Blog

Who regulates my health plan, the state, the Labor Department or CMS?

A decision list by plan type that names the agency to contact about a complaint, what each can and cannot do, and what to bring when you call or file.

The agency that can help with a health plan complaint depends on what kind of plan you have, not on how serious the problem is. An individual plan bought in your state's marketplace answers to your state. A plan your employer pays claims for itself answers mostly to the federal Labor Department. A Medicare Advantage plan answers to the federal Medicare agency. Send the complaint to the wrong place and you can lose weeks. This post is a decision aid: find your plan type, go to the agency listed, and bring what that agency asks for.

Why the answer is split in the first place

Health coverage in the United States is regulated in layers. States regulate insurance: they license insurers and agents, review forms and, in many cases, rates, and handle complaints about insured plans. The federal government regulates employee benefit plans (through the law known as ERISA), Medicare and parts of Medicaid, and sets some rules that apply nationwide, such as the Affordable Care Act's consumer protections and the No Surprises Act. Some federal rules are enforced by the states, and some by federal agencies, depending on the plan.

The pieces that matter for you are these:

  • The state insurance department (the name varies: department, division, office of the commissioner) is the front door for insured plans. state insurance department describes the role.
  • The Labor Department's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) oversees private employer plans under ERISA, including self-funded ones.
  • CMS (the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services) runs Medicare and oversees state Medicaid programs and the federal marketplace, and enforces some federal rules where a state does not.
  • The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) runs the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program.

The decision list

Start with the first line that matches. If you are unsure which line you are on, see the next section on how to tell.

Plan type: individual or family plan, bought on the marketplace or directly from an insurer. First stop: your state insurance department. Problems with enrollment, eligibility, subsidies or the marketplace website go to the marketplace (HealthCare.gov or your state's exchange) first. Claims, denials, billing and service complaints against the insurer go to the state department. CMS can step in where a state does not enforce a federal rule.

Plan type: employer plan that is fully insured (the employer buys a policy from an insurer). First stop: your state insurance department for insurance-law questions such as state benefit mandates, claim-handling deadlines, network standards and rate rules. EBSA also has authority over ERISA-covered employer plans for things like disclosure and the claims and appeals process.

Plan type: employer plan that is self-funded (the employer pays claims itself, often with an insurance company or administrator running the paperwork). First stop: EBSA for private employers. The state insurance department generally cannot act on the plan's benefit decisions, because ERISA keeps the state from regulating self-funded plans. The insurer's name on your ID card is often just the administrator.

Plan type: state or local government employee plan, or a school district plan. First stop: depends. These "governmental plans" are exempt from ERISA. The state, the plan sponsor or the state insurance department may handle complaints, and some federal rules are enforced by CMS. Ask the plan or the benefits office which agency handles it.

Plan type: church plan. First stop: ask the plan. Church plans have their own rules under ERISA and tax law, and the answer varies.

Plan type: Medicare Advantage or a Part D drug plan. First stop: the plan's own grievance or appeals process, then Medicare. Complaints about the plan can be made to Medicare through its helpline or the Medicare website. The state insurance department has a small role, typically with licensed agents who sell the plans. A SHIP counselor can help for free.

Plan type: Original Medicare. First stop: Medicare, 1-800-MEDICARE, and the appeals process printed on your Medicare Summary Notice. State regulators do not oversee Original Medicare.

Plan type: Medicaid, including a Medicaid managed care plan. First stop: the plan's grievance process and the state Medicaid agency. A denial usually gives you the right to a state fair hearing. Many states also have an ombudsman or a managed care helpline. CMS oversees the state program, but individual cases go through the state.

Plan type: Federal Employees Health Benefits (FEHB). First stop: the carrier's disputed-claims process, then OPM, which has the final administrative word on disputed claims. Contact OPM through the retirement and insurance office that serves your plan.

Plan type: TRICARE or VA coverage. First stop: the regional contractor, the Defense Health Agency or the VA, depending on who runs the benefit. Neither the state insurance department nor EBSA has authority.

Plan type: short-term limited-duration coverage. First stop: your state insurance department; short-term plans are regulated by states and are not subject to the same federal consumer rules as marketplace plans.

Plan type: health care sharing ministry. First stop: the ministry itself. In most states these are not insurance, and the insurance department may not regulate them, though some states have taken action against ministries. The attorney general's consumer protection office may take complaints.

Problem type: a surprise bill from an out-of-network provider. First stop: the federal No Surprises Help Desk, which takes complaints about providers and plans, and your state insurance department if your state has its own surprise-billing law. For a self-funded plan, the federal law is enforced by federal agencies, not the state.

Problem type: a medical bill dispute with a provider, not the plan. First stop: the provider's billing office, then your state's consumer protection office or attorney general. The insurance department regulates insurers and their agents, not hospitals or doctors.

