Blog
I'm moving to another state. What happens to my Medigap policy?
A Medigap policy generally goes with you, but premium, state rules and your options for a new policy can change. What to check before and after a move.
A Medigap policy is built to be kept. In general, it is guaranteed renewable, which means the insurer cannot cancel it because you got older, developed a health condition or moved, as long as you keep paying the premium. Original Medicare works in every state, so the policy that sits on top of it keeps working too. What changes after a move is less dramatic but still matters: the premium may be re-rated, a different state's rules may start to apply, a new policy may or may not be easy to buy, and any Medicare Advantage or drug plan you have is tied to where you live in a way that Original Medicare is not.
Say Elena, 69, is retiring from a city in one state to a smaller town in another, about 800 miles away. She has Original Medicare, a Plan G Medigap policy she has held for four years and a stand-alone drug plan. Her neighbor has a Medicare Advantage plan and is making the same move. This post walks through both situations in the order the questions come up. Laws and insurer practices differ by state, so the last section lists who to ask.
Step 1: write down what you have
Before you call anyone, list what you hold:
- Original Medicare (Parts A and B), or a Medicare Advantage plan.
- A Medigap policy: the insurer, the letter, the pricing method, the policy number and the date you bought it.
- A drug plan: stand-alone, or part of an Advantage plan.
- Anything else that touches the move, such as employer or retiree coverage, a Medicare Savings Program or Medicaid.
This matters because the answers differ. Original Medicare with a Medigap policy follows you. An Advantage plan and a stand-alone drug plan are tied to a service area. A Medicaid or Medicare Savings Program benefit comes from your state and does not transfer; you reapply in the new state. For the broader picture, see health insurance when moving states: what carries over and what does not.
Step 2: understand what "guaranteed renewable" covers
For Elena, the central fact is this: her insurer generally cannot cancel the policy because she moved. She can keep it as long as she keeps Original Medicare and pays the premium. Medigap claims are paid after Medicare pays, using the information Medicare sends, so the policy works at doctors and hospitals in her new state exactly as it did at home.
What guaranteed renewable does not mean:
- It does not mean the premium stays the same. The insurer can change rates for the policy, and the rate for your ZIP code or state may differ from the old one.
- It does not mean the insurer sells new policies in the new state. It may keep your existing policy and not offer the same letter to new buyers there.
- It does not mean you could buy the same policy again today without health questions. Moving does not open a guaranteed-issue window by itself.
Call the insurer before you move and ask these questions, then ask for the answers by email:
- Will my policy stay in force after I change my address, and what date should I notify you?
- Will my premium change because of the move? If so, what will it be?
- Does the premium rating method (attained-age, issue-age or community-rated) stay the same under the new address?
- Do you sell this policy in my new state, and does the state have rules that affect my existing policy?
- If I later want a different policy, what do your rules say about health questions?
Update your address with Social Security, which handles Medicare enrollment records, and with the Medicare program so your Medicare Summary Notices and your supplement's claims follow you. Notify the insurer too. A missed premium notice because of an old address is an avoidable way to lose a policy.
Step 3: premiums and rating after a move
Medigap rates depend on where you live. Even without a move, rates can differ by ZIP code or county in some states. After a move, the insurer has to decide how to rate the policy at the new address. Practices vary. Some insurers keep the policy on its original rate basis, and others re-rate to the new area's schedule at the next renewal. Some states restrict what can change. Ask in writing, as in the list above.
The premium can go up or down. In some states Medigap premiums run lower than in others, and a policy rated to a higher-cost area can cost less after the move. A move from a state with community rating or age restrictions to one that allows attained-age rating, or the reverse, may also affect how the premium evolves. This is why the question about the rating method is on the list: the same letter can behave differently in the new state.
The post Why does my Medigap premium keep rising? Three pricing methods explained explains the three methods, and A checklist for comparing Medigap quotes from different insurers helps compare quotes if you decide to shop.
Step 4: if you want a new policy, expect underwriting
The tempting idea is to use the move as a chance to switch to a cheaper policy from an insurer that is strong in the new state. Whether that is easy depends on your health and on the state:
- Outside a guaranteed window, the new insurer may ask health questions and can decline or charge more. See medical underwriting.
- A move does not by itself create a guaranteed-issue right for Medigap. Rights come from specific events, such as the six-month open enrollment period or the loss of other coverage; see medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue.
- Some states give existing policyholders a switching right around their birthday. Ask the new state's insurance department whether the rule applies to someone who bought the policy in another state. The answer can differ from what you would assume.
