Blog

How state benefit mandates work and why some plans skip them

What a state benefit mandate is, how it fits with essential health benefits, why self-funded employer plans are exempt, and what supporters and critics say.

Two friends in two states both have job-based health insurance. One has coverage for fertility treatment, hearing aids or a specific therapy; the other is told the plan does not cover it. Neither has made a mistake. The difference usually comes from two rules working together: a state may require the insurance policies sold in that state to include certain services, and those requirements do not reach every plan. This post explains how state benefit mandates work, how they relate to the federal list of essential health benefits, why plans that pay their own claims are exempt, and what supporters and critics argue.

What a state benefit mandate is

A benefit mandate is a state law that says insurance sold in the state must cover a particular service, provider or condition, or must cover it in a particular way. Mandates come in a few forms:

  • Covered services. The plan must cover a treatment or test, for example some form of fertility treatment, hearing aids for children or adults, or a particular screening.
  • Covered conditions. The plan must cover treatment of a condition, such as autism-related therapies, in at least a stated way.
  • Covered providers. The plan must pay for care from a type of licensed provider, such as chiropractors or midwives, if the service is otherwise covered.
  • Coverage design. The plan must offer a benefit on terms equal to other medical benefits (a parity rule), limit certain cost sharing or cover a specific preventive item beyond the federal list.
  • Continuation and eligibility rules. Not a "benefit" in the narrow sense, but state laws also set things like how long a state continuation right lasts for smaller employers' workers.

Legislatures pass mandates in response to patient groups, clinicians and advocates who argue that a service is under-covered. The number and kinds of mandates differ across states, which is why this post does not give a count. Your state insurance department's website, and often a state page on this site, lists the main ones.

Where mandates sit next to essential health benefits

The Affordable Care Act sets a federal baseline for individual and small-group plans: the ten categories of essential health benefits (ambulatory care, emergency services, hospitalization, maternity and newborn care, mental health and substance use services, prescription drugs, rehabilitative and habilitative services, laboratory services, preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management, and pediatric services including oral and vision care). The guide Essential health benefits: the 10 categories ACA plans must cover covers them.

Each state picks a "benchmark" plan that defines what those categories look like in detail, and it generally includes the state mandates that were in place when the benchmark was chosen. Those are therefore part of the essential benefits in that state's individual and small-group markets. A mandate enacted later that goes beyond the benchmark raises a cost question: for marketplace plans, federal rules say a state that requires extra benefits beyond the essential health benefits must cover the added cost of that extra benefit, not pass it to the plan or the federal subsidy. The mechanism is called defrayal. It does not stop a state from enacting a mandate; it determines who pays for it in the marketplace and can make states cautious about adding new ones there.

This matters for the friend question because an essential benefit in one state's benchmark may not be one in another's. Both states have to cover all ten categories, and they can differ on details inside the categories.

Which plans the mandates reach

Here is the part that surprises people. State insurance law applies to insurance. It does not apply to everything that pays for health care.

Type of coverage Do state benefit mandates apply? Why
Individual plan sold in the state (marketplace or off-exchange) Yes State regulates the insurance contract
Fully insured employer plan (employer buys a policy) Yes, generally the state where the policy is issued The policy is insurance, and the state regulates it
Self-funded employer plan (employer pays claims itself) No Federal law (ERISA) keeps states from regulating the plan
Medicare and Original Medicare No Federal program with its own benefit rules
Medicaid Not as mandates; state sets its own benefits State and federal program rules apply
Federal employee plans (FEHB) Generally no Federal contracts and law apply
State or local government plans Depends on the plan and the state Governmental plans are exempt from ERISA, and the state decides

Three details in the table reward attention. The first is "the state where the policy is issued." A worker who lives in one state but works for a company whose policy is issued in another may be covered by the other state's mandates, because the policy, not the worker's address, decides. The second is that self-funded is a different thing from small or large; plenty of large employers buy insured policies, and some mid-sized employers self-fund. The third is that a plan can be exempt from state mandates and still be bound by federal rules.

Why self-funded plans are exempt

The federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, usually called ERISA, was passed in 1974 to set national standards for private employer benefit plans. It includes a preemption clause that overrides state laws that "relate to" employee benefit plans, with an exception for state laws that regulate insurance. Courts have read it this way: a state law that regulates insurance can apply to an insured plan, because the insurer is the regulated party. But a state may not "deem" a self-funded plan to be an insurer, so state insurance mandates do not reach plans where the employer itself bears the risk.

That is how a large employer with workers in many states can run one self-funded plan under one set of rules, rather than a different one in each state. The employer typically hires an administrator and buys stop-loss insurance to cap its exposure to very large claims. stop-loss insurance explains that arrangement, and the guide self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you compares the two models. If you want help identifying yours, How can I tell whether my employer's health plan is self-funded? goes through the clues.

Being exempt from a state mandate does not mean the plan excludes the service. Many self-funded plans cover fertility treatment, hearing aids and similar services because the employer chose to, often to compete for workers. It means the choice belongs to the employer, not the legislature, and you must read the plan document to find out.

What federal rules still apply to self-funded plans

State mandates are one layer; the federal layers go further:

  • Federal protections for most group plans, insured or self-funded: no lifetime or annual dollar limits on essential benefits, coverage of adult children to age 26, preventive services without cost sharing for non-grandfathered plans, and no pre-existing condition exclusions.
  • Mental health parity rules, which require comparable treatment of mental health and medical benefits.
  • The No Surprises Act, which covers most group plans, including self-funded ones.
  • ERISA's claims and appeals rules, which set deadlines and require a full and fair review.

Not every ACA requirement applies equally: for example, self-funded and large-group plans need not cover the essential health benefit categories in the way individual and small-group plans must, although those plans may not impose annual or lifetime limits on whatever essential benefits they do cover. Read the Summary of Benefits and Coverage and the full plan document to see which services are in or out.

What supporters and critics say about mandates

Mandates are one of the more argued-over tools in insurance regulation. Each side has a case.

Supporters argue:

  • Without a requirement, insurers may leave out services that are costly for a small number of people, and the patients who need them are least able to pay out of pocket.
  • Coverage of an effective treatment can reduce larger costs later, such as hospital stays.
  • Spreading a rare, large cost across a big pool of premium payers is what insurance is for. For a given mandate, the added cost per member is small.
  • Legislatures, not individual insurers, are the right place to decide what counts as a basic benefit.

Critics argue:

  • Each mandate adds cost to premiums, and the total of many mandates can be large. Higher premiums can push some small employers and individuals to drop coverage.
  • Mandates are often passed in response to lobbying by providers who would be paid for the service, and they may require coverage of treatments with limited evidence.
  • Because self-funded plans are exempt, mandates fall on small employers and individuals and may give larger employers a reason to self-fund, which narrows the insured pool.
  • One state-wide rule cannot fit every person's needs, and employers and insurers should offer a range of plan designs.

Economists have estimated the cost of particular mandates, but the numbers vary by service, state and method, so treat any single figure with caution and look for its source and year.

A small example of how mandate cost spreads

Here is a hypothetical with round numbers to show the arithmetic; it is not any state's real cost. Say a state requires insured plans to cover a service that costs the insurer an average of $0.50 per member per month once it is spread over everyone in the plan. For an insurer with 100,000 insured members in the state:

  • Monthly cost: $0.50 times 100,000 is $50,000.
  • Yearly cost: $50,000 times 12 is $600,000.

If the average premium were $500 per month, $0.50 is 0.1% of the premium ($0.50 divided by $500). Supporters call that a small price for a benefit a few families rely on. Critics add up many such items: ten of them at $0.50 each would be $5.00 a month, or 1% of that premium. Both are arithmetic truths. The real argument is over how many such mandates there should be, whether each one's benefit justifies its cost, and who should decide.

What to do with this

  • When you are comparing plans, do not assume a covered benefit follows you across state lines. Check the plan's evidence of coverage for the service you need, whether it is mandated or not.
  • If you have employer coverage, ask your benefits office whether the plan is insured or self-funded, and ask for the plan document's section on the service by name.
  • If a service is denied, ask the insurer to cite the contract provision. If your plan is insured, ask whether a state mandate applies, and use the state insurance department's website to find it. Who regulates my health plan, the state, the Labor Department or CMS? helps you pick the right agency.
  • If you are moving, a new employer's plan may cover different things, and an individual marketplace plan in the new state follows the new state's rules. The guide what does health insurance cover and what is left out? describes what is usually included.
  • If you care about the policy question, your state legislature's committee hearings and the insurance department's mandate reviews, where they exist, are public.

Key takeaways

  • A state benefit mandate requires insurance sold in the state to cover a service, condition or provider; it does not require employers to offer coverage.
  • Federal essential health benefits are the baseline for individual and small-group plans, and states can add mandates, but marketplace rules make the state responsible for the cost of benefits beyond the essential list.
  • Self-funded employer plans are exempt from state mandates because of federal law (ERISA), which is why two coworkers or two friends with employer coverage can have different benefits.
  • Exempt does not mean excluded; many self-funded plans cover the service by choice, and the plan document is the proof.
  • Supporters point to access and shared risk, and critics point to premium cost and the incentive to self-fund; both sides' arithmetic depends on the specific benefit.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic