Blog

Medicare Advantage selling points tested: $0 premium, perks and giveback plans

Five claims from Medicare Advantage ads checked against how premiums, extra benefits and Part B giveback work, plus a way to price each perk by your own use.

The mailer says "$0 premium," "up to $2,000 for dental," "a card to spend on groceries" and "we may give back part of your Part B premium." Every line can be literally true. What the ad cannot show is what you give up elsewhere, what each extra is limited to, and whether you would use any of it.

This post takes the common selling points one at a time, states the claim, tests it against how the rules and the plan contracts work, and ends with a method for putting a dollar value on each perk based on your own habits. It is written to be even-handed: extra benefits do help some people, and the same plans can disappoint others.

Claim 1: "$0 premium, so it costs nothing"

What is true. Many Medicare Advantage plans charge no monthly premium of their own. KFF reported that about 75% of people in Advantage plans with drug coverage paid no plan premium in 2026, with an enrollment-weighted average of $15 a month. For 2027, CMS reported a lower average Advantage premium of $12.00 a month, based on the plans' filings.

What the claim leaves out.

  • The Part B premium is still owed. To join an Advantage plan you must have Parts A and B, and you keep paying the standard Part B premium ($202.90 a month in 2026), usually deducted from Social Security. The plan's $0 refers to its own premium, not to Medicare's. See Part B premium. Higher-income enrollees also pay income-related surcharges on top.
  • Cost-sharing replaces premium. A plan without a premium still has copays, coinsurance, possibly a deductible, and an out-of-pocket limit that can reach the Medicare maximum. For 2026, plans can set an in-network limit as high as $9,250. A plan with no premium and a high limit is not "free"; it moves the cost to the days you use care.
  • Drug premiums can be separate. Some plans carry a drug-coverage premium even when the medical premium is $0, and Part D plans carry their own premium and cap.
  • A $0 plan can cost more than a plan with a premium. A $30 monthly premium is $360 a year. A plan that charges $20 more per specialist visit costs the same $360 after 18 visits. The math depends on how often you go.

Verdict. The statement is true and incomplete. "$0 premium" should read "$0 for the plan's own premium"; the number to compare is the year's total, which Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket limit: what a bad year costs, in worked numbers lays out line by line.

Claim 2: "Extra benefits are included"

What is true. Advantage plans may offer benefits Original Medicare does not, such as routine dental, vision, hearing, over-the-counter allowances, fitness memberships, transportation to appointments, and meals after a hospital stay. They are called supplemental benefits, and the rules for them are in Medicare Advantage supplemental benefits. They are real, and for the right person they are valuable.

What the claim leaves out. Each extra has its own boundaries:

  • Dollar limits. A dental benefit is typically capped per year. A $1,000 allowance does not buy a $4,000 implant; the rest is yours. See dental annual maximum for how annual maximums work in other dental plans.
  • Networks. The dentist, the optician, the hearing clinic and the gym are often in separate networks from your medical doctors. Your own dentist may not be in it.
  • Waiting rules and frequency. Some benefits can be used once a year, once every two years or only after a service is approved. Hearing aid allowances, in particular, are often per device and per period.
  • Eligibility. Some benefits apply only to people with certain chronic conditions or after a hospital discharge, and a limited number of rides or meals is common.
  • Use it or lose it. A quarterly over-the-counter card typically does not roll over, and the list of items it can buy is a catalog set by the plan.
  • They can change. A plan can reduce or drop an extra each January, which the Annual Notice of Change will say. The benefit that persuaded you this year may not be in next year's plan.

The guide Does Medicare cover dental, vision and hearing care? sets out what Original Medicare does and does not cover, which is the baseline these extras are compared to.

Verdict. The extras are real but limited, and what they are worth depends on how much of each you would use and whether your providers are in the benefit's network.

Claim 3: "A giveback plan pays part of your Part B premium"

What is true. Some plans offer a "Part B premium reduction," often called a giveback. The plan covers part of the standard Part B premium, so the amount taken from your Social Security payment goes down by the amount the plan announces.

What the claim leaves out.

  • Only part of the premium. If a plan gives back $50 a month in 2026, the Part B premium owed drops from $202.90 to $152.90, an illustration with round numbers. You still pay the rest, and any income-related surcharge is separate.
  • The plan has a budget. Every extra the plan offers is paid for out of the plan's funding, and a plan that spends on a giveback has less to spend on lower copays, a larger network or other extras. Where the cost shows up differs from plan to plan: look at specialist copays, the out-of-pocket limit and the network.
  • It can change. Like other extras, a giveback can be reduced or removed in a later year.
  • It does not lower the plan's other costs. The out-of-pocket limit, copays and prior authorization rules are separate.