How to tell which plan you have

Many people are not sure. These clues help, and none of them is conclusive alone:

  1. Where the coverage came from. If you bought it yourself, you almost certainly have an insured plan regulated by the state. If it came from an employer, keep reading.
  2. Your benefits documents. A summary plan description that mentions ERISA, a plan administrator and "claims administrator" language points to an employer plan. If it says the plan is "self-insured" or "self-funded," that answers the question.
  3. Your ID card. A card that says "administered by" or "claims processed by" often signals a self-funded plan. A card that says "insured by" with a policy number suggests a fully insured one. Neither is guaranteed.
  4. Your employer's benefits office. It can answer "is this plan fully insured or self-funded?" in one sentence. Ask in writing so that you have it.
  5. Your employer's size. Larger employers are more likely to self-fund. A small employer is more likely to buy an insured plan, though many large and small employers do either.

See How can I tell whether my employer's health plan is self-funded? and Is my plan ERISA or state-regulated? Five clues and why it changes my appeal for a longer walk through, and the guide self-funded vs fully insured employer plans: why it matters to you for how the two differ. CMS and the Labor Department have cited Census data showing that over 180 million people get coverage through employers that sponsor self-funded plans. Many people therefore assume state law protects them when it does not.

State setups differ in names and in how the work is split. In California, oversight of health plans is shared between the Department of Managed Health Care (most HMO-style plans) and the Department of Insurance (most other insured plans); see California. Other states put everything in one department. The guide how to find your state's marketplace, regulator and local help shows how to find the right office.

Three hypothetical people and where each would go

These are invented cases to show the decision list at work.

  • Rosa buys her own silver plan on her state's exchange. Her insurer denies a claim and has not answered her appeal. She files a complaint with the state insurance department and asks about external review. If the problem were a subsidy error, she would start with the marketplace instead.
  • Sam works for a large manufacturer. His ID card says the plan is "administered by" an insurance company, and the summary plan description says the plan is self-funded. A state complaint would probably be turned away, so he uses the plan's appeal, then asks EBSA for help and, if the issue is large, talks to a lawyer.
  • Lena has a Medicare Advantage plan that refuses to cover a rehab stay. She uses the plan's fast appeal, which the plan's notice describes, and files a complaint with Medicare. A SHIP counselor helps her gather records at no charge.

What to bring when you contact an agency

Whichever agency you choose, a complaint goes faster when it is complete. Gather:

  • your name, address and member ID, and the group number if you have employer coverage;
  • the plan's name and the name of the insurer or administrator, as printed on the card;
  • the dates and details of the claim, service or enrollment problem;
  • the denial letter, explanation of benefits or notice, with the date it arrived;
  • your appeal or grievance, and the plan's response, if you have filed one;
  • notes of calls: date, representative and what was said;
  • the outcome you are asking for, in one sentence (for example, "reprocess claim at in-network rates").

If you have not appealed to the plan, many agencies will tell you to do that first, and the deadline for an internal appeal runs from the denial date. Do not let a complaint to a regulator replace the appeal. A complaint is not an appeal, and Appeal, grievance or complaint: which one am I filing? explains the difference. The guide how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step shows the sequence.

What each agency can realistically do

Regulators are not courts and cannot always change an outcome, so set expectations:

  • A state insurance department can investigate a complaint against an insured plan, require the insurer to respond, find whether state law or the policy was violated, and in many states run or oversee external review. It cannot hear a self-funded plan's case, and it does not award damages.
  • EBSA can answer questions about your rights, contact the plan on your behalf in some cases and investigate violations. It does not decide coverage disputes the way a court does. A lawsuit is the route for some benefit claims.
  • CMS and Medicare can take complaints, run appeals through independent reviewers for Medicare Advantage, and oversee plans' performance.
  • The state Medicaid agency runs fair hearings, which can overturn a plan's denial.

For all of them, the useful result in many individual cases is a reprocessed claim or an explanation that lets you decide your next step. A specific outcome is never guaranteed.

When two agencies might both apply

A fully insured employer plan is the common overlap: the state handles the insurance questions, and EBSA handles ERISA disclosure and claims-procedure questions. If you are not sure, start with the state insurance department and ask it to tell you if the case belongs elsewhere. Agencies commonly route complaints to the right office, though the transfer may take time, so send your appeal to the plan in parallel and keep your deadlines. If a lawyer is involved, that person can tell you which forum applies, since some claims against employer plans must go through a federal process before a lawsuit.

Key takeaways

  • The regulator depends on your plan type: states for insured plans, the Labor Department for private employer plans (especially self-funded ones), CMS and Medicare for Medicare plans, the state Medicaid agency for Medicaid and OPM for federal employee plans.
  • Find out whether your employer plan is fully insured or self-funded; the benefits office can answer in writing.
  • A complaint to a regulator does not replace the plan's appeal, and the appeal deadline keeps running.
  • Bring the card, notices, dates, call notes and one sentence stating what you want fixed.
  • Regulators can investigate and often get claims reprocessed, but they do not guarantee a result, and a lawyer is the right person for questions about suing.

Terms used in this guide

Related states

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic