Blog

How does a sharing ministry actually pay a hospital bill, step by step?

One hypothetical hospital bill followed from admission to payment under a typical sharing arrangement, with the math, timing and what the member still owes.

Under most sharing arrangements, a hospital never sends the bill to the ministry. The hospital bills you, because as far as the hospital is concerned you are a patient paying for yourself. The ministry's role comes afterward: you submit the bills and records, the ministry decides whether and how much the need is eligible to be shared, and the sharing is paid out of other members' monthly contributions under the ministry's guidelines. Everything that is not shared stays your debt to the hospital.

This walkthrough follows one invented bill from admission to payment. The numbers are round illustrations, and real ministries differ in their steps, names and timing, so treat it as a map of the stages and not as the rules of any one program. The ministry's guidelines are the source for the actual process, and the companion post What should I ask a health care sharing ministry before I join? lists what to ask before joining.

The setting

Say Maria is a member of a sharing ministry. She is not covered by an insurance plan. Her ministry's guidelines, in this illustration, have a $1,000 initial amount that the member pays on each eligible need, and a $250,000 per-incident cap. Maria has an unplanned hospital stay with surgery. One stay produces several bills, because the hospital, the surgeon and the anesthesia group bill separately.

The health care sharing ministry entry defines the term. What matters for this walkthrough is the legal shape: the ministry is not an insurer, has no contract with the hospital in the usual case, and promises only what its guidelines say.

Before the money: steps 1 to 4

Step 1: At admission, say how you will pay

In an emergency, the hospital treats first and the paperwork comes after. When the admission is planned, or as soon as you can, tell the registration desk how you will be paying. Under a typical arrangement the honest answer is that you have no insurance and will be a self-pay patient. Do not present the ministry's membership card as insurance, because it is not, and the hospital's staff will ask.

Three things to do at this point:

  1. Ask for a written estimate if the care is scheduled. Federal rules give uninsured and self-pay patients a right to a good faith estimate of expected charges for scheduled care when they ask or schedule it.
  2. Ask for the hospital's financial assistance application and its policy. This is the parallel track described below.
  3. Ask who handles billing questions and whether the hospital offers a prompt-pay or self-pay discount.

Step 2: Notify the ministry

Many ministries ask members to notify them of a need within a set period, sometimes before treatment when it is planned. Ask yours how many days you have and how to do it. A late notice can matter, so do this early, even if you do not yet have the bills.

Step 3: Collect the itemized bills

The first bill the hospital sends may be a summary. Ask for an itemized bill from each provider: the hospital, the surgeon, the anesthesia group and any radiology or pathology group. An itemized bill lists each service and charge with a code. Ministries usually require itemized bills, and you want them anyway to check for errors. The guide how to get an itemized medical bill and spot billing errors explains how to read one.

In this illustration Maria's bills, at the hospital's full "billed" charges, are:

Provider Billed charge
Hospital facility $40,000
Surgeon $6,000
Anesthesia group $2,000
Total billed $48,000

Billed charges come from a hospital's price list, called the chargemaster, and are usually much higher than what insurers pay. A self-pay patient can be billed the full amount, and the stage that follows is partly about getting that figure down.

Step 4: Submit the request

Most ministries have a form or portal. Expect to send the itemized bills, your medical records or a physician's note, proof of any payments you have made and the ministry's own sharing form. Ask in advance what the checklist is, because missing documents are a common cause of delay.

Keep copies of everything you send and the dates. Send by a method that gives you a receipt.

The money: steps 5 to 9

Step 5: Repricing and negotiation

Many ministries, directly or through a vendor, try to lower the provider's charge before sharing it. The method is a negotiation: offering a reduced amount for prompt payment of a self-pay bill. The ministry may ask the provider to accept a self-pay price, or ask you to authorize it to negotiate. Some members negotiate on their own, as described in how to negotiate a medical bill: steps and what to say.

In this illustration the repriced amounts are:

Provider Billed Repriced
Hospital facility $40,000 $17,000
Surgeon $6,000 $2,500
Anesthesia group $2,000 $500
Total $48,000 $20,000

The total fell by $28,000, more than half. A repriced amount is not guaranteed, and a provider that declines to reduce its bill can leave the member owing the full billed amount. A provider's agreement to take less is normally for a prompt lump-sum payment, and that matters in step 7. Ask whether, once a provider agrees to a repriced amount, the member can still be balance-billed for the difference (balance billing). Practice varies.

Suppose instead that the hospital refuses to move. The facility bill stays at $40,000 while the surgeon and anesthesia groups agree to $2,500 and $500, a total of $43,000. Some guidelines share only up to a repriced or "reasonable" amount and leave the excess with the member, so Maria's exposure could be as much as $23,000 higher ($40,000 - $17,000) than in the table. Other programs would share the larger bill, up to the cap. This is why the guidelines' wording on repricing is worth reading before a bill arrives.

Step 6: The ministry decides what is eligible

The ministry reviews the request against its guidelines. It may find that all of it is eligible, or that some items are not. In the illustration, say $1,500 of the hospital's repriced amount is for a service the guidelines do not cover. Then the eligible part is $20,000 - $1,500 = $18,500.

Step 7: The member's first payment

Under the guidelines in this illustration, Maria pays the first $1,000 of the eligible amount herself. Some ministries ask the member to pay the initial amount to the provider, others deduct it from what they share. Ask which.

Putting the arithmetic together:

Item Amount
Repriced total $20,000
Not eligible, stays with Maria $1,500
Eligible amount $18,500
Maria's initial amount $1,000
Amount to be shared $17,500
Maria's total responsibility $1,000 + $1,500 = $2,500

Check the cap: $17,500 is far below the $250,000 per-incident limit in this illustration, so the cap does not bite. Had the repriced bill been $400,000, it would.

Step 8: Payment and timing

How the shared amount reaches the provider varies. Some ministries pay the provider directly, some send the money to the member, who pays the provider, and some pay in installments. The timing also varies, from weeks to months, and the ministry's guidelines should say whether there is a queue or a target date. Ask it, and ask what happens if the hospital's discounted price expires before the share arrives. A hospital may only honor a reduced price if it is paid by a certain date, and the member may need to cover that gap or request an extension in writing.

During this period, check that the hospital has not sent the account to collections. Tell the billing office that you are working on the bill, ask for a written hold and get the name of the person you spoke to. If an account reaches collections anyway, the guide on medical debt and your rights: collections, credit reports, lawsuits explains the steps.

Step 9: The balance that stays with the member

At the end, the member's responsibility is whatever was not shared. In the illustration that is the initial amount and the ineligible item: $2,500. A member also pays:

  • anything above the per-incident or annual cap,
  • items the guidelines exclude,
  • charges the member was not able to get repriced,
  • care outside a program's rules, such as a provider the ministry did not approve if approval was required.

If the hospital and Maria agree to a payment plan for $2,500, ask for it in writing, with no interest where possible.

Why there is no insurance-style appeal

An insurance plan sold under the Affordable Care Act must give you an internal appeal and, generally, an independent external review of a denial, and the state insurance department takes complaints about plans. A sharing ministry is not an insurer, and in most states is not regulated as one, so those rights usually do not apply. The ministry's guidelines may offer a review process, and it is worth using, but it is the ministry's own, and there is generally no outside decision-maker who can require payment. Ask before joining what review is available and who decides.

The hospital is a separate matter. A bill dispute with the hospital, such as a charge you believe is wrong, goes to the hospital's billing office first, and the state attorney general or the consumer protection office may take complaints about billing practices.

The parallel track: hospital financial assistance

Hospital financial assistance does not depend on ministry membership. Federal tax rules require nonprofit hospitals to have a written financial assistance policy, often called charity care, and many hospitals reduce or write off bills for patients below an income level. Applying costs nothing, and an approved application can reduce the balance the ministry would otherwise be asked to share, or the part that stays with you.

  • Ask for the policy and the application early, because many have a window to apply.
  • Tell the ministry what the hospital does, because a write-off changes what is eligible to be shared.
  • Ask the hospital whether ministry membership or a pending share affects how it counts your resources.

The guide hospital financial assistance and charity care: how to apply and the post four households, one $18,000 hospital bill: who gets financial help? show how that works, and the bill dispute side is in how to negotiate a medical bill: steps and what to say.

A checklist for the whole process

  1. Tell the registration desk you are self-pay and ask for the financial assistance application.
  2. Notify the ministry within its deadline.
  3. Request itemized bills from every provider.
  4. Submit the ministry's form with the bills, records and receipts, and keep copies.
  5. Ask whether repricing is done and whether you can be balance-billed for the difference.
  6. Pay your initial amount as the guidelines direct, and ask about timing for the share.
  7. Ask the hospital in writing to hold the account while the request is pending.
  8. Track the balance that stays with you, and ask for a written payment plan if needed.

Key takeaways

  • The hospital bills you as a self-pay patient, and the ministry's share is a separate step after the bills are submitted, so you stay responsible for the debt until it is paid.
  • Repricing can lower the bill substantially, but it is not guaranteed, and a discount often depends on prompt payment.
  • In the $48,000 illustration, the repriced bill was $20,000 and Maria's share was $2,500, which included the initial amount and a $1,500 ineligible item.
  • There is usually no insurance-style appeal or external review; ask what the ministry's own review process is before you need it.
  • Hospital financial assistance is a separate option you can apply for at the same time.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic