Advantage plan I didn't choose. How do I fix it? covers a switch you never agreed to.
Part 7: Where to report abuse
- The plan itself, to its compliance or complaint line, with names, dates and numbers.
- 1-800-MEDICARE, which takes complaints about marketing.
- Your state insurance department, for agent conduct and licensing.
- The Senior Medicare Patrol and the HHS Inspector General's hotline, for fraud.
- The Federal Trade Commission for scam calls.
Keep a record of the call: date, number, name, what was said. See how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it for more detail.
Key takeaways
- Legitimate Medicare marketing is regulated: generally no cold calls or unscheduled door knocks, required disclosures about which companies an agent represents, recorded calls and licensed, trained agents.
- Ask whether you started the contact, who the sender is by name and whether they claim to be the government. Each answer is a quick filter.
- Ask a licensed agent how they are paid, which companies they cannot offer and whether your doctors and drugs are covered, then verify those answers in the plan's own directory.
- Pressure, deadlines outside October 15 to December 7, requests for your number up front and payments by gift card are all red flags.
- Verify through Medicare.gov, your state insurance department and a free SHIP counselor, and report abuse to the plan, Medicare and your state.