Verdict. A giveback is a real reduction in a bill you pay every month. It is worth comparing to what the same plan charges in cost-sharing, because both come from the same plan design.

Claim 4: "Perks are free"

What is true. You do not pay a separate fee for the fitness membership, the flex card or the ride benefit.

What the claim leaves out. Perks are not free in the sense that someone is paying for them, and what you pay shows up in other places: the premium, cost-sharing, the size of the network, how many services need approval and how the plan handles claims. Supporters of Advantage extras argue that they help members with limited incomes cover things Original Medicare does not, and that plans can use them to encourage preventive care. Critics argue that extras are used to attract enrollment, that benefits that sound large can be little used, and that members can lose them or lose access to their doctors. Both views can be true for different plans and different people.

A practical test is to ask, "If I did not have this perk, would I buy the thing myself?" If yes, the perk replaces a cost you would have had. If no, it is not worth much to you, however large the headline number.

Verdict. A perk is worth what you would actually use it for, minus what you give up in the rest of the plan to get it.

Claim 5: "This plan includes everything you need"

Ads often imply that the plan covers every need. Advantage plans must cover what Original Medicare covers, but how they cover it differs: networks, referrals and prior authorization decide whether a given test, doctor or hospital is covered and at what cost. The Summary of Benefits will show the copays; the Evidence of Coverage shows the rules. See Medicare Advantage explained: how Part C plans work and Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage: how to compare the two for the structural comparison. The plan finder at Medicare.gov and a SHIP counselor can confirm drugs, pharmacies and doctors.

How to price a perk against your own use

Make a table with one row per perk. For each, estimate three things: what you would spend on that thing anyway, how much of the perk you would realistically use, and whether your provider is in the benefit's network. Value the perk at the smaller of the allowance and your realistic use.

Here is an illustration with invented numbers. Say Plan A has no premium, a dental allowance of $1,000 a year, an over-the-counter card of $150 a quarter, a fitness membership, and a $50-a-month Part B giveback. Plan B has no perks, no premium, and a specialist copay $20 lower. The reader expects to see specialists 12 times a year, needs one dental crown that would cost $1,100, and would use about half of the over-the-counter card. They have never used a gym.

Perk in Plan A Reader's realistic value
Dental allowance The crown costs $1,100 and the allowance is $1,000 at an in-network dentist: $1,000
Over-the-counter card $150 x 4 = $600 a year; the reader would use about half: $300
Fitness membership Never used: $0
Part B giveback $50 x 12 = $600
Total perk value $1,000 + $300 + $0 + $600 = $1,900

Now the cost on the other side. Plan A's specialist copay is $20 higher than Plan B's: 12 visits x $20 = $240. The net advantage of Plan A in an average year for this reader is $1,900 - $240 = $1,660.

That is not the end of the comparison. Suppose Plan A's out-of-pocket limit is $3,000 higher than Plan B's. In a bad year, Plan A can cost up to $3,000 more. The perks have an expected value; the limit is a risk. Whether $1,660 in an average year is worth a possible extra $3,000 in a bad one is a judgment about health, savings and comfort with risk, and it is a good place to bring a SHIP counselor or a insurance broker who will compare plans without steering you to the highest commission. The tool Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage cost comparison can help with the rest of the year's arithmetic.

Notice that the value depended entirely on the reader's habits. A person who needs no dental work and takes no interest in the card would value the same plan at $600, the giveback alone.

Questions to ask before you enroll

  1. "Is the premium $0 for the medical plan, and what is the drug premium, if any?"
  2. "What are the specialist, hospital and skilled nursing copays, and what is the in-network limit for 2027?"
  3. "For each extra benefit: what is the dollar or visit limit, which providers are in its network, how often can I use it, and does it roll over?"
  4. "If the plan offers a Part B giveback, how much is it per month, and has it changed in recent years?"
  5. "Are my doctors, hospital and pharmacy in the plan's network?"

Be wary of a call or ad that pressures you to decide at once, asks for your Medicare number up front or promises "free" benefits. The post How do I know a Medicare plan sales call or ad is legitimate? covers how to check one.

Key takeaways

  • "$0 premium" refers to the plan's own premium; you still owe the Part B premium, and cost-sharing can replace the premium on the days you use care.
  • Extra benefits are real but have dollar limits, separate networks, frequency rules and no promise of next year; value each one at what you would realistically use.
  • A Part B giveback lowers only part of the premium, and the plan funds it from the same budget as its copays, network and other extras.
  • In the invented example, perks worth $1,900 to one reader offset $240 in higher copays, but a $3,000 higher out-of-pocket limit remains a risk in a bad year.
  • Compare the whole year, bad and good, and get help from a SHIP counselor if the ads and the numbers do not line up.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic