Blog

What should I ask a health care sharing ministry before I join?

Questions on the legal disclosure, eligible needs, waiting periods, caps, payment timing, denied requests and regulation, with what supporters and critics say.

A health care sharing ministry is not an insurance company, and what that means in practice is the reason to ask questions before joining. Members send monthly amounts that the ministry uses, according to its own guidelines, to help pay other members' eligible medical bills. There is no contract of insurance, so there are no insurance-style guarantees of payment, appeal rights or state review of the rules. Whether that is an acceptable trade for a lower monthly cost is a personal decision, and this checklist is meant to make sure it is made with the terms in front of you.

Nothing here is a recommendation for or against any ministry, and it describes a category in which the programs differ from each other. Details such as caps, waiting periods and eligibility rules vary, and the ministry's own guidelines are the source for any one of them. For the general picture, the guide health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? and the plan-type page Health care sharing ministry cover what these programs are.

Ministries generally publish a statement, in their guidelines or application, that says in substance that the program is not insurance and that payment of any bill is not guaranteed. The wording varies, and some states have rules about it.

Ask, and read:

  • What does the disclosure say, word for word? Why: it is the ministry's own statement of what it promises. If you read it and what a salesperson told you do not match, the document is the one that counts.
  • Is the ministry a nonprofit, and how are the monthly amounts handled? Why: it tells you whether your payments go to a common pool or to the ministry's operating costs, and who decides how they are spent. Ask for the share of monthly amounts that goes to member bills versus administration, and whether it is audited.
  • Is the ministry's application a "sharing" or a "coverage" document? Why: language matters, and a program that describes itself as "coverage" or "insurance" in its marketing contradicts its own disclosure.

The health care sharing ministry entry defines the term in more detail.

What counts as an eligible need

Each ministry has a written list of what it will consider for sharing and what it excludes. Ask for it and read both halves.

  • What conditions, treatments and providers are eligible, and what is excluded? Why: exclusions are where members are most often surprised. Typical examples that differ between programs include routine and preventive care, mental health care, maternity, certain medications, and care related to conduct the ministry's guidelines disapprove of.
  • Are routine and preventive visits, prescriptions and dental or vision care included? Why: many programs focus on large, unexpected medical events and do not share routine expenses. You may still pay those out of pocket.
  • Does a need have to be "medically necessary," and who decides? Why: the standard and the decision-maker are not the ones an insurer uses.
  • Are there limits on which providers or facilities can be used? Why: some programs prefer or require certain providers, or reprice bills only for certain providers.

Waiting periods and pre-existing conditions

  • Is there a waiting period before new members' needs are eligible? Why: if you need care soon after joining, a waiting period decides whether the program helps. A waiting period might apply to everything or to certain services such as maternity.
  • How does the ministry treat a pre-existing condition? Why: insurance plans sold under the Affordable Care Act cannot turn you away or charge more because of one, but a ministry is not bound by that rule. Ask whether a pre-existing condition is excluded, subject to a waiting period, limited to a dollar amount or shared only after a period of membership. Ask how the ministry defines "pre-existing" and how far back it looks.
  • What do I have to disclose on the application, and what happens if I leave something out? Why: an incomplete answer can lead to a request being declined later.
  • If I join after a new diagnosis, what exactly will be shared? Why: this is the most important question for anyone with a known health condition.

Caps, unshared amounts and the member's share

  • Is there an initial amount I pay for each need before sharing starts? Ministries may call this an annual or per-incident "unshared amount." It works something like a deductible but is not governed by insurance rules. Ask whether it applies per person, per household, per incident or per year.
  • Is there a cap per incident, per year or for a lifetime? Why: this is the maximum the program may share. Ask whether there is a separate cap for specific conditions.
  • What portion of a bill is shared once the initial amount is met? Why: some programs share all eligible costs above the initial amount, others share a percentage.
  • Is there an out-of-pocket limit comparable to the one on a marketplace plan? Why: with insurance, the out-of-pocket maximum caps your exposure for covered in-network care. With sharing, it may not exist.

As a labeled hypothetical, say a ministry's guidelines have a $500 initial unshared amount and a $250,000 per-incident cap. A member has a hospital stay with an eligible, repriced bill of $400,000. The member pays the first $500. The program may share up to $250,000, and the remaining $400,000 - $500 - $250,000 = $149,500 stays with the member, plus whatever was not eligible. These numbers are invented, and a real ministry's caps may be higher, lower or absent. The point is to find the actual figures before you rely on them.

How and when shares are paid

  • How does a member submit a need, and what documents are required? Why: knowing the process in advance saves weeks. The step-by-step version for one bill is in how does a sharing ministry actually pay a hospital bill, step by step?.
  • Do you pay the provider directly, or do you send the money to me? Why: if the money comes to the member, the member must pay the hospital and may owe it before the share arrives.
  • How long does it take, from submission to payment? Why: timing can run from weeks to many months, and providers do not always wait.
  • Do you reprice bills or negotiate with providers? Why: some ministries work to lower the provider's charge before sharing it. Ask who does it and whether the member can be balance-billed for the difference.
  • Are shares paid in the order requests are received, or by another method? Why: a queue can slow payment.
  • What happens if the ministry's pool is short? Why: a program that depends on monthly contributions can have a shortfall, so ask what the guidelines say.

What happens when a request is not shared

  • What are the reasons a request can be declined or reduced? Why: the list tells you where the risk is.
  • Is there an appeal or review process, and who decides? Why: in an insurance plan, you have an internal appeal and, generally, an independent external review. Ministries are not subject to those rules, though some have their own review process. Ask whether the review is by someone outside the staff who decided the claim. See external review for what an insurance plan must offer.
  • Can I ask for the decision in writing, with the reason and the guideline relied on? Why: you will want it if you need to dispute it or ask for help.
  • What recourse do I have if the ministry does not pay? Why: an honest answer is "the guidelines, and in most cases not a state insurance appeal." Most states do not regulate ministries as insurers.

Membership terms, faith requirements and cost

  • Is a statement of faith, church membership or a pledge about lifestyle required? Why: some ministries have faith or lifestyle requirements and may ask you to confirm them yearly. Ask what happens if your circumstances change.
  • What is the monthly amount, and can it change? Why: the amount may depend on age, household size and the initial amount you choose, and may rise. Ask how much notice members get.
  • Are there enrollment or annual fees, and can I cancel? Why: ask for refund and cancellation terms in writing.
  • What happens if I move to a different state? Why: rules and the ministry's disclosure may differ.

State regulator status

  • How does my state treat the ministry? Why: state rules differ, and many states do not regulate ministries as insurance, while some have rules about disclosures or exempt them under specific statutes. The state insurance department can tell you whether it regulates the program and whether it has received complaints. See state insurance department and the guide on how to file a complaint with your state insurance department.
  • Has any regulator taken action against the ministry? Why: a search of your state department's and attorney general's websites is a good check.

What it does not guarantee

A ministry does not guarantee that your bill will be paid. It is not required to meet the standards that insurers must, such as coverage of pre-existing conditions, essential health benefits or the no-surprise-billing protections. Whether it counts as qualifying coverage under federal or state rules, and whether you must have other coverage for any reason, are questions for the state or federal agency and a tax professional, and not for the ministry's website.

What supporters and critics say

Supporters say the arrangement offers lower monthly costs, shared values among members, a community that helps in a crisis and more freedom of choice among providers. Many members report satisfaction with how needs have been shared.

Critics, including some consumer advocates and state regulators, say members can mistake the program for insurance, that exclusions and caps can leave members with large bills, that there is no right to appeal and that people with health conditions can be turned away from a safety net they thought they had. They also point out that members who leave an ACA plan may lose access to premium tax credits.

Both views can be accurate about different members. A healthy household with savings may do fine, and a household that cannot absorb a large unshared bill may not.

Red flags

  • A program or seller that calls it insurance, "coverage" or a "plan" without the disclosure.
  • Pressure to join right away or claims that it works "just like insurance."
  • No written guidelines, or a refusal to show them before payment.
  • No clear process or timeline for payment.
  • A guarantee of payment, which the disclosure itself will contradict.

The guide fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance describes products that look like coverage but are not. For comparing how a ministry, a short-term plan and a marketplace plan each handle a year with big medical costs, see How a sharing ministry, short-term plan and ACA plan each handle a bad year.

Key takeaways

  • A sharing ministry is not insurance, and payment of any bill is not guaranteed; read the legal disclosure and the guidelines first.
  • Ask about eligible needs, exclusions, waiting periods, pre-existing condition limits, caps and the amount you pay before sharing begins.
  • Find out how and when shares are paid, who negotiates the bill and what happens when a request is not shared, since there is usually no insurance-style appeal.
  • Ask your state insurance department how the ministry is regulated and whether it has complaints on file.
  • Compare the lower monthly cost against what you could pay out of pocket in a bad year.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic