Blog
Compare two plans' total cost for a light, average and heavy year (worksheet)
A repeatable worksheet that totals two plans at low, medium and high use, capped by the out-of-pocket maximum, with filled-in examples and a risk rule.
This worksheet takes about twenty minutes and works for any two plans: employer, marketplace or otherwise. You will write down each plan's terms, price a low, a medium and a high year of care, add the premiums, and end with a total for every combination. The point is to replace the question "which plan is cheaper?" with the more useful "cheaper in which kind of year?"
The example uses invented plans and round numbers. Replace them with your own from the plans' summaries of benefits and coverage.
Step 1: Gather the terms
For each plan, write down:
- Monthly premium. If you buy through the marketplace with a credit, use the amount you pay after the credit. If your employer pays part, use your share.
- Annual premium. Monthly premium times twelve.
- deductible. Is it one number for medical and drugs, or separate? If you cover family members, note both the individual and the family figures.
- coinsurance rate (the percentage you pay after the deductible) and any copays for care you expect to use.
- out-of-pocket maximum. The most you pay in a year for covered in-network care. For plan year 2027 the federal limit is $12,000 for self-only coverage and $24,000 for other coverage, per CMS's January 2026 guidance, so no plan's figure should exceed those.
Step 2: Pick three usage levels
Choose three amounts of allowed charges, which are the prices the plan recognizes for your in-network care, before your share. Be honest about what "light" and "heavy" mean for you.
- Low: preventive care and perhaps a visit or two.
- Medium: a typical year for you, with some regular visits, tests and prescriptions. Last year's explanations of benefits are a good guide.
- High: a year with a major event, such as a hospital stay or surgery. If you do not know a number, use something that is at or above the larger plan's out-of-pocket maximum, because after that point a higher bill changes nothing for you.
Step 3: Price each level, one plan at a time
For each plan and usage level, use the formula:
- If the allowed charges are less than or equal to the deductible, you pay all of them.
- If they are above the deductible, you pay the deductible plus the coinsurance rate times the amount above it.
- Whatever the result, you never pay more than the out-of-pocket maximum.
Then add the annual premium. The result is your total cost for that plan in that kind of year. The health insurance cost estimator can do the arithmetic if you prefer.
A filled-in example
Say you are comparing two hypothetical plans.
| Feature | Plan X | Plan Y |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium | $380 | $520 |
| Annual premium | $4,560 | $6,240 |
| Deductible | $3,000 | $1,000 |
| Coinsurance | 20% | 10% |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | $7,000 | $4,500 |
The three usage levels are low ($1,000 of allowed charges), medium ($8,000) and high ($60,000).
Plan X
- Low: $1,000 is below the $3,000 deductible, so you pay $1,000.
- Medium: $3,000 deductible plus 20% of the other $5,000 ($1,000) equals $4,000.
- High: $3,000 plus 20% of $57,000 ($11,400) would be $14,400, but the cap is $7,000, so you pay $7,000.
Plan Y
- Low: $1,000 equals the deductible, so you pay $1,000.
- Medium: $1,000 plus 10% of $7,000 ($700) equals $1,700.
- High: $1,000 plus 10% of $59,000 ($5,900) would be $6,900, but the cap is $4,500, so you pay $4,500.
Now add the premiums.
| Year | Plan X cost sharing | Plan X total | Plan Y cost sharing | Plan Y total | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | $1,000 | $5,560 | $1,000 | $7,240 | X by $1,680 |
| Medium | $4,000 | $8,560 | $1,700 | $7,940 | Y by $620 |
| High | $7,000 | $11,560 | $4,500 | $10,740 | Y by $820 |
Plan X wins a quiet year by $1,680 and loses the other two. That is a clean illustration of the usual tradeoff: the lower-premium plan costs less when you use little care and more when you use a lot, with the crossover somewhere in between.
Step 4: Find the break-even
The crossover point tells you how much care it takes before the more expensive plan pays off. In the example, the premium gap is $1,680 ($6,240 minus $4,560). In the range of allowed charges from $1,000 to $3,000, Plan X pays nothing (you bear all of it), while Plan Y has met its deductible and shares the rest: you pay $1,000 plus 10% of the amount above $1,000.
At allowed charges of A dollars in that range, the difference in cost sharing is A minus $900 minus 10% of A, which simplifies to 0.9 times A minus $900. Setting that equal to $1,680 gives A equals about $2,867. Check it: at $2,867, Plan X's cost sharing is $2,867 and Plan Y's is $1,000 plus 10% of $1,867 ($187), or $1,187. The difference is about $1,680, matching the premium gap.
So above roughly $2,870 of allowed charges in the year, Plan Y is the cheaper plan overall. A person who would spend less than that on care is better off with Plan X, and a person who expects to spend more is better off with Plan Y. The deductible vs premium break-even calculator finds this point for any pair of plans.
Step 5: Add your risk tolerance
The break-even gives you the facts. Your tolerance for a bad year decides what to do with them. Two simple rules:
The expected-cost rule. Assign your own rough odds to the three years, say 50% low, 35% medium and 15% high, and multiply. This is a guess about your own life, not a statistic, so use your own history and any known upcoming care.
- Plan X: 0.50 times $5,560 plus 0.35 times $8,560 plus 0.15 times $11,560 equals $2,780 plus $2,996 plus $1,734, which is $7,510.
- Plan Y: 0.50 times $7,240 plus 0.35 times $7,940 plus 0.15 times $10,740 equals $3,620 plus $2,779 plus $1,611, which is $8,010.
On these odds, Plan X is cheaper by about $500 on average over many years. But you live one year, not an average.
The worst-case rule. Compare the ceilings: premium plus out-of-pocket maximum. Plan X: $4,560 plus $7,000 equals $11,560. Plan Y: $6,240 plus $4,500 equals $10,740. If you could not comfortably absorb the extra $820 in a bad year, or the cash you would need up front, Plan Y limits the damage.
Neither rule is the answer. The expected-cost rule favors the cheaper plan when you are comfortable with risk, and the worst-case rule favors the more protective one when a bad year would be painful. Where the two disagree, as they do here, the decision comes down to savings and tolerance. A household with $8,000 in an emergency fund might choose Plan X and keep the premium difference. A household without that cushion might choose Plan Y and accept the higher monthly bill.
A second example: copays against a high-deductible plan
The first example used one structure for both plans. Real choices often mix designs, so here is a pair from a hypothetical employer's open enrollment. All amounts are invented, and the premiums are your payroll share.
| Feature | Plan P (copays) | Plan Q (high deductible, HSA-eligible) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium, your share | $200 | $90 |
| Annual premium | $2,400 | $1,080 |
| Deductible | $2,000, hospital care only | $3,500 |
| Visit copays | $25 primary, $50 specialist | none; deductible applies |
| Generic drug copay | $10 | none; deductible applies |
| Coinsurance after deductible | 20% | 20% |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | $6,000 | $5,000 |
| Employer contribution to your HSA | none | $500 |
Three years of care, all in network. The low year is preventive care only, which both plans cover without cost sharing. The medium year is six primary care visits at $150 allowed each ($900), two specialist visits at $250 ($500), $600 of labs and imaging, and twelve generic fills at $20 ($240), for $2,240 of allowed charges. The high year is a $40,000 hospital episode.
Plan P, medium year. Visit copays: six times $25 plus two times $50 is $250. Generic fills: twelve times $10 is $120. In this simplified design, labs and imaging carry no cost sharing. Cost sharing: $370, so the total is $2,400 plus $370 equals $2,770.
Plan Q, medium year. All $2,240 falls inside the $3,500 deductible, so you pay it. Total: $1,080 plus $2,240 equals $3,320. The employer's $500 goes into an account you can spend on qualified medical costs, so your net outlay is $2,820.
High year. Plan P: $2,000 plus 20% of $38,000 ($7,600) is $9,600, so the $6,000 cap applies. Total: $2,400 plus $6,000 equals $8,400. Plan Q: $3,500 plus 20% of $36,500 ($7,300) is $10,800, so the $5,000 cap applies. Total: $1,080 plus $5,000 equals $6,080, or $5,580 after the HSA contribution.
| Year | Plan P total | Plan Q total (net of HSA money) | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low | $2,400 | $580 | Q by $1,820 |
| Medium | $2,770 | $2,820 | P by $50 |
| High | $8,400 | $5,580 | Q by $2,820 |
The copay plan is not the winner in any year by a lot, and the high-deductible plan wins two of three. The worksheet also shows what Plan Q demands: in the medium year you pay $2,240 yourself, and in the high year you pay up to $5,000 within the year, so the savings are real only if you can fund them. Plan Q's design fits the federal rules for an HSA-eligible plan in 2027, which require a deductible of at least $1,750 and an out-of-pocket maximum no higher than $8,700 for self-only coverage (Rev. Proc. 2026-24); the HSA contribution limit for 2027 is $4,500 for self-only coverage. High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) explained: pros and cons covers the tradeoffs of that plan type.
Choosing your three usage levels honestly
The worksheet is only as good as the three numbers you feed it. A few ways to make them less arbitrary:
- Start from last year. Add up the allowed amounts on last year's explanations of benefits, and add a pharmacy printout. If you changed plans, the numbers still describe your habits.
- Add what you know is coming. A planned procedure, a pregnancy, a new prescription or a child's orthodontic work belongs in the medium or high case, not a footnote.
- Make "high" real. A hospital stay or a new diagnosis is the case the plan exists for. Use a figure above the larger out-of-pocket maximum so you see each plan's ceiling.
- Keep "low" low. Preventive care and a visit or two. If you take a regular medicine, it belongs in every case.
- Re-run it when your life changes. A new job, a move, a marriage or a new child changes both the plans on offer and the right usage levels.
Your blank worksheet
Copy this table and fill it in for each plan.
| Item | Plan 1 | Plan 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium (after any credit or employer share) | ||
| Annual premium (monthly times 12) | ||
| Deductible | ||
| Coinsurance rate | ||
| Out-of-pocket maximum | ||
| Low-year cost sharing | ||
| Medium-year cost sharing | ||
| High-year cost sharing | ||
| Low-year total (annual premium plus cost sharing) | ||
| Medium-year total | ||
| High-year total | ||
| Worst case (annual premium plus out-of-pocket maximum) |
What this worksheet leaves out
- Copays and separate drug rules. If a plan charges copays for visits or drugs before the deductible, price those lines separately and add them. I take a specialty drug. How do I choose a plan when coinsurance applies to it? shows how for an expensive drug.
- Networks. The numbers only apply to in-network care. Check your doctors, the hospital and the pharmacy against each plan before you trust a total.
- Family deductibles. If more than one person is covered, check whether the deductible and maximum are embedded or aggregate. embedded versus aggregate family deductibles and how they change my pick covers the difference.
- Tax effects. A health savings account, a pretax employer premium or a premium tax credit can change what you actually pay. A tax professional can help with those.
- Two plan years. A bill that straddles December and January splits across two deductibles.
how to estimate your total yearly health care costs for a plan covers building your own usage levels, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs covers networks, drugs and service quality.
Key takeaways
- Compare plans by annual premium plus cost sharing at three usage levels, bounded by each plan's out-of-pocket maximum, instead of by premium or deductible alone.
- The lower-premium plan usually wins a quiet year and the higher-premium plan a heavy one; the break-even shows where they cross.
- Compute the worst case as annual premium plus the out-of-pocket maximum, and ask whether you could pay it.
- Use your own odds to weight the three years if you want an expected cost, but treat it as a guess about one life, not a forecast.
- Confirm networks, drug tiers and family deductible rules before relying on any total.