Blog
Someone called saying my Medicare card is expiring. What do I do?
What to do after a suspicious Medicare call: hang up, verify on your own, report it, and respond to anything you already shared.
The call is a scam, or close enough that you should treat it as one. Medicare cards do not expire, replacing one costs nothing and Medicare does not phone people to sell them a new card, collect a fee or "verify" a number. If the caller said otherwise, end the call and work through the steps below, in order. They are ranked by what to do first, and every one costs nothing.
This playbook describes common scam scripts in general terms. The scripts change, but the pattern underneath does not: a reason to act now, a request for information or money, and a reason not to hang up.
Step 1: Hang up, and do not press anything
You do not owe the caller a polite goodbye. Hang up the phone, or delete the voicemail or text without replying.
- Do not press a number to speak to a person or to be removed from a list. A keypress can confirm that your line is active and lead to more calls.
- Do not say "yes" or "I agree" in a way that can be recorded as consent to something.
- Do not call back the number that appeared on your screen. Scammers can display any number they like, including one that looks like Medicare's, and a call back goes to them.
- Do not follow a link in a text or an email that claims to be about your card.
If you have already stayed on the line, you have not been harmed by listening. The risk comes from what you give them.
Step 2: Do not confirm any information
A scammer often starts with something that sounds like proof: your name, your address, the name of your doctor, or the last digits of a number. They may have bought it from a list, or pulled it from a past breach. It does not mean they work for Medicare.
If they asked you to "confirm" information, the safe answer is none of it. That includes:
- your Medicare number (the Medicare Beneficiary Identifier on your card)
- your Social Security number, even the last four digits
- your date of birth
- bank, credit card or gift card details
- the names of your doctors or your medical conditions
A real representative of a real plan or agency you called will understand if you say you want to hang up and call the number on your card. A scammer will argue.
Step 3: Check what is true, on a channel you chose
Call or log in yourself, using contact details you found independently.
- The number on your card or your plan's card. The back of a Medicare Advantage, Part D or Medigap card has a member services number. For Original Medicare, 1-800-MEDICARE is the general line, and the number is also on Medicare.gov.
- Your Medicare.gov account. Type the address into your browser rather than clicking a link. Your coverage, claims and the latest notices appear there. If the card were really changing, nothing in the account would say so, because it is not. See How do I set up my Medicare online account and what should I check in it? for what to look at in the account.
- Your most recent Medicare Summary Notice, or the plan's explanation of benefits. Confirm that no charge looks unfamiliar. How do I read my Medicare Summary Notice and spot billing errors? explains how.
You will find that the facts are unremarkable: the card is valid, nothing is expiring, and no new card is waiting for a payment.
Step 4: Report it
Reporting helps investigators connect calls to a pattern, and it helps other people. You do not need to prove anything to make a report.
- Medicare. Call 1-800-MEDICARE and tell the representative that someone called about your card. They can note it and tell you what to check.
- The Senior Medicare Patrol. Each state has a local program that helps people spot and report Medicare fraud. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor, a SHIP counselor, can usually connect you.
- The Office of Inspector General of the Department of Health and Human Services, which runs a fraud hotline and takes reports online.
- The Federal Trade Commission, at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, which collects reports of phone scams.
- Your state attorney general or insurance department, if the caller claimed to sell insurance.
The guide How to spot and report Medicare fraud, hospice fraud and billing abuse lists the details and explains what happens next. Note the date and time, the number that appeared on your caller ID, what the caller said they were from and anything you shared.
Registering on the National Do Not Call Registry stops lawful telemarketers, not scammers, so it will not end the calls, though it is free and cuts down legitimate sales calls that blur into the noise.
Step 5: If you shared information, act on what you shared
Working out what you gave determines what to do. The right action differs by item.
| What the caller got | What to do next |
|---|---|
| Your Medicare number | Call 1-800-MEDICARE, tell them, and ask whether a new Medicare number is advisable. Check your claims and notices for services you did not receive. |
| Your Social Security number | Review your my Social Security account at ssa.gov, consider a fraud alert or credit freeze with the three credit bureaus, and file a report with the FTC's identity-theft site. |
| Bank account or routing numbers | Call the bank using the number on your statement, say you gave details to a scammer and ask about monitoring or a new account number. |
| A credit or debit card number | Call the card issuer, report the number as compromised and ask for a replacement. Dispute any charge. |
| Gift cards or a wire or cash payment | Contact the card company or transfer service right away and ask whether the payment can be stopped. Report it to the FTC and your local police. Recovery is often difficult, but speed helps. |
| Your login or a one-time code | Change the password at once, and tell the site's support line. |
| Access to your computer | Disconnect from the internet, seek help from a trusted technician and change passwords from a clean device. |
Do not be embarrassed. People who work in finance, medicine and law all get taken in by these calls, because the scripts are designed to work on busy, careful people. Reporting quickly is the best response.
The guide medical identity theft and insurer data breaches: what to do covers longer-term steps for health-related identity theft.
Step 6: Keep watching for the next few months
A call that did not get anything from you can still be the first of several, and a call that did can show up later in your records. Set a small routine and keep it for a few months:
- The first week: open your Medicare.gov account and your plan's member site, and look at the list of recent claims. Write down anything unfamiliar and ask the provider's billing office about it.
- The next notice: when the quarterly Medicare Summary Notice arrives, or the plan's explanation of benefits, read every line. A service you did not get is the signal to call 1-800-MEDICARE.
- Your mail and email: expect follow-up messages that mention the call, or a "confirmation" of an enrollment you never made. If a plan says you enrolled, call the plan at the number on its official site and ask for the application date and how it was submitted. A change you did not authorize can be reversed, and the sooner you ask, the easier it is.
- Your bank and card statements: look once a week for small charges, which are sometimes used to test whether an account works.
If you find something, the steps in the table above still apply, and the report to Medicare and the Inspector General can be made at any point.
What the scripts sound like
The following are composite descriptions, not quotations from any one scam:
- The expiring card. The caller says your card will expire or be "deactivated" unless you confirm your number, or pay a fee, to get a new one. In fact, cards do not expire, and a replacement is free.
- The plastic card upgrade. You are told that a new, "permanent" or "plastic" card is being issued and that you must verify identity for it.
- The refund or overpayment. The caller says you are owed money because of an overcharge and asks for banking details to deposit it.
- The free equipment or test. An offer of a brace, a genetic test, a "cancer screening kit" or similar, billed to Medicare if you give the number.
- The benefits increase. The caller says new benefits, a cost-of-living increase or a grocery card are available and need your number to enroll.
- The threat. The caller says your coverage will end or you will be penalized if you do not respond today.
- The official-sounding transfer. After you question the call, you are passed to a "supervisor" or to someone who says they are from Social Security, the Department of Justice or the police.
- The spoofed number. The number on your screen looks like a government office.
- The text or email. A message with a link to "update your Medicare card," which opens a form asking for your number or a payment.
Each one asks for information or money that a real Medicare process would not ask for by phone.
Why the calls reach you
You were probably not targeted for anything you did. Scam callers work from purchased lists, and anyone who is 65 or older, or who is on a list of Medicare-age people, is a candidate. They are busiest when the news makes people anxious about their coverage, and in the fall when open enrollment calls are common. During the Annual Enrollment Period, from October 15 to December 7, many real plans and agents are also calling and mailing, which is why a scammer can sound like one more sales call. The companion checklist, How do I know a Medicare plan sales call or ad is legitimate?, covers how to tell a legitimate marketing contact from a bad one.
A rule of thumb that is hard to get wrong: if you did not start the contact, do not give out information, whatever the caller says about who they are.
What if the caller is actually from my plan or Medicare?
It happens. Your own plan may call to welcome you, to follow up on an application, to remind you about a service or to confirm that you want to change something. A caller who is real will understand if you say you will call back on the number printed on your card. A scam artist will often push back with a deadline. You can check in a few minutes.
If you called a number and asked for a callback, or if you submitted a form asking a plan to contact you, a call is expected.
Helping a parent or a friend
A relative who has been called may be frightened or ashamed. These steps tend to work:
- Ask what the caller said in a calm way, and take notes.
- Help them place the verification call, so they see what happens.
- Check their claims and bank accounts together for anything unfamiliar.
- Set up an arrangement with a trusted person to talk before they act on any call about money or coverage, because the callers rely on isolation and speed.
- Go through how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it together.
Key takeaways
- Medicare cards do not expire, a replacement is free, and Medicare does not phone to sell you a card or to collect your number.
- Hang up without pressing anything, and do not confirm your Medicare number, Social Security number or bank details. Do not call back the number on your screen.
- Verify through the number on your card or your Medicare.gov account, and check your claims and notices.
- Report the call to 1-800-MEDICARE, the Senior Medicare Patrol, the Inspector General's hotline and the FTC. If you shared information, act on the specific item: new Medicare number, fraud alert, bank or card issuer.
- If you did not start the contact, do not give out information, however official the caller sounds.