Blog

How do I use the Summary of Benefits coverage examples to compare plans?

What the baby, diabetes and fracture examples on a Summary of Benefits assume, how the split is worked out, what they omit, and how to compare two plans.

Near the end of every Summary of Benefits and Coverage there is a page that looks like a small case study: a woman having a baby, a man managing type 2 diabetes, a child with a broken bone. Each one lists a total cost and then shows how much the person would pay under that plan. Most readers skip it, which is a waste, because it is one of the few places where two plans are run through identical care and the results are printed side by side.

The examples are not a forecast of your costs. They are a standardized test, and their value is that the test is the same for every plan. This post explains what the three examples assume, how the split between plan and patient is calculated, what the examples leave out and how to use them as a quick comparison. All dollar figures in the worked examples below are invented round numbers, not the figures on any real SBC.

What the three examples are

The summary of benefits and coverage is a standardized document that health plans must provide so that consumers can compare plans. The page of coverage examples is part of that standard format. It contains three scenarios, each described in a sentence and each with a fixed list of services:

  • Having a baby (a normal delivery). A run of prenatal visits, tests and the hospital stay for a vaginal delivery, with the newborn's routine care. It is the largest of the three.
  • Managing type 2 diabetes. A year of routine, in-network care for a well-controlled condition: regular visits, lab tests, and the medicines and supplies that go with it. It tests how the plan treats prescriptions and ongoing visits.
  • Treating a simple fracture. An emergency room visit for a broken bone, with imaging and follow-up. It is the smallest, and it tests how the plan treats an emergency and imaging.

The services in each example, the prices assigned to them and the assumptions about where the care is delivered are set by federal rules, not by the insurer. Each example states a total example cost, the same for every plan that uses the same version of the form. Beneath it the page shows how much the person would pay under that plan, broken into the deductible, copayments, coinsurance and, for some, the amounts for services the plan limits or does not cover.

Two things follow. The examples assume in-network care, so they are a best case for the plan's network. And because the underlying services and prices are fixed, the only thing that changes between plans is the plan's design: its deductible, its copays, its coinsurance and its exclusions. That is what makes the comparison fair.

How the cost split is calculated

Think of the plan as a machine. It takes the fixed list of services and prices, applies its own rules in order, and reports what is left for the patient. The rules are the same ones that govern a real claim.

  1. The service is priced at the allowed amount. The example uses a fixed price for each service, standing in for the plan's allowed amount.
  2. Copays apply to the services they cover. A visit with a $30 copay costs $30 to the patient, and the plan pays the rest, whatever the deductible.
  3. The deductible applies to the services subject to it. The patient pays full price for those services until the deductible is met.
  4. coinsurance applies to the rest. After the deductible, the patient pays a percentage of what remains.
  5. The out-of-pocket maximum caps the total. If the total reaches the plan's out-of-pocket maximum, the patient's share stops there.
  6. Excluded or limited services are added. If the example includes a service the plan does not cover or caps, the patient pays that amount, and the form notes it separately.

The form then adds the pieces and gives the total the person would pay. It is the same arithmetic you would do on your own, applied to a standard case.

A worked comparison with invented numbers

Say two plans are being compared, and the examples on each form use the same invented prices. Plan X has a lower premium, $300 a month ($3,600 a year), and a higher deductible. Plan Y costs $500 a month ($6,000 a year) and pays more of the routine care. The premium gap is $2,400 a year. The premium is not part of the example, so it has to be added by hand.

The baby example

Say the invented total example cost is $10,000, made up of $2,000 in prenatal visits and $8,000 for the delivery and hospital stay.

  • Plan X charges a $30 copay for each of ten prenatal visits, which is $300, and applies the deductible and coinsurance to the $8,000. The deductible is $3,000, and coinsurance is 20% of the remaining $5,000, which is $1,000. The patient pays $300 plus $3,000 plus $1,000, which is $4,300.
  • Plan Y covers the prenatal visits without cost sharing. The $8,000 is subject to a $500 deductible, and 10% coinsurance applies to the remaining $7,500, which is $750. The patient pays $500 plus $750, which is $1,250.

The difference is $3,050 for this event, more than the $2,400 premium gap. A household that expects a birth in the plan year would find Plan Y cheaper overall by $650: Plan X costs $3,600 plus $4,300, which is $7,900, and Plan Y costs $6,000 plus $1,250, which is $7,250. For a deeper look at the cost of a birth on your own plan, see How much will my pregnancy cost under my plan? A worked cost estimate.

The diabetes example

Say the invented total example cost is $5,000 for a year of care.

  • Plan X applies its deductible to everything. The patient pays the $3,000 deductible and 20% of the remaining $2,000, which is $400. The patient pays $3,400.
  • Plan Y uses copays: four visits at $40 is $160, twelve prescription fills at $25 is $300 and two lab tests at $15 is $30. The patient pays $490.

