Blog
Two plans look identical on paper. What tiebreakers should I use?
An ordered process for choosing between two plans with the same deductible, premium and copays, ending with a rule for when to stop analyzing and decide.
You have laid out two plans and the numbers match. The premium is within a few dollars, the deductible is the same, the out-of-pocket maximum is the same, and the specialist copay is the same. Two hours of comparing have produced no winner, and open enrollment is not going to wait. This is a common place to get stuck, and it has a way out: the cost lines on the summary are only part of what a plan is. The rest lives in the network, the drug list, the approval rules and the way the insurer behaves when something goes wrong.
This playbook is an ordered list of tiebreakers. Work down it and stop at the first step that separates the plans for your own situation. The last section gives a rule for deciding when to stop, because it is possible to analyze past the point where the answer matters. The people and plans below are invented, with round numbers, to show the method.
Before the tiebreakers: confirm the tie is real
A tie on the summary of benefits and coverage is a tie on a standardized page. Confirm these first, which take five minutes and often settle it.
- Same plan year and same coverage start date. One plan may start January 1 and the other February 1 if you enroll after the first-of-year deadline.
- Same deductible structure. A family deductible can be embedded, meaning each person has a smaller individual deductible inside it, or aggregate, meaning the whole family amount must be met before the plan pays for anyone. Two plans with the same family figure can behave very differently for one sick child.
- Same treatment of your regular services. If your regular care is therapy, imaging or a specialist, compare those rows, not the headline ones.
- The total-year cost. Premiums times twelve, plus the cost sharing you expect, gives a single number per plan. The guide on estimating total health care costs explains how. If the totals differ by more than your tolerance for risk, the tie was an illusion.
If the plans are still tied, move on.
Tiebreaker 1: the network, tested provider by provider
A plan's network is the largest hidden difference between two plans with equal prices, and the cheapest one to test. Look up each of the following in both plans' directories:
- Your primary care doctor and any specialists you see regularly
- The hospital you would want in an emergency or a planned stay
- Your regular lab and imaging center, because a hospital-owned lab can be out of network even when the doctor is in
- Your child's pediatrician, a therapist or any other ongoing relationship
Then phone each office and ask whether it accepts that exact plan name for the coming year. The directory is a starting point, not a promise, as the entry on the provider directory explains.
Next, check referrals. Some plans require a primary care doctor to refer you before you see a specialist, and some let you book directly. Two plans with the same specialist copay differ a lot if one lets you see a dermatologist next week and the other requires a visit first.
Finally, look at breadth. A narrow network can offer lower premiums, and for many households it works well. If your care could take you out of the area, or if you travel, count the number of hospitals and specialists you could reach under each plan.
Decision for this step. If one plan includes your doctors and the other does not, you have your answer. The cost of leaving a trusted clinician usually exceeds a small difference elsewhere.
Tiebreaker 2: the drug list
Run every medicine you take, including ones you take only now and then, through each plan's formulary. For each drug, record the tier, whether approval or a trial of another drug is required, and any quantity limit. The cost for a drug depends on its tier and on whether the plan uses a flat copay or a percentage there.
Say Sam takes one maintenance drug. Plan A puts it on tier 2 with a $20 copay per 30-day fill, and Plan B puts it on tier 3 with a $60 copay. The annual difference is 12 × ($60 − $20) = $480. If Sam takes a second drug with the same pattern, the gap doubles. Add the premium difference and you may have found the separator.
Also check:
- Pharmacy network. Whether your pharmacy is in network, and whether a preferred tier lowers copays at certain pharmacies.
- Mail order. Many plans offer a 90-day supply through a mail-order pharmacy for less than three 30-day fills. If you take daily medicine, this can matter. If your plan requires mail order after a number of refills, that is worth knowing too.
- Specialty drugs. If you take one, ask how the plan charges for it, because a percentage on an expensive drug can reach the out-of-pocket maximum in one or two fills.
Tiebreaker 3: prior authorization lists
Two plans with the same costs can differ in which services they require approval for. Look for the prior authorization list on each insurer's site, or ask for it in writing, and check the services you expect to use, such as an MRI, a sleep study, physical therapy beyond a set number of visits, a specialty drug or a planned surgery.
Approval is not a reason to avoid a plan. It is an extra step, and the number of steps can affect how quickly you get care. The guide on how prior authorization works describes the process, and a related post on comparing plans by approval burden goes further.
Decision for this step. If one plan requires approval for a service you know you will need and the other does not, the second plan has the edge, all else equal.
Tiebreaker 4: telehealth and virtual care
Check each plan's virtual care. The differences that can matter are:
- Whether a video visit with a primary care doctor or a therapist costs less than an in-person visit, and whether it carries a flat fee or counts toward the deductible
- Whether the plan runs its own virtual service or lets you use your own doctor by video
- Whether mental health care by video is covered at the same level as in-person care
For a household in a rural area, a household with a young child or someone with a mobility limit, this can move more of the cost than a small premium gap. For a household that rarely uses care, it will not.
Tiebreaker 5: customer service and getting help
This one is harder to compare, but not impossible. Two plans that look the same on paper can feel different the first time you need a claim fixed. You can test it before you enroll:
- Call each plan's member or sales line with one specific question, such as whether a named drug needs approval. Notice how long you wait and whether the answer comes with a reference you can write down.
- Check whether the plan has a member portal, an app, a nurse line and a care navigation team. Ask what the plan will do to help find an in-network doctor.
- Search your state insurance department's site for complaint information about each insurer. Many departments publish complaint data or a way to ask. The guide to comparing health insurers covers where to look.
Treat anecdotes with care. A friend's bad week with an insurer is one data point.
Tiebreaker 6: what could change during the plan year
A plan can change during the year in ways the summary does not show. Look for:
- Formulary updates. Many plans reserve the right to move a drug to a higher tier or remove it mid-year. Ask how much notice the plan gives, and whether a current prescription is protected.
- Network changes. A doctor or hospital can leave a network at any time. Ask about continuity-of-care rules, which in many plans allow a transition period for a patient in treatment.
- Whether the plan is new or continuing. A plan that already exists has a published history of formulary and network behavior. A plan in its first year has none.
- What the plan changes next year. The insurer's notice of changes, or the benefits team's changes document for a workplace plan, shows what next year's version removes or adds.
If you cannot compare these for the current year, note that one plan is a known quantity and the other is not. Some people value that, and some value the new plan's price.
Tiebreaker 7: the secondary details
If you still have a tie, look at the smaller differences:
- Out-of-network coverage. One plan pays something out of network, and the other pays nothing except in an emergency. See in-network versus out-of-network care. If you travel or live near a state line, this can be worth something.
- Wellness features. Gym discounts and rewards programs are rarely the deciding factor, and are often small.
- Add-ons. Dental, vision or hearing coverage bundled with one plan but not the other.
- Ease of changing. If your employer lets you change plans only at open enrollment, an error costs a year. A marketplace plan carries the same limit unless a qualifying life event opens a special enrollment period.
A worked example
Say Dana and Marcus, a hypothetical couple, are choosing between Plan A and Plan B. Both have a $300 monthly premium, a $4,000 deductible, 20% coinsurance and an $8,000 out-of-pocket maximum.
- Network. Both of their doctors are in both networks. Their hospital is in Plan A's network and is in Plan B's network only for emergencies. The network step settles it for a planned procedure: they plan to use that hospital, so Plan A leads.
- Drugs. Dana takes one maintenance drug at a $20 copay under Plan A and $60 under Plan B: a $480 annual difference in Plan A's favor.
- Prior authorization. Plan A requires approval for an MRI. Plan B does not. Marcus expects one MRI for his knee, so the edge here is small.
Plan A leads on two of three steps, and the third is minor. They do not need steps four to seven. If the hospital and the drugs had been the same, they would continue to telehealth and customer service, and so on.
When to stop analyzing
You can stop when any of these is true:
- A step produced a difference that affects care you know you will use. A doctor in network, a drug at a lower tier or a hospital covered at normal cost sharing outweighs a trivial feature.
- The total-year difference between plans is smaller than the cost of your time. If two plans differ by less than the price of one month's premium and no step separated them, pick either. The choice will not be the thing that decides how your year goes.
- The rest is guesswork. If what is left depends on events you cannot predict, such as a future provider leaving a network, no further reading will settle it.
A tie that survives all seven steps is a tie. Flip a coin, or choose the plan with the better service experience in your test calls. You can revisit the choice at the next open enrollment, and if you want a second opinion in the meantime, a marketplace navigator or a licensed broker will go through the plans with you at no cost to you in most cases. The guide on how to compare health plans and the plan comparison calculator cover the cost side, and the network and drug check worksheet records the network side. A related post compares two similar silver plans with a different example.
Key takeaways
- Before declaring a tie, compare embedded versus aggregate deductibles and the rows for the services you really use.
- Test the network by doctor, hospital, lab and pharmacy, then call the offices, because the directory is a starting point only.
- Price each of your medicines by tier, approval rule and pharmacy path. A tier difference of a few dollars a fill adds up over twelve fills.
- Telehealth, customer service and mid-year changes matter more for some households than others, so rank them by how often you will use them.
- Stop when a step separates the plans for care you will need, when the remaining difference is smaller than a month's premium, or when only guesswork is left.