- A few states have continuous or annual guaranteed-issue windows for Medigap. Those rights belong to the state, so a move into such a state may open options that did not exist before.
Elena, who is healthy, could try to switch. She should apply while keeping the old policy until the new one is approved and past its free look period, as described in Switching Medigap insurers to pay less without losing coverage. If her health had changed, the safe choice would be to keep the policy she has.
Step 5: if you have a Medicare SELECT policy
A Medicare SELECT policy is a Medigap policy that uses a network of hospitals and sometimes doctors. If you move out of the network's service area, you generally have a right to buy a different Medigap policy from any insurer in your new state without health questions, within a limited time. The timing and the letters you may buy are set by federal and state rules. Check with the insurer and a SHIP counselor, because the window is limited and the details matter. If you do not know whether your policy is a SELECT policy, the policy's outline of coverage will say.
Step 6: Medicare Advantage and drug plans are different
Elena's neighbor has a Medicare Advantage plan. Advantage plans are local. Each one has a service area, usually one or more counties, and a network of doctors and hospitals inside it. When your permanent address moves outside the service area, the plan generally cannot keep you, and you will need new coverage. The key points:
- A special enrollment period opens when you move to a place the plan does not serve. It generally starts the month before you move and runs for two full months after, so notify the plan and plan ahead. See medicare special enrollment period.
- You can pick another Advantage plan available in the new area, or return to Original Medicare. If you return to Original Medicare, you will need a stand-alone drug plan, and you will probably want to consider a Medigap policy. See the next point.
- Medigap rights may open. Moving out of an Advantage plan's service area is one of the situations that can give a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap letters, with a time limit. The right is similar to the one that applies when a plan ends, which is covered in My Advantage plan is ending: do I get a guaranteed Medigap policy?. Confirm the dates and the letters with the plan, the insurer and a SHIP counselor.
- Check the new plans' networks first. Your doctors, hospitals and pharmacies in the new area may be different, and a plan that was a good fit at home may have few providers nearby.
Stand-alone Part D plans are also regional. If you move outside your plan's region, a special enrollment period applies, and you must choose a plan sold in the new area. Do not let a gap in drug coverage run past 63 days, because a late-enrollment penalty can result; see Medicare Part D. The post I'm moving. What happens to my Medicare Advantage plan, and when can I switch? lays out the Advantage and drug timeline in more detail.
Step 7: doctors, drugs and the practical side
- Doctors who accept Medicare. Most do, but not all accept assignment, so ask a new doctor's office before the first visit. Plan G pays Part B excess charges; some letters do not.
- Pharmacies. Check that your pharmacy chain or a mail-order option works under the drug plan in your new area.
- Records. Ask your old doctors for copies of records, a list of medications and any referrals in progress.
- A moving checklist. For the full list of tasks, see What happens to my Medicare when I retire to another state?.
- Part-year moves. If you will split the year between two states, the answers differ; see I spend winters in another state: Medicare Advantage or Original Medicare?.
Who to ask in each state
Moves cross two jurisdictions, so two sets of people can help:
- The old state's insurance department can tell you what your rights were there and whether any notice is required.
- The new state's insurance department can tell you which Medigap rules apply to you after the move, whether a switching window exists and whether an insurer is authorized to sell there. Use the state marketplace, regulator and help lookup or how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help to find the right contact.
- A SHIP counselor in the new state can review your whole situation for free and without selling anything. Find the program through the new state's lookup or Medicare.gov.
- Your Medigap insurer can confirm the rate and the rule for your policy.
Mistakes to avoid
- Assuming the policy will be cancelled by the move, and dropping it in a panic.
- Cancelling a Medigap policy before a replacement has been approved.
- Forgetting to tell the insurer and Social Security about the new address.
- Leaving an Advantage or drug plan in place without checking whether it serves the new address, which can leave you without coverage when the plan disenrolls you.
- Assuming a guaranteed-issue right exists because you moved, when it often does not.
Key takeaways
- A Medigap policy generally stays in force when you move because it is guaranteed renewable, but the premium and the rating method may change.
- A move alone does not create a right to buy a new Medigap policy without health questions; check the new state's rules and any birthday-rule window.
- Medicare Advantage and stand-alone drug plans are tied to service areas, so a move opens a special enrollment period and may open Medigap rights.
- Notify the insurer, Social Security and Medicare of the new address, and ask each answer in writing.
- The new state's insurance department and a SHIP counselor can tell you what applies where you now live.