Plan Y's advantage is $2,910, again larger than the premium gap. The household's all-in cost would be $3,600 plus $3,400, or $7,000, on Plan X, and $6,000 plus $490, or $6,490, on Plan Y. Plan Y is cheaper by $510.

The fracture example

Say the invented total example cost is $2,500.

  • Plan X applies its deductible to the whole bill, and $2,500 is below the $3,000 deductible. The patient pays $2,500.
  • Plan Y charges a $250 emergency room copay, and the other $2,250 is subject to a $500 deductible and 10% coinsurance on the remaining $1,750, which is $175. The patient pays $250 plus $500 plus $175, which is $925.

Here the difference is $1,575. For a household that expects no care at all, the comparison goes the other way: Plan X costs $3,600 and Plan Y $6,000, and the examples do not show that, because they only describe care.

Plan X pays out of pocket Plan Y pays out of pocket Gap
Baby $4,300 $1,250 $3,050
Diabetes $3,400 $490 $2,910
Fracture $2,500 $925 $1,575

The pattern is typical: the plan with the higher premium looks better on all three examples, because every example involves care. A household that uses little care would find the lower-premium plan cheaper.

Why you cannot just add the three examples

It is tempting to add the three totals as a "bad year." Do not. Each example is calculated as if it were the only care in the year, so each one has its own full deductible. In a real year, a household that had all three would meet the deductible once and might reach the out-of-pocket maximum. On Plan X in the invented example, $4,300 plus $3,400 plus $2,500 is $10,200, but the plan's maximum might cap the real total at much less. Treat the three as separate tests, and choose the one that is closest to your situation.

What the examples leave out

The examples are a fair test of design, and they are narrow. They leave out:

  • Premiums. The form does not include them, as the worked comparison above shows. Add twelve months of premiums yourself.
  • Out-of-network care. All three examples assume in-network care. If your doctor or hospital is not in the network, the form tells you nothing about what you would pay.
  • Your own drugs, doctors and conditions. The diabetes example uses standard medicines, and a person with different medicines, a pump or a complicated condition may see very different costs. A cesarean delivery, a complicated pregnancy or a stay for the newborn can cost more than the baby example.
  • Services the example does not include. A fracture that needs surgery, or a baby who needs intensive care, is outside the example.
  • Different years and prices. The fixed prices are set for the form, not for your local market. The real allowed amounts at your hospital will differ.
  • The fine print. The example's footnotes and the "limits or exclusions" line may mention things that matter, such as a cap on a service. The full plan document has the rest. See the summary says it's covered, so where do limits hide in the plan document?.

Using the examples as a quick comparison

  1. Collect the SBCs. Each plan must provide one, and you can request it from the plan, from your employer's benefits office or from the plan's page on the marketplace. Make sure each is for the plan year you are shopping for.
  2. Open the coverage examples page on each SBC and check that the total example costs are the same. If they are, the comparison is direct.
  3. Pick the example closest to your household. A household expecting a birth looks at the baby example; someone on regular medication looks at the diabetes one for how the plan treats ongoing care; a household with young children and active kids may find the fracture example the most relevant.
  4. Compare the totals, then look inside them. A plan with a lower total may achieve it through a low deductible or through low copays. Check the lines for deductibles, copayments and coinsurance, since they show where each plan is generous and where it is not.
  5. Add the premium for the year and compare the all-in totals for each example. Then add the "nothing happens" case, which is premiums alone.
  6. Check the network and the drug list for your own doctors and medicines before you decide. The examples assume them and do not verify them.
  7. Use a calculator for your own numbers. The health plan comparison calculator takes your expected visits and prescriptions, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs covers the wider comparison.

If two plans come out nearly identical, Two plans look identical on paper. What tiebreakers should I use? suggests how to break the tie. For help reading the rest of the form, see How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage.

Where to get help

A navigator or licensed broker can walk through the SBCs for marketplace plans, and an employer's benefits office can do the same for workplace plans. The plan's member services can confirm which services the examples cover and how they are priced. The examples are an aid for a decision, and the decision is still yours.

Key takeaways

  • The three examples (baby, type 2 diabetes, simple fracture) run fixed care at fixed prices through each plan's rules, so differences in the totals come from plan design alone.
  • The cost split is the plan's own arithmetic: copays, then the deductible, then coinsurance, up to the out-of-pocket maximum, plus anything excluded.
  • The examples do not include premiums, out-of-network care, your own medicines and doctors, or complications, so add twelve months of premiums and check the network and the drug list.
  • Do not add the three examples together as a bad year, because each assumes it is the only care in the year.
  • Pick the example closest to your household, compare the totals and their components, and use a calculator or a navigator for your real numbers